fbpx

Anti-Israel Divestment Vote Fails at Chapman

Students for Justice in Palestine plans a rally to protest the decision on Sept. 12.
[additional-authors]
September 12, 2024
MattGush/Getty Images

Chapman University’s Investment Committee of the Board of Trustees rejected a proposal to divest from companies that conduct business with Israel.

The Orange, California-based school said in a statement on Sept. 11, “As promised, Chapman University’s Investment Committee of the Board of Trustees agreed to consider proposals from students on the topic of divestment, which it heard at its Sept. 10 meeting. Leading up to the committee meeting, Chapman leadership met and engaged with students several times in the spirit of collaboration and learning.”

The statement continued: “The Investment Committee has declined to divest from its investments. Trustee Jim Burra, who chairs the committee, noted: ‘We have a fiduciary responsibility to preserve and grow the endowment, which directly supports the mission of the university. It is important that we make financial decisions based on risk and return.’”

According to The Panther, Chapman’s student newspaper, the vote was determined by a simple majority.

Chapman’s Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP) chapter had posted on Instagram that their proposal would have had the university “divest from companies involved in the military industrial complex and the apart/heid [sic] state of Israel” and increase investment transparency.

The Panther reported that SJP’s proposal had “gained momentum” after the anti-Israel group organized an encampment in the spring and had been in contact with university officials on the proposal during the summer. The university has also since announced a new policy that encampments are no longer permitted on campus, but those involved in the encampment will be given amnesty, per The Panther.

“In addition to the divestment proposal, SJP has advocated for other changes, including the creation of a Middle Eastern-North African (MENA) advocate position within the university’s Diversity, Equity and Inclusion (DEI) office. Bouchard confirmed that this position is expected to be filled by June 2025,” The Panther reported. “Other demands, such as ending study abroad programs in Occupied Palestine and discontinuing university-sponsored Birthright trips, remain under consideration and continue to generate debate within the university.”

The Chapman SJP chapter posted on Instagram that the vote is a “major disappointment by our institution” and will be holding a rally on Sept. 12 as a result.

Prior to the vote on the proposal, nearly 2,000 people had signed a petition launched by parents of Chapman Jewish students advocating against the proposal. “Moving Chapman University towards divestment and sanctions against Israel would only serve to exacerbate an already volatile situation, steering us away from a path of resolution and peace, while fostering an atmosphere of division and instability within our university,” the petition stated. “We firmly believe that our university’s resources should be used to promote knowledge, understanding, and cooperation, rather than being manipulated for political objectives.”

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

Searching for the Red Heifer

While there’s nothing wrong with keeping your eyes on the horizon for that magical heifer to appear, be sure to appreciate what you already have.

Broadening the Fight

If we agree that antisemitism is only one example of a widespread and pernicious instinct toward division and “other-ization,” then it becomes clear that we can only eradicate these animosities as part of a far broader effort.

Evil Does Not Negotiate

Evil is repeatedly misunderstood because civilized societies instinctively judge others through the lens of their own moral framework.

How the World Cup Makes Boredom Look Good

Can you imagine telling someone about a sport where after 90 minutes, a team only manages three shots on goal? It’d be like going to a Bruce Springsteen concert and only hearing three songs.

No Wars for Jews

It was of paramount importance, particularly to the Americans, that their fight in World War II not be seen as a war on behalf of the Jews.

Shabbat Shalom, America

In the midst of our parties and barbeques, Shabbat is God’s birthday present to America to remind us that we still live in the greatest country on earth.

The More We Analyze, the Worse It Gets

Here we are with brilliant commentators producing brilliant commentary on, say, the roots of antisemitism and antizionism – complete with books, summits and white papers – and it barely makes a dent.

A Bisl Torah — Go Out Before Them

No matter if we assign ourselves the title of leader, we each lead in some respect, whether it’s leading as a parent, a supervisor, a friend, or a member of our neighborhoods.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.