This piece is a response to “A note to stiff-necked people” by David Mamet which first appeared on JewishJournal.com on Nov. 1.
David Mamet recently asked the following questions of “Jews planning to vote for Obama.” Herewith, my responses.
Are you prepared to explain to your children not the principles upon which your vote is cast, but its probable effects upon them?
Yes. My children will be struggling with climate change for their entire lives, which is one major reason I am voting for Obama. I live in New York, and I do not want to see a Hurricane Sandy every year.
Irrespective of your endorsement of liberal sentiments, of fairness and “more equal distribution,” will you explain to your children that top-down economic policies will increasingly limit their ability to find challenging and well-paid work, and that the diminution in employment and income will decrease their opportunity to marry and raise children?
I would explain that, if there were any evidence of it. I’m not sure what “top-down economic policies” you are referring to. The “trickle down economics” of the last Republican administrations have widened the wealth gap, caused middle-class wages and savings to fall, and led to the financial crisis by aggregating risk at the top. Moreover, the Republican refusal to invest seriously in education means that China is going to kick my children’s collective butts in the coming century. For these reasons, the best vote for my children is a vote for Obama.
Will you explain (as you have observed) that a large part of their incomes will be used to fund programs that they may find immoral, wasteful and/or indeed absurd? And that the bulk of their taxes go to no programs at all, but merely service the debt you entailed on them?
I will. The largest shares of the federal budget are the military (spending which Romney wants to increase), Medicare, and Social Security. All the rest is window-dressing. As for the debt, Romney’s absurd additional tax cuts for the wealthiest 1% — including you, Mr. Mamet – cannot be paid for and will increase the burden on my children.
Will you tell your children that a liberal government will increasingly marginalize, dismiss and weaken the support for and the safety of the Jewish state?
If I told them that, why would they believe me instead of the Israeli generals who said that the Obama administration is the most pro-Israel in American history? Really, what’s causing the marginalization of the Jewish state is the right/far-right alliance in the Israeli government which is undermining Israeli democratic ideals. I will tell my children how I lived in Israel for three years, and how I continue to care about the state now – which is why I support the majority of Israelis who want peace, not more confrontation.
Will you tell them that, in a state-run economy, hard work may still be applauded, but that it will no longer be rewarded?
Yes. Fortunately, only conspiracy loons on the far-right believe that the U.S. economy is state-run.
Will you explain that whatever their personal beliefs, tax-funded institutions will require them to imbibe and repeat the slogans of the left, and that, should they differ, they cannot have a career in education, medicine or television unless they keep their mouths shut?
No, since this is demonstrably untrue. Please provide a single example.
Will you explain to them that it is impossible to make a budget, and that the basic arithmetic we all use at the kitchen table is not practiced at the federal and state level, and to suggest that it should be is “selfishness?”
No, since this also is untrue. First, as economists (rather than playwrights) understand, the federal government is not a household. Household debt is very bad; government debt is sometimes bad, sometimes good. What is “selfishness” is to increase that debt so that the wealthiest 1% of Americans can enjoy a tax cut, can pay no taxes whatsoever on overseas income, and pay no taxes upon inheriting millions of dollars.
Most importantly, will you teach them never to question the pronouncements of those in power, for to do so is to risk ostracism?
Of course I will not teach that. I personally have been ostracized from parts of the Jewish community for my support of a moderate Zionist organization, J Street. However, I would rather be ostracized than abandon my love of Israel and the Jewish values on which I grew up.
Are you prepared to sit your children down and talk them through your vote on the future you are choosing for them?
Of course. As a gay man married to my partner, I will explain how Mitt Romney wants to destroy their family and make it impossible for them to be the legal children of their two fathers. I will explain how a small handful of neo-conservatives are making a ‘deal with the devil’ with fundamentalist religious know-nothings who believe that rape is sometimes a good thing and that evolution is a “lie straight from hell.”
Please remember that we have the secret ballot and, should you, on reflection, vote in secret for a candidate you would not endorse in public, you will not be alone.
Fortunately, I am not a hypocrite. I do not do one thing in private and another in public. For the sake of my children, my country, my Jewish people, and the world in which I live, I am proud to be voting Obama.