fbpx

The Jewish Response to a Cheap Dress

[additional-authors]
February 28, 2015

Did you see blue-and-black, or were you in the white-and-gold camp?  Was your family as polarized as mine?

I can't help it.  I am a Jewish doctor.  What seems to be a trivial, yet highly popular discussion on social media about the true colors of this $70 dress, keeps me up at night wondering.  If there are fifty shades of grey, there are even more hues to this story.

I am fascinated that my daughter and I can look at the same thing and be absolutely convinced that the other is wrong.  We are very close genetically, and yet we see differently.  We are all aware of color blindness, and yet the discussion over this dress broke the internet.  Medicine is filled with examples of genetic varieties that affect how we process sensory input.  For example, not everyone suffers from the unpleasant smell of the urine after eating asparagus;  your genetic makeup determines whether your urine has the odor and whether you can actually smell it. 

How we process information is vital.This orientation affects all of life.

Does God exist or are you an atheist?  Is the cup half full or half empty?  Are you a Republican or a Democrat?  There may be genetic basis for how we experience life and form beliefs.

This week, we read the story of Esther, the sexy Persian queen who becomes the savior of the Jews, by transforming from a caterpillar into a butterfly when she puts on a special robe.  Through concealment of her true self, she uncovers a heroine.  The cloth transforms us.  Our clothes influence how people see us, and how we see ourselves.  A black suit sends out an entirely different message than a red miniskirt- specially when the accompanying stilettos have a red bottom. 

We need to respect each other's opinions, point of views and diversity. We are marvelous creatures and to remain narrow is to put on blindfolds.  A prism takes natural light and breaks it up into the colors of the rainbow.  Each of us has a function and a way of seeing the truth which leads to a world whose whole is greater than the sum of its parts. 

Only God knows what's in our hearts beneath the Tallit- the prayer-shawls which are commanded to be marked unequivocally with blue-and-white stripes.

The proper Jewish response to this cheap dress puzzle is to see past what meets the eye and find the hidden fabrics of our lives.

#TheDress

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

The Crisis in Jewish Education Is Not About Screens

If we want to produce Jews who carry Torah in their bones, we need institutions willing to demand that commitment, and not institutions that blame technology for their own unwillingness to insist on rigor.

A Bisl Torah — Holy Selfishness

Honoring oneself, creating sacred boundaries, and cultivating self-worth allows a human being to better engage with the world.

Does Tucker Carlson Have His Eye on The White House?

Jason Zengerle, a contributing writer for The New York Times Magazine, and staff writer at the New Yorker wrote a new book about Carlson, “Hated By All The Right People: Tucker Carlson and The Unraveling of The Conservative Mind.”

Cain and Abel Today

The story of Cain and Abel constitutes a critical and fundamental lesson – we are all children of the covenant with the opportunity to serve each other and to serve God. We are, indeed, each other’s keeper.

Belonging Matters. And Mattering Matters Too.

A society that maximizes belonging while severing it from standards produces conformity, not freedom. A society that encourages mattering divorced from truth produces fanaticism, not dignity. Life and liberty depend on holding the two together.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.