fbpx

NYT Criticized for Romanticizing Iranian Nuclear Scientist

The Times tweeted: “Despite his prominent position, Iran's top nuclear scientist wanted to live a normal life. He loved reading poetry, taking his family to the seashore and driving his own car..."
[additional-authors]
September 20, 2021
Handout / Getty Images

The New York Times is being criticized for allegedly romanticizing a top nuclear scientist for the Iranian government who was killed in November 2020.

The Times reported that the scientist, Mohsen Fakhrizadeh, was killed by a remote-controlled machine gun that fired at the vehicle in which he was traveling at the time. The report states that the Israeli government was likely behind the assassination, as Fakhrizadeh was considered to be the mastermind behind Iran’s nuclear program.

In a September 18 tweet promoting the story, the Times tweeted: “Despite his prominent position, Iran’s top nuclear scientist wanted to live a normal life. He loved reading poetry, taking his family to the seashore and driving his own car instead of having bodyguards drive him in an armored vehicle.”

Former Israeli Ambassador to the United Nations Danny Danon, who currently chairs World Likud, tweeted, “If you ask the @nytimes, Fahrizade was a poetry-loving family man. They ‘forget’ to mention that he was developing nuclear weapons with the ultimate goal of destroying the USA and Israel.”

Other Jewish and pro-Israel Twitter users also denounced the tweet.

“Unbelievable this [New York Times] tweet remains up,” Anti-Defamation League CEO Jonathan Greenblatt tweeted. “Absolutely disgraceful to romanticize Fakhrizadeh as a ‘lover of poetry.’ Who cares about his hobbies when he made clear his true passion project was the annihilation of the only Jewish state in the world.”

American Jewish Committee CEO David Harris similarly wrote that the Times tweet is “a new low for the paper.” “Apart from a key role in Iran’s goal of destroying Israel, he ‘wanted to live a normal life.’ Hey, as long as he loved poetry & the beach, why allow the planned murder of 9 million people to detract from his life story?”

Human rights lawyer Arsen Ostrovksy, who heads the International Legal Forum, also tweeted: “I can only shudder at how [The New York Times] would have described Hitler today: ‘Despite his prominent position, the Nazi leader wanted to live a normal life. He was a vegetarian, loved art and reading poetry, and was a doting uncle.’”

Adam Kredo, reporter for the conservative website Washington Free Beacon, noted that the Times reporter who wrote the story “recently had two formal complaints filed against her for pro-Iran bias and multiple faculties inaccuracies” and linked to a story he had written on the matter.

The Times did not respond to the Journal’s request for comment.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

A New Borscht Belt?

If renewed exclusion teaches us only to become more protective of Jewish work, we will have learned the wrong lesson from the original Borscht Belt.

Judaism as a Covenant for the Ages

Given the realities of our current time, we are more in need than ever of the depth, wisdom, and joy that Jewish tradition offers.

A Summit to Remember

Our shared stories of hatred, humiliation, oppression and slavery obligate us to show up for one another.

Old-Guard Dems Pushing Back

While it’s indisputable that younger and progressive voters are driving the party away from its historic support for Israel, the old-guard Zionist Democrats have made it clear that they will not surrender without a fight.

Why I Write

The column went from being about a neighborhood to being all over the map. Now, I can’t attend any event, watch any movie, read any essay, discover any story, hear any conversation, see any news item without thinking, “this might be a column.”

Does Jewish Existence Conflict with Human Survival?

Unlike Dana Nessel, most Jews still consider the existence of the Jewish people, and the Jewish state, to be a Jewish value. They’re proud to be Jews—and they’re equally proud of the role Jews have played in human history.

A Bisl Torah — Season of Renewal

What is it that we want to renew within ourselves, strengthen, embolden, and what characteristics and traits should ultimately be discarded?

Mark Ruffalo, Meet Dolly Parton

Instead of the arrogance of cynicism, Parton embodied the innocence of humility. We could all use some of that humility.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.