fbpx

When ‘Never Forget’ Goes Too Far

Virtual reality should not be applied to Holocaust remembrance.
[additional-authors]
June 19, 2020
The Hall of Names at Yad Vashem in Jerusalem; Photo from Deposit Photos

On May 11, The New York Times ran a disturbing story about a proposed design for the Babyn Yar Holocaust Memorial Center, the site of the Ukrainian massacre of 33,771 Jews by Nazi forces in 1941. The center’s design, envisioned by filmmaker Ilya Khrzhanovsky, proposed to sort visitors into “victims” or “executioners” and then conduct a role-playing exercise that uses virtual reality to re-create the event. Such a plan would be revolting. 

Museums and educational settings often employ historical re-enactments. For decades, high schools, camps and museums have run Underground Railroad re-enactments, in which “fugitive slaves” crawl through forests and lakes under the cover of night to reach “freedom.” Civil War re-enactors can be seen on the grounds of Gettysburg. Even a Titanic exhibit in San Diego offers a degree of personalization by issuing visitors a passport of a real passenger to follow throughout the exhibition. These types of re-enactments offer a chance for the visitor to become not just an observer, but a witness to history.  

Re-enactment can seem especially appealing to those committed to Holocaust remembrance. Jews are taught to “Never Forget” the Holocaust by attending museums, talking to survivors  and going on programs such as March of the Living. By immersing oneself in the stories and sites of the Holocaust, the veil between then and now thins, and the commitment to memorialize becomes not just about the survivors, but each subsequent generation of Jews. Tastefully done, museums can imbue this sense of timelessness and deeper engagement: The Museum of Tolerance in Los Angeles, for example, has visitors walk through the two doors — “Able Bodied” and “Children and Others” — that were used to send Jews to manual labor or to the gas chambers. 

No depiction could fully capture the horror of those who lived through the Holocaust.

But the design for the Babyn Yar memorial contorts this charge to memorialize. Most glaringly, the proposed design sought to use personality tests to sort individuals into Nazis and Jews, which is nightmarish and disgusting. But on a deeper level, combining individuals’ traits with historical identities is disturbing because it overwrites the identities of real perpetrators and victims with ours. This degree of immersion removes the ability to imagine ourselves as the victims, and instead we become them. And with virtual reality showing the events in “real time,” we override the experiences of victims and perpetrators with that of our own. Rather than remember, we erase. 

Re-enactment also risks shutting down productive dialogue. Many survivors kept silent for decades after the Holocaust, largely because the experiences were so traumatizing. The virtual reality programming proposed by Khrzhanovsky risks creating that same type of trauma for visitors playing perpetrator and victim almost 80 years later. Rather than fostering deeper, more meaningful engagement with the Holocaust, Babyn Yar’s proposed programming would flood visitors’ with such fear, shame and terror that the emotions could utterly overwhelm any attempts to understand and process the event. It’s estimated that as many as 150,000 people, including Soviet prisoners of war and Roma, were killed there. 

At its worst, the Babyn Yar memorial ignores the role of the post-Holocaust generation. The descendants of survivors didn’t experience the events of the Holocaust firsthand. Their charge, then, is to bear witness to history by making the events of the Holocaust tangible enough that younger generations can understand how they occurred and how it can prevent them. That diverse effort is achieved by passing on stories through museums, plays, shows and songs, often sparking debates over depictions that teeter between the powerful and the pastiche. Critically, these depictions are subservient to the knowledge, experiences and stories of the survivors — no depiction could fully capture the horror of those who lived through the Holocaust, nor should any portrayal try to. Khrzhanovsky’s design takes “bear witness” too literally, boasting an experience that detracts from the post-Holocaust’s generation of passing on stories from one to the other.

As the number of Holocaust survivors dwindles, the Jewish community must make critical decisions as to how to pursue “Never Forget.” That maxim is — and should remain — a communal act of remembering those who lived through those horrors themselves. “Never Forget” does not, nor should it, entail Khrzhanovsky’s vision of creating those atrocities live and on demand.


Ari Berman is assistant editor at Foreign Affairs. 

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

A Night of Gratitude Honoring Dennis Prager

Latest Articles

Print Issue: What Happened? | November 13, 2026

A story of bipartisan support that gradually became a story of one-party support, until it flips entirely and becomes once again a story of consensus – this time, of bipartisan opposition.

Why Are We Even Here?

When we’re tempted to ask, Lamah zeh anochi? — Why am I here? What’s the point? — we can remind ourselves of the extraordinary goodness that exists in the world. And, even more importantly, we can become part of it.

Leo David Honored as FIDF Gala Raises

Throughout the years, David has donated millions of dollars to numerous causes, but FIDF has always held a particularly special place in his heart.

What If Jewish Americans Just Showed Up?

We mourn on Oct. 7, but Nov. 8 gave us something to celebrate: a community that showed up, on its feet, public and proud. Now we need to make that response a habit.

Genocide and International Relations

The book casts its net far and wide, from debates within the field of research itself to the analysis of genocidal events across the past century.

A Concrete Case for Hope

Over the last few weeks, Americans and Israelis voted in elections that are consequential to the characters of both countries. For many, these elections represent inflection points, where the outcome signals the directions their respective societies will take moving forward.

AIPAC Isn’t the Problem. It’s Part of the Solution.

The future of the U.S.-Israel relationship will not be secured by winning one more primary. It will depend on whether Americans understand why Israel matters, why Jewish self-determination is legitimate, and why the alliance benefits both nations.

The Last Signer

Carroll, having helped swing Maryland toward independence, was elected to Congress on July 4, and signed the Declaration in August, the only Catholic among the signers and the only one to add his estate to his name.

Torah Portion: Toldot

The parsha begins with a direct statement: “This is the story of Isaac, son of Abraham.”  

Faith and the Power of Pretend

Rabbi Kushner provides a path for elevating our humanity, appreciating the wisdom of Jewish tradition and practice, and experiencing the divinity residing within all humans, even those who do not yet acknowledge God’s presence.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.