fbpx

December 14, 2025

Blasting a Broken Record—This Time, Bondi Beach

The Festival of Lights just plunged Australia, and its beleaguered Jewish community, into darkness Down Under.

One thousand Aussies gathered on Bondi Beach for the lighting of the menorah on the first night of Hanukkah. An Israeli intelligence officer told Fox News that his Australian counterparts were on notice about the probability of a Hanukkah attack. The Australian Jewish Association posted on Facebook, “How many times did we warn the Government?”

Doubtlessly, Australian intelligence agencies, and Prime Minister Anthony Albanese, ignored those warnings. Five Australian policemen were reportedly watching nearby and did nothing. One of the shooters was known to the police—not for shoplifting, but violence against Jews.

All these Australian officials had long trivialized the colossal rise in antisemitic hatred that was occurring in Australia ever since the global license to kill Jews was implicitly issued on October 7.

Australian officials had long trivialized the colossal rise in antisemitic hatred that was occurring in Australia ever since the global license to kill Jews was implicitly issued on October 7.

Two terrorists with assault rifles, one named as Naveed Akram, positioned themselves on a bridge and for more than ten minutes engaged in target practice against a mass of defenseless Jews. As many as 15 Jews were murdered while another 29 were rushed to local hospitals.

Within the shooters’ line of sight was also a petting zoo and a bubble station for the kids. Surely those guided by the depraved slogan “By any means necessary” will psychotically insist that the Bondi Beach murders were “necessary.” Israelis who refuse to dismantle their state and move from their ancestral homeland justify the killing of Jews wherever they happen to be—including at a petting zoo.

Police recovered improvised explosive devices from a vehicle at Bondi Beach. The terrorists had apparently hoped for their killing spree at the beach to continue somewhere else in Sydney.

Prime Minister Albanese announced soon after the shooting that “An attack on Jewish Australians is an attack on every Australian.” Even on such a tragic day, that statement is laughably hollow and contemptible. The past several years have not been pleasant for Australian Jews—and Albanese surely knows that.

Whether taking orders from Allah or Iran, Islamists torched a kosher cafe in Sydney’s Bondi suburb in October 2024. There was an arson attack on the Adass Israel Synagogue in Melbourne in December 2024. Over the past 12 months, synagogues in Sydney and Melbourne have been targeted with arson and graffiti. A day care center and an Israeli restaurant were attacked, as well.

Meanwhile, mobs of screaming, marching Muslims have repeatedly taken to the streets, making it known that they prefer a Jew-slaughtering intifada any day over rooting for the Collingwood Magpies Australian rules football team.

Here’s two sidenotes: Shootings are rare in Australia, a nation with among the lowest gun-related deaths in the world. And Australia has more Holocaust survivors than any country after Israel. At least one such survivor is reported to be among the dead at Bondi Beach.

Radical Islam continues to be the gift that keeps on giving. Where would the West be without it? France just announced that it is cancelling its annual New Year’s Eve celebration.

Most witnesses at the Bondi Beach crime scene, not surprisingly, refused to be named. Why? Because they know what the rest of the Western world has long painfully learned: Muslims do not shy away from violence, and they absolutely refuse to find fault in the bloody handiwork of Islamists.

Does incoming New York City mayor Zohran Mamdani still believe that “Globalize the Intifada!” is an innocuous statement, and that Islamists who welcome martyrdom should not be disarmed? Do the presidents at Columbia, Harvard, Berkeley and Brown universities still believe that “From the River to the Sea”—the eradication of all Jews from the land between the coastal waterways of Greater Israel—is merely a harmless exercise of free speech and academic freedom?

Does incoming New York City mayor Zohran Mamdani still believe that “Globalize the Intifada!” is an innocuous statement, and that Islamists who welcome martyrdom should not be disarmed?

Speaking of universities, Columbia just released its final report from the Task Force on Antisemitism it had convened. It relentlessly exposes the rot within the Ivy League, emblemized by the “moral” support its faculty and students gave to Hamas almost immediately after the October 7 massacre. Anyone who blithely minimized the misery Jews experienced on Columbia’s campus should be chastened by the report’s findings.

An instructor in public health regaled his 400 students with the blood libel that Columbia’s Jewish donors used their gifts to “launder blood money.” He also denied the existence of the Jewish state. Those who complained were chastised as “privileged white students.”

Malevolently antisemitic professors believed that Columbia had provided them with lecture rooms not to teach but to demonize the Jewish state and intimidate Jewish students.

An Israeli professor’s class on Zionism (the only one on campus that did not vilify Israel) was overtaken by masked students. A professor told an Israeli student who once served in the IDF—in front of her classmates—that she was a murderer. Another instructor mocked an Israeli student, “You must know a lot about settler colonialism. How do you feel about that?” Another Israeli was labeled an “occupier.” A Jewish, non-Israeli student was told, “It’s such a shame that your people survived [the Holocaust] in order to commit mass genocide.”

And these were not even classes where Israel should be mentioned! An introductory astronomy class commenced with the “genocide” in Gaza. Similar deviations for the curriculum were reported in classes on photography, architecture, nonprofit management, film, music, humanities and Spanish. The report confesses that seemingly in every subject imaginable, professors “condone[d] (or even celebrated) terrorist atrocities, deploy[ed] antisemitic tropes, and peddle[d] bigoted stereotypes.”

One student emailed her professor to object to how Israel was being presented. At the next class he read her email out loud, mocking each of her arguments. A professor who taught a class on advocacy, openly proclaimed that “accounts of sexual violence by Hamas were exaggerated or fabricated.” A student in another class was told that the founder of Zionism, Theodor Herzl, was himself an antisemite, and that Jews from Eastern Europe were “not really Jewish.”

Is it any surprise that when the organization StopAntisemitism just this past week issued its report card on campus life for Jews in America, Columbia received an “F”? The report cited the appalling practice of “singling out” and “scapegoating” Jews and Israelis.

I have been writing and speaking out against violent antisemitism being tolerated on campus and around the world for several years now. Much of it, in fact, began long before Israel’s justified self-defense in Gaza after October 7, 2023.

If I’ve sounded like a broken record, so be it. If some readers insist that I use my weekly essays instead to condemn Donald Trump, that, too, would be a broken record, replayed by most everyone else. President Trump certainly has his faults, but standing beside Israel and defending Jews at home and abroad are not among them. What other world leader can it be said is doing that?

I am looking forward to a day when there will be a symphony of broken records.


Thane Rosenbaum is a novelist, essayist, law professor and Distinguished University Professor at Touro University, where he directs the Forum on Life, Culture & Society. He is the legal analyst for CBS News Radio. His most recent book is titled, “Beyond Proportionality: Israel’s Just War in Gaza.

Blasting a Broken Record—This Time, Bondi Beach Read More »

Sydney Attack Shows What the West Can Learn from the Zionist state

According to press reports, one of the survivors of the Bondi Beach terror attack said four police officers just “froze” during the 20-minute rampage on Sunday that killed 16 and injured dozens more.

“For 20 minutes. They shoot, shoot. Change magazines. And just shoot,” the witness told reporters. “Twenty minutes, there was four policemen there. Nobody fires back. Nothing. Like they froze,” he said of the slow response.

It’s hard to imagine four Israeli policemen “freezing” while two terrorists are shooting at civilians. But there’s a logical reason for that: Israel can’t afford to be in denial about the threats it is facing.

Since its birth in 1948, Israel was put on notice that it was not welcome in the neighborhood and that its enemies would do everything possible to destroy it. That has instilled a sense of hyper-realism among Israelis about taking these threats seriously and defending itself at all cost. The massacre of Oct. 7 caused such trauma precisely because Israel violated its most sacred principle of self-defense.

The West, and especially Europe, has no such sacred principle. Unlike Israel, it has failed to take the threats to its civilizational survival seriously. Slowly, inexorably, it has allowed those threats to fester internally, while losing its own sense of self.

The elephant in the room has always been radical Islam, an ideology that seeks to dominate and eventually replace the societies it enters. As the West grows weaker, the Islamists only grow bolder.

Remember that glittering New Year’s Eve celebration on the Champs-Élysées in Paris that drew more than a million revelers last year? In the face of migrant terror, the proud French decided to cancel it this year.

That is weakness.

“More than any other continent or culture in the world today, Europe is now deeply weighed down with guilt for its past… it has lost faith in its beliefs, traditions, and legitimacy,” Douglas Murray wrote eight years ago in his book “The Strange Death of Europe: Immigration, Identity, Islam.”

We see a similar weakness in Australia.

As Gregg Roman writes, “For twenty-six months, the warning signs accumulated. For twenty-six months, the Albanese government treated a developing terrorist campaign as a community relations problem.

“The trajectory was unmistakable. On October 9, 2023, two days after Hamas’s massacre in Israel, a mob descended on the Sydney Opera House, burning Israeli flags and chanting threats against Jews while police advised the Jewish community to stay away rather than dispersing the crowd. That failure to enforce basic public order established the permissive environment for everything that followed.”

You can be forgiven for rolling your eyes when Australian Prime Minister Antony Albanese now spews out the obligatory verbiage we hear after terror attacks: “An act of evil antisemitism, terrorism, that has struck the heart of our nation…An attack on Jewish Australians is an attack on every Australian.”

Yeah, well, Mr. Prime Minister, those are heartfelt words after the fact that provide little solace for those who perished. Better would have been to take real action ahead of time against a real threat that you knew existed.

One of the outrageous ironies of our time is that the country that is most reviled—Israel—has the most to teach the West about that little thing we call survival.

“The victims may have been Jews, but we will recover, rebuild, and grow stronger,” Liel Leibovitz posted on X following the Bondi attack. “But the nations that gave in to an insidious, murderous ideology never will. Nearly a century after the Holocaust, Jews are strong and the Jewish state is thriving, but Europe is holding on for dear life, awash in violence and un-freedom, a shadow of its former self.

“And in a decade or two, Jews will be ever stronger and the suicidal West will have been devoured by the benighted jihadis it so cheerfully let in.”

The last thing Europe wants to hear right now is that it has important things to learn from the Zionist state.

But if it cares about its future, not least how to train police officers dealing with a terrorist attack, it will make the call.

Sydney Attack Shows What the West Can Learn from the Zionist state Read More »

Holding the Light

By Cari Uslan

This year, as Hanukkah approaches, I keep returning to the image of a small flame holding its ground in a very dark room. A single, determined light that doesn’t pretend the darkness isn’t real, but refuses to be swallowed by it.

The past year has left many in our community feeling unmoored. The continued rise in antisemitism, the ongoing grief and fear since October 7, and the sense of division rippling through our world have affected all of us and profoundly shaped the emotional world of our children. Jewish youth are navigating questions of identity and safety at an age when they should be free to simply grow.

Hanukkah reminds us that light doesn’t appear because the world is peaceful. It appears because someone chooses to kindle it.

The miracle wasn’t just that the oil lasted, but that it was lit at all. That act of courage, of insisting on hope even when the outcome is unclear, feels like the spiritual work of this moment.

In my role supporting youth at Jewish Big Brothers Big Sisters of Los Angeles, I see versions of that courage every day. I see it when a “Big” decides to show up for a “Little” who is trying to make sense of a complicated world.

One mentor told me recently, “At a time like this, I needed to do something that brought light to someone else’s life.” The impulse to turn fear into connection, to counter isolation with presence, is profoundly Jewish and is how light endures.

Later, when I asked another volunteer how she finds the time to mentor a teen, she shrugged and said, “You find time for things that are important.” A simple sentiment, but one that captures the essence of Hanukkah: the commitment to sustaining something fragile yet essential.

The work of showing up for Jewish children, of offering them identity and belonging, has surpassed valuable, and is now vital. Mentorship doesn’t erase darkness or undo grief, but it creates pockets of warmth and safety where young people can breathe, question, connect, and imagine their future with confidence. And that is what Hanukkah calls us to do: to keep lighting the next candle. As we enter the holiday, I invite you to join us in carrying that light forward. Support the work that uplifts our youth. Become a Big.

 

Encourage someone else to get involved.

Help us ensure that every Jewish child has someone steady in their corner as they navigate the world as it is, and the world as we hope it will become.

Because every moment of Jewish connection is a small flame, and when we protect those flames, we continue the enduring resilience that has been our people’s miracle all along.

 

  Cari Uslan is Chief Executive Officer at Jewish Big Brothers Big Sisters of Los Angeles

Holding the Light Read More »

Sydney Bondi Beach Shooting Chanukah

Mass Shooting at Chanukah Event in Bondi Beach Leaves Multiple Dead and Injured

A mass shooting at a Chanukah event in the Sydney, Australia suburb of Bondi Beach has left multiple dead and injured, after gunmen opened fire during a public celebration marking the first night of Hanukkah.

The event, organized by Chabad of Bondi, was taking place near the children’s playground at Bondi Beach Park and included a public menorah lighting and family activities. The Sydney Morning Herald reported that the shooting began just after 6:30 p.m. Sunday, Dec. 14 (11:30pm Saturday, Dec. 13 Los Angeles time) killing 10 people and wounding several others. Police said two suspects were taken into custody, though authorities said the operation was ongoing and urged the public to avoid the area and follow police directions.

Jeremy Leibler, who leads the Zionist Federation of Australia, said roughly 2,000 people from the Jewish community were at the gathering. One of the victims has been reported by several local news outlets as Chabad emissary Rabbi Eli Schlanger.

The celebration had been promoted in advance as “Chanukah by the Sea.” An Instagram story posted by Chabad of Bondi advertised the event as beginning at 5:00 p.m. local time, and a flyer listed the location as “Bondi Beach Park – Near the Children’s Playground.” The flyer promoted “live entertainment, interactive Chanukah activities, music games & fun for all ages, grand menorah lighting overlooking Bondi Beach,” and invited the public: “Come celebrate the light of Chanukah together with the community. Bring your friends, bring the family, let’s fill Bondi with Joy and Light.”

Video footage appears to show a civilian approaching one of the shooters from behind and forcibly removing his long gun. Another video reviewed shows police arresting a suspect, during which one person on the scene appears to stomp the suspect in the head as officers place him in handcuffs.

The Australian Jewish Association posted a video to its X account showing two men being apprehended by police, with the caption: “Bondi Beach Man appears to stomp on a suspected terrorist. How many times did we warn the Government? We never felt once that they listened. Tragic but no surprise.”

In a public statement, the New South Wales Police Force said, “Two people are in police custody at Bondi Beach; however, the police operation is ongoing and we continue to urge people to avoid the area. Please obey ALL police directions. Do not cross police lines.”

Emergency services responded to the scene as authorities examined suspicious items found in the vicinity. Police said there were no confirmed related incidents elsewhere in Sydney at the time of their statement.

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese addressed the attack, saying, “The scenes in Bondi are shocking and distressing. Police and emergency responders are on the ground working to save lives. My thoughts are with every person affected. I have just spoken to the AFP Commissioner and with the NSW Premier. We are working with the NSW Police and will provide further updates as more information is confirmed. I urge people in the vicinity to follow information from the NSW Police.”

A source who was on the scene shared the following message with a Los Angeles-based Jewish WhatsApp group: “It was a mass shooting in a Hanukkah parade. We’re taking shelter. There are lots of children on the beach. There was nonstop gunfire.”

Sydney is home to an estimated 43,738 Jews, according to figures cited from the 2021 census. Bondi Beach is located on the east shore of Sydney, approximately 9.5 kilometers from the Sydney Harbour Bridge.

As of publication, authorities had not released the identities of the victims or suspects.

Developing story.

Mass Shooting at Chanukah Event in Bondi Beach Leaves Multiple Dead and Injured Read More »