Post-Zionism in a diaspora world
What does it mean to be a Jew in a Post-Zionist world?
For centuries, for Jews, the notion of living free in Zion was a dream.
In Theodor Herzl’s famous essay, “The Jewish State,” the journalist and
playwright transformed the dream of living in a Jewish state into a
“Next year in Jerusalem,” the words we say at the end of every seder,
was in those days a true aspiration for nationhood. Today, it is often
treated as the lead-in to a joke whose punch line is, “And if we’re
lucky, next year at … (fill in the blank for someone’s home or any
The notion that all Jews should one day live in Israel was very much
part of my own childhood Hebrew school education, and I recall many
elders talking about their dreams of retiring to Israel or being buried
As I was growing up, it seemed that Jewish immigration to Israel,
making aliyah, was the silver lining to be found in every contemporary
Jewish Diaspora calamity: Soviet Jewry is suffering? Then let them go
… to Israel. Ethiopian Jews in trouble? Airlift them … to Israel.
More recently, after calamities in Argentina and anti-Semitic attacks
in France, incentives were offered to families to move to Israel. Yet I
imagine these campaigns were less successful than those of my youth. In
part this has to do with the global community we live in now.
Here in Diaspora Los Angeles 2008, Israeli culture is woven into my
daily fabric: On any given day, I can find myself watching an Apple
Computer commercial featuring “New Soul” by French-born Israeli singer
Yael NaÃ¯m, or watching HBO’s “In Treatment,” which is based on an
Israeli show. A recent L.A. Weekly issue carried a profile of short
story writer and filmmaker Etgar Keret written by film critic Ella
Taylor, who once lived in Israel herself.
Israelis seem to be everywhere — at the mall, all the kiosks are
manned by Israelis; the most popular vendor in the food court sells
shwarma; and Krav Maga, an Israeli martial art, is taught just down the
street. Santa Monica might be home to more British citizens, but I just
seem to notice the Israelis.
Once upon a time, Israelis living here would have been viewed as
disloyal — dropouts. Today, they are just another ethnic community
placing a stake in Los Angeles.
This is post-Zionism.
As Israel celebrates its 60th anniversary, it seems that we have
entered an age where living in Israel is no longer the goal of all, or
even most Jews in the Diaspora — even for some born there. This begs
the question, what then is Israel in the hearts and minds of today’s
Jews? What should it be?
Israel was founded as something of an agrarian socialist utopian
society — its form of government inspired by the Mensheviks. The
kibbutz was the soul of the country. But that hasn’t been the case for
several decades. What is the soul of the country today? Its high-tech
industry? Its army?
Perhaps it is Israel’s diversity.
In a recent interview in Germany’s weekly Die Welt, author Amos Oz
said, “When I look at the German or other European media and see that
image of Israel it creates, I learn that Israel supposedly consists of
80 percent religious fanatics, 10 percent settlers in West Jordan, 9
percent brutal soldiers and 1 percent intellectuals who criticize the
government and who are wonderful writers. This is of course a
distortion of reality.”
The reality is that Israel is a country that prides itself on having at
least one of everything (from ski mountain to Dead Sea, from tofu
factory to star fruit farm); what doesn’t Israel produce, manufacture
and what can’t you do there? Israel has produced world-class literature
and has a vigorous free press that voices every opinion on every side
of every issue and uncovers every scandal, and it has a Supreme Court
that has come to be the moral conscience of the country.
Nonetheless, one can argue that the main impact of post-Zionism has
been to make Israel less self-absorbed and the Diaspora more so.
In Israel itself, 60 years of existential peril have created a sense of
living in the moment — currently there is a surprising sense of
well-being among certain strata of the Israeli population that comes
from focusing on family, on work and on materialistic concerns divorced
from national and political concerns. When you live in the moment, you
can live anywhere: This, in part, explains the lessened stigma of being
an Israeli who chooses not to live in Israel.
By contrast, for Jews in the Diaspora, while Israel remains a
touchstone in their hearts and minds, and the life-changing trip to
Israel is a de rigueur experience, there is nevertheless a growing
malaise about Israel and its policies, whether you are on the far left,
or the far right. This is true even among people like me, who consider
themselves centrists, but who are too left for the right and too right
for the left.
I am reminded of the Israelites in Exodus who, when delivered from
Egypt, began to complain, and continued to complain at each turn —
about being in the wilderness, about the food, about their thirst and
on and on. In a similar vein, it strikes me that the age of
post-Zionism is also the age of complaining. There may even be a reason
In the mid-1980s, Israeli archives adopted a liberal policy of
declassifying official documents, giving historians and journalists
access to troves of official papers related to Israel’s founding and
early years. Many historians, most notably Tom Segev and Benny Morris,
began to search out the truth of those early years. In time, they and
others, collectively referred to as “the New Historians,” wrote a
series of books about the mandate era, the war for independence, and
the 1967 Six-Day War — revisiting the pillars of Israel’s national
story — the most recent of which is Morris’ just-published “1948 — A
History of the First Arab-Israeli War” (Yale University Press). As
these accounts have been published, journalists,
historians and readers alike have had to confront some difficult facts.
Contrary to the national narrative of manifest destiny that Jews in
Israel and the Diaspora had come to accept as gospel, the history of
Israel turns out to be far more complex. The historical record reveals
what had been hidden or glossed over in the service of nationalism:
That in birthing a nation, the Israelis did not all have clean hands —
Arabs were expelled, their villages destroyed, massacres and rapes
occurred. These are anguishing events, and we are too close in time to
not feel their blot on the collective self-image. They are fresh enough
to color and contribute to a sense of existential crisis about Israel
on its 60th anniversary.
In each country’s annals, including those of the United States, we must
accept those facts we can’t ignore, the dark actions that stain our
history. Individuals may argue their significance, sometimes for
generations to come. But we need only accept them as our past — we are
not compelled to imbue them with any greater power in the present
beyond accepting them and saying: How shall we go forward?
There will always be those, Jewish and not, who can only focus on
Israel’s wrongs as an indictment of all Israelis and Israel’s right to
exist. At the same time, there will always be those, Jewish and not,
who will cite a double standard applied to Israel as a way to avoid
confronting those wrongs in Israel’s past and its present.
As each group gets more vocal, empowered by the Internet, blogs and a
polarization that preaches opinion to its own fervent choir, it becomes
increasingly difficult to stand up to the clatter and to voice a simple
truth: That a true democracy thrives, regardless of the bad and
regrettable actions of individuals in one regime’s government (as is
evidenced by what’s going on right now in this country). That is the
point of a democracy. A post-Zionist will continue to believe in
Israel’s dream of an open society, with truly democratic institutions
and a democratic rule of law.
Herzl wrote his essay, “The Jewish State,” in reaction to witnessing
France’s Dreyfus trial. Herzl felt that the only answer to the
anti-Semitism he saw in Europe was to found a Jewish state. Today, we
hear that anti-Semitism exists in Europe and elsewhere because of
actions of the Jewish state (plus Ã§a change…..).
By some accounts, there are now more Jews living in Israel than in any
single country in the world, yet anti-Semitism continues to flare up
even in countries with little or no Jewish population
How in this age of post-Zionism do we distinguish between criticism of
Israel and its supporters (both Israeli and American), and criticism
informed or motivated by anti-Semitism?
>From my experience (and I have met quite a few Holocaust
more than anything, the issue boils down to the Gestalt, not the simple
fact of criticism but the pattern, the language, the generalizations,
the tone. Although that doesn’t sound very precise (and I’m afraid it
is not), let me refer you to someone who has done some serious research
on the subject:
April Rosenblum, a Philadelphia-based progressive activist was troubled
enough by her leftist friends not standing up to anti-Semitism that she
produced a 32-page pamphlet, “The Past Didn’t Go Anywhere.” While
critical of American and Israeli policies, the pamphlet explains in the
language of the struggle how anti-Semitism weakens the cause of those
committed to social action.
Rosenblum’s is one response. But the point is that, for those imbued
with the Gestalt of supporting and defending Israel, post-Zionism means
finding a way to speak truth to Israel’s faults as well as to those
with anti-Semitic agendas.
As Israel turns 60, post-Zionism is a love of Israel without borders,
unafraid to accept truth and confident that a democratic Jewish state,
despite its imperfections and failings, will continue to nourish our
souls, and will one day fulfill its promise; and that as part of our
covenant, we will continue to dream and work and support Israel, so
that promise may come true in our lifetimes.
These words, which for years I’ve mumbled in Hebrew, without paying
them any attention, seem strangely appropriate. They were written by
Naftali Herz Imber in Zolochiv, Ukraine, in 1878. You may know them as
the words to the Israeli national anthem, “Hatikvah”:
As long as in the heart, within,
A soul of a Jew is yearning,
And to the edges of the East, forward,
An eye gazes toward Zion
Our hope is not yet lost,
The hope of two thousand years,
To be a free nation in our land,
The land of Zion and Jerusalem.
It’s crazy to think about it. With a predatory regime like Iran on its doorstep and more than 100,000 terror missiles pointed at its citizens,...
As an undergraduate at UC San Diego, I was active in our campus pro-Israel group. I loved every minute of it, even if it meant...
“Do you ever wonder just what God requires? You think He’s just an errand boy to satisfy your wandering desires?” — Bob Dylan “You call...
I’ve always had a low threshold for pain. Whenever I bump into a wall or get a little cut, I act as if I’ve been...
Fifteen years ago, the Journal published a story about cellphone use in synagogue. Some parents justified the practice, as they needed to call “Rosa” during...
Last week in New York, I was the lone son of a British Methodist amid 1,800 Jews and people of other faiths at the Anti-Defamation...
When Brooke Goldstein was in her third year at Yeshiva University’s Benjamin N. Cardozo School of Law in New York City, her graduation was almost...
When Republican impeachment lawyer Steven Castor and Republican representatives implied Lt. Col. Alexander Vindman might have dual loyalty to the Ukraine, many Jews cringed. After...
Israel is known as one of the world’s most vegetarian- and vegan-friendly countries. Perhaps it’s the abundance of fresh and delicious produce, Jewish dietary laws...
Writing a book about Israel can be frustrating for many reasons, the first of which is that it constantly needs to be updated. Reality changes...
On Sept. 18, one day after election day, the numbers came in — and they said nothing new. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu of Likud didn’t...
One verse, five voices. Edited by Salvador Litvak, Accidental Talmudist And he dreamed, and behold! a ladder set up on the ground and its top reached...
The word on the street is that polenta must be stirred constantly while it cooks, similar to risotto. There are even automatic polenta stirrers made...
A Jewish Sephardic vocalist backed by an Arab Moroccan string ensemble formed the backdrop to a unique event at the Beverly Hills Hotel when San...
Liz Vogel, the Los Angeles executive director of the nonprofit Facing History and Ourselves, recalls the moments in her young adulthood where she experienced anti-Semitism. And...
In her new book, “Good Habits, Bad Habits: The Science of Making Positive Changes That Stick” (Farrar, Straus and Giroux), Wendy Wood, a professor of...
Some may wonder why actress and comedian Tiffany Haddish titled her latest Netflix stand-up comedy special “Black Mitzvah” and opens with a rap to the...
Producer Elisabeth (Lizzie) Bentley, the spearheading force behind director Terrence Malick’s new biopic, “A Hidden Life,” first became aware of the film’s protagonist, Franz Jägerstätter,...
Two things set apart “Mistletoe & Menorahs” from the other holiday romantic comedies airing on Lifetime this month. As the title suggests, it celebrates both...
As Shirley Maisel, the loud and overbearing Jewish mother of Joel and former mother-in-law of the titular standup comedian in “The Marvelous Mrs. Maisel,” Caroline...
With phrases such as “Move forward,” “Listen carefully,” “Make art from your heart” and “Woman, speak up,” Sara Erenthal invites observers of her art to...
Over his long and remarkable career, Theodore Bikel achieved the status of living treasure. He is perhaps best known for the roles he played on...
“Theodore Bikel’s The City of Light” is based on a short story by Theodore Bikel but the book’s author is his widow, Aimee Ginsburg Bikel. Born...
Drew Leach was completing her undergraduate degree at the University of Arizona during the Second Lebanon War in Israel in 2006. On her campus, she...
A unique women-owned business is helping charities while promoting Hanukkah this year. Amanda Foley was busy working as a casting director in Los Angeles, while...
Sylvia Bar died Oct. 26 at 92. Survived by daughter Jeanine; son Malchi; 1 grandchild. Hillside Tully Becker died Oct. 9 at 86. Survived by...
I love receiving gift cards, but I do feel a little guilty giving them because I’m afraid the recipient will presume I didn’t put any thought...
It is the central irony of American life that the national holiday about gratitude anchors the biggest shopping frenzy of the year. Here’s what I...
Milken Community Schools held its third annual community-wide challah bake, during which 500 people prepared challah for Shabbat. Attendees at the Nov. 14 event at...
FRI DEC 6 Zamru Friday Night Shomrei Torah Synagogue holds Zamru Friday Night, a unique, musically rich kabbalat Shabbat service and dinner. Cantor Jackie Rafii...
Responding to Rosner I believe that Israel will never experience peace, and global anti-Semitism will not be reduced, until there is a real home for...