fbpx

January 16, 2014

Netanyahu discusses peace process with King Abdullah in Amman visit

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu made an unannounced visit to Amman to meet with King Abdullah II of Jordan.

At Thursday’s meeting, the two leaders discussed the current round of Israeli-Palestinian peace negotiations, according to the Prime Minister’s Office.

Netanyahu stressed the important role played by Jordan in the efforts to arrive at a peace agreement. He also stressed the importance of security arrangements, which also would take Jordan’s interests into consideration in a peace deal.

The meeting comes a week after Abdullah met with Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas, and days after a meeting between Abdullah and U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry.

Abdullah urged Netanyahu to “build on the opportunity made available by the consolidated efforts of the U.S. secretary of state to achieve tangible progress in the peace negotiations,” according to a statement from the palace cited in news reports.

Abdullah and Netanyahu also “discussed an array of economic cooperation between both countries in a number of fields as well as other regional matters.” according to the statement from the Prime Minister’s Office.

Netanyahu visited Jordan to meet with Abdullah three times last year.

Israel and Jordan signed a peace treaty in 1994.

Netanyahu discusses peace process with King Abdullah in Amman visit Read More »

Anat Kamm awarded early prison release

Former Israeli soldier Anat Kamm, who turned classified military documents over to an Israeli reporter, will go free by the end of the month after approval of her appeal for early release.

Kamm’s early release was approved Thursday by the Israel Prison Service, which commended her behavior at the all-female Neve Tirzah Prison since November 2011. She had been scheduled to go free in May 2015.

Kamm was convicted in February 2011 of collecting, holding and passing on classified information without authorization. She had been charged originally with espionage, but the charge was dropped as part of a plea bargain. Kamm was arrested in early 2010.

She admitted to stealing about 2,000 documents, including hundreds identified as classified or top secret, which she downloaded on two discs, while serving her mandatory military service in the Israeli army’s Central Command. She turned the information over to Haaretz reporter Uri Blau, who wrote stories based on the information that were approved by the military censor. The stories led to a search for Blau’s source.

“I didn’t have the chance to change some of the things that I found important to change during my military service, and I thought that by exposing these [materials] I would make a change,” Kamm is quoted as telling police investigators. “It was important for me to bring the IDF’s policy to public knowledge.”

Anat Kamm awarded early prison release Read More »

Bill would link funding for Palestinians to incitement

A bill introduced by the chairman of the House Foreign Affairs Committee would link assistance to the Palestinian Authority to its efforts to stop incitement.

Under the bill presented Wednesday by Rep. Ed Royce (R-Calif.), the president would have to determine that the Palestinian Authority “no longer engages in a pattern of incitement against the United States or Israel; and is engaged in peace preparation activities aimed at promoting peace with the Jewish State of Israel.” The president would have to re-certify compliance every six months.

“As Secretary of State John Kerry engages in negotiations between the Israelis and Palestinians, Congress will make it clear to the Palestinian Authority that continuing anti-Israel incitement to violence through PA-controlled media outlets must cease,” Royce said in a statement.

The United States earmarks about $400 million annually to assistance for the Palestinians. Israel gets $3.1 billion annually, the vast majority in defense assistance.

Bill would link funding for Palestinians to incitement Read More »

Are Feinstein’s fears about the Iran sanctions bill overblown?

Sen. Dianne Feinstein (D-Calif.), in a half-hour speech on the Senate floor on Tuesday, made her case against proposed new Iran sanctions. And she provoked some controversy with her take on some Israel-related language in the legislation.

Feinstein left the Israel component for the end of her speech (and thanks to Lobe Log for transcribing the entire speech). Here’s the relevant passage of her remarks:

And let me acknowledge Israel’s real, well-founded concerns that a nuclear-armed Iran would threaten its very existence.

While I recognize and share Israel’s concern, we cannot let Israel determine when and where the U.S. goes to war.

By stating that the U.S. should provide military support to Israel should it attack Iran, I fear that is exactly what this bill will do.

The interim agreement with Iran is strong, tough and realistic. It represents the first significant opportunity to change a three decade course in Iran and an opening to improve one of our most poisonous bilateral relationships.

It opens the door to a new future which not only considers Israel’s national security—but protects our own.

What she’s referring to is this part of the bill:

If the Government of Israel is compelled to take military action in legitimate self-defense against Iran’s nuclear weapon program, the United States Government should stand with Israel and provide, in accordance with the law of the United States and the constitutional responsibility of Congress to authorize the use of military force, diplomatic, military, and economic support to the Government of Israel in its defense of its territory, people, and existence.

The Republican Jewish Coalition called on Feinstein to apologize, saying she mischaracterized the relevant portion of the bill:

The ‘provision’ of S. 1881 that Feinstein points to is carefully crafted and subject to a special additional provision making it clear that it does not provide an authorization for war in any contingency.

“Moreover, the language of the provision Senator Feinstein cited is identical to language contained in S. Res. 65, which passed the Senate unanimously – and which Senator Feinstein cosponsored!

The “special additional provision” that the RJC refers to is at the end of the sanctions bill now under consideration:

Nothing in this Act or the amendments made by this Act shall be construed as a declaration of war or an authorization of the use of force against Iran.

So is Feinstein’s characterization of the bill “reckless and false” and “incendiary and inaccurate” as the RJC says in its release? The broader question is whether the bill’s language commits the United States to militarily support of Israel should it strike Iran.

There is an amorphous hierarchy in the language of congressional legislation: On top, naturally, is the action portion of bills, and this itself has its own hierarchy of verbs (“will,” “shall,” “may,” etc.). Below that are the “whereases,” which set up the action language; there is along with that, “sense of Congress” portions of bills, which is where the language Feinstein refers to appears. Anything that is a “sense of Congress” is, by definition, not binding (the earlier resolution is also non-binding), which means that it does not commit the United States to an action. On the other hand, “sense of Congress” language exists for a reason — otherwise why include it?

So perhaps Feinstein’s concern that the inclusion of the language would compel the U.S. “go to war” is overblown, but she is not mischaracterizing the language. That said, the RJC poses an excellent question: Why does language that she co-sponsored in May so rankle her in January?

Are Feinstein’s fears about the Iran sanctions bill overblown? Read More »

Recycling Norman Mailer

Thursday is my recycle day, which means I reluctantly toss whole floors from the mounting tower of periodicals that occupy every available surface in my home.

Today I came across a November 2013 issue of the New York Review of Books in which Columbia University professor Edward Mendelson wrote a marvelous essay about Norman Mailer. I had underlined and highlighted all the way through suggesting my intention to blog about it, but alas, I read it on a ride through the rambling mountains of Mexico’s Sierra Madre where, naturally, there was a shortage of electricity.

I confess my introduction to the literary lion Norman Mailer was through his wife.

This is hardly a strange route since Mailer notoriously had a lot of wives — six of them, in fact — though I came to know him through Norris Church, the scarlet haired beauty half his age, who after his death penned the stunning memoir, “A Ticket to the Circus,” about their time together. If you want to know something distinguishing about Church Mailer, it’s this: Whenever someone would approach her at a dinner party or any other social event wanting to know, “Which wife are you?” Church Mailer would say: “The last one.”

On that count, she was right; the Mailers were married 27 years until Norman’s death in 2007 at age 84. (She followed soon after, succumbing to gastrointestinal cancer in 2010, at age 61.)

Though Church Mailer had long dreamed of being a writer, her marriage to a master of the craft proved prohibiting. Her husband hardly encouraged her; Mailer thought his wife’s writing was silly and slight, and it seems fair to say that in comparison to him, it was. In their household, the regular haunt of many famous literary friends, anything short of genius was deemed profligate and pointless. But Church Mailer’s artistry was exemplified in how she lived. Whereas he often behaved like an ape — practicing chronic infidelity, brawling, boxing and nearly stabbing his second wife to death; “Crude thoughts and fierce forces are my state,” he said — Church Mailer lived admirably.  

Mailer was a man with demons, as the NYRB reminds us.

“His whole career was a search for transcendence,” Mendelson observes, echoing what his friend Mashey Bernstein claimed after Mailer’s death, when he wrote, “He was concerned with God and the Devil, Good and Evil.”

“Mailer was less interested in human beings than in the quasi-divine forces they embodied, and in the vast unconscious currents that shaped political and cultural history,” Mendelson writes. Such a notion could almost be pinned on the Jewish idea of B’tzelem Elohim, that human beings are created in God’s image and possess sparks of the divine they must work to magnify.

Mailer of course was Jewish, born in New Jersey and raised in Brooklyn, though the family was not religious. He did claim a grandfather who was a rabbi but ultimately distanced himself from religion.

“He cared nothing about modern Judaism,” Mendelson writes, “which seemed a shell emptied of its ancient visionary energies.” Still, religious systems and the concept of God obsessed him. He wrote, in Mendelson’s phrase “a curious sport of a novel” narrated by Jesus, “The Gospel According to the Son” (1997) and was excited by Jewish mysticism, limning a commentary on Tales of the Hasidim.

Mailer told Bernstein that despite his disaffection from Judaism, he promised his mother he would never write anything negative about it.

His attitude towards Judaism is best summed by Bernstein's paraphrase of an interview he did with Nextbook:

When asked, “What role has your being Jewish played in your being a writer,” Mailer replies emphatically, “An enormous role.” He picks two aspects of the Jewish experience that influenced him – the sense of history that makes it “impossible to take anything for granted” and also the Jewish mind. “We're here to do all sorts of outrageous thinking, if you will … certainly incisive thinking,” Mailer said. “If the Jews brought anything to human nature, it's that they developed the mind more than other people did.”

Mailer had great respect for minorities, and empathized with the underdog. “Minorities groups are the artistic nerve of a republic,” he once wrote. He famously befriended a convicted felon whose literary style he admired, helping to get him released from prison, only to see his goodwill shamed and squandered when that same felon subsequently murdered a waiter.

“When we act with great energy, it is because god and the devil has the same interest in the outcome,” Mailer cryptically wrote. But perhaps it explains why in the 1950s, he had a religious epiphany while high on drugs. “His atheism withered and belief took hold, belief in a god who was not all-powerful, an existential god,” Mendelson writes. Mailer’s new belief inverted the Jewish concept; rather than see human beings as sparks of the divine, Mailer wanted his God to be more like himself. He conceived of a God that was “in danger of dying….who [could] suffer from moral corruption.”

Mailer’s sense of morality is for another essay, another time. My hunch, though, is that it was just as conflicted as his religious worldview, his lust for women and his appetite for violence. As Mendelson points out, in his 1959 novel “Time of Her Time,” the main character brings a girl to orgasm by whispering in her ear, “You dirty little Jew.”

Only Mailer could turn an offensive epithet orgiastic. It’s a baffling, almost demented turn on. Was Jewish identity a form of ecstasy or revulsion? His relationship to the idea of a morally ordered spiritual universe was at best, ineffable.

He was clear only on one thing: being a writer.

Recycling Norman Mailer Read More »

Vogue: Lena Dunham, “hardest-working millennial in show business”

What would Bob Dylan think about Vogue magazine’s new profile on Lena Dunham?

In “Lena Dunham: The New Queen of Comedy?” a Jan. 15 article in the fashion magazine, Dunham draws comparisons to the famous folk singer. 

“Since Girls launched in 2012, the 27-year-old Dunham has become to comic television roughly what Bob Dylan was to sixties folk: She’s not the first person to wield her form and her subject (middle-class postcollegiate life), but she does it with such unmatched skill, charisma, and vision that she’s now the genre’s uncontested master, the standard other people strive to reach,” the article's writer, Nathan Heller, says.

Dunham, who has struck a chord with the 18-34 demographic, is known for the half-hour television comedy, “Girls.” Its third-season premiere aired last weekend.

If Dunham and Dylan have in common the ability to speak to their generation, there’s something else they share to: both are averse to fame.

Dunham admitted to Heller that she’s a recluse, preferring the comfort of her home to the Hollywood scene, despite her reputation as an over-sharer.

“To me, privacy isn’t necessarily equated with secret-keeping,” she says. “What’s private is my relationship with myself.”

Fortunately, Dunham’s output has revealed a lot about her. The first two seasons of the award-winning “Girls,” offered semi-autobiographical portrayals of a recent college graduate living in New York. Dunham, 27, is the daughter of a pair of New York artists.

Dunham’s early work, the film “Tiny Furniture,” chronicles the mistakes of a young adult moving back home with her two artist parents after college.

Dunham tells Heller that even with all the acclaim and new fans she has earned with the television series, she still messes up.

“No matter what happens with your level of success, you still have to deal with all the baggage that is yourself,” she says.

Heller’s piece will appear as the cover story of Vogue’s Jan. 28 issue, alongside photographs of Dunham and her co-star, Adam Driver. In photographs by Annie Leibovitz, which are available for viewing online, Driver and Dunham are standing in the middle of a street, with Dunham sitting on Driver’s shoulders. In another photo the two actors share a bed.

In the article, Dunham discusses writers she admired in high school. Dunham names novelists Philip Roth, Sylvia Plath and others, whose confessional art helped mold her own.

“She came to regard candor as a powerful inventive tool: one that offered the energetic release of an uncorked bottle but also created a bond between artist and audience,” Heller writes of the younger Dunham. 

“Girls” airs every Sunday night on HBO.

Vogue: Lena Dunham, “hardest-working millennial in show business” Read More »

Omar Barghouti at UCLA: A speaker who brings hate

Omar Barghouti, co-founder of the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement, is on the road again with his anti-Israel show and its pack of bigotry and lies. On Jan. 15, UCLA’s Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP) hosted him at UCLA for his talk, “International Solidarity With Palestine: Towards a Global Intifada.” An apt title, although he piously insists his movement is nonviolent, he banged the drum for more bloodshed against Israeli Jews, for a fight to the finish that would undo the results of the 1948 war and be Zionism’s death knell. Nothing else would do.

For Barghouti, compromises that bring peace are unacceptable. As he said, if peace did not include the right of an allegedly 8 million diaspora Palestinians and Palestinian refugees living across the Middle East and elsewhere to “return” to Israel (a euphemism since 1949 for destroying Israel by turning Jews into a minority), peace would merely signify the “end of resistance to injustice,” and “contentment” with a “slave situation.” 

The event began with SJP laying out ground rules. No videotaping, no disruptive behavior, no loud noises, no standing up and blocking the view of the speakers. These are precisely the tactics that anti-Israel groups, led by SJP and the Muslim Student Union, have used to shout down or silence pro-Israel speakers and which in those cases they defended as “free speech.” It is unlikely that the organizer saw the irony.

A slick, seasoned propagandist who postures as a reasonable academic, Barghouti presented an alternate reality of falsehoods, perverse logic and scrambled principles worthy of the “big lies” perpetrated in 1930s Germany. He had clever, practiced answers to deflect most questions. The audience of approximately 120 people, mostly students who reflected UCLA’s diversity, could come away with only two clear messages: Israeli Jews and their supporters are racist and wantonly evil, and have deprived Palestinians of justice and of their humanity; and being anti-Israel aligns you with the romantic, heroic social justice movements of the past.

[Omar Barghouti at UCLA: No to BDS, no to occupation]

Indeed, Barghouti began by claiming that BDS follows the heroic legacy of Martin Luther King Jr., Nelson Mandela and the anti-apartheid movement, which was now “Palestine’s South Africa moment.” He insisted his calls for boycotts against Israel were akin to the boycotts of apartheid South Africa, conveniently ignoring the fact that they are more akin to the Arab nations’ historic boycotts against Jews. Arab leaders called for boycotts against the Jewish community in pre-state Israel in the 1930s; the Arab League instituted a cultural, economic and diplomatic boycott in 1945 before Israel was even re-established, and have maintained it since, though they relaxed it minimally in the 1990s.

Much of his litany of false accusations he’d presented before, cherry-picking anomalous examples or making up “facts,” such as that Israel steals Palestinian water (it gives Palestinians 30 percent more Israeli water than it even agreed to give in the Oslo Accords), and that checkpoints are choking Palestinians (B’Tselem, an Israeli human rights group very sympathetic to the Palestinians, reports there has been free movement in the West Bank for the past few years and the Israeli government reports that only nine checkpoints remain, which are manned only during terrorist alerts). He likes inventing terms to make his accusations seem more sinister. Absurdly claiming Israel is systematically destroying Palestinian education, he accused it of “scholasticide” and omitted the fact that he himself attended graduate school at Tel Aviv University. He praised the American Studies Association’s vote for an academic boycott of Israel, claiming it showed BDS was succeeding, despite the fact that the most prestigious American academic associations and more than 200 major universities unequivocally condemned the resolution as an assault on academic freedom and an unfair singling out of Israel.

But Barghouti didn’t stop there. 

He hurled blood libels. Israeli soldiers shoot Palestinian children “for sport.” Indeed, they “provoke” the children, “entice them like mice, and then shoot them” for no reason. Often, it is just because the soldiers are “bored.”

He justified terrorism against Israelis, defending the Palestinians’ right to “resistance by any means, including armed resistance.” When he insisted that the only way to end terrorism was to end the “root cause” — that is Israel’s alleged oppression of Palestinians — the audience erupted into finger snapping, the way college audiences show approval.

He shamelessly told lies. When asked how Israel could be called an apartheid state, given the prominent positions of Israeli Arabs in government and the judiciary, he snapped back that every evil system has its collaborators. He claimed there were even Jews in the Nazi government.

He declared that many large Jewish communities don’t accept a Jewish state and cited a Satmar rabbi for proof. When UCLA Hillel Rabbi Chaim Seidler-Feller interrupted to protest that the Satmars are only a fringe group that doesn’t represent the vast Jewish community, the organizer reprimanded him and threatened to have him removed. The rabbi stormed out, declaring, “This is anti-Semitic!”

Barghouti repeatedly denied that Jews are one of the indigenous peoples of the region. When an Israeli stood up and said he is a 10th-generation Israeli and indigenous, Barghouti scoffed. “You aren’t indigenous just because you say you are.” He allowed that colonialists could be indigenized but only if they melded and intermarried with the existing society, not if they sought to disenfranchise the real indigenous peoples. The Boers, he explained, described themselves as an indigenous people when they fought British colonialism. 

He denied that the Jewish people have a right to self-determination. They are not a people, he declaimed, and the United Nations’ principle of the right to self-determination applies only to colonized people who want to acquire their rights. While he insisted that Palestinians must have “the right to have rights,” he denied that the Jewish people had any collective rights.

He claimed that Israel’s fears about terrorism and potential massacres if there were a one-state solution are merely “projections” of what Israelis really want to do to Palestinians. Indeed, according to Barghouti, Israel’s self-defense measures are “routine terrorism.”

When asked what he is doing to bring Hamas, the popular Palestinian fundamentalist movement that oppresses women and minorities and wants to establish a theocracy, to share his supposedly progressive vision, he sidestepped the question. He said BDS can’t deal with every social rights issue. The anti-apartheid movement couldn’t deal with social and economic issues until it succeeded. Similarly, first the occupation must end, then these problems can be addressed. Meanwhile, Hamas violence and its violent ideology are excusable and even justifiable in Barghouti’s worldview.

I have often wondered what Jews or decent people could have done to push back against the anti-Semitic propaganda of 1930s Germany. I don’t know. But I do know that Omar Barghouti follows in that tradition of the “big lies,” the dehumanization of Israelis and incitement that would lead others to justify or excuse those who murder Israeli Jews. Historically, Jewish blood has been cheap too many times. It is critical that people
of good will mobilize to protest and discredit the lies, educate the public, and re-educate the students who have been misled by the heady blend of bigotry, idealism and furious outrage that animates extremists like Barghouti.


Roberta P. Seid, PhD, is Research/Education Director of StandWithUs.

Omar Barghouti at UCLA: A speaker who brings hate Read More »

Messianic? – Speaking about Kerry, Yaalon Made a Much Harsher Accusation

1.

It is funny how both left and right use “messianic” as the ultimate insult. But even if Defense Minister Yaalon should not have publically stated that State Secretary Kerry is “obsessive and messianic”, it doesn't mean he is not right in making this assessment. David Horovitz aptly summed it up in one sentence: “Ya’alon’s been thoroughly dumb. But he’s not entirely wrong”. In fact, a majority of Israelis would say that he is right. And while the Americans have been rushing to get some diplomatic mileage out of Yaalon's mistake – to “put Israel in its place, perhaps to put it on the defensive as Kerry comes back to continue his diplomatic efforts”, as Herb Keinon remarks – one would hope that this fact was not lost on them. One would hope that they realized that their initiative hardly impresses the Israeli public and its leadership. In other words, if you want to put a positive spin on Yaalon's carelessness, try this: He was a messenger that had to be sacrificed in order to send a clear message of dissent to the American mediator, a message that no polite disagreement behind closed doors can convey.

2.

The fact that the US decided to play hardball on this matter doesn't bode well for Israel's chances to come out on top in case negotiations fail. Let me explain: it is clear that Kerry intends to put a piece of paper on the table. It is also clear that Israel will try hard not to be the one rejecting the paper. It is also very possible that the paper will lead nowhere, and that Kerry's effort will come up short. What happens then? The thinking in Israel would be: if we accept the American paper, we will not be blamed when the effort doesn't provide results. Yet looking at the Yaalon-Kerry battle one gets the impression that the Americans are already laying the groundwork for blaming Israel – at least partially – if there's a failure. Obviously, Kerry would not blame himself in case of failure. And blaming the Palestinians is boring and fruitless – they are used to being blamed, and they care much less than Israel about having to cope with a campaign of denunciations (because Israel has a lot more to lose). Making the Yaalon remarks such a big issue might be a hint that Kerry already has a plan B in case of failure: blame Israel (partial blame would be enough to legitimize attempts to punish Israel).

3.

The personal insult to Kerry was a mistake, but Yaalon also has some serious accusations related to policy, not just personality: he says that the proposed American plan is dangerous to Israel's security. Yaalon – as we've seen in recent days – is not yet a very good diplomat. But he does know something about defense and security. I believe that most Israelis (me included) would trust his judgment regarding Israel's security needs much more than the judgment of the American experts sent here to make their own assessment. Accusing the US of proposing a plan that is dangerous to Israel is a much harsher accusation than “messianic”. 

 

Messianic? – Speaking about Kerry, Yaalon Made a Much Harsher Accusation Read More »

Finding God in neighborly kindness when disaster strikes

“The epicenter of the earthquake was under our kitchen. The house jumped 10 feet in the air, and my wife and I woke to the beautiful view of the San Fernando Valley,” Rabbi Ed Feinstein, 59, of  Valley Beth Shalom in Encino, recalled with dry humor.

Feinstein’s experience, as it was for many others who lived in his Granada Hills neighborhood, was traumatic. The back wall of his house, along with its windows, was smashed and destroyed, and its water heaters exploded. Feinstein and his family moved out of their home, which was uninhabitable, and eventually moved permanently into a new house in Encino.

Despite the similar trauma of many members of the Valley Beth Shalom community, synagogue leaders dove into action in the days after the earthquake. Leaders contacted every member of the synagogue and put together an emergency committee of lawyers, personal counselors and architects from the congregation who could help community members.

“We made sure everyone in the community who needed help was getting help,” said Feinstein, who was a rabbi at Valley Beth Shalom at the time. “The physical shockwaves left people feeling emotionally shaky. At the same time, there was a tremendous sense of bonding together to help one another. It was very special.”

The synagogue’s Hebrew classes resumed a week after the earthquake, and a wedding ceremony interrupted by an aftershock was improvised in the synagogue’s parking lot.

Feinstein also recalls acts of support in his neighborhood. A policeman neighbor and his son guarded the cul-de-sac on their block, since there was no police protection. A man driving around in a big yellow truck sold cases of water for the same price they cost at Costco, despite the higher profits he could have made.

“What we saw was the best of human beings,” Feinstein said. “When I had to explain to my kids where is God, I said, ‘God is in the yellow truck. God is with all the people who help their neighbors and give them support, and our job is to be part of that, too.”

Finding God in neighborly kindness when disaster strikes Read More »