fbpx

June 6, 2023

Holocaust Remembrance Counters the Axis of Resistance to Change in the Middle East

When I first moved to the Jewish quarter in Strasbourg, I had no idea Jews lived there. It may seem naive, but I assumed that part of the city simply received its name from history and Jews — like most Jewish neighborhoods in the Middle East — and no longer had an active presence in those areas.

Imagine my surprise — and sadly, horror — when I realized that I was living in the epicenter of Jewish life in the city. 

My first encounter with a Jewish individual occurred as I entered a grocery store. When I saw a Jewish man enter, I immediately had a panic attack, dropped my groceries and fled. 

In hindsight, I understand that reaction was not only misguided but bigoted. However, as a young woman whose parents were Lebanese and Syrian and who had family members belonging to Hezbollah, this is how I was conditioned to react to a Jew. I was told they were scary, dangerous and not to be trusted. And after going through three wars in Lebanon where the state told me Israel was the aggressor, my feelings not only felt justified; they were encouraged.

But when I gathered up the courage to go inside, and I locked eyes with the Jewish grocer, I saw nothing but kindness.

He bagged my groceries and made no mention of my outburst.

In my work, I’ve come to understand that Jews have contributed to Arab culture in a myriad of ways, only to be excluded and marginalized. The very idea that Jews are part of where I came from compelled me to uncover more.

I often think of that moment as I immerse myself in Jewish and Islamic studies, examining why these two groups harbor such visceral reactions toward each other. In my work, I’ve come to understand that Jews have contributed to Arab culture in a myriad of ways, only to be excluded and marginalized. The very idea that Jews are part of where I came from compelled me to uncover more.

Sharaka, a nongovernmental initiative that cultivates people-to-people relationships from Arab countries that reached normalization agreements with Israel as part of the Abraham Accords, has accompanied me on this journey of cross-cultural understanding.

Last year, I had the privilege of visiting Poland for March of the Living — a nearly three-mile march from the Auschwitz concentration camp to the Birkenau extermination camp on Holocaust Remembrance Day. Ironically, it was there, while touring the depths of human depravity, that I saw the beauty of humanity. I didn’t find it in the horrific displays of abuse and torture, but instead I witnessed it when Jewish visitors at Auschwitz were moved by the presence of our Arab delegation.

At the same time, solidarity between Arabs and Jews must go beyond these touching moments. With the rise of immigration to their continent, far more Europeans are turning to the far right and its political leaders, who are associated with extremism, violence and antisemitism. My home is now in Germany — as my ties with Jews and Israelis have made it impossible for me to move back to Lebanon — and I’m concerned what kind of Europe my son will see in the years to come.

Some 80 years ago, Jews were considered subhuman in Germany and paid a heavy price. It’s shocking to know that one of the most educated countries in the world was home to the masterminds of one of the most brutal genocides in human history. The Nazis listened to the opera as Jews burned.

If Germany and the Jewish community can make peace, I firmly believe that Jews and Arabs can continue to do the same.

And yet, today Germany and Israel enjoy a positive relationship in which they cooperate on an array of initiatives, ranging from education to culture to security. If Germany and the Jewish community can make peace, I firmly believe that Jews and Arabs can continue to do the same.

Thankfully, with the Abraham Accords, that process is already underway as governments and Arabs and Israelis on the ground have begun to forge deep and meaningful relationships. 

This year, I again joined Sharaka’s delegation of Arab influencers at the March of the Living. Last year’s delegation was a breakthrough. This year was an affirmation. I anticipate that more Muslims will visit Auschwitz on Holocaust Remembrance Day as the word spreads, forming a new alliance of tolerance that counters the axis of resistance to change in the Middle East.


Rawan Osman is a Syrian-Lebanese peace activist, currently writing a book about her perception of the Jewish people and Israel before and after leaving the Middle East. Formerly with the PeaceComms Institute, Osman is studying Jewish and Islamic studies at Heidelberg University in Germany. 

Holocaust Remembrance Counters the Axis of Resistance to Change in the Middle East Read More »

Taste Buds with Deb: Whet Your Appetite

Cooking shows are fun to watch. You see these vibrant, colorful dishes — some look better than others — but it’s really such a tease. In most cases they leave out the most important part: the recipe. 

While the episodes are designed to draw you in, part of the joy is trying to recreate what you see, so you can smell, taste and enjoy.

I need only think of a dish, whether it’s my maternal grandmother’s mandel bread, my paternal grandmother’s kugel or my mom’s chicken soup, and it brings me back to my youth. So you can imagine how strong the memory is after preparing and eating any of these dishes. 

When I started the “Taste Buds with Deb” podcast, my priority was to include a recipe with each episode. My guests are eclectic in background and experience, which shows in the recipes they share. They are not all chefs. There’s a TV producer, community builder and networking expert in the mix. What they have in common is their love of food and an understanding that food brings people together.

I have found that this love of food, cooking and community is everywhere. People get excited when I talk about my food podcast. 

I have found that this love of food, cooking and community is everywhere. People get excited when I talk about my food podcast. My Jewish and non-Jewish friends, strangers I meet at events, they all want to learn more. They want to hear what others have to say, but also, they ask, “Do you want to share recipes? Can we sit and talk about food? Can I be on your show?” 

The other day, I mentioned my Instant Pot casually in conversation; it happens. A woman responded, “I may finally take my Instant Pot out of the box.” 

This is what I want my show to do. To get people to take their appliances out of the box … to see a recipe that is out of their comfort zone and decide to try it … to have a conversation with a stranger and find common ground. 

Remember, if you love food, you can be in any setting, and you are never at a loss for words. 

These are the people I spoke with in May on Taste Buds with Deb, along with what recipes they shared. You can listen to these bite-sized conversations and get the recipes at JewishJournal.com. You can also find the episodes on iTunes or your favorite podcast platform.

Warning: This show may make you hungry.

And, because I will not leave you without a new recipe to try, below I added chef Judi Leib’s Pound Cake.

  1. Chef Shimi Aaron: Being Babka King, the Art of Food and Eggplant Carpaccio

  1. The Swell App’s Deborah Pardes: Storytelling, Entertaining and Portobello Leek Soup

  1. Samantha Ferraro: Little Ferraro Kitchen, Mediterranean Flavors, and One Pot Chicken

  1. Producer Arthur Smith: “Hell’s Kitchen,” “Reach” and his Wife’s Brisket

  1. Baking It’s Norma Zager: Comedy, Cooking and Chocolate Pasta

  1. Author Robbie Samuels: “Croissants vs Bagels,” Food Analogies & Networking

  1. Judi Leib: Whisk in the Southern, Cooking Fearlessly and Pound Cake

Aunt Rosie’s Pound Cake by Judi Leib

Equipment
1 10-inch Tube Pan
Ingredients
1 cup unsalted butter, at room temperature
2 cups granulated white sugar
5 large eggs, at room temperature
2 cups all-purpose flour
1 tsp kosher salt
5 Tbsp pineapple juice

Instructions:
1. Preheat oven to 325°F
2. Cream together butter and sugar. You are looking for it to be light in color and fluffy.
3. Add eggs, one at a time, beating well after each addition.
4. Whisk flour and salt together.
5. Add flour, in thirds, alternating with pineapple juice. Always start and finish with your dry ingredients.
6. Do not overmix. Just let the flour barely incorporate. Finish mixing with a spatula, by hand.
7. Grease and flour a 10-inch tube pan. Pour batter in and set on a baking sheet.
8. Bake for 50 minutes to an hour.
9. Let cool for 10 minutes in the pan. Then invert and let fall naturally out of the pan.
Note: In Aunt Rosie’s pound cake recipe, Judi Leib uses pineapple juice for the liquid. But you don’t really taste the pineapple. You can use any other juice or buttermilk too.


Debra Eckerling hosts the “Taste Buds with Deb” podcast.

Taste Buds with Deb: Whet Your Appetite Read More »

The Film “Israelism” Assaults the Truth and Hurts Palestinians

It’s too easy to criticize the new documentary “Israelism” and debunk its gross misrepresentation of the complex Israel-Palestinian conflict. But as bad as I feel for viewers who have to brave the propaganda, as I watched the film I felt even worse for the filmmakers and the Palestinians.

I felt bad for the filmmakers because I could feel the exertion they must have gone through to stick to only one side of the story. Don’t assume it’s so easy to exclude crucial context that is so obviously missing. There is no mention, for instance, of the UN role in the creation of Israel, Arab aggression at the birth of the state, chronic Palestinian terror and rejection of peace offers, the denial of any Jewish connection to Jerusalem, and on and on. These facts are so well known, I could almost feel the filmmakers asking themselves: “Should we include at least a little of this stuff just to appear more credible?”

In fact, as I watched the film, I imagined an enterprising activist who would re-edit the film to include the missing context and correct the misleading claims. They might call the film, “Israelism: Exposed,” with the slogan: “For those who want the whole truth.” It would become must-see viewing for anyone interested in Zionism, the Palestinian cause, the dark art of propaganda and the search for truth.

It’s ironic, of course, that a film that specializes in withholding information complains about the same thing. The film features a few carefully selected young American Jews complaining that their Jewish upbringing advocated for Israel but withheld any advocacy for Palestinians. To hear them, you’d think there was a total blackout in Jewish America on discussing the plight of the Palestinians, which is quite the opposite. A five-second Google search would have given these young Jews an overdose of the Jewish soul-searching and self-criticism they claim was “hidden” from them. But the movie wants us to believe that Zionist advocacy was so one-sided and all-consuming it created a generation of young Jews who, feeling duped, have turned against their own.

This narrative is convenient if you want to predictably bash the Jewish “establishment” and let Jew-haters off the hook. Indeed, the narrative ignores the great number of Jewish kids who have had no connection to that establishment and never went to Jewish day schools or summer camps. Those kids have been poisoned on Israel not by some mythical establishment but by propaganda vehicles like “Israelism,” not to mention BDS campaigns that routinely malign Israel as a genocidal, baby-killing apartheid regime.

Evidently, the real culprits in “Israelism” are not the slew of anti-Israel groups dedicated to demonizing the world’s only Jewish state, but those Jewish schoolteachers and summer camp leaders who couldn’t curb their enthusiasm for sharing their Zionist pride.

Thus, the very notion of Israel advocacy in the film takes on a sinister tone, as if anything short of perfect even-handedness is an unforgivable sin. This coming from a documentary that is so one-sided it crosses into boredom. When a filmmaker doesn’t mind being repetitive and melodramatic for the sake of an agenda, you know it’s propaganda.

When a filmmaker doesn’t mind being repetitive and melodramatic for the sake of an agenda, you know it’s propaganda.

But boring doesn’t mean it won’t be popular, for the simple reason that bashing Israel is the safe, conformist choice in today’s progressive circles. In truth, the real rebels these days are the Zionists, because they don’t mind being unpopular if it means standing up for what they believe. They believe that a people that yearns for 1900 years to come home, and then creates against all odds an imperfect but vibrant and resilient nation bursting with innovation that helps the planet, is an endeavor worth defending and being proud of. These Zionists don’t feel duped by their education– they feel blessed.

The real rebels these days are the Zionists, because they don’t mind being unpopular if it means standing up for what they believe.

Ultimately, though, watching “Israelism” made me feel worse for the Palestinians. For years, the dark secret of anti-Israel activists is that they bash Israel a lot more than they help Palestinians. By putting all their resources on going after Israel, these activists have perpetuated the illusion that the resolution of the conflict is a one-way street, with Israel having all the responsibility and Palestinians having no agency. A more courageous and compelling film would have exposed the corruption and glorifying of terrorism at the highest levels of Palestinian leadership, which has turned out to be the biggest obstacle to Palestinian progress.

That film would have shown something college students rarely see—how Palestinian leaders have suppressed their own people by fattening their personal bank accounts and teaching Palestinians that a Jewish state has no right to exist and is worthy only of hatred and rejection. If the Jewish activists in “Israelism” really cared about Palestinian well-being and conflict resolution, they would plant themselves at Palestinian offices at the UN as often as they do at the ADL.

But that would mean they’d have to be more balanced and even-handed, and who would want to star in that movie?

The Film “Israelism” Assaults the Truth and Hurts Palestinians Read More »