fbpx
Thursday, July 9, 2020

Shoah Foundation Director: Amazon Must Cancel ‘Hunters’

https://jewishjournal.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/jj_avatar.jpg
Stephen Smith
Stephen D. Smith is Finci-Viterbi executive director of the USC Shoah Foundation.

Enjoying this article?

You'll love our roundtable.


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Jewish Journal, 3250 Wilshire Boulevard, Los Angeles, CA, 90010, http://www.jewishjournal.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

Hunters,” the heavily promoted new Amazon series about a ring of vigilantes chasing and torturing Nazis in Son of Sam-era New York, is entertaining. It’s also deceptive, voyeuristic, trivializing pulp nonsense that nevertheless claims to be, as its creator says, “representationally truthful.”

As a scholar of genocide and director of a global organization devoted to recording the testimonies of Holocaust survivors, I believe it’s the most egregious distortion of Holocaust history in my lifetime. The series, created by the well-intentioned grandson of a survivor, does not serve the memory of those it purports to respect. And I fear its pernicious blend of fact and fiction risks being weaponized by Holocaust deniers.

Amazon must not renew it for a second season.

I’m not averse to fictionalized depictions of the Holocaust; USC Shoah Foundation grew out of Steven Spielberg’s work on “Schindler’s List.” I learned a great deal from the 1978 miniseries “Holocaust.” I devoured “Man in the High Castle.” And just last year, our foundation partnered with “Jojo Rabbit,” which took us into the minds of 10-year-old Nazis with brutal elegance.

 

But “Hunters is dangerously different.

 

The problem is not the acting. Al Pacino and Carol Kane, in particular, are deeply convincing as survivors of the camps. The problem is not the production values, which are glossy, or the storytelling, which is engrossing.

The problem is the premise. Survivors of the Shoah sought justice, not revenge. Not so in “Hunters.” The series’ specious spectacle of eye-for-eye justice (a term one of the characters uses in the fifth episode) collapses all meaningful differences between victim and perpetrator. There’s a scene in the pilot in which Pacino’s vigilantes gas a former Nazi chemist in her shower, presented with all the dramatic flair of an action movie. Jews never gassed Nazis. Period. That I must even make this point is proof enough how perilous this slippery slope can become.

Much of the criticism of the show has revolved around its fabricated depiction of a human chessboard at Auschwitz. But worse is the invention of fake, especially sadistic Nazis who are presented as “famous,” leaving the viewer to do their own research to discover they never existed. Every day I hear testimonies — real testimonials, from survivors — that are horrific beyond imagination and yet true. If the filmmakers had taken the time and trouble to listen to some real experiences, the flashbacks to the Holocaust in the series could have been real things that happened to real people, rather than the fantasies of scriptwriters.

By blurring the line between fact and fiction, “Hunters muddies the historical record, disrespects those who perished, and provides ammunition to those who seek to deny the truth of the Holocaust.

We have been here before. “The Night Porter,” a 1974 Italian erotic psychological drama about former Nazis hiding their pasts, included depictions of their sadomasochistic activities during the war. The film drew acclaim and derision. Using the symbology of the camps to re-create a past that did not exist, and then sexualizing it, was clearly for the benefit of entertainment. The question became, did this entertainment come at the expense of those who died?

The 1997 comedy “Life Is Beautiful earned three Oscars — including Roberto Benigni  for lead actor — and widespread critical acclaim. But his mining of the Holocaust for comedic entertainment raised questions about using plausible scenarios that hadn’t occurred and thereby instrumentalizing the suffering of those who endured unimaginable horrors.

Similarly, in “Hunters,” the danger of plausible fiction is that it creates a sense of real history, just enough for viewers to suspend disbelief. It then becomes the story, even though it never happened. Later, by “disproving” this invented history, Holocaust deniers can argue that the veracity of all stories can be called into question.

 

When a story straddles the line of reality to make everything seem plausible, it crosses the lines of historical integrity and social good. If even a well-meaning audience can walk away confused about this historicity of the Holocaust, then we have done the work of anti-Semites for them.

When everything becomes possible, nothing becomes real. When anything might be true, everything might be false. The Shoah’s survivors know better. So should Amazon.


Stephen D. Smith is Finci-Viterbi executive director of the USC Shoah Foundation. 

Enjoyed this article?

You'll love our roundtable.


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Jewish Journal, 3250 Wilshire Boulevard, Los Angeles, CA, 90010, http://www.jewishjournal.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

Latest Articles

Gloria Steinem to Marry Roxane Gay and Debbie Millman in Jewish Ceremony

"We're going to do some of the traditions: the chuppah, the breaking of the glass, and so on."

Rosner’s Torah Talk: Parshat Pinchas with Rabbis Rice

Rabbi Laurie Rice and Rabbi Philip Rice ("Flip") lead congregation Micah in Nashville, TN. Rabbi Laurie hails from Los Angeles, California, and was ordained by the...

U.S. Anti-Semitism Envoy Calls J Street Annexation Image Anti-Semitic, J Street Accuses Envoy of ‘Bad Faith’

"Their imagery uses Antisemitism and crude anti-Semitic conspiracy theories to advance their agenda."

Stumbling Upon French Jewish History

It’s only because I got lost, and it’s only because I’m an inexperienced driver who white-knuckles the wheel when I drive stick-shift anywhere that’s...

Pittsburgh Steeler Zach Banner Calls on NFL to Address Anti-Semitism

Jews have been donating to Banner's charity in appreciation.

Washington Police Officer Says He Will Remove Tattoo Resembling Insignia of Nazi SS

(JTA) — A police officer in Walla Walla, Washington, said he will remove his tattoo resembling the insignia of the SS, the Nazi paramilitary...

Find the Nazi! [Video]

The Bundestag, the German parliament, passed a motion in early July 2020 condemning Israel for its "annexation plans," a largely inaccurate term used to...

Tribeca Drive-In Presents Classic Movies and Comedy

Drive-in movie theaters largely went extinct in the age of the multiplex, but they’re having a renaissance during pandemic times. Tribeca Drive-in is bringing...

Julian Edelman Invites DeSean Jackson to Have ‘Uncomfortable Conversations’ About Anti-Semitism and Black Lives Matter

“I know he said some ugly things, but I do see an opportunity to have a conversation.”

Do We Really Have to Read Beinart Again?

Had I not known Peter Beinart’s periodic cries for attention, I’d probably be angry with his chutzpah.

Culture

Gloria Steinem to Marry Roxane Gay and Debbie Millman in Jewish Ceremony

"We're going to do some of the traditions: the chuppah, the breaking of the glass, and so on."

Pittsburgh Steeler Zach Banner Calls on NFL to Address Anti-Semitism

Jews have been donating to Banner's charity in appreciation.

Tribeca Drive-In Presents Classic Movies and Comedy

Drive-in movie theaters largely went extinct in the age of the multiplex, but they’re having a renaissance during pandemic times. Tribeca Drive-in is bringing...

Julian Edelman Invites DeSean Jackson to Have ‘Uncomfortable Conversations’ About Anti-Semitism and Black Lives Matter

“I know he said some ugly things, but I do see an opportunity to have a conversation.”

Pittsburgh Steeler Gets Emotional Speaking Out About DeSean Jackson and Anti-Semitism

"I stand in solidarity with all my Jewish brothers and sisters."

Latest Articles
Latest

Gloria Steinem to Marry Roxane Gay and Debbie Millman in Jewish Ceremony

"We're going to do some of the traditions: the chuppah, the breaking of the glass, and so on."

Rosner’s Torah Talk: Parshat Pinchas with Rabbis Rice

Rabbi Laurie Rice and Rabbi Philip Rice ("Flip") lead congregation Micah in Nashville, TN. Rabbi Laurie hails from Los Angeles, California, and was ordained by the...

U.S. Anti-Semitism Envoy Calls J Street Annexation Image Anti-Semitic, J Street Accuses Envoy of ‘Bad Faith’

"Their imagery uses Antisemitism and crude anti-Semitic conspiracy theories to advance their agenda."

Stumbling Upon French Jewish History

It’s only because I got lost, and it’s only because I’m an inexperienced driver who white-knuckles the wheel when I drive stick-shift anywhere that’s...

Pittsburgh Steeler Zach Banner Calls on NFL to Address Anti-Semitism

Jews have been donating to Banner's charity in appreciation.

Hollywood

‘Expecting Amy’ Highlights a New Comedy Dynamic of Jewish Mothers Making, Not Being, the Jokes

Jewish moms like Amy Schumer, who were once the material, have become the premier comics of this age.

Russell Crowe Asked Jared Kushner for Advice on How to Portray Former Fox News CEO Roger Ailes

Crowe said he asked Kushner for the advice at Hugh Jackman’s 50th birthday party.

Ice Cube Denies Report He Ordered Entourage to Beat up a Rabbi

Above the letter he wrote “Don’t play with me. This is just phase one.”

Podcasts

Pandemic Times Episode 67: What is the root of anti-Semitism?

New David Suissa Podcast Every Monday, Wednesday and Friday. A conversation with David Weinberg of the ADL on fighting anti-Semitism in the greater Middle East region. How...

Is Annexation Good for Israel?

July 1 was a date some Israelis were looking forward to. For the past few months, most Israelis have been speaking about one thing,...

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Jewish Journal, 3250 Wilshire Boulevard, Los Angeles, CA, 90010, http://www.jewishjournal.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

x