Elon Musk is not an antisemite. Full stop.
An antisemite doesn’t rush to Israel to show his support for the Jewish state after Oct 7. An antisemite doesn’t consistently support the plight of innocent Israeli hostages still being beaten starved, raped, kidnapped and murdered by Hamas while these terrorists are given a moral free pass by much of the world starting with the United Nations. An antisemite doesn’t visit Auschwitz Birkenau with a Holocaust survivor and Rabbi Menachem Margolin, an important European Jewish leader, and then participate in a memorial at the site of the gas chambers and crematoria at Birkenau. An antisemite does not declare after that visit that in his own words he is “Jewish by Association.”
We live in a world where real antisemites and antisemitism have become the norm at storied elite universities like Columbia and Harvard. We live in a world where synagogues and Jewish day care centers are targeted in Australia. We live in a world where religious Jews on the streets of world class cities from Sydney to Toronto to Berlin, Paris, Amsterdam, and New York must think twice if it safe to wear a kippah or a Star of David necklace.
We live in a world where Jew-hatred is the statecraft of Iran and where antisemites and terrorists can count on the deep pockets of some leaders in the Middle East to spread the wildfires of hatred.
Mr. Musk, in the world we live in today, you now have greater responsibilities to yourself and society. Because you are a person who redefines trailblazer and innovator, a person for whom the heavens are not too distant to dream about and reach out to on behalf of humankind, and now because you are a key member of President Trump’s new administration.
Please remember that you are not infallible. No human being is. And so, it would be prudent for you and important for the future of democracy around the world, and here in the United States, that it would be wrong to endorse a political party in Germany, which includes in its ranks people who refuse to learn from the past, who see no reason to visit a Nazi death Camp, unless it would be to mock the six million.
In a democracy, you and every other American have every right to address controversial issues, including immigration and closed borders. However, as a man who now represents all Americans, as the activist owner of the global X social media platform, and the leading proponent of maximum free speech, you also have the responsibility to take these powerful positions into account when declaring your views through word and deed.
Finally, it would be a mistake to assume that anyone criticizing you is automatically an enemy. Quite the contrary. Young people especially look to you as a visionary role model. Help them understand your ideas, ideals, and goals with clarity not only when it comes to technology and the sciences but in the domain of moral clarity.
May we all learn from and be inspired by Simon Wiesenthal’s words:
“Freedom is not a gift from Heaven. We must fight for it each and every day.”
Rabbi Marvin Hier is Emeritus Founder and CEO of the Simon Wiesenthal Center. Rabbi Abraham Cooper is Director of Global Social Action of the Simon Wiesenthal Center and immediate past Chair of the US Commission on International Religious Freedom.
Elon Musk is No Antisemite but He Now Has Greater Obligations
Marvin Hier and Abraham Cooper
Elon Musk is not an antisemite. Full stop.
An antisemite doesn’t rush to Israel to show his support for the Jewish state after Oct 7. An antisemite doesn’t consistently support the plight of innocent Israeli hostages still being beaten starved, raped, kidnapped and murdered by Hamas while these terrorists are given a moral free pass by much of the world starting with the United Nations. An antisemite doesn’t visit Auschwitz Birkenau with a Holocaust survivor and Rabbi Menachem Margolin, an important European Jewish leader, and then participate in a memorial at the site of the gas chambers and crematoria at Birkenau. An antisemite does not declare after that visit that in his own words he is “Jewish by Association.”
We live in a world where real antisemites and antisemitism have become the norm at storied elite universities like Columbia and Harvard. We live in a world where synagogues and Jewish day care centers are targeted in Australia. We live in a world where religious Jews on the streets of world class cities from Sydney to Toronto to Berlin, Paris, Amsterdam, and New York must think twice if it safe to wear a kippah or a Star of David necklace.
We live in a world where Jew-hatred is the statecraft of Iran and where antisemites and terrorists can count on the deep pockets of some leaders in the Middle East to spread the wildfires of hatred.
Mr. Musk, in the world we live in today, you now have greater responsibilities to yourself and society. Because you are a person who redefines trailblazer and innovator, a person for whom the heavens are not too distant to dream about and reach out to on behalf of humankind, and now because you are a key member of President Trump’s new administration.
Please remember that you are not infallible. No human being is. And so, it would be prudent for you and important for the future of democracy around the world, and here in the United States, that it would be wrong to endorse a political party in Germany, which includes in its ranks people who refuse to learn from the past, who see no reason to visit a Nazi death Camp, unless it would be to mock the six million.
In a democracy, you and every other American have every right to address controversial issues, including immigration and closed borders. However, as a man who now represents all Americans, as the activist owner of the global X social media platform, and the leading proponent of maximum free speech, you also have the responsibility to take these powerful positions into account when declaring your views through word and deed.
Finally, it would be a mistake to assume that anyone criticizing you is automatically an enemy. Quite the contrary. Young people especially look to you as a visionary role model. Help them understand your ideas, ideals, and goals with clarity not only when it comes to technology and the sciences but in the domain of moral clarity.
May we all learn from and be inspired by Simon Wiesenthal’s words:
“Freedom is not a gift from Heaven. We must fight for it each and every day.”
Rabbi Marvin Hier is Emeritus Founder and CEO of the Simon Wiesenthal Center. Rabbi Abraham Cooper is Director of Global Social Action of the Simon Wiesenthal Center and immediate past Chair of the US Commission on International Religious Freedom.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
Jay Ruderman: Meaningful Activism – Not Intimidation – Makes Change Possible
It’s Good to Be a Jew
Are We Ready for Human Connection Through Glasses?
The Israel Independence Day Test: Can You Rejoice That Israel Is?
I Am the Afflicted – A poem for Parsha Tazria Metzora
BagelFest West at Wilshire Boulevard Temple, Yom HaShoah at Pan Pacific Park
A Bisl Torah — But It’s True!
Even if the information is true, one who speaks disparagingly about another is guilty of lashon hara, evil speech.
A Moment in Time: Rooted in Time
Pioneers of Jewish Alien Fire
Print Issue: We the Israelites | April 17, 2026
What will define the Jewish future is not antisemitism but how we respond to it. Embracing our Maccabean spirit would be a good start.
Cerf’s Up!
As the publisher and co-founder of Random House, Bennett Cerf was one of the most important figures in 20th-century culture and literature.
‘Out of the Sky: Heroism and Rebirth in Nazi Europe’
As Matti Friedman demonstrates in his riveting new book, one of Israel’s greatest legends is also riddled with mysteries and open questions.
Family Ties Center ‘This Is Not About Us’
The book is not a single narrative but a novel of interconnected stories, each laced with irony, poignancy, and hilarity.
‘The Kid Officer’: Recalling an Extraordinary Life
Are We Still Comfortably Numb?
Forgiving someone on behalf of a community that is not yours is not forgiveness. It is opportunism dressed up as virtue.
Don’t Dismantle the Watchdogs — Pluralism Is Still Our Best Defense
Although institutional change can be slow, Jewish organizations fighting antisemitism have made progress…Critics may have some legitimate concerns about mission drift — but this is solved with accountability, not defunding.
A Sephardic Love Story–Eggplant Burekas
The transmission of these bureka recipes from generation to generation is a way of retaining heritage and history in Sephardic communities around the world.
National Picnic Day
There is nothing like spreading a soft blanket out in the shade and enjoying some delicious food with friends and family.
Table for Five: Tazria Metzora
Spiritual Purification
Israelis Are Winning Their War for Survival … But Are American Jews Losing It?
Israelis must become King David Jews, fighting when necessary while building a glittering Zion. Diaspora Jews must become Queen Esther Jews. Fit in. Prosper. Decipher your foreign lands’ cultural codes. But be literate, proud, brave Jews.
We, the Israelites: Embracing Our Maccabean Spirit
No one should underestimate the difficulty of the past few years. But what will define us is not the level or nature of the problem but how we deal with it.
Rosner’s Domain | Imagine There’s No Enemy …
Before Israel’s week of Remembrance and Independence, it is proper to reflect on the inherent tension between dreams and their realization.
John Lennon’s Dream – And Where It Fell Short
His message of love — hopeful, expansive, humane — inspired genuine moral progress. It fostered hope that humanity might ultimately converge toward those ideals. In too many parts of the world, that expectation collided with societies that did not share those assumptions.
Journeys to the Promised Land
Just as the Torah concludes with the people about to enter the Promised Land, leaders are successful when the connections we make reveal within us the humility to encounter the Infinite.
A Suitcase of Diamonds: Meditation on Friendship
It is made of humility, forged from the understanding that even with all our strengths, we desperately need one another.
Should We Be Surprised by Right-Wing Antisemitic Conspiracy Theories?
We should not be surprised that conspiratorial antisemitism has reemerged in the current circumstances. But there is a deep reason that ties it specifically to the right.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.