Last week, we celebrated Passover, commemorating the first time the Jewish people fled persecution and found refuge in Zion. For 3000 years, we have celebrated this first Zionist voyage with cries of “Next Year in Jerusalem!”
Three weeks ago, a Jewish congressional staffer found a U.S. Capitol officer reading the “Protocols of the Elders of Zion” on the job — just two months after neo-Nazis stormed the epicenter of American democracy. This reemergence of the “Protocols” reminded us that the demonization of Jews as “Zionists” (“Elders of Zion”) long predates the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the establishment of the modern State of Israel.
Paradoxically, two weeks ago, 200 academics, some Jewish and some not, signed a declaration denying that “anti-Zionism” is explicitly anti-Jewish. The goal of the new “Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism” (JDA) is to undermine overwhelming support for the globally-established International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of antisemitism, or at least to muddy the waters enough that application of IHRA’s definition becomes taboo.
Ironically, though, by its very existence, JDA clearly demonstrates why IHRA is not only important, but also entirely appropriate — and why certain criticisms of IHRA leveled by some of JDA’s signatories have always been somewhere between confused and intellectually dishonest.
JDA claims it exists to answer one urgent question: “When does political speech about Israel or Zionism cross the line into antisemitism and when should it be protected?” But if this is JDA’s primary raison d’être, it was all for naught, as this question is itself a false choice, a manufactured binary.
Any American lawyer could have told JDA’s drafters that all political speech about Israel or Zionism is protected — even when it crosses the line into antisemitism. That’s why neither JDA’s nor IHRA’s definition could possibly criminalize or ban any speech, antisemitic or not. Antisemitic speech, like all hate speech, is quintessentially protected in the United States, unless it incites imminent lawless action. Whether certain speech was identified as antisemitic under IHRA or JDA (or both), it would remain constitutionally protected. This tells us that the histrionics about IHRA “violating free speech” were always a pretext, and that JDA’s proponents have no problem with “policing speech” — just as long as they are the ones wearing the badge and drawing the lines.
The problem with the lines that JDA aims to draw is that they seem significantly more concerned with protecting accused antisemites than protecting victimized Jews. While IHRA describes scenarios that “could, taking into account the overall context,”be antisemitic, JDA dedicates ample space to “examples that, on the face of it, are not antisemitic.” IHRA warns us to proceed with caution after entering potentially antisemitic territory, while JDA provides cover for anyone approaching the danger zone unless and until they pass a threshold of gross bigotry. In creating a bright-line rule about what is not antisemitic, JDA deflects from the most common — antisemitic — manifestations of the issues it addresses to intellectually rationalize the liquidation of the Jewish state.
Moreover, the IHRA definition already incorporates examples that, on their face, are not antisemitic. By describing scenarios that could be antisemitic, IHRA necessarily confirms that these examples are not antisemitic per se. So why did JDA’s drafters consider it necessary to, quite literally, flip the script? Ostensibly, to define antisemitism in a way that’s comfortable for people who hold clear anti-Jewish prejudices, like disgraced UN rapporteur Richard Falk, who signed the JDA, and Linda Sarsour, who appeared on a panel championing it.
Is it possible to gaslight Jews more cynically or to a greater extent than this? But JDA goes further, dispensing with language fundamental to any understanding of antisemitism, relating to the double standards to which Jews are constantly held. The definition of a “double standard” is unfairly holding one group to a different standard from another in a discriminatory fashion, and the double standards applied to Israel are arguably the most commonplace, institutionalized, politically correct manifestations of antisemitism that exist today. Exclusively criticizing Israel is not necessarily antisemitic, but JDA is silent on a phenomenon that can only be called an obsession with the Jewish state as compared to every other state on earth. Take, for example, the fact that, in 2020, the United Nations General Assembly condemned Israel 17 times, while issuing only six resolutions condemning the rest of the world, combined.
But JDA goes further, dispensing with language fundamental to any understanding of antisemitism.
It isn’t a coincidence that removing references to the double standard is the only way that JDA could deny that it is antisemitic to be “anti-Israel” — rejecting the legitimate existence of one state on earth — or claim it’s appropriate to argue against “Zionism as a form of nationalism” — despite the fact that the vast majority of those making that argument are, in the same breath, arguing for Palestinian nationalism. Their problem with Zionism is not nationalism, it’s Jewish nationalism.
It is understandable that the signatories of the JDA want to stand in solidarity with Palestinians facing a devastating reality in Israel-Palestine; they could even be called well-intentioned. It is also true that for some Palestinians, opposition to Israel is not antisemitic per se, but is a product of their lived experience. But it is undeniable that most people who will use JDA as a shield against claims of antisemitism are not Palestinian and know next to nothing about the actual history or complexities of the Middle East. This is the difference between an idealistic and a realistic definition of antisemitism — only the latter of which stands a chance at protecting Jews.
Intentions aside, the JDA is wildly out of touch — about what antisemitism actually is, how American Jews report experiencing it, and how it has always appeared in the world: as an attack not just on individual Jews or Jewish religious observance, but on Jewish peoplehood and the Jewish collective. There is nothing more representative of that than the Jewish movement for liberation — Zionism — and the sovereign Jewish state it ultimately (re)produced — Israel.
Anti-Jewish bigotry is not abstract, philosophical or academic; it is tangible, visceral and dangerous, and it appears at times and in spaces where Jews who live it do not have the luxury of nuanced academic parsing. For some, the creation of JDA is yet another chapter in the interminable story of the Jewish people: In any given room of Jews, there are more opinions than there are bodies. But for many, this new intellectual definition of antisemitism is an affront to their actual, real-life experiences of antisemitism on their campuses, in their workplaces, in their social lives and in the justice movements to which they commit time, resources and heart.
While the IHRA definition of antisemitism is imperfect, the gaslighting effect of JDA only affirms to thousands of American Jews who actually experience contemporary antisemitism how important IHRA really is. By exposing that the claims about IHRA violating free speech were always mendacious, JDA reinforces that IHRA is wholly appropriate as a non-legally binding reference. And by comparing IHRA to JDA, any observer who cares principally about protecting Jews will know which definition is more likely to accomplish that imperative.
Perhaps if, in the past, we had a global consensus on antisemitism as powerful as the one supporting IHRA, Jewish lives would have been spared. The only guarantee stronger for those Jewish lives would have been — to the great frustration of the JDA authors — the State of Israel itself.
Amanda Berman, Esq. is the founder and executive director of Zioness.
The Existence of JDA Only Serves to Bolster the Argument for IHRA
Amanda Berman, Esq.
Last week, we celebrated Passover, commemorating the first time the Jewish people fled persecution and found refuge in Zion. For 3000 years, we have celebrated this first Zionist voyage with cries of “Next Year in Jerusalem!”
Three weeks ago, a Jewish congressional staffer found a U.S. Capitol officer reading the “Protocols of the Elders of Zion” on the job — just two months after neo-Nazis stormed the epicenter of American democracy. This reemergence of the “Protocols” reminded us that the demonization of Jews as “Zionists” (“Elders of Zion”) long predates the Israeli-Palestinian conflict and the establishment of the modern State of Israel.
Paradoxically, two weeks ago, 200 academics, some Jewish and some not, signed a declaration denying that “anti-Zionism” is explicitly anti-Jewish. The goal of the new “Jerusalem Declaration on Antisemitism” (JDA) is to undermine overwhelming support for the globally-established International Holocaust Remembrance Alliance (IHRA) definition of antisemitism, or at least to muddy the waters enough that application of IHRA’s definition becomes taboo.
Ironically, though, by its very existence, JDA clearly demonstrates why IHRA is not only important, but also entirely appropriate — and why certain criticisms of IHRA leveled by some of JDA’s signatories have always been somewhere between confused and intellectually dishonest.
JDA claims it exists to answer one urgent question: “When does political speech about Israel or Zionism cross the line into antisemitism and when should it be protected?” But if this is JDA’s primary raison d’être, it was all for naught, as this question is itself a false choice, a manufactured binary.
Any American lawyer could have told JDA’s drafters that all political speech about Israel or Zionism is protected — even when it crosses the line into antisemitism. That’s why neither JDA’s nor IHRA’s definition could possibly criminalize or ban any speech, antisemitic or not. Antisemitic speech, like all hate speech, is quintessentially protected in the United States, unless it incites imminent lawless action. Whether certain speech was identified as antisemitic under IHRA or JDA (or both), it would remain constitutionally protected. This tells us that the histrionics about IHRA “violating free speech” were always a pretext, and that JDA’s proponents have no problem with “policing speech” — just as long as they are the ones wearing the badge and drawing the lines.
The problem with the lines that JDA aims to draw is that they seem significantly more concerned with protecting accused antisemites than protecting victimized Jews. While IHRA describes scenarios that “could, taking into account the overall context,”be antisemitic, JDA dedicates ample space to “examples that, on the face of it, are not antisemitic.” IHRA warns us to proceed with caution after entering potentially antisemitic territory, while JDA provides cover for anyone approaching the danger zone unless and until they pass a threshold of gross bigotry. In creating a bright-line rule about what is not antisemitic, JDA deflects from the most common — antisemitic — manifestations of the issues it addresses to intellectually rationalize the liquidation of the Jewish state.
Moreover, the IHRA definition already incorporates examples that, on their face, are not antisemitic. By describing scenarios that could be antisemitic, IHRA necessarily confirms that these examples are not antisemitic per se. So why did JDA’s drafters consider it necessary to, quite literally, flip the script? Ostensibly, to define antisemitism in a way that’s comfortable for people who hold clear anti-Jewish prejudices, like disgraced UN rapporteur Richard Falk, who signed the JDA, and Linda Sarsour, who appeared on a panel championing it.
Is it possible to gaslight Jews more cynically or to a greater extent than this? But JDA goes further, dispensing with language fundamental to any understanding of antisemitism, relating to the double standards to which Jews are constantly held. The definition of a “double standard” is unfairly holding one group to a different standard from another in a discriminatory fashion, and the double standards applied to Israel are arguably the most commonplace, institutionalized, politically correct manifestations of antisemitism that exist today. Exclusively criticizing Israel is not necessarily antisemitic, but JDA is silent on a phenomenon that can only be called an obsession with the Jewish state as compared to every other state on earth. Take, for example, the fact that, in 2020, the United Nations General Assembly condemned Israel 17 times, while issuing only six resolutions condemning the rest of the world, combined.
It isn’t a coincidence that removing references to the double standard is the only way that JDA could deny that it is antisemitic to be “anti-Israel” — rejecting the legitimate existence of one state on earth — or claim it’s appropriate to argue against “Zionism as a form of nationalism” — despite the fact that the vast majority of those making that argument are, in the same breath, arguing for Palestinian nationalism. Their problem with Zionism is not nationalism, it’s Jewish nationalism.
It is understandable that the signatories of the JDA want to stand in solidarity with Palestinians facing a devastating reality in Israel-Palestine; they could even be called well-intentioned. It is also true that for some Palestinians, opposition to Israel is not antisemitic per se, but is a product of their lived experience. But it is undeniable that most people who will use JDA as a shield against claims of antisemitism are not Palestinian and know next to nothing about the actual history or complexities of the Middle East. This is the difference between an idealistic and a realistic definition of antisemitism — only the latter of which stands a chance at protecting Jews.
Intentions aside, the JDA is wildly out of touch — about what antisemitism actually is, how American Jews report experiencing it, and how it has always appeared in the world: as an attack not just on individual Jews or Jewish religious observance, but on Jewish peoplehood and the Jewish collective. There is nothing more representative of that than the Jewish movement for liberation — Zionism — and the sovereign Jewish state it ultimately (re)produced — Israel.
Anti-Jewish bigotry is not abstract, philosophical or academic; it is tangible, visceral and dangerous, and it appears at times and in spaces where Jews who live it do not have the luxury of nuanced academic parsing. For some, the creation of JDA is yet another chapter in the interminable story of the Jewish people: In any given room of Jews, there are more opinions than there are bodies. But for many, this new intellectual definition of antisemitism is an affront to their actual, real-life experiences of antisemitism on their campuses, in their workplaces, in their social lives and in the justice movements to which they commit time, resources and heart.
While the IHRA definition of antisemitism is imperfect, the gaslighting effect of JDA only affirms to thousands of American Jews who actually experience contemporary antisemitism how important IHRA really is. By exposing that the claims about IHRA violating free speech were always mendacious, JDA reinforces that IHRA is wholly appropriate as a non-legally binding reference. And by comparing IHRA to JDA, any observer who cares principally about protecting Jews will know which definition is more likely to accomplish that imperative.
Perhaps if, in the past, we had a global consensus on antisemitism as powerful as the one supporting IHRA, Jewish lives would have been spared. The only guarantee stronger for those Jewish lives would have been — to the great frustration of the JDA authors — the State of Israel itself.
Amanda Berman, Esq. is the founder and executive director of Zioness.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
AJU’s Ziegler School to Launch Dual-Degree Model for Future Rabbis
Sharon Osbourne: ‘It’s Very Fashionable to Hate Jews and Israel’
A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to an Antisemitic Spin Class
What Isaac the Blind Sees
Rabbis of LA | IDF Veteran, Guest of Rabbi Kahn, Remembers Oct. 7, 2023
L.A. Federation’s Tour de Summer Camps, International Chabad Conference in NYC
Call Sheet – A poem for Parsha Toldot
See who’s in the cast.
A Bisl Torah ~ Dangerous Comparisons
Let us not compare child to child. God will remind us; there are ample parental blessings for each child to receive.
A Moment in Time: Holding On
Abraham Plants a Tamarisk Tree
Print Issue: What Happened? | November 13, 2026
A story of bipartisan support that gradually became a story of one-party support, until it flips entirely and becomes once again a story of consensus – this time, of bipartisan opposition.
Why Are We Even Here?
When we’re tempted to ask, Lamah zeh anochi? — Why am I here? What’s the point? — we can remind ourselves of the extraordinary goodness that exists in the world. And, even more importantly, we can become part of it.
Leo David Honored as FIDF Gala Raises
Throughout the years, David has donated millions of dollars to numerous causes, but FIDF has always held a particularly special place in his heart.
Boulou: A Cookie That Traveled From Djerba to Los Angeles
Boulou has deep roots in Djerba, but is treasured in all Tunisian Jewish kitchens, where it is baked for the holidays and special occasions.
What If Jewish Americans Just Showed Up?
We mourn on Oct. 7, but Nov. 8 gave us something to celebrate: a community that showed up, on its feet, public and proud. Now we need to make that response a habit.
“What Did the Doctor Say?” and Other Things that Keep Us from Laughing
Who’s got time to crack up in these crazy times? Well, I do.
NCSY Welcomes 400 Proudly Jewish Student Leaders to the JSU President’s Conference
JSU is a network of Jewish culture clubs in public and secular private high schools in North America, and it’s a program of NCSY, the international youth movement of the Orthodox Union.
Table for Five: Toldot
Sibling Rivalry
Genocide and International Relations
The book casts its net far and wide, from debates within the field of research itself to the analysis of genocidal events across the past century.
Heading Toward Bipartisan Opposition?
For an Israeli observer of the American elections, there is a double cause for concern.
A Concrete Case for Hope
Over the last month, Americans and Israelis voted in elections that were consequential to the characters of both countries. For many, these elections represented inflection points, signaling the directions their respective societies will take moving forward.
AIPAC Isn’t the Problem. It’s Part of the Solution.
The future of the U.S.-Israel relationship will not be secured by winning one more primary. It will depend on whether Americans understand why Israel matters, why Jewish self-determination is legitimate, and why the alliance benefits both nations.
After the Haredi Public’s Defeat: Change Must Come from Outside
Everyone is entitled to choose how to live, but the state is not obliged to finance every choice. Those who do not complete secondary education, do not serve in the military, and do not work should not receive state support to maintain that way of life.
The Last Signer
Carroll, having helped swing Maryland toward independence, was elected to Congress on July 4, and signed the Declaration in August, the only Catholic among the signers and the only one to add his estate to his name.
The 24-Hour Window That Changed the U.S.–Israel Relationship
Trump said Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu had agreed to the change and argued that Israel no longer needed the funding.
Can’t Jews Take a Break From Being Liberals to Worry About Israel?
It is easy to be proudly Jewish when our identity is celebrated. It is harder when Jewish solidarity demands disagreeing with one’s friends or political party.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.