fbpx

A Moment in Time: Three Reflections in reaction to Nice

[additional-authors]
July 15, 2016

Dear all,

Torah teaches that Adam and Eve had two sons, Cain and Abel.  We don't know too much about them.  But we do know that Cain rose up and murdered his brother.

Perhaps Cain was like many of the disenfranchised young men we find in the world today.  He felt marginalized and unwanted.  He didn't seem to fit it.  He was angry. 
And he was out of touch with reality.

After Cain committed this heinous crime, God asks, “Where is your brother?”

Cain responds, “Am I my brother's keeper?”

God then says, “The bloods of your brother are crying out to Me from the earth.”


This Shabbat, as our world cringes in the aftermath of Nice, we need to reflect on
these three excerpts.

We need to ask ourselves, “Where is my brother?”  In other words, we need to be mindful of all humanity on the face of the earth.  We need to be aware of what they
are doing, how they are thinking, and who is influencing them.  We are dealing with Islamic Fundamentalist Terrorism, a cancer that eradicates traditional boundaries. 
We can't have our heads buried in the sand.  We need to be able to answer God's question:  “Where is my brother?”

Am I my brother's keeper?”  Torah doesn't answer this in words.  But I will respond:  YES.  We are responsible for what our brothers do.  We must speak up.  We must speak out.  We all must step up to the plate.

The bloods of your brother are crying out to Me from the earth.”  My grammar teacher would have failed me if I wrote an original sentence like this.  But as the
original Hebrew includes this phrase, our rabbis seek meaning.  They teach that it
was not only Abel who died, but all of Abel's descendants.  It is therefore the bloods
of each future human being that would have come from Abel – each soul is crying out.  From this story, the Talmud teaches, “If you destroy a single life, it is as though you have destroyed the world.”  In Nice, it is not 80 (at last count) who were murdered…. 
It was the 80 – and all the possibilities they could have produced.


Please, please, reflect on these excerpts.  The epidemic of modern day “Cains” is overwhelming (in addition to the fundamentalist crisis, think of all the non-religious based shootings in this country). 

And so … we have a responsibility.  We can make a difference.  And we need to listen, really listen, to the voices that are calling out to us.

Wishing you all a Shabbat of peace,

Rabbi Zach Shapiro

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

Post-Passover Pasta and Pizza

What carbs do you miss the most during Passover? Do you go for the sweet stuff, like cookies and cakes, or heartier items like breads and pasta?

Freedom, This Year

There is something deeply cyclical about Judaism and our holidays. We return to the same story—the same words, the same questions—but we are not the same people telling it. And that changes everything.

A Diary Amidst Division and the Fight for Freedom

Emma’s diary represents testimony of an America, and an American Jewish community, torn asunder during America’s strenuous effort to manifest its founding ideal of the equality of all people who were created in the image of God.

More than Names

On Yom HaShoah, we speak of six million who were murdered. But I also remember the nine million who lived. Nine million Jews who got up every morning, took their children to school, and strove every day to survive, because they believed in life.

Gratitude

Gratitude is greatly emphasized in much of Jewish observance, from blessings before and after meals, the celebration of holidays such as Passover, a festival that celebrates liberation from slavery, and in the psalms.

Freedom’s Unfinished Journey

The seder table itself is a model of radical welcome: we are told explicitly to invite the stranger, to make room for those who ask questions and for those who do not yet know how to ask.

Thoughts on Security

For students at Jewish schools, armed guards, security gates, and ID checks are now woven into the rhythm of daily life.

Can Playgrounds Defeat Antisemitism?

The playground in Jerusalem didn’t stop antisemitism, and renovating playgrounds in New York City is not likely to stop it there, either — because antisemitism in America today is not rooted in a lack of slides or swings.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.