fbpx

December 1, 2024

Rabbi Chaim Mentz of Chabad of Bel Air Organizes Healing Trip for Wounded IDF Soldiers

Rabbi Chaim Mentz of Chabad of Bel Air traveled to Israel twice after Oct. 7 to show support. On one of his trips, he donated 5,400 NIS (approximately $1,450 U.S. dollars) to 36 young widows. He also visited Beit Halochem hospital, where he witnessed hundreds of wounded soldiers, many in their 20s and facing life-altering injuries, receiving treatment.

“I asked one of the doctors what we can do in America besides just sending money and he said, ‘R and R: Rest and Relaxation.’ I said, ‘I’m not a psychiatrist or psychologist. What do I do?’ And the doctor replied, ‘I’m not a psychiatrist either. Figure it out.’”

On his way back to Los Angeles, Mentz considered the advice and devised a plan: Why not bring the soldiers to L.A., giving them an opportunity to forget about the war and enjoy life?

“I went to my community and said, ‘We can send all the helmets we want, but if these people are emotionally hurting, they won’t be good parents tomorrow. We need to ensure they have healthy families,’” Mentz said. “Yes, we need to support the hospitals and send helmets, but we also need to help them relieve their stress.”

“We need to support the hospitals and send helmets, but we also need to help them relieve their stress.” – Rabbi Chaim Mentz

The congregation responded enthusiastically. When Mentz suggested funding the trip by selling Torah covers, it took just 90 seconds to sell five, raising $25,000. It was Rosh Hashanah, and the plan was to bring the soldiers to L.A. in time for Simchat Torah, which was only 18 days away.

“I said, ‘I want you to dance with them, lift them up on chairs and make them feel like a million bucks,’” said Mentz.

Soon, the entire congregation began offering activities: Trips to Universal Studios, Warner Brother Studios, spa days and more. Adina Finn of Encino coordinated with Beit Halochem hospital to arrange the arrival of three soldiers, Amitai Cohen, 22, Israel Ben Shitrit, 39 and Michal Padlad, 27.

All three had sustained severe injuries during the war. Ben Shitrit was injured on March 31 in Khan Younis, Gaza when a rocket struck a house, killing two IDF soldiers. “We were tasked with reaching the location where the rocket was launched,” he said. “As I exited one house, I saw an RPG heading toward me. I told myself, ‘This is it. This is the end.’”

Ben Shitrit fell unconscious. When he came to a minute later, he realized he was hurt. His leg was bleeding profusely. “I tried to hide, but they saw me moving and shot me with an AK-47,” he said. “I told myself my mission was to save my soldiers, so I started crawling to another house. I began rescuing my friends, but they shot at us again. Sadly, one soldier died in my arms.”

The father of five spent three and a half months in the hospital and initially couldn’t walk. Now, he uses a cane and faces a long rehabilitation process. His vision was also affected by nerve damage, but he remains hopeful it will improve. “It is amazing being here,” he said. “It’s been two weeks and it’s stress-free to not hear news about the war and just live a normal life.”

The group visited Universal Studios and saw the WaterWorld show, famous for its loud special effects, including gunfire and explosions. Despite the noise, they remained relaxed and enjoyed the show with no signs of PTSD, which usually affects many soldiers after battles.

Padlad, another one of the visiting IDF soldiers, is one of the few female soldiers in a combat unit. Her role involved managing the supply chain and ensuring the unit had everything it needed. In August, during an operation, she was injured and spent nearly three months in the hospital before being released to join the trip. It’s important to her that people recognize that there are female warriors who are just as brave and, like their male counterparts, got injured during this war.

In a Zoom interview, she shared how much the experience meant to her. “The Bel Air community was simply amazing,” she said. “I felt their warmth the moment I arrived. They helped with our healing, took us out for fun activities and helped us clear our heads. To be honest, I cried the whole way to the Ben Gurion Airport because I didn’t want to come. I thought it would be too hard and I was scared. But the minute we arrived, we were greeted with such a big hug from the rabbi and the entire community. I didn’t expect that at all.”

Padlad, Cohen and Ben Shitrit were treated like royalty. They enjoyed a helicopter ride, visited the Santa Monica Pier and Disneyland and went shopping. They were surprised with a private Pilates class from a Muslim woman who heard about their visit and wanted to show her support.

 “We even crashed a million-dollar bar mitzvah,” Mentz said. “It was in the backyard of a mansion in Beverly Hills. I said we’d stop for just a few minutes, but I knew what would happen once the guests learned who they were.” Sure enough, the bar mitzvah hosts and guests warmly welcomed the soldiers and wouldn’t let them leave. “They felt so much love, which was exactly my intention: To help them forget the war and everything they had endured and simply have fun,” the rabbi said. 

Mentz accompanied the soldiers every day, making sure they were having fun and had everything they needed. “I had more fun than they did,” he said. “I became a 19-year-old again.”

After their visit in L.A., the rabbi took the soldiers to New York, where they continued their trip before returning to Israel. Witnessing the positive impact of the trip on the three soldiers, Mentz said he would, God willing, arrange another trip for a new group.

Rabbi Chaim Mentz of Chabad of Bel Air Organizes Healing Trip for Wounded IDF Soldiers Read More »

Awaiting the Day 1 Dictator

I don’t know about you, but I am waiting anxiously for the day after Donald Trump’s second inauguration—you know, when the dictatorship is set to begin.

At least for “Day 1.”

Remember, that’s what Trump allegedly promised would happen if he was re-elected. It was a pretty big deal. The Democratic Party chose to fixate on “Dictatorship Day” all throughout its doomed campaign. That’s why “fascist” was invoked so often, along with comparisons to Hitler and Mussolini.

Huge mistake. Time would have been much better spent convincing American voters that Joe Biden’s vice president was prepared to fix the many things he had bungled: the border, crime, the economy, anti-American progressivism, America’s declining influence in the world, the assiduous tolerance of antisemitism and the backstabbing of Israel.

Like many things that require elocution, what Trump said in that December 5 Iowa town hall was spontaneous, impulsive, irresponsible and nonsensical. From what I can decipher, he meant that he plans to dictate on day one to “fix the border” and “drill, drill, drill.” It sounds like he was jokingly saying: “Those two issues are so important, I am going to get them done on my first day back in office—by fiat, if I have to.”

No matter, that’s all Never Trumpers and those longsuffering Trump Derangement Syndrome survivors needed to hear.

You can’t really blame them. From when he first ran for the presidency beginning with the Republican primaries back in 2016, the Trump persona was defined by scary off-the-cuff remarks. Remember: “I could stand in the middle of 5th Avenue and shoot somebody and wouldn’t lose any voters, ok? It’s, like, incredible.”

A candidate for the nation’s highest office probably shouldn’t leave voters with the impression that he was already so popular, he could attempt murder and still receive their endorsement—even when speaking in jest. Of course, it turns out he was right: Many of his core constituency probably would overlook a violent crime on his record.

This past campaign, Trump intimated that he would investigate Comcast, NBC and MSNBC for treason, possibly execute former Joint Chiefs of Staff Chairman Mark Milley for the same offense, and maybe even terminate the Constitution in order to reverse a fraudulent election result.

Many applaud such public statements, but none are funny, dignified, appropriate or in any way presidential. Of no other American politician could it be said that he would be far more successful if he simply slashed his public statements and social media postings in half, if not by two-thirds. Trump would have swept Joe Biden back in 2020 and retained the White House if he had simply spoken and tweeted less.

But regardless of all that Trump ill-advisedly said this election cycle, those ramblings are in no way comparable to the iron-clad promises and governmental reforms Adolf Hitler brought to Berlin.

I know what some readers are thinking: “Give Trump some time and watch his brand of American fascism at work.”

That’s why more than a few of our fellow citizens have already liquidated their assets (and, in doing so, missed out on a nice stock market bump) and are making plans to leave the United States. Several Hollywood celebrities have suggested that their house-hunting in Europe has already begun. (Great idea: you think we have problems with immigrant gangs and crime, Islamist terror warnings, and antisemitism?)

If you are one of those making plans or threatening to leave the United States, let me sincerely ask you: Do you need any help packing? Would you like the name of a good mover? Here are a few suggested destinations that may be more to your liking: Venezuela, Sudan, maybe Yemen.

The tragic irony is that in this era of fashionable anti-white Scrabble—DEI, CRT, BDS and PHD (Pro-Hamas Derangement)—the nonbinary thrashing of gender and sexuality, anti-colonial anti-Americanism, and all those protesting, screaming and shoving, disrupting Black Friday and Christmas tree lightings, resisting arrest and now planning to leave the country: all of these “Americans” actually believe that they are the true patriots.

I’ll have to ask George Washington, John Adams, Benjamin Franklin and Thomas Jefferson about that. Never mind: The original patriots are now just racists.

You may not respect people who wear MAGA caps, but there’s no shame believing in American greatness. Yes, I am aware that one can’t obtain tenure with such a grandiose love of country, or snag an invite to a fashionable party in Brooklyn, Brentwood, Bayview-Hunters Point, or Albany Park, but one of the reasons Trump is being returned to the White House is, in part, because progressive America is a regression to American mediocrity.

A majority of Americans observed and then rejected that in the policies and priorities of the Biden administration: the over-political correctness, the self-censorship, groupthink, moral certainty, and racial underpinnings of almost everything, and the lax enforcement of border control and prosecution of violent crime.

You know that voters deservedly rejected the anti-American platform of Democratic progressives when nearly 70 percent of Native Americans—from the far-flung tribes in North Dakota, South Dakota, Wisconsin, Kansas, Arizona, and New Mexico—voted for Trump. Yes, that’s no misprint. Native Indians have every reason to hate America, and they swung for Trump alongside his greatness-seeking American cowboys.

I, of course, realize that punch-drunk red-state-haters believe that Trump supporters are plain stupid and uneducated.

You are not morally superior or more virtuous because you have three pronouns, believe that every interaction has a racial overtone, can’t define the anatomy of women, believe that America is a global menace, and Israel is the worst human rights violator in the history of our planet. What you are is arrogant, paranoid, narcissistic, self-righteous, and antisemitic.

But here’s a thought for solipsistic coastal elites: You are not morally superior or more virtuous because you have three pronouns, believe that every interaction has a racial overtone, can’t define the anatomy of women, believe that America is a global menace, and Israel is the worst human rights violator in the history of our planet. What you are is arrogant, paranoid, narcissistic, self-righteous, and antisemitic.

A lot of conformist scripted talk and self-hating beliefs led to a lost election for Democrats. For over two centuries, America succeeded because of a shared sense of what it meant to be an American. That vision has clearly been lost. The only question now is: Will a Day 1 dictator be able to bring it back.


Thane Rosenbaum is a novelist, essayist, law professor and Distinguished University Professor at Touro University, where he directs the Forum on Life, Culture & Society. He is the legal analyst for CBS News Radio. His most recent book is titled “Saving Free Speech … From Itself,” and his forthcoming book is titled, “Beyond Proportionality: Is Israel Fighting a Just War in Gaza?”

Awaiting the Day 1 Dictator Read More »