fbpx

November 6, 2014

Israeli Housing Minister Uri Ariel’s ironic homage to Yitzhak Rabin

Housing Minister Uri Ariel is a staunch supporter of Jewish settlements in Jerusalem, Judea and Samaria. Unlike his old times as the first mayor of the settlement of Beit El and as the head of the Council of Jewish Settlements, in his ministerial capacity today, he can practically send the bulldozers anywhere he likes.

That some of his settlement drives are perceived by many as detrimental to the Israeli-Palestinian peace process doesn’t seem to bother him. Ignoring Prime Minister Netanyahu’s Bar-Ilan speech, in which he had endorsed the two-state solution, Ariel, in a speech at Merkaz HaRav yeshiva on Jerusalem Day (May 27), said that “(t)here will be just one state between the Jordan River and the sea, and that is the State of Israel.”

Let’s leave aside the question of how, with the current demographic trends between the Jordan River and the sea, such a single state will be able to remain both Jewish and democratic. What matters is that Ariel envisages for his ministry plenty of extra work in the future, because I assume that as the Housing Minister of the single state he intends to build for everybody living between the Jordan River and the sea, not for Jews only.  

That is an awesome task. Leaving Gaza aside (unless Ariel wishes that we take it over again), there are some 3 million Palestinians living in the West Bank, many of them in appalling housing conditions, which will require huge investments. To get an idea how huge these investments might be, we should remember that in 1991 Israel asked lawn guarantees of $10 billion from the US Administration, to house the million immigrants from the collapsing Soviet Union.

At this point, some readers might be dismissing all this as nonsense, because everybody knows perfectly well that Minister Ariel is building only for Jews, and let the Arabs take care of themselves. I beg to differ: Ariel cares about the Arabs as well.

Two weeks ago, the National Council for Planning and Building approved the construction of a new Arab city east of Acre. The city, with an expected population of 50,000, would be the first non-Bedouin Arab city to be erected in Israel since its establishment. Minister Ariel, quoted by TheMarker on Nov.5, explained that “the shortage of housing is a cross-sector problem, making life difficult for Jews and minorities alike,” and therefore, he promised, “we will do our best to push the plan forward as quickly and efficiently as possible, for the benefit of the non-Jewish population in northern Israel”.

By working to enhance the standards of living of Israeli Arabs, Ariel is following in the footsteps of the late Yitzhak Rabin. There is, however, a significant difference: In 1992, Rabin stopped the funding of the settlements in Judea and Samaria and suddenly there were big chunks of money available not only for the long-neglected Israeli Arabs, but also for roads and railways, as well as for the key to Israel’s excellence: Education.

Uri Ariel would have nothing of that. Back then, he fought fiercely against Rabin’s policy, and now, as Housing Minister, he can boost the Jewish settlements in Judea and Samaria freely.

Only the future will tell if Israel will be able to keep Judea and Samaria forever, without compromising either its Jewish or democratic nature. And if Israel does keep this territory, will Minister Ariel be able to go on building there for Jews only? And if he builds for the West Bank Palestinians as well, will the Israelis be willing to shoulder the huge economic burden involved?

In the meantime, until these questions are answered, Uri Ariel should be commended for building a city for the Israeli Arabs. By doing so he is promoting equality among citizens, thus strengthening the Israeli society immensely. And with an ironic twist of history, he is fulfilling an important part of the legacy of Yitzhak Rabin.


Uri Dromi was the spokesman of the Rabin and Peres Governments, 1992-96.

Israeli Housing Minister Uri Ariel’s ironic homage to Yitzhak Rabin Read More »

Syrian government forces retake gas field from Islamic State

Syrian government forces and allied armed groups recaptured a gas field from Islamic State fighters on Thursday, a monitoring group said.

The Sha'ar gas field in central Syria has changed hands four times since July, when Islamic State fighters first seized it and killed about 350 government troops, allied militiamen, guards and staff, according to the Britain-based Syrian Observatory for Human Rights.

Government forces retook the field, which lies to the east of the central city of Homs, later that month but lost it again to Islamic State last week in fighting that killed at least 30 pro-government fighters.

The Observatory did not give casualty figures or further details for Thursday's fighting when pro-government forces again retook the field.

Clashes between forces loyal to President Bashar al-Assad and Islamic State were relatively rare until the summer, when the jihadists began taking government bases including several in the northern province of Raqqa.

The two sides have continued fighting as U.S.-led forces began bombing Islamic State in Syria in September. The United States says it is not coordinating with Assad's forces.

Reporting by Alexander Dziadosz; Editing by Janet Lawrence

Syrian government forces retake gas field from Islamic State Read More »

Geckos Play the Angles: The Art of Adaptation!

I was carrying my daughter into the house when a gecko that was hanging on the door jumped into the house. He dashed behind the garbage, then behind the fridge, then down the hall. I chased him, and was amazed at its speed and ability to camouflage itself.

It turns out geckos are quite unique in their ability to run at a speed up to 20 body lengths per second, managing to unstick their feet as effectively as they manage to stick them. It has been suggested that their trick is to “play the angles.” Lizards adjust the angles of their hairs by a few degrees to turn their stickiness on then they merely shift them back. It takes almost no energy and happens instantaneously.

Another animal, the ubiquitous gray squirrel, also has an odd ability. Its hind legs can literally reverse direction (by 180 degrees), which gives squirrels a nearly unique ability to climb down a tree head first (unlike cats and dogs, for example). This ability has served the squirrel well for survival in arboreal areas.

There is a significant leadership learning opportunity here. How can we develop this type of adaptability where we are sticky (rooted) and yet un-sticky (versatile) as well, or have our feet reverse to go up and down with equal ease? How can we “play the angels” where we can bend ourselves backwards, scaling walls, and adapting ourselves to change, grow, and journey as we must?

The Jewish people have been forced throughout history to become like geckos. We have engaged locally with the culture we have lived in yet we have been ready to leave when we have had to (generally under unpleasant circumstances). We not only travelled throughout the desert for 40 years, we have journeyed from country to country throughout history.

There is a depressingly long list of areas (and even nations) from which Jews have been expelled. These include England (1290), central France (1306), Spain (1492), and Portugal (1497), and in 1348 many Jews fled modern Germany after they were absurdly accused of having caused the bubonic plague by poisoning wells. Even in areas where Jews were allowed to live, restrictions were placed. Even the modern word “ghetto,” often denoting an area in which a minority are forced to live due to political or economic reasons, has its origins in Jewish history. In 1516, the city-state of Venice forced its Jews to move to an area by an old iron foundry (“geto” in the local dialect), and were locked in every night.

In response, Jews often moved to modern-day Poland, the Ottoman Empire, and other areas in northern Africa, but even here Jews were frequently the target of attacks, most notoriously the pogroms (the word has been translated as “attack”) in what was then Russia (modern-day Poland) in 1881, when Jews were blamed for the assassination of the tsar. In three waves (1881, 1903-1906, and 1917-1921), these organized riots subjected hundreds of Jewish communities to murder, rape, and destruction of property in an unlimited frenzy of violence that often went on for days. Still later in the 20th century, the Holocaust threatened the annihilation of all Jews, and even today there are existential threats to Jews worldwide.

As difficult as these persecutions have been, hardship can compel us to search for new opportunities, a theme expressed very well by the mythologist and writer Joseph Campbell (in A Joseph Campbell Companion: Reflections on the Art of Living):

We must be willing to get rid of
the life we’ve planned, so as to have
the life that is waiting for us.

The old skin has to be shed
before the new one can come.

If we fix on the old, we get stuck.
When we hang onto any form,
we are in danger of putrefaction.

Hell is life drying up.

Sir Moses Montefiore (1784-1885) epitomized this spirit (New Yorkers may be familiar with Montefiore Hospital, named after him). He was born in Italy, and shortly after his family moved to England (Jews had drifted back in small numbers over the centuries). After amassing a fortune in business, he devoted the last half-century of his life to philanthropy in the international Jewish community. He traveled to what is now Israel seven times, and tried to buy land and promote industry for the small Jewish population. He also traveled to Russia, Morocco, Romania, and other nations in an effort to stop persecution against Jews. For example, in 1840 he was instrumental in getting the Sultan to defuse a “blood libel” (the bigoted lie that Jews use the blood of Christians to make matzo for Passover) campaign against Jews by issuing a decree denouncing this falsehood and prohibiting its dissemination. For his activities, he was knighted by Queen Victoria.

While the list of Jewish scientists and intellectuals (and their impact on scientific developments and academia) who came to America from Europe, often fleeing from persecution, are well known, the contribution of Jewish immigrants from Europe and their descendants on American popular culture should be noted. American popular music (e.g., “Tin Pan Alley” and Broadway musicals) was dominated by people such as Irving Berlin, Jerome Kern, George Gershwin, Sigmund Romberg, and Richard Rodgers. Others who fled from Germany after 1933 included Kurt Weill and Erich Wolfgang Korngold, who wrote the music for many famous Hollywood films of the 1930s (including an Oscar for The Adventures of Robin Hood) after an illustrious operatic career in Europe. Even a lesser known composer such as Werner R. Heymann, who had written successful songs and movie scores in Germany, managed to write the music for the film Ninotchka. That so many Yiddish, Russian, and German-speaking Jews could make the transition to America is a tribute to their astonishing perseverance. Sadly, so many others never had the opportunity to escape.

This resilient value is embedded within Jewish law as well. We must be rooted in tradition and yet evolving to meet new challenges. We must be “sticky” to our past and yet “un-stuck” to journey. Sinai was a moment in history and yet the rabbis also teach that “Each and every day the Divine Voice issues from Sinai.”

Rabbi Lawrence Kushner wrote:

There are many ways to confront history. Some people are Luftmenschen (sky people), living beyond history in hermit retreats or in the theological clouds of other worlds waiting for God. Others try to be Ubermenschen (super people), grabbing history by the throat and drinking its life blood for their own power and vainglory. But not Jews. They get neither peace not power; instead, they must be “Grundmenschen” (grounded people), ones stuck with barely enough power to survive on this earth. Their survival is not ensured seeking it but rather in accord with one principle. Remember, once you were a slave. You know deep inside what it is like to be a stranger, other, powerless, (God was in this place, 112).

In the end I caught the gecko (to the great relief of my wife and kids) but that’s only due to luck. Or maybe I’m learning a little bit about how to play the angles.

In a spiritual sense, we might recognize our greater interdependence:

God is the ocean and we are the waves. In some sense each wave has its moment in which it is distinguishable as a somewhat separate entity. Nevertheless, no wave is entirely distinct from the ocean which is its substantial ground. The waves are surface manifestations of the ocean. Our knowledge of the ocean is largely dependent on the way it manifests itself in the waves. (Richard L. Rubenstein, Morality and Eros, 133).

Humanity and Divinity are interconnected like an ocean and waves. We are to cling to the big picture (the ocean) while also tending to the small facets (our waves). It is in this back-and-forth relationship that we oscillate between acceptance and rejection, stagnancy and mobility, calmness and urgency. Our endurance as a people has depended on this.

 

Rabbi Dr. Shmuly Yanklowitz is the Executive Director of the Valley Beit Midrash, the Founder & President of Uri L’Tzedek, the Founder and CEO of The Shamayim V’Aretz Institute and the author of six books on Jewish ethics.  Newsweek named Rav Shmuly one of the top 50 rabbis in America.”

Geckos Play the Angles: The Art of Adaptation! Read More »

Israel tried to limit civilian casualties in Gaza: U.S. military chief

The highest-ranking U.S. military officer said on Thursday that Israel went to “extraordinary lengths” to limit civilian casualties in the recent war in Gaza and that the Pentagon had sent a team to see what lessons could be learned from the operation.

Army General Martin Dempsey, the chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, acknowledged recent reports criticizing civilian deaths during the 50-day Gaza war this year but told an audience in New York he thought the Israel Defense Forces “did what they could” to avoid civilian casualties.

Israel was criticized for civilian deaths during the conflict, including by the White House. More than 2,100 Palestinians were killed during the fighting, most of them civilians and many of them children, according to U.N. and Palestinian figures.

A Human Rights Watch report in September accused Israel of committing war crimes by attacking three U.N.-run schools in the enclave, while Amnesty International said in a report released on Wednesday that Israel showed “callous indifference” to the carnage caused by attacks on civilian targets.

Dempsey was asked about the ethical implications of Israel's handling of the Gaza war, during an appearance in New York at the Carnegie Council for Ethics in International Affairs.

“I actually do think that Israel went to extraordinary lengths to limit collateral damage and civilian casualties,” Dempsey told the group.

“In this kind of conflict, where you are held to a standard that your enemy is not held to, you're going to be criticized for civilian casualties,” he added.

Dempsey said Hamas had turned Gaza into “very nearly a subterranean society” with tunneling throughout the coastal enclave.

“That caused the IDF some significant challenges. But they did some extraordinary things to try and limit civilian casualties, to include … making it known that they were going to destroy a particular structure,” Dempsey said.

He said the IDF, in addition to dropping warning leaflets, developed a technique called “roof-knocking” to advise residents to leave sites they planned to strike.

Rights groups have criticized the technique, which involves dropping a low-yield explosive or non-explosive device on a rooftop, saying it did not constitute an effective warning and could kill residents too.

Dempsey said the Pentagon three months ago sent a “lessons-learned team” of senior officers and non-commissioned officers to work with the IDF to see what could be learned from the Gaza operation, “to include the measures they took to prevent civilian casualties and what they did with tunneling.”

The general said civilian casualties during the conflict were “tragic, but I think the IDF did what they could” to avoid them.

He said he thought his Israeli counterpart would look at lessons learned from the conflict to see what more could be done to avoid civilian deaths in future operations.

“The IDF is not interested in creating civilian casualties. They're interested in stopping the shooting of rockets and missiles out of the Gaza Strip and into Israel,” Dempsey said.

Israel tried to limit civilian casualties in Gaza: U.S. military chief Read More »

Start-up Nation takes on disabilities

Voiceitt, an Israeli start-up developing voice-translation technology for people with disabilities, was named recently the audience favorite at a Wall Street Journal-sponsored international technology conference.

The company’s new app, called Talkitt, converts the utterances of people with various speech disabilities into more easily understandable elocution. It is slated for release in the middle of 2015.

But Talkitt is hardly the only Israeli tech innovation for people with disabilities. Last year, three Israeli organizations – PresenTense, Beit Issie Shapiro and the Ruderman Family Foundation – teamed to launch what they say is the world’s first “accelerator” focused on addressing the needs of people with disabilities. Called AI3, for Accelerating Inclusion in Israel, the Raanana-based program has enrolled 15 start-up initiatives, such as Sesame Enable, which has created a smartphone that can be controlled with facial and head movements instead of touch for those who are unable to use their hands.

Jay Ruderman, president of the Ruderman Family Foundation – which has been a leader in promoting inclusion in the American Jewish community and Israel – praised Israel’s tech sector for developing solutions that “help people with disabilities and enable them to become part of society.”

However, he said, the Start-up Nation’s government is lagging behind on the disabilities front.

“What it supports is antiquated in terms of housing, employment and the right legislation,” Ruderman said, adding that while “the tech sector’s way ahead in Israel,” its inventions don’t “trickle down to everyone.”

“I’m not sure it’s helping the average person with disabilities yet,” he said.

Start-up Nation takes on disabilities Read More »

IDF generals try love where ‘chickenshit’ failed

If there’s one thing we learned from the debacle last week in U.S.-Israel relations, it’s that swearing at Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu doesn’t persuade him to make peace.

So now, 100 retired Israeli army generals are taking a different tack: They’re sucking up to Netanyahu. And telling him to make peace.

In a letter published as a full-page ad last weekend in Israeli papers, a chorus of former senior officers says something like this:

Bibi, you’re the man. You’re awesome. You know what awesome people do? They take chances to make peace. So don’t screw this opportunity up. Love, the (ret.) army.

“We were impressed by your level-headed leadership in Operation Protective Edge,” the generals write, in a translation supplied by the Israel Policy Forum.

In those circumstances Israel could not and cannot allow fire on our homes nor to put the public in danger. But this operation may turn out to be in vain if we do not act to prevent the next war. The government of Israel and its residents do not have the privilege of sitting around idly. It is time to take responsibility for our future and take advantage of the historical opportunity that has come up following Operation Protective Edge.

Senior Israeli veterans pushing the peace process is nothing new. What’s striking here is the tone of the letter, which sounds wholly supportive of Netanyahu’s leadership. Sentence after sentence start with phrases like “Sir, you yourself have declared” and “You know…”

It’s reminiscent of billboards placed across Israel earlier this year that featured Netanyahu’s face alongside slogans like “Only with an agreement can we secure a Jewish and democratic state. Bibi, only you can do it!” The billboards were a project of Breaking the Impasse, a coalition of 300 Israeli and Palestinian business leaders aimed at advancing a peace accord.

We all know how that worked out. But as the generals’ letter notes, Netanyahu himself said that this summer’s war, and the regional realignments it hinted at, presented a “possible diplomatic horizon” for Israel in the region. The generals see now as the time to capitalize on that chance, and they see Netanyahu as the leader to do it.

The letter pushes the prime minister to embrace the Arab Peace Initiative, a Saudi-sponsored document that promises Israel full diplomatic relations with the Arab world in exchange for a withdrawal from most of the West Bank and an agreement regarding Palestinian refugees. Successive Israeli governments have ignored or rejected the initiative out of fear that a wholesale return of refugees means demographic death for Israel, but recently some Knesset members have pushed it as a starting point for a regional agreement.

Given the repeated failure of Israeli-Palestinian negotiations, the generals seem surprisingly bullish on the chances for a regional peace process. “There is a high chance that this initiative will succeed,” they write near the end of the letter.

“But even if it doesn’t, you owe this to the people of Israel,” they continue. “Only then can we look our children and grandchildren in the eye and say: ‘We tried; we are sorry, we did not succeed.'”

They end by writing, “Lead the way and we will stand behind you!”

We’ll see if the love letter works.

 

IDF generals try love where ‘chickenshit’ failed Read More »

Ex-Hungarian Jewish leader’s government gig sparks talk of betrayal

In the 22 years he ran Hungary’s Mazsihisz Jewish umbrella organization, Gusztav Zoltai was called out for many things.

Zoltai, a former secret police agent who led the Jewish federation until his retirement earlier this year, was accused of corruption and labeled a relic of dark times. Others took issue with his flirtatious behavior toward women.

Yet for all his perceived flaws, no one had called Zoltai a traitor or questioned his loyalty to Hungarian Jewry — until September, when in the wake of a fierce war of words over what many Jews saw as the Hungarian ruling party’s pandering to far-right voters, Zoltai abruptly switched sides.

Just hours before the first meeting between community leaders and the government since relations came to a halt in February over a disputed Holocaust monument, Zoltai accepted a position as a government consultant. In the Sept. 12 meeting, Zoltai sat with Hungarian officials opposite his former Jewish colleagues.

“Betrayal. That’s the only way to call what Zoltai has done,” said Judit Csaki, a journalist who led a series of recent protests against the planned staging of a pro-fascist production at a municipal theater. “Zoltai gave his name and his face to a classic divide-and-conquer tactic designed to break up the Jewish community for its criticism of the government.”

Andras Heisler, the newly elected president of Mazsihisz, said Zoltai had “destroyed his life’s work — that wasn’t immaculate to begin with.” The board of the famed Dohany Street Synagogue, where Zoltai once served as president, voted to expel him.

For Zoltai, a Holocaust survivor who has represented the Jewish community in restitution talks with the government, being branded a traitor was painful. Raised in a Budapest suburb, Zoltai lost 27 members of his family in the Holocaust. His father died en route to a concentration camp. The fate of his mother remained unknown until 1995, when Zoltai brought back her remains from Germany, where she had died in a camp one day after its liberation.

“People who say I am a traitor are not right in the head,” Zoltai told JTA in a brief interview at his new synagogue at Bethlen Square. “I took this position to help the community, not the government. And my credentials speak for themselves. I’m no right-wing nationalist.”

Mazsihisz Vice President Peter Tordai also defended Zoltai, telling the media that the treason charge is “ridiculous.”

Raised in an orphanage, Zoltai went to work in a textile plant at the age of 18. In the harsh postwar years, he was married twice but both wives died young.

Zoltai went on to serve as an airport border guard in the feared AVO secret police. Later he joined the Worker’s Guard, a communist militia set up to suppress resistance following the failed 1956 rebellion against the Soviet-backed government.

“Zoltai had absolutely nothing,” said Peter Feldmajer, a former Mazsihisz president who worked with Zoltai for 20 years. “The party was his way to get ahead in life.”

But instead of pursuing a government career, Zoltai became the director of a small theater in the 1980s before assuming the directorship of Mazsihisz. Some allege Zoltai was forced out as part of Heisler’s attempt to reform a notoriously opaque organization that owns assets worth millions of dollars.

“The man knows everything, every little dirty secret about every community leader, past and present,” said Rabbi Zoltan Radnoti, who heads a popular synagogue in Budapest. “That he could share this knowledge with his new employers is very frightening to them. I know the government likes this, and I think Zoltai enjoys seeing them shake with fear.”

The Holocaust monument dispute followed a series of moves by the ruling rightist Fidesz party that critics allege were designed to compete for the nationalist vote against the rising far-right Jobbik party. Among the government’s decisions were plans to name a Budapest street after an anti-Semitic author and to stage a play by another at a municipal theater.

But the monument fight turned out to be a turning point. Like other community bosses, Zoltai had previously lambasted the government over the monument, which depicts an angel being attacked by an eagle. Critics charged the statue was a symbolic statement of Hungary’s innocence in the wartime murder of 500,000 Jews, a claim the government denied. Efforts to have the design altered foundered in February, after which Mazsihisz suspended contact with the government.

Citing a confidentiality clause in his contract, Zoltai would not say what his new government position requires of him, nor how much money he is earning.

Like many Hungarian Jews, Radnoti is furious with Zoltai, but the rabbi also describes him as a kind man. When Radnoti’s father lost an eye in a car accident that rendered him jobless and penniless, it was Zoltai who put him up in a community-owned home within a day of being asked to help.

Working for the government, Radnoti says, is above all Zoltai’s way of reinserting himself into the center of the action.

“This is a man who ran the show for decades but has been excluded just like that against his will,” Radnoti said. “He took the government job because can’t let go now. It would kill him. He needs to be in the center. He needs to have power.”

To Feldmajer, that Zoltai should be ostracized for accepting a government position is a paradox that is indicative of the problems facing Jews in a society that has failed to fully come to terms with its Holocaust-era culpability.

“What’s really sad about this whole case is that in any other country, the Jewish community would be honored to have a former leader become a consultant,” Feldmajer said. “But this is Hungary.”

 

Ex-Hungarian Jewish leader’s government gig sparks talk of betrayal Read More »

Yitzhak Glick: My brother is a ‘man of peace’

Yitzhak Glick cannot stand hearing his younger brother referred to as a right-wing “extremist.”

“He is a man of peace and a huge supporter of religious dialogue,” he told JTA on Tuesday, one week after his brother Yehuda was shot in the chest and stomach outside Jerusalem’s Menachem Begin Center by an assailant who fled on a motorcycle.

The alleged assailant, who worked in the kitchen at the center and who served 10 years in an Israeli prison for involvement in terrorist activities as a member of Islamic Jihad, was killed in a shootout with Israel Police at his home in eastern Jerusalem.

More than a week after the shooting, Yehuda Glick, 48, is showing signs of improvement. Shaare Zedek Medical Center on Thursday released a statement saying that Glick “was partially communicating with his environment and recognizes those around him.” He was also being weaned off of a respirator.

The Temple Mount activist used to laugh at those who labeled him an extremist and call it “ridiculous,” his brother  said.

He “firmly believes Jews should have the right to pray on their holiest site,” the Temple Mount, said his brother, adding that he thinks there can be “prayer alongside and prayer along with Muslims.”

Since 2006, the New York-born activist has worked for The Temple Institute, which is dedicated to educating about the Holy Temple in Jerusalem and which has created vessels and priestly garments in accordance with descriptions in the Bible.

“I always keep my mobile phone on, in case I get the message that permission has been granted to build the Temple and I have to run,” Yehuda Glick said wryly when his cellphone rang at the beginning of his speech Oct. 29, the night of the assassination attempt, at a conference on the Jewish right to pray on the Temple Mount.

In addition to having rabbinical ordination, Yehuda Glick is a licensed tour guide, specializing in the Old City of Jerusalem, in particular the Western Wall, Temple Mount and surrounding areas.

Glick’s goal, his 54-year-old brother said, is to encourage observant Jews to visit the Temple Mount. The majority of Orthodox rabbis believe this is forbidden, following a 1967 chief rabbinate ruling that bars them out of concern they will accidentally walk on sacred parts of the Temple.

But Glick has attempted to address these concerns by meeting with archeologists to learn which areas of the Temple Mount are non-sacred and then urging rabbis to make rulings permitting visits there. He has brought thousands of Orthodox Jews to the Temple Mount in the past 15 years. Nonetheless, in December 2013, the two chief rabbis of Israel, David Lau and Yitzhak Yosef, reiterated the ban on Jews entering the Temple Mount.

Meanwhile, the Muslim Wakf, which manages the Temple Mount, bars Jews from praying at or bringing ritual objects to the site. After the Israel Police, who enforce the Wakf’s prohibition, stopped Glick from saying prayers the two sides fought it out in Israel’s Supreme Court, which ruled about three years ago that it is legal for Jews to pray at the Temple Mount, but that the police can prevent the prayer if they believe it will endanger the public.

“Glick is an exceptional right-wing activist, who also befriends secular Jews and left-wingers,” columnist Roy (Chicky) Arad wrote in Haaretz days after the shooting. “In contrast to (right-wing lawmaker Moshe) Feiglin, who insists that visits to the Temple Mount should not be regarded as part of the discourse on human rights but rather as an issue of Israeli sovereignty, Glick views the matter as a question of freedom of worship for members of all religions, so he manages to reach a broader audience.”

Glick believes the Temple Mount could function the same way that the Tomb of the Patriarchs in Hebron does, with separate areas for Jewish and Muslim worship and where access to the whole site is provided to Jews or Muslims on certain holidays.

Glick, who has been arrested several times for praying on the Temple Mount, went on a hunger strike last October in protest of a ban on his visiting the site. Less than two weeks after he started the hunger strike police agreed to allow him to visit the Temple Mount, but without praying.

Yitzhak Glick, who travels once a month to work at a hospital in Cleveland, is the founder of the Efrat Emergency Medical Center – which treats both Jewish and Palestinian patients from the Gush Etzion area. He also volunteers as the center’s medical director and visits nearby Palestinian villages to provide free medical care to its residents.

A representative of the United States’ diplomatic corps spoke with the family on Tuesday, a week after the shooting. The call came hours after a report circulated on Facebook, and later in the Israeli media, that no representative of the U.S. government had contacted the family.

Yehuda Glick, the father of eight, is a resident of the West Bank settlement of Otniel, located south of Hebron, where he oversees the foreign student program at the Otniel yeshiva.

“Yehuda was always a doer,” Yitzhak Glick said. “He always felt he had to do something meaningful for someone.”

 

Yitzhak Glick: My brother is a ‘man of peace’ Read More »

Is she Jewish? Rabbinate says yes, Israel says no

In 2012, Anna Varsanyi was married in an Orthodox Jewish ceremony conducted through Israel’s Chief Rabbinate.

Two years later, the Hungarian immigrant has made a life in Israel, settling with her husband in the central city of Modiin and working a desk job in a hospital. She is weeks away from having her first child.

But the baby won’t be Jewish, according to the State of Israel.

Varsanyi, 30, is the victim of an unusual bureaucratic mix-up.

Israel abounds with immigrants who are considered Jewish by the state but not by the Orthodox Chief Rabbinate under its stricter qualifications. Varsanyi is the rare case in which the opposite is true.

Born to a Jewish mother, Varsanyi meets the Chief Rabbinate’s standards for who is a Jew. But Israel claims Varsanyi isn’t Jewish because her mother converted to Christianity.

Varsanyi says her mother is Jewish and it was her great-grandmother who converted — in 1930.

“It’s like they tell you, ‘Come, make aliyah, you’re Jewish, you’re one of us,’” Varsanyi said, using the Hebrew word for immigration to Israel. “But when you’re already here, they say ‘You’re second-class, you’re not one of us. So you might as well leave.’ ”

Born under Hungary’s Communist regime to a Jewish mother and a non-Jewish father, Varsanyi grew up barely aware of her Jewish heritage. But a growing interest in her Jewish roots led her to study Yiddish literature and culture at university and to register for a 10-day Birthright Israel trip. Next came a year abroad at the University of Haifa, where she met her Israeli future husband. After a stint working for the Jewish Agency for Israel in Budapest, she immigrated in 2011.

Varsanyi gained citizenship under the Law of Return, which requires only one Jewish grandparent for an immigrant for automatic citizenship. Varsanyi’s maternal grandfather was unambiguously Jewish.

But when Israel’s Interior Ministry saw a document concerning her great-grandmother’s conversion, they refused to register her as Jewish, claiming she was raised Christian. To be recognized as Jewish, the ministry told Varsanyi, she needed to convert.

Except Varsanyi can’t convert because she is already Jewish according to Jewish law, which doesn’t recognize conversions to other religions. The chief rabbinates of both Israel and Hungary consider Varsanyi, her mother, her grandmother and her great-grandmother to be Jewish.

“It’s hard to imagine anybody more committed to the Jewish people than someone like Anna,” said Rabbi Seth Farber, the founder of Itim, an Israeli organization that guides people with religious status issues through Israeli bureaucracy. “They’re simply not looking at the facts. This woman’s basic rights are being violated, and those of her unborn child are being violated.”

At first, the Interior Ministry’s decision had little effect. Varsanyi already had citizenship and was married, the two areas in which issues of personal religious status are most likely to cause problems.

But last year she began petitioning the ministry for a change in status, worried that her future children would not have their marriages recognized by the government.

“I think it’s ridiculous,” Varsanyi said. “Why would they force me to convert when I’m Jewish? If I didn’t have principles or problems I’d say let them win. But I wouldn’t be able to face myself.”

The ministry has rebuffed her requests, claiming that her mother converted from Judaism before she was born. Varsanyi says this is not true, that it was her great-grandmother who converted.

The ministry also has refused to rely on the Chief Rabbinate’s recognition of Varsanyi as Jewish, despite a 2012 law allowing it to do so. Interior Ministry spokeswoman Sabine Haddad told JTA that the ministry has asked the rabbinical court that declared Varsanyi Jewish for an explanation but has yet to receive a response.

After several rejections, Varsanyi has come to feel like the ministry’s employees “don’t give a crap.” She said she once met with a ministry official, who after reading her papers said, “I don’t know what you want because you’re not Jewish.”

“It was traumatic — I almost cried,” she said. “Like, ‘Welcome to Israel: You’re not a Jew.’ ”

 

Is she Jewish? Rabbinate says yes, Israel says no Read More »

Polanski escapes extradition again, plans Dreyfus Affair movie

The Roman Polanski saga added another chapter last week, and it didn’t leave anybody looking too good.

First, the United States petitioned the Polish government to arrest film director Roman Polanski and hold him for extradition, the latest in a fruitless, decades-long effort to bring Polanski back to the U.S. to face a 1978 rape conviction.

However, in a rather extraordinary bit of tactlessness, the U.S. made the request while Polanski, a Polish-born Holocaust survivor, was visiting Poland for the opening of the country’s new Polin Museum of the History of Polish Jews. Polish officials made sure to emphasize this point in denying the request. To be clear: the U.S. bungled this so badly that they made a convicted rapist look sympathetic.

Polanski’s crime, of course, was the rape of then-13-year-old Samantha Geimer in 1977, in which the director fed his victim quaaludes and alcohol and then had sex with her against her will, all as part of a putative photo shoot. He fled the U.S. in 1978 when his plea bargain appeared set to fall apart. He has since resided in Europe, where he continues to be revered for his directing talent, which apparently outweighs the whole rape thing.

Geimer, for her part, has long since forgiven Polanski and declared that she doesn’t wish him to return to the U.S. for trial, as the resulting media circus would make her life miserable. (She has also declared that the trial and ensuing media circus were more damaging to her than the rape, which is one hell of a comment on this country’s press and legal system.) Polanski publicly apologized to Geimer in 2011.

The most pathetic part of the latest extradition effort was that Polanski has been in and out of Poland quite frequently of late, presenting plenty of other opportunities to attempt to nab him. He is preparing to shoot his next movie in Poland, provided that the government can assure that he will not be extradited.

After the events of last week, that looks like a pretty safe bet.

The movie will focus on the infamous Dreyfus Affair, the 1894 trial and conviction of French Jewish officer Alfred Dreyfus on fraudulent espionage charges. Polanski will reportedly base his movie on the Robert Harris novel, “An Officer and a Spy,” a thriller about another French officer who begins to investigate the Dreyfus case and unmasks the conspiracy. The movie has been in the works since at least 2012 and is supposed to start shooting in the spring.

Given his own legal tangles, Polanski should have plenty of personal material to draw upon. And nobody ever said the man doesn’t have talent.

 

Polanski escapes extradition again, plans Dreyfus Affair movie Read More »