fbpx

December 29, 2020

My Christmas Amid the Nashville Bombing

Three years ago, on December 26, the darkest, most tragic and painful night of my entire life happened at 7:29 PM. My husband, Gary Canter, had gone upstairs an hour prior to take a nap. But when I entered the room, I found him flat on the floor. I immediately called 911, and the operator talked me through CPR. When the paramedics came, I tried to reassure myself that all I needed was to get to the hospital. But then, it dawned on me — the paramedics hadn’t moved. As I sobbed, a responder tapped me on the shoulder at exactly 7:29 PM and said, “ma’am, he didn’t make it.”

Based on that Christmas, it probably goes without saying that for the last two years, I thought I would never be able to celebrate Christmas ever again. No hanging twinkle lights. No buying or exchanging gifts. Just me, alone, forever trapped in the darkest hours of December 26, 2017.

But all that changed on December 25, 2020, when my family drove to Nashville for a three-day holiday getaway. My sister, Tyra, was in the passenger seat. Her longtime boyfriend, Tim, was in the driver’s seat and my 16-year-old niece, Madeleine, was in the back seat with me.

I had been living with them since mid-July of this year, when I sent out a distress phone call to my sister, lamenting the ever-changing landscape that had ravaged Los Angeles and the entire country, which has been in a constant state of rage and unrest since the first protests on May 28.

My sister could sense the fear and panic in my voice, so she said, “Come to Evansville.”

A week later, I took off on a road trip across the country — a road trip that carved out a much better and stronger version of me. On that trip, I let go of the fears that had always held me back and the strictest of boundaries that my marriage had designed for my husband and me. My husband Gary, after all, was a safety commissioner who was fiercely overprotective.

I didn’t know it at the time, but life was about to teach me how to survive any emergency — including the one on December 25 in Nashville. 

Being woken up at 6:28 AM by a loudspeaker on Christmas Day was not actually unfamiliar territory for me. I have suffered from debilitating night terrors for the last three years. It’s always the same dream — I’m fleeing for my life.

What was unfamiliar territory for me, however, was waking up to a human voice. From beneath my blanket, I looked all around the room and thought that this must be another one of my night terrors. But the more I told myself to go back to sleep, the more the looping message broadcasting from the room’s intercom — “THIS IS AN ORDER FROM THE NASHVILLE METROPOLITAN POLICE. EVACUATE NOW TO THE THIRD AVENUE EXIT” — began to feel real.

I eventually got out of bed, thinking that any minute now, I would wake up from this nightmare. Yet, every time I heard the “Evacuate” message, it slowly dawned on me that this night terror was real.

Thoughts of 9/11 began whirling in my head. “No way could anything compare to that,” I thought to myself. “I mean, Nashville isn’t a terrorism target. This can’t be that big of a deal,” I reasoned. I threw on my clothes from the night before and even took the time to brush my teeth. “I mean, this can’t really be anything urgent. This isn’t an emergency.”

When I walked out of the bathroom, the dire reality of this emergency became real. I was stopped in my footsteps by a massive thrust that jolted the hotel into the air, accompanied by the sound of an explosion. For the first minute, as I stood frozen in time, I thought there was a 50-50 chance that the floors beneath me would soon give out.

As I looked around, I thought to myself, “I still have a chance. GET OUT NOW.” I grabbed my jacket, my purse and my electronics bag and began to flee. As I raced down the five flights of stairs, I kept telling myself, “You’ve got his. Just keep going… One foot in front of the other. Don’t panic.”

By the time I reached the second to last staircase, I could hear my sister yelling in a panic, trying to locate her daughter. A calm feeling of “you are not alone” swept over me. For the first time in three years, I had my family with me for a life emergency. My heart was overcome with such joy as I spotted the three of them on the ground floor.

By this time, a small group of us had made our way down the staircase and were now congregated in the back of the hotel’s entrance. But we then heard a voice yell down the stairwell that all of the doors were locked. This was a real-life emergency.

Then, almost in unison, the hotel guests all shouted, “break it down.” While I turned around and reached for a steel chair, a man to my right began kicking in the glass door with his boot. By his fourth kick, we all heard the glass shatter. We all made our escape from the hotel by climbing through the shattered glass door. We took a collective sigh as we entered the street — our safety zone.

But we weren’t safe quite yet.

6:33 AM

I began to snap photos so that I could eventually make sense of the morning. I took a photo of the alley across the way.

6:34/6:35 AM

Police cars raced down the former empty holiday streets — an indication that we were not alone and that we could even begin to let our guard down.

Huddled together, we began to question what had just happened. This must have been a mistake. Or a gas leak. I wasn’t buying either. Then we heard there was a shooting — no, a bomb exploded — no, it was just a gas leak. Nothing was adding up.

6:35 AM

Just when we had reached an almost calm state, a panicked voice screamed: “It’s NOT safe. Get back inside. Get back inside NOW.”

As adrenaline rushed through us, we scrambled to get back inside the hotel.

6:36 – 6:38 AM  

While we were all still trying to make sense of the little information we had been given, we heard over the loudspeaker, “Attention all guests. Head down to the lower level immediately. Head down to the lower level immediately.”

My family repositioned our bodies to move down the staircase and rushed in an orderly fashion past metal beams in a narrow, industrial hallway. As we entered the lower levels of a museum, which was in the basement of the hotel, I had a flashback to the day before, when I calmly walked past the museum entrance, never imagining it would be my very own escape room.

Immediately upon entering the museum, a man explained what he just had observed on Second Street. “There was a big explosion, and there is glass everywhere… we are better off down here.”

6:41 AM

We now met the person who was the voice behind the loudspeaker in the hotel. The hotel staff person was passing out bottles of water. He said that there was an explosion and to remain calm and stay in place until he learned more.

7:11 AM

He then took a roll call of the small group of hotel guests. Because of COVID-19 and the holidays, the hotel had a very small number of guests, only about five or seven rooms.

7:25 AM 

Then came the next burst of adrenaline as the hotel staff person instructed us to flee the building. We made it safely up to the library courthouse and waited patiently while all of the armed forces and ambulances cascaded down Second Street and began roping off the neighborhood.

7:44 AM

The man that kicked down the glass door with his boot and his girlfriend were seated across from me. My niece was sitting next to me on a bench. My sister and Tim were still watching the masses of police and state troopers but came over to tell us that the national guard had been called in.

8:13 AM 

With no one around to give us directions, Tim had an idea. He led us toward shelter — the Fairlane Hotel. After almost two hours of panic and fleeing, we finally arrived to safety, the tall Christmas tree a reminder of what day it was.

We took a seat in the hotel’s lobby, which had a comfortable feel. We were offered coffee and water by the staff, and within minutes, we had made ourselves at home, sipping on our caffeine, taking off our jackets and plugging in our chargers.

I looked around and was perplexed that we were the only ones from our former group to have journeyed this way.

9:46 AM

The Metro Police cased the streets and placed yellow tape on the vehicles that had been sniffed down by bomb-sniffing dogs.

10:23 AM

We remained settled inside the hotel, which began to feel like our own living room, from which we were watching a high-speed car chase on TV. As I looked out the window, the song “Christmas is here to stay” began to play. I was mesmerized by a police car’s flashing blue lights.

11:23 AM 

My family arrived at the Capital Grill. Nothing would deter us from enjoying our preplanned holiday meal.

After five hours of what felt like being cast into a feature-length movie, I finally exhaled. Even though the morning was chaotic, terrifying and surreal, it was the best Christmas I had ever experienced. 

Two years ago, I would have still been in my home preparing for the saddest January and February to come, staring at the eviction notice that my former in-laws began almost immediately following my husband’s tragic passing. One year ago, I was still in such a state of distress that a therapist diagnosed me with multiple levels of PTSD. But throughout it all, I heard my husband Gary’s voice, telling me to never give up until I found my own protection, my own happiness, my own path. 

And I did. Even in the midst of a tragic, traumatizing explosion, I found joy, exuberance and happiness. I protected myself in a moment of tragedy. Now, I know that my husband can finally rest in peace. I have my troops. I’ve built my fort. I have an abundance of emergency contacts. And I am, once again, protected.

So on a day known for giving, I was reminded on Christmas that each and every day is a gift and a treasure. My once very somber Christmas holiday narrative is no longer a dark chapter to be relived every holiday season. It is a time to celebrate this magical gift called life.


Traci Canter was married to Gary Canter for 10 years. Traci and Gary assisted the family business, Canter’s Deli, in acquiring licensing deals. 

My Christmas Amid the Nashville Bombing Read More »

Israel Should Offer to Vaccinate Every Jew in the World

Israel has reason to celebrate the distribution of the COVID-19 vaccines, which are quickly protecting millions of people — nowhere more efficiently than in Israel. As of December 27, Israel has already vaccinated 379,000 people, at the rate of perhaps 100,000 a day. If the government begins administering doses 24 hours a day (which it has considered), the nine million population of Israel could be immunized within weeks.

Yes, Israel should rejoice that it has been able to vaccinate so many people. But it should get some more doses — and offer them to every Jew in the world willing and able to come get it. (Providing the vaccine in people’s home countries could be very complicated legally and medically.)

During the three weeks between the first inoculation and the second, Diaspora Jews could tour, spend money and interact with Israelis and fellow Jewish travelers. Once the government lifts the current lockdown, organizations of all stripes could form countrywide tours, especially for people who have never been to Israel. Local Jewish communities could partner with Israel to raise money to bring Jews with fewer resources to Israel to get lifesaving inoculations.

Of course, in order to be inoculated in Israel (which by then will have herd immunity), Diaspora Jews would still have to travel at a dangerous time. But Israel could try to minimize risk by arranging El Al flights from cities like Seattle and Mexico City, which have no nonstop charter flights. A massive airlift that evokes the rescue in Uganda and bringing Ethiopian Jews home? What a chill-inducing landmark in Jewish history.

For far too long, conversation between Israel and Diaspora Jewry has revolved around the secondary status of non-Orthodox movements regarding conversion and the Kotel — and the political system that enables that status to continue. But by inoculating millions of Jews, Israel can rise above those conversations and demonstrate that it cherishes its brethren around the world.

by inoculating millions of Jews, Israel can demonstrate that it cherishes its brethren around the world.

A mass Diaspora vaccination campaign could be a landmark pivot in Jewish communal solidarity, long remembered as a time when Jews from all communities and backgrounds joined together in common purpose. And it would live up to the highest ideals of our faith.

Of course, there are many Palestinians in the West Bank and Gaza who are also at risk, as are others in the developing world. All of them need and deserve vaccination.

But in life-saving triage, Jewish law is unambiguous: Jews get priority. One example of the many texts that emphasize that point is in the Talmudic tractate Bava Metzia 71a, which explicitly says that if the choice is between helping a Jew and a non-Jew, the Jew gets preference (עמי ונכרי – עמי קודם). This sentiment is also echoed by the oft-cited Talmudic dictum (Shevuot 39a), “All Israel is responsible for one another.” The meaning is “Jews,” but the word, fittingly, is Israel.

With the priorities of ancient Jewish texts in mind, Israel can send a very modern WhatsApp text to every Jew in the world: Israel has vaccines. Come get one.


David Benkof is an online teacher and freelance writer living in Jerusalem.

Israel Should Offer to Vaccinate Every Jew in the World Read More »

California’s Last Jewish Senator

On New Year’s Day 2017, California was represented by two Jewish women in the U.S. Senate. By this time next year, there may be none.

Barbara Boxer and Dianne Feinstein served in the Senate together for almost a quarter of a century, until Boxer retired and was succeeded by Kamala Harris four years ago. It now looks possible that Feinstein will no longer be serving twelve months from now, either.

California’s senior senator has been on the receiving end of unfamiliar criticism recently, most notably for her collegial approach to this fall’s Supreme Court confirmation hearings, after which she complimented and embraced Senate Judiciary Chair Lindsey Graham. This led to such an uproar among Democratic party progressives that Feinstein has since stepped down from her senior role on that committee and fueled speculation that she might choose to leave the Senate altogether before her term expires in 2024.

The progressive fragging that Feinstein has endured became even more intense after the election, as various interest groups lobbied Governor Gavin Newsom to appoint Harris’ replacement from their own respective demographic groups.

During the pre-selection frenzy, many Democratic activists began to publicly call for Feinstein to resign from her seat, arguing that the state should be represented by a younger and more left-leaning senator that better reflected the state’s demographic diversity. (These critics ignore the fact that Feinstein was re-elected just two years ago over a younger, more progressive Latino opponent.)

Ironically, the public pressure on Feinstein is only likely to stiffen her resolve. She is a justifiably proud woman, who would prefer to depart on her own terms rather than the result of grassroots bullying.

But if Feinstein’s critics are smart enough to bite their tongues, they still could get their wish. Feinstein may have left a clue about her future a few weeks ago, when she publicly endorsed Secretary of State Alex Padilla for Harris’ seat. At that time, Newsom was facing competing demands to appoint a Latino or an African-American woman, a decision that would cause him to upset a key Democratic constituency no matter what he decided. Padilla’s first job in politics was as a junior staffer in Feinstein’s Senate office, but Feinstein could have weighed in just as effectively for Padilla in a private conversation with Newsom if getting him appointed was her only objective.

If Feinstein’s critics bite their tongues, they still could get their wish.

It didn’t make much sense for Feinstein to put her thumb on the scale in public, especially for a male candidate, given her own record of promoting and supporting female political leaders. That is, unless she was thinking about her own exit, as well.

It is not hard to imagine Feinstein letting Newsom know that she will let him off the hook by gifting him a second Senate seat to fill, thus allowing him two satisfy two competing power bases within the party. In doing so, she would not only demonstrate loyalty to her former employee but also would make sure that her own Senate seat is filled by another woman. As a result, she would strengthen her legacy as a champion of female political leadership even further.

All in all, not a bad swan song for a longtime leader’s final act.

To be clear, Feinstein has earned the right to finish the term to which she was elected. Whenever she chooses to step aside, she will leave a rich history as a pioneer, a trailblazer and one of California’s most admired leaders. It’s unfortunate that the skills that led her to such an impressive record of accomplishment — her penchant for collaboration and compromise ­— have fallen into such disfavor in today’s hyperpolarized environment and may prevent her from receiving the recognition she is due.

As Joe Biden prepares to take office with a similarly-declared goal of bipartisan cooperation, Feinstein could be a valuable ally in his efforts. Helping a new president navigate an unprecedented set of challenges during his first year in office might just be the way a longtime bridge-builder like Feinstein chooses to conclude her career before riding off into the sunset — at the time of her own choosing.


Dan Schnur teaches political communications at UC Berkeley, USC and Pepperdine. He hosts the weekly webinar “Politics in the Time of Coronavirus” for the Los Angeles World Affairs Council & Town Hall.

California’s Last Jewish Senator Read More »