fbpx

The Chabad exchange, Part 1: ‘Chabad does not give up’

[additional-authors]
November 4, 2015

Rabbi David Eliezrie is the Director of North County Chabad –Congregation Beit Meir Ha'Cohen, Yorba Linda, CA. He serves as President of the Rabbinical Council of Orange County and Long Beach; Board Member of the Jewish Federation and Family Services of Orange County; Member of the Allocation Committee of the Federation, Chairman of the Chabad International Crisis Committee; Chair of the Chabad Partners Conference; and Member of the Advisory Committee of the Rohr Jewish Learning Institute.

The following exchange will focus on Rabbi Eliezrie’s new book, The Secret of Chabad (The Toby Press, 2015).

***

Dear Rabbi Eliezrie,

Your interesting new book starts with the 2008 terrorist attack on the Chabad Center in Mumbai. Why did you choose to start telling the story of the rise and rise of the global Chabad movement with this particular episode? What does it tell us about the movement, and why is it a good place to begin your narrative?

Yours,

Shmuel.

***

Dear Shmuel,

Two days after the terror attack, a prominent orthodox rabbi asked me to give him background on Rabbi Gavriel Holzberg. I told him, “He completed the Talmud by the age of 18.” This an intellectual feat that can take a lifetime. He was puzzled, asking me “then why did he go to Mumbai?” My answer was that this exactly was the reason. In Chabad the best and brightest leave the cocoon of a religious community to dedicate their lives to others. Mumbai represents the central question about the secret of Chabad. Why move to place like Mumbai? It’s not a resume building track on the way to Beverly Hills. Why have the challenge of raising a family that remains true to your values, raise money, build communal institutions, overcome a wide variety of obstacles to create a Jewish renaissance?

As a member of the Crisis Management Team dealing with the attack, it was deeply personal. For those few days it was a roller coaster of emotion. There were moments of hope as we attempted to negotiate with the terrorists holed up in the Chabad House from the US. There was the constant fear of the fate of Gabi and Rivkie, the rabbi and rebbitzen, and others in the Chabad House. There was a moment of elation when the baby Moishe was saved, clutched from the Chabad House due to the heroic efforts of Indian nanny Sandra.

There was the reaction after the terrible news of the loss of everyone became known. The Jewish world mourned as one. In our Chabad Center dozens of women, many far from observant, gathered to light Shabbat candles. In Israel, a few days later, the whole nation paused to weep. We as Shluchim felt that our brother and sister had been taken from our midst.  

And, finally, there was our response to the tragedy. Chabad does not give up. Not in the face of Communist oppression, not when faced with indifference of American Jews distant from tradition, and not when faced with evil whose sole purpose was to destroy goodness. The Rebbe taught us that more light pushes away darkness. The tragedy of Mumbai became a moment of inspiration to us Shluchim to work harder and do more.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

Who Knows?

When future generations tell your story and mine, which parts will look obvious in hindsight? What opportunities will we have leveraged — and decisions made — that define our legacy?

You Heard It Here First, Folks!

For over half a decade, I had seen how the slow drip of antisemitism, carefully enveloped in the language of social justice and human rights, had steadily poisoned people whom I had previously considered perfectly reasonable.

Trump’s Critics Have a Lot Riding on the Iran Conflict

Their assumptions about the attack on Iran are based on a belief in the resilience of an evil terrorist regime, coupled with a conviction that Trump’s belief in the importance of the U.S.-Israel alliance is inherently wrong.

Me Llamo Miguel

With Purim having just passed, I’ve been thinking about how Jews have been disguising ourselves over the years.

The Hope of Return

This moment calls for moral imagination. For solidarity with the Iranian people demanding dignity. For sustained support of those who seek a freer future.

Stranded by War

We are struggling on two fronts: we worry about friends and family, and we are preoccupied with our own “survival” on a trip extended beyond our control.

Love Letters to Israel

Looking around at the tears, laughter, and joy after two years of hell, the show was able to not just touch but nourish our souls.

Neil Sedaka, Brooklyn-Born Hit-Maker, Dies at 86

Neil Sedaka was born March 13, 1939 in Brooklyn, New York, the son of Mac and Eleanor Sedaka. His father was Sephardic and his mother Ashkenazi; Sedaka was a transliteration of the Hebrew “tzedakah.”

Letter to the UC Board of Regents on Fighting Antisemitism

We write as current and former UC faculty, many of us in STEM fields and professional schools, in response to the release of When Faculty Take Sides: How Academic Infrastructure Drives Antisemitism at the University of California.

Shabbat in a Bunker

It turned out that this first round of sirens was a wake-up call, a warning that Israel and America were attacking – so we could expect a different day of rest than all of us had planned.

Community Reacts to U.S.-Israel Attack Against Iran

Though there was uncertainty about what would ensue in the days following, those interviewed by The Journal acknowledged the strikes against the Islamic Republic in Iran constituted a pivotal turning point in the history of the Middle East.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.