fbpx

It’s Never a Good Idea to Hit a Rock – a Love Poem for Water for Torah Portion Chukat

[additional-authors]
July 15, 2016

Oh water, source of life,
when I need you, I need you
which is all the time.

Oh water, you can’t blame
Moses for striking the rock
instead of talking to it.

These days, and those days
if you talk to a rock, no one
will listen. Not even the rock.

Oh water, if you can get
the rock to listen, be kind.
Even the rock will grow

deaf ears if you issue
demands with fury. Surely
you’re not angry with the rock?

It’s not the rock’s job to
give water anyway. Why
are you yelling at the rock?

Why are you hitting the rock?
What made you think the
rock would want to

develop any kind of flow?
Is this how you get what you
want? Is this how even

a rock should be treated?
Oh water, I need you like I
need you. I’m mostly you.

The best parts anyway.
Satisfying. Sustaining. Wet.
Is that redundant? Sorry,

wet is your best feature.
Oh water. Where am I going
with you? Rivers go where

they go and I’m just along
for the ride. Forty years in now
and there’s the Jordan.

Oh water it’s filled with you
and it won’t be long before
we cross over. Most of us.

We’re dropping like flies
in the desert. A sister, a brother
a generation of people who

remember Egypt’s soil. Gone.
Oh water will you recognize us
when we get there?

We can almost taste the
land that was promised.
Sorry about the yelling.

Sorry about the stick.
We couldn’t do this
without you.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

A Nod from the Judges

Noam Bettan taught them something important through his performance. He showed them that despite the adversity they may face in the future, they can press on and still create something meaningful; that they can rise above the screaming crowds of detractors.

Christians, Jews and America

The Trump administration’s active participation and sponsorship of activities like last weekend’s prayer service makes many of us feel like we are unwelcome when patriotic gatherings take on overtly religious overtones.

Finding Love, From Inglewood to Jerusalem

It’s not easy to think about love during times of crisis. When the battles facing us are so hard, we don’t look for emotions that appear soft. When we’re surrounded by hate, we don’t run to something like love.

Antisemitism Un-Masked on Broadway

The play “Giant” and its urgent, timely message could not have come sooner—in part because it clashes with the antisemitism we see on the news. Today a dandy like Dahl is not the problem. What we are all witnessing now is low-class thuggery prowling city streets.

The Book and the Sword

You must keep one foot in the sanctuary even while going out to war; and you must go out to war even when your heart yearns to remain in the sanctuary.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.