fbpx

#SadSadIsrael Trends Mocking NYT Article

Ini noted that Israel is consistently ranked among the happiest countries in the world in the World Happiness Report and polling data shows that the overwhelming majority of Israelis are “satisfied with their lives.”
[additional-authors]
November 4, 2021
Photo from Twitter

The hashtag #SadSadIsrael has been trending on Twitter as various users mock a New York Times article depicting Israel as a lachrymose place.

CAMERA’s [Committee for Accuracy in Middle East Reporting and Analysis] Gilead Ini wrote that the Times’ October 26 front-page story from Jerusalem Bureau Chief Patrick Kingsley describes Israel as an “unwanted child” and “an ‘unsolvable’ puzzle of ‘incompatible’ factions burdened by ‘grievances’ and ‘consequences.’ And that’s only in the first seven paragraphs.” Kingsley’s article goes onto depict “underlying tensions and inequities,” “ethnic abuse,” “oppression” and “apartheid,” according to Ini. 

Ini noted that Israel is consistently ranked among the happiest countries in the world in the World Happiness Report and polling data shows that the overwhelming majority of Israelis are “satisfied with their lives.” “In a country whose history of conflict makes all the more remarkable its resilience, vibrancy, and happiness, the New York Times, whose reputation of anti-Israel advocacy has grown in recent years, bends itself out of shape to curate malcontent,” he wrote. “It isn’t following where the Israeli roads leads, letting chance encounters eventually paint an accurate picture. Rather, it’s flipping a two-headed coin to get the intended result.”

The Times article prompted the #SadSadIsrael hashtag mocking Kingsley’s portrayal of Israel.

“In a recent article, @nytimes tries to falsely portray Israelis as sad and miserable,” StandWithUs tweeted. “Israel is now open for tourists, come see for yourself. Fun fact: According to the UN’s annual World Happiness Report, Israel was ranked 11th happiest country in the world. #SadSadIsrael.”

Writer Sarah Tuttle-Singer tweeted, “We stay out all night and swim in warm sea water, or argue with our friends on crowded corners, or drink whiskey until sunrise or dance until our feet hurt and then stop for a minute and keep on dancing… we chose life with our arms and eyes wide open.”

Human rights lawyer Arsen Ostrovsky, who heads the International Legal Forum, tweeted out a photo of himself smiling in water. “Greetings from the Dead Sea! You should check it out @PatrickKingsley @nytimes. Beautiful place. Just beware all those happy people!”

Shlomi Ben-Meir, a researcher for CAMERA in Israel, tweeted out photos of children playing in school and wrote, “My kids’ schoolyard, this week. Look at all the shabbiness these Israeli kids experience! The horror!”

Journalist David Collier tweeted, “Just come back from a walk through Tel Aviv. Everywhere I went – pubs were full, restaurants were overflowing, kids were out playing – and the promenade was packed. Israel truly is a sad place. #SadSadIsrael.”

Writer Emily Schrader tweeted out a photo of Arab-Israeli activist Yoseph Haddad proposing to her and wrote: “Just two sad sad Israelis in the middle of a war, getting engaged. Look how sad we are! I guess @nytimes and @PatrickKingsley hate this since they want to portray Israelis as sad miserable people in their latest absurd article. #SadSadIsrael”

Even Israel’s official Twitter account joined in on the #SadSadIsrael hashtag, sarcastically tweeting at the Times: “We’re sooo sad” with a photo of people eating what appeared to be shawarma.

Kingsley declined to comment on the matter.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

The Legacy of Everyday Love

We may not remember every conversation or every accomplishment, but we remember how people made us feel. In the end, it is those ordinary acts of kindness that stay with us the longest.

I’m So (Sorta) Sorry

The classic case of a “nonapology” apology is when the allegedly contrite offender says something to the effect of “I’m so sorry that you’re upset.” Note that the speaker doesn’t actually acknowledge doing anything wrong.

Off the Hook

Without noticing it, my body has gone from a shiny new Audi to a dented rent-a-wreck. I went from “Let me get it” to “Just give me two minutes to catch my breath.”

AIPAC’s New Challenge

AIPAC’s leaders face fundamental strategic questions unlike those they have confronted in the modern era.… Their ability to adapt to these new circumstances will define not only their future, but that of the U.S.-Israel relationship in this uncertain era.

“Genocidaire: A Twilight Zone Episode”

Once an accusation this explosive becomes accepted as fact, it changes the moral status of the accused. Israelis become genocidaires. Zionists become supporters of genocide. Jews who support Israel become apologists for genocide.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.