“How are you doing today? How are you guys holding up?” How can I possibly answer that question? We are physically safe for now. We are at home in Jerusalem. My children are too young to serve in the army. My husband doesn’t have Reserve duty, so he is around. I feel guilty admitting that I spend many hours of the day feeling so not okay. There are thousands of families who have more rights than I do to feeling “not okay” – families of soldiers on active duty, families of reservists, families who lived through the absolute horrors that took place in the South, and relatives and friends of all the families and soldiers who didn’t live through it. Thousands upon thousands of people affected and mourning, but as it turns out, there is still enough “not okay” to go around.
In raising our kids in Israel, which is deeply wrought with a pervading sense of us and them (Jews vs Arabs, religious vs irreligious, charedi vs Zionistic, Right vs Left, etc) we always emphasize that no one group is all good and no one group is all bad. There can be rotten eggs anywhere, but for the most part, humanity wants to live and let live, and we just need to follow our own moral compass. How can I, in good conscience, continue to tell them that? I wish I could shelter them from knowing of the complete and utter barbarism that was carried out here just a few days ago. I wish I could have sheltered myself too.
I don’t believe in lying to children; we told them the simplified truth when we learned about what was going on “A large group of terrorists from Gaza managed to cross into Israel, and they took control of several settlements. Unfortunately, many people were killed, and some people were kidnapped and taken into Gaza. The army is bringing a lot of soldiers down there to get control back, and we are now at war.” This is not my children’s first rodeo. They know what terrorists are, they know what Gaza is, and they know what the air raid sirens we were hearing meant. But I naively pray that they’ll never have to know the facts of what really went on there, and never have to encounter such pure evil and hatred.
I can handle navigating a slew of complicated existential questions from my kids, but when my sweet caring 8-year-old daughter turned to me one night and asked the simplest question of all, “But why? Why do they hate us so much?” I have no answer for her. She also asked why couldn’t we just share the area that they wanted. I told her we already tried that, and that’s how Gaza came to exist in the first place. Our family’s moral compass doesn’t work here.
Here we are, several days in, and we are still far from “okay”. I haven’t slept a full night’s sleep in days, I lie awake listening to fighter jets flying back and forth through all hours of the night. Between the knots in my stomach and the pit in my throat, I have no appetite, I haven’t eaten a full meal in days.
I try to put on a good face for my kids and sometimes I can disconnect from everything going on outside and move along with my life…until my ears start pulsing again from the sound of explosions in the distance. Will the next barrage be aimed at us? Where are my slippers and hoodie if we have to run out to the bomb shelter again? And my kids, they’re rockstars; they’re calm and collected and know precisely what to do when the siren goes off. They know to drop what they’re doing and go straight to the shelter. Even my 3-year-old daughter knows what to do, “Mommy, are the booms done yet?”
But when my thoughts aren’t occupied by other distractions and dealing with my family’s needs, I am just consumed. Consumed by worrying about and praying for all the soldiers who are fighting on the front lines now. Soldiers who were like younger brothers to me growing up, soldiers who are loving sons of dear friends and neighbors of ours. Consumed by imagining the nightmare scenes unfolding.
We’re considered a “low danger” zone, so we have the maximum amount of time to get to a shelter if there is an air raid siren – 90 seconds. We can handle that — a 90-second sprint can get us pretty far, even with a toddler in tow. I think about all the families in the 15-second zones who probably haven’t left their shelters in days.
The only way through this is through faith and support. I am a person of faith, and I believe that G-d runs the world. Something good will come of this; it is all part of a plan, and maybe the most crucial – it is all out of my hands. The only thing I am personally in a position to do is to pray, and pray, and pray and support the people around me.
Everyone’s overwhelming desire to help is inspiring. A need arises and is filled within seconds. Families of reservists are getting home-cooked meals delivered to their door as soon as they ask. Other families of reservists are getting care packages even if they don’t ask for them – because everyone wants them to know that we care, and no one is in this alone. People are willing to stand in line for hours on end just to donate blood. Carloads of treats, snacks, and supplies are being delivered to army bases all over the country to help raise soldiers’ morale, all the time.
Now it is a gorgeous, clear day outside. Maybe we’ll venture out to the park this afternoon to stretch our legs and get fresh air. Then we’ll come home, look for something to make for dinner, throw in a load of laundry, and sit down to pray some more. Because even when you’re “not okay”, life moves on. We keep putting one foot in front of the other, and tomorrow will be a new day.
Ariella Tenenbaum grew up in Venice, California. She made Aliyah as a teenager and now lives in Jerusalem with her husband and four children.
No, We’re Not Okay
Ariella Tenenbaum
“How are you doing today? How are you guys holding up?” How can I possibly answer that question? We are physically safe for now. We are at home in Jerusalem. My children are too young to serve in the army. My husband doesn’t have Reserve duty, so he is around. I feel guilty admitting that I spend many hours of the day feeling so not okay. There are thousands of families who have more rights than I do to feeling “not okay” – families of soldiers on active duty, families of reservists, families who lived through the absolute horrors that took place in the South, and relatives and friends of all the families and soldiers who didn’t live through it. Thousands upon thousands of people affected and mourning, but as it turns out, there is still enough “not okay” to go around.
In raising our kids in Israel, which is deeply wrought with a pervading sense of us and them (Jews vs Arabs, religious vs irreligious, charedi vs Zionistic, Right vs Left, etc) we always emphasize that no one group is all good and no one group is all bad. There can be rotten eggs anywhere, but for the most part, humanity wants to live and let live, and we just need to follow our own moral compass. How can I, in good conscience, continue to tell them that? I wish I could shelter them from knowing of the complete and utter barbarism that was carried out here just a few days ago. I wish I could have sheltered myself too.
I don’t believe in lying to children; we told them the simplified truth when we learned about what was going on “A large group of terrorists from Gaza managed to cross into Israel, and they took control of several settlements. Unfortunately, many people were killed, and some people were kidnapped and taken into Gaza. The army is bringing a lot of soldiers down there to get control back, and we are now at war.” This is not my children’s first rodeo. They know what terrorists are, they know what Gaza is, and they know what the air raid sirens we were hearing meant. But I naively pray that they’ll never have to know the facts of what really went on there, and never have to encounter such pure evil and hatred.
I can handle navigating a slew of complicated existential questions from my kids, but when my sweet caring 8-year-old daughter turned to me one night and asked the simplest question of all, “But why? Why do they hate us so much?” I have no answer for her. She also asked why couldn’t we just share the area that they wanted. I told her we already tried that, and that’s how Gaza came to exist in the first place. Our family’s moral compass doesn’t work here.
Here we are, several days in, and we are still far from “okay”. I haven’t slept a full night’s sleep in days, I lie awake listening to fighter jets flying back and forth through all hours of the night. Between the knots in my stomach and the pit in my throat, I have no appetite, I haven’t eaten a full meal in days.
I try to put on a good face for my kids and sometimes I can disconnect from everything going on outside and move along with my life…until my ears start pulsing again from the sound of explosions in the distance. Will the next barrage be aimed at us? Where are my slippers and hoodie if we have to run out to the bomb shelter again? And my kids, they’re rockstars; they’re calm and collected and know precisely what to do when the siren goes off. They know to drop what they’re doing and go straight to the shelter. Even my 3-year-old daughter knows what to do, “Mommy, are the booms done yet?”
But when my thoughts aren’t occupied by other distractions and dealing with my family’s needs, I am just consumed. Consumed by worrying about and praying for all the soldiers who are fighting on the front lines now. Soldiers who were like younger brothers to me growing up, soldiers who are loving sons of dear friends and neighbors of ours. Consumed by imagining the nightmare scenes unfolding.
We’re considered a “low danger” zone, so we have the maximum amount of time to get to a shelter if there is an air raid siren – 90 seconds. We can handle that — a 90-second sprint can get us pretty far, even with a toddler in tow. I think about all the families in the 15-second zones who probably haven’t left their shelters in days.
The only way through this is through faith and support. I am a person of faith, and I believe that G-d runs the world. Something good will come of this; it is all part of a plan, and maybe the most crucial – it is all out of my hands. The only thing I am personally in a position to do is to pray, and pray, and pray and support the people around me.
Everyone’s overwhelming desire to help is inspiring. A need arises and is filled within seconds. Families of reservists are getting home-cooked meals delivered to their door as soon as they ask. Other families of reservists are getting care packages even if they don’t ask for them – because everyone wants them to know that we care, and no one is in this alone. People are willing to stand in line for hours on end just to donate blood. Carloads of treats, snacks, and supplies are being delivered to army bases all over the country to help raise soldiers’ morale, all the time.
Now it is a gorgeous, clear day outside. Maybe we’ll venture out to the park this afternoon to stretch our legs and get fresh air. Then we’ll come home, look for something to make for dinner, throw in a load of laundry, and sit down to pray some more. Because even when you’re “not okay”, life moves on. We keep putting one foot in front of the other, and tomorrow will be a new day.
Ariella Tenenbaum grew up in Venice, California. She made Aliyah as a teenager and now lives in Jerusalem with her husband and four children.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
Unbreakable Bond: From Einstein’s $500 Bond to $57 Billion in Israel Bonds
Kitchri—Comfort and Culture in a Bowl
Everyone Screams for Ice Cream in July: Culturally and Creamy Rich Recipes from Pati Jinich
Great Grilled Grub for National Grilling Month
A Moment in Time: On Sabbatical
Table for Five: Devarim
Letter from Los Angeles
A Jewish Angeleno looks back several decades and wonders whether the golden age of LA Jewry is behind us.
Dear England: Don’t Cry for Thee Argentina
When England took a 1-0 lead early in the second half, I felt a sense of cosmic justice. Sixty years is a long time. Argentina won it the last time. Maybe it was England’s turn.
The Admirable Epstein: ‘Mr. Moonlight: Brian Epstein and the Making of the Beatles‘
The Beatles’ manager’s life makes “a wonderfully inspiring and terribly sad story.”
Summer in Israel: Still Waiting for Tourists to Return
Restaurants, gift shops, hotels and car rental companies have all been hit hard by the ongoing war. The blow to the economy is evident almost everywhere you go.
Rosner’s Domain | Can You Be a Zionist Without Zionism?
Do you want to convince Jews, and the world, that Zionism is a cause worth supporting? Explain what “Zionism” is, and perhaps it will turn out that the world is actually on our side.
The Story This Moment Needs
In this moment of rising antisemitism, I’ve noticed that the way I remember, and retell, my own childhood has changed too.
The Jewish Tree of Life and American Tree of Liberty
The Kristallnacht Monument and the Question of Whether to Stop
Miniature, polite gestures of memorialization serve neither as insurance against future catastrophes nor as tributes to the victims. So should we stop to acknowledge them?
Jewish Donors: Don’t Walk Away
Do not give up on institutions — but do not disengage from the responsibility to hold them accountable.
Capping the Fire Hydrant
For close to 30 years, we forked up whatever we could afford and were happy to do it. It was now time for them to experience the exhilaration of staring at a pile of bills, not knowing where the money would come from.
Lindsey Graham’s Last Dream
It is difficult to see another member of Congress or administration official capable of moving a possible Israel-Saudi deal to fruition.
L.A. Jewish Leaders Split Over Rahm Emanuel’s Israel Speech
During his roughly 30-minute speech, he warned that Israel had become a “prisoner of its own tools” and that the American-Israel relationship, although historically strong, was “at a crossroads.”
When Confronting Israel Becomes a Career Strategy, Who Speaks for California?
At a moment when California faces soaring costs, housing shortages, energy challenges, water insecurity and mounting technological competition from China, Ro Khanna chose to travel halfway around the world in pursuit of yet another public confrontation with America’s closest and best ally in the Middle East.
Bar-Ilan University and Sheba Medical Center Joining Forces for Biotech Innovation Institute With $120 Million Investment
This $120 million investment is modeled after the American NIH, and it will accelerate the timeline from lab discovery to clinical treatment.
Jew Hatred is an Emotion. Discrimination is the Evidence.
Just like any emotion or any label, hate can be denied. What is much harder to deny is one set of rules for the world and another for the Jews. That’s not an emotion. It’s an action.
The Movie Europe Doesn’t Want You to See
“Citizen Vigilante” serves as a warning to governments that if they don’t secure their borders, enforce laws, and protect their most vulnerable, ordinary people will resort to self-help.
Why Was Platner’s Nazi Tattoo Tolerable?
Why America Wins When Europe and Israel Stand Together
Hasan Piker and the Narrative about Israel – Untethered to Reality and Harming the Cause of Palestine
The only hope for a better future is to turn the Palestinians away from Hamas and back on the path of building their economy and a democratic society that conceivably could regain the trust of Israelis.
Who is Going to Disarm Them?
No one else is willing to pay the price except Israel which understands its survival depends on it.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.