fbpx

April 25, 2022

Elon Musk Buying Twitter Won’t Improve the National Conversation

Technology and social media have changed the dynamics of free speech in America, and the announcement today that mercurial billionaire Elon Musk will take over Twitter will bring this change into sharp relief.

The constitutional view of speech in our country has always been to protect the most vile and offensive speech as the price to pay for liberty. The thinking was that in an environment where ideas can be vigorously debated, the best ones would rise to the top.

“Free speech is the bedrock of a functioning democracy, and Twitter is the digital town square where matters vital to the future of humanity are debated,” Mr. Musk said in a statement announcing the deal. Musk had said earlier that “it’s just really important that people have both the reality and the perception that they are able to speak freely within the bounds of the law.”

The problem is that in an impulsive medium like Twitter, it’s not ideas that dominate speech but attitude. Speaking freely, or should I say tweeting freely, means lots of snap, snark and darts. The ideas are there, but they’re lost in the noise of verbal warfare and partisan and personal agendas. To quote The New York Times: “Political leaders have used it as a megaphone, while companies, celebrities and others have employed it for image-making and brand building.”

None of that will change with new ownership. More unfettered speech on Twitter, no matter in which political direction, won’t improve or deepen the national conversation. But is that even on Musk’s agenda? It doesn’t look like it.

When Musk champions the ability to “speak freely within the bounds of the law,” he must know that the law allows the most disgusting speech, including even hate speech. Indeed, if the “law” is Musk’s only boundary, good luck developing an algorithm that can ferret out the very narrow legal exceptions to free speech.

In any case, private industry is not bound by Constitutional protections of speech, which is why giant platforms like Twitter and Facebook have tried  to moderate speech as they saw fit, whether to censor bigoted speech or blatant disinformation.

The problem is that these platforms lost credibility when they showed their political bias. The most blatant example was the blocking of the now-verified New York Post story on Hunter Biden’s laptop before the last presidential elections.

A medium that prizes snarky repartee and partisan agendas will always mitigate against vigorous and constructive debate.

But beyond the impossibility of objectively moderating a free-for-all platform like Twitter, the real problem is that a medium that prizes snarky repartee and partisan agendas will always mitigate against vigorous and constructive debate.

Ironically, the best way to nourish such debate is to look to traditional media, not social media. It’s only by having sharp editors carefully vet and edit smart, thoughtful commentary from all sides that we can hope to elevate the national conversation.

If Elon Musk wants to elevate the national conversation, he should buy The New York Times and CNN.

That would require, of course, more media companies in America that care about and value smart, thoughtful commentary and analysis from all sides. As Batya Ungar-Sargon documented in her book, “Bad News: How Woke Media is Undermining Democracy,” these editors are now few and far between, and their bias has infected even social media.

If Elon Musk wants to elevate the national conversation, he should buy legacy media like The New York Times and CNN, and hire editors who are passionately committed to deep and vigorous debate that won’t favor any side. That may even improve the quality of our tweets.

Elon Musk Buying Twitter Won’t Improve the National Conversation Read More »

JETS School Releases New Video Featuring Students and Alumni: “We Are JETS.”

Jewish Educational Trade School (JETS), the innovative Los Angeles-based school that combines Judaic learning with real-world skills, has released a new video highlighting the stories and journies of its students and alumni. The video, titled “We Are JETS,” was shot in Los Angeles and Miami over ten days and features 20 JETS students, alumni, and staff.

“We’re extremely proud of our students and alumni and their achievements,” said JETS principal Naftali Smith. “This video is a great way to showcase their hard work, dedication, and the tremendous growth JETS has created in these young professionals’ lives.”

JETS alumni have gone on to successful careers in various fields, including mortgage banking, software development, digital marketing, real estate development, and more.

JETS alumni have gone on to successful careers in various fields, including mortgage banking, software development, digital marketing, real estate development, and more. The school is known for its unique educational model combining traditional Jewish studies with top-notch vocational training, through which students gain valuable real-world skills and launch lucrative careers and companies.

“Our students and alumni are doing amazing things every day,” said Rabbi Mayer Schmukler, JETS founder & director. “The new video is just a tiny taste of the extraordinary impact they are providing to their communities and a great way to show the world that anything is possible with hard work and dedication.”

Watch the new video ‘We Are JETS” below, and learn more about JETS by visiting their website at https://www.jetsschool.org

JETS School Releases New Video Featuring Students and Alumni: “We Are JETS.” Read More »

The Duplicity and Violence of Al-Quds Day

What will you all be wearing this Friday for Al-Quds Day? If you’re Jewish, you should really be giving it some serious thought. I wouldn’t take the day too lightly.

Those who observe the holiday are hoping for a bash, which is what Iran and its Palestinian proxies always desire — not so much a celebration of Islam’s ties to Jerusalem, but more pointedly, the pummeling of Jews, wherever they might be found.

Beginning with the Islamic Revolution in 1979, Iran has hosted a worldwide annual hate-fest against Jews, celebrated on the last Friday of Ramadan. What a sad but revealing coda to the most pious month in the Islamic calendar — end your fast, and then get back to the joyous business of replenishing your rage against Israel. It’s a special day each year where Muslims pledge themselves to the destruction of the Jewish people by first eliminating their state.

It’s a special day each year where Muslims pledge themselves to the destruction of the Jewish people by first eliminating their state.

Think of Al-Quds as a whirlwind of antisemitic, anti-Zionist propaganda — a Passion Play for Muslims with Jews, naturally, typecast as villains. Ostensibly it’s a day of solidarity with the Palestinians, but in actuality, it’s just another excuse to burn flags and incite violence against Israel.

How do I know that despite all the hoopla, Quds is only peripheral to the Palestinians? Well, when Jordan truly “occupied” Jerusalem and the West Bank during Israel’s first 19 years of existence (unlike Israel, Jordan had no lawful claims to the land, at all), the rights of Palestinians were notably unmentioned in the Arab world. Statehood hardly ever came up. Muslims didn’t demand that Jordan surrender the land to the Palestinian people.

It was only when Israel recaptured and reclaimed those territories in the Six-Day War did Arabs and Persians pay duplicitous lip service to Palestinian national aspirations.

Now, imagine if Luxembourg set aside a day for the exclusive purpose of hating France and its people — regardless of where they might live. The world would be outraged. Yet, when it comes to the unremitting hostility Arabs have toward Jews, double standards abide, and the lowest of expectations are accepted. How can we not expect Arabs to incite violence against Jews at the conclusion of Ramadan?

Were it not for Israeli control over Jerusalem, would Muslims really need a day dedicated to this particular holy city? Yes, of course there is the Al-Aqsa Mosque on the Temple Mount, but in Islamic sacred scripture, Jerusalem isn’t even a footnote. I am not kidding. Jerusalem appears in the Old Testament 670 times. In the Koran — not once. If Jerusalem is that important to Muslims, how come it got left entirely out of its holy text?

Moreover, if Al-Quds was really about Palestinian self-determination, there would be less burning of the Israeli and American flags, and far less trash talk. Palestinians are not on the minds of those who finance the holiday. In 2018, Iran’s President Hassan Rouhani celebrated Al-Quds by stating that “Israel can never feel that it is in a safe place.” In 2012, Iran’s then president, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad said that “confronting the Zionist regime is a national and religious duty.”

Worse still, the bloodthirstiness of Al-Quds is not confined to the region. It is celebrated internationally, in over 80 countries, in New York, London, Paris, Stockholm, Berlin, and Toronto. In London it attracts as many as 3,000 people. In Berlin, 1,600 protesters showed up in 2018. The United States can expect to see rallies in as many as 18 cities, especially on college campuses, with great fanfare.

Quds Day may be a pep rally, but beware of Game Day, which is when the real fervor unfolds.

Remember last year? Unlike other holidays, which were canceled during the pandemic, Al-Quds was deemed too essential to skip. The demonization of Israel is more infectious than the coronavirus.

The demonization of Israel is more infectious than the coronavirus.

It got a boost from the Israeli Supreme Court deciding the fate of four Palestinian families who faced eviction from homes owned by Israelis in the East Jerusalem neighborhood of Sheikh Jarrah. So on Quds Day, Palestinians outside the Al-Aqsa Mosque tossed rocks at Jewish worshippers on their way to the Western Wall. Israeli police gave chase and fired rubber bullets inside the mosque. That led to Hamas launching rockets at Israeli population centers. Israel retaliated, which ignited all those familiar Middle Eastern fireworks.

What was different last year, however, were the reprisals by Muslims living in London, Paris, Los Angeles, New York and Miami, against Jews in those cities who never saw themselves as reservists in the IDF. Why were they being targeted so far away from the actual theater of war? No one even asked them if they were Zionists.

Bloody festivities have already begun, with a wave of terrorism against Israelis throughout March and early April. Fourteen have been killed: a terror attack in Bnei Brak and another in a bar in Tel Aviv; additional murders in Hadera and Beersheba. On Friday, April 15, Al-Aqsa was once again used as a pretext to bait Israel into a fight. Palestinians hurled stones at Jews celebrating Passover. Israeli security forces restored order with stun grenades and tear gas. On April 21, after the Iron Dome intercepted Hamas rockets, Israeli warplanes struck military targets in Gaza.

Conditions overseas are equally dire. In New York City on April 22, outside the Israeli consulate, one of a number of pro-Palestinian demonstrators savagely attacked a man carrying an Israeli flag. No surprise. Antisemitic attacks against Jews have doubled this year in New York. The United Kingdom has reported an alarming spike in antisemitic violence, too. German domestic intelligence officials fear that increased hostilities against Jews will only get worse. In France, a Jewish man was punched and kicked, and then killed by an oncoming tram when chased by a gang onto the tracks.

In each of these cities, most of these incidents occurred soon after, or right before, Al-Quds Day.

Brace yourselves, Jews. And consider wearing a flak jacket this week. Some extremist might be sporting a different kind of vest—something very loud, and by that, I don’t mean its color.


Thane Rosenbaum is a novelist, essayist, law professor and Distinguished University Professor at Touro University, where he directs the Forum on Life, Culture & Society. He is the legal analyst for CBS News Radio. His most recent book is titled “Saving Free Speech … From Itself.”

The Duplicity and Violence of Al-Quds Day Read More »

SJP Targets U of I Hillel During March

Students for Justice in Palestine (SJP) at the University of Illinois Urbana-Champaign targeted the campus Hillel during a march protesting the actions of the Israeli police at the Al-Aqsa Mosque, The Algemeiner and Jewish News Syndicate (JNS) reported.

The protest, which was held on April 18, was dubbed as an “emergency protest” against “Zionist militia forces” at Al-Aqsa, was a march through parts of campus that eventually stopped in front of the Cohen Center for Jewish Life, where the campus Illini Hillel is located. While the protesters were in front of the Hillel, an unknown object was thrown through one of the Hillel’s windows. The Hillel was serving kosher food to Jewish students for Passover meals inside at that time.

“We find it really unacceptable that Jewish students need to be cornered in a situation where they need to cross through a field of yelling people to come and get their religious needs answered,” Illini Hillel Executive Director Erez Cohen told the student newspaper Daily Illini. He later added: “When people come to the Jewish center to yell against Israel, they’re creating an equation between any Jewish person and the state of Israel. That’s singling out an entire community based on a country that’s miles away.”

One of the pro-Palestinian protesters told WCIA that Hillel has “a very direct connection to Israel and that’s why we’re targeting that area in specific.” One Jewish student told WCIA that she doesn’t support Israel’s actions at Al-Aqsa and that “Hillel exists to support Jewish students,” not for supporting Israel.

Anti-Defamation League (ADL) Midwest tweeted, “SJP’s targeting of a Jewish institution at @UofIllinois to protest Israeli policies is antisemitism. We are horrified it occurred during a Passover celebration and reports are an object was thrown at Hillel, crossing the line from protest to violence.”

Judea Pearl, Chancellor Professor of Computer Science at UCLA, National Academy of Sciences member and Daniel Pearl Foundation President, tweeted in response to ADL Midwest that he is “more distressed by the timidity of Hillel’s students (and director), speaking as though Israel’s actions are indefensible, and as though Israel survival is not central to Jewish life. This is not the Hillel I knew, it’s a Hillel that projects guilt and invites more bullying.”

ADL CEO Jonathan Greenblatt tweeted that SJP’s “attempt to terrorize Jewish students by targeting their cultural space is despicable. Protesting during a Passover gathering adds insult to injury.”

There have been ongoing clashes at the Al Aqsa Mosque, the third holiest site in Islam, during Passover and Ramadan between Palestinian rioters and Israeli police. Rioters, many of whom are donning Hamas garb, have lobbing stones and firebombs from the mosque, prompting the police to take action and disperse the riots.

SJP Targets U of I Hillel During March Read More »