The Jewess and the Jurist
Ruth Bader Ginsburg, whose death on the first night of Rosh Hashanah sent shockwaves throughout the country, was a trailblazer. She was the second woman to serve on the Supreme Court and the first Jewish woman. Although she came from humble beginnings, she never forgot her upbringing or the obstacles she overcame, using them to drive her pursuit of justice. May we learn from her life so we can inherit her spirit, her legacy and her battle for a better world.
From Brooklyn to the bench
Ginsburg’s childhood resembles that of many Jewish Americans. She grew up in Flatbush with an immigrant father and an American-born mother. Her father, Nathan Bader, came to the United States with his parents at age 13 as a part of the great wave of Jewish immigration from the pogroms. Ginsburg’s mother, Celia Amster, was born in the United States within months of her parents’ arrival from Europe. Gifted, Celia graduated from high school at age 15 but was unable to afford college, working instead in the garment industry, which was, at the time, a major source of jobs for Jewish men and women. In Flatbush, education was the key to advancement.
The Bader family attended East Midwood Jewish Center, a thriving Conservative congregation at the heart of the neighborhood. Although she attended Hebrew school, Ruth Bader didn’t have a bat mitzvah because that practice didn’t become mainstream for Conservative synagogues until the 1950s. Remarking on the role of women in Judaism, Ginsburg once said, “My colleague Elana Kagan was the first Supreme Court Justice to have a bat mitzvah” — but that was only after Kagan’s family left their Modern Orthodox synagogue so she could do so.
But the Brooklyn that Ruth Bader grew up in was a place where barriers were being broken. When she was 14, the Brooklyn Dodgers’ Jackie Robinson broke the color barricade in baseball. She intuited his example: to get ahead, you had to be twice as good, twice as tough, twice as determined. All around her, fellow students were the first in their family to speak English, the first to graduate from high school, the first to attend college, the first whose horizons were less limited by poverty. After World War II, America became a land of opportunity, at least for men.
Throughout her successful career, Ginsburg remained deeply proud of Jewish tradition and Jewish history. It was at the core of her values and influenced her immensely.
Based on her academic success in high school, Ginsburg was able to attend Cornell University, where she met the man she would marry — Martin Ginsburg. Their love and marriage would enter lore as the justice achieved celebrity status. Martin was outgoing and gregarious, his wife shy and reserved. He loved to cook and bake. She was told by her family never to enter the kitchen. They both loved music and, above all, each other.
Martin Ginsburg was a confident man who could revel in his wife’s achievements. Although he was a successful tax attorney, he was willing to adjust his life to make room for her to rise to the top of her profession. Unapologetically, he used all his contacts and clout to advance her candidacy for the Supreme Court.
Ruth Bader Ginsburg became an icon of modern feminism — but so did Martin. By witnessing their love, many husbands are reminded that it takes a real man to be supportive of and empower an accomplished spouse. True to form, on his deathbed, Martin wrote, “My dearest Ruth … You are the only person [aside from my parents, children and grandchildren] I have loved in my life and I have admired and loved you almost since the day we first met at Cornell. What a treat it has been to watch your progress to the very top of the legal world.”
After she married Martin, the two moved to Lawton, Okla., as Martin had to fulfill his military obligation. Ginsburg was offered a job, but the offer was rescinded after her employer learned she was pregnant. Ginsburg had to accept another job with the government as an entry-level GS-2, quite a demotion for a brilliant Ivy League student. One can hear the echo of those early rejections in her later efforts to achieve equal justice for women.
After their stay in Oklahoma, the Ginsburgs enrolled in Harvard Law School. When Ruth entered, there were no women on the law faculty and only nine women in her class of 552. Each woman was challenged by the eminent dean of Harvard Law School — Erwin Griswold — to justify why they were taking “a man’s place.” Ruth Bader Ginsburg never forgot this question.
At a seminar on gender discrimination led by Justice Ginsburg and her husband, both of them exemplified the duty of attentiveness.
In his third year of law school, Martin developed testicular cancer. Rather than wallow, Ruth went into overdrive. She attended her classes, gathered the notes taken by Martin’s fellow students, typed them up, and worked with him to get him to graduate on time — all while excelling at her own studies and mothering their daughter, Jane. Her work ethic and her fierce determination served them both well. Many of those who have looked at Ginsburg have not appropriately recognized the herculean effort it took for her many accomplishments.
When Martin graduated, he took a job in New York. This posed a problem for Ginsburg, who still had her last year of law school left. She approached Griswold with a request that she take her last year at Columbia but obtain a Harvard degree. Griswold refused such an accommodation, so she transferred to Columbia. It was a decision that Harvard lives to regret and one that Columbia continues to celebrate.
After graduating from Columbia, Ruth Bader Ginsburg looked for clerkship opportunities, and only after enormous pressure from her professor was she offered a clerkship for a federal judge. But even that couldn’t compensate for her gender. Ginsburg was unable to secure a position in a prestigious law firm. Instead, she went into academia — first at Rutgers and then at Columbia — and worked with the American Civil Liberties Union on landmark gender equality cases. For her trailblazing legal work, President Jimmy Carter appointed Ginsburg to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit in 1980. In 1993, President Bill Clinton appointed her to the Supreme Court. Ginsburg, who was excluded from law firms and the bimah, secured one of the most exclusive jobs in the country.
A trailblazing Jew
Throughout her successful career, Ginsburg remained deeply proud of Jewish tradition and Jewish history. It was at the core of her values and influenced her immensely. In a speech at the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum in 2004, Ginsburg said:
My heritage as a Jew and my occupation as a judge fit together symmetrically. The demand for justice runs through the entirety of Jewish history and Jewish tradition. I take pride in and draw strength from my heritage, as signs in my chambers attest: a large silver mezuzah on my doorpost, [a] gift from the Shulamith School for Girls in Brooklyn [a Charedi school] ; on three walls, in artists’ renditions of Hebrew letters, the command from Deuteronomy: “Tzedek, tzedek, tirdof” — “Justice, justice shall you pursue.” Those words are ever-present reminders of what judges must do that they “may thrive.”
But like her work in the legal sphere, Ginsburg went beyond respecting Jewish tradition — she sought to change it. In the early 1980s, when the chancellor of the Jewish Theological Seminary said with pride that “we accept women in a cantorial school,” Ginsburg reminded him that the new generation of women didn’t understand why women could not be rabbis. For her outstanding work in both the legal and Jewish community, Israel sought to give her its Genesis Prize in 2018 (the prize was ultimately not awarded to her, because judicial ethics would not permit her to receive a prize from a foreign government.)
Ginsburg also held immense respect for the Jewish community. From time to time, I (Michael Berenbaum) would reach out to her to participate in Jewish events, where I thought she might truly have an impact. Her answers were always gracious, and when her schedule permitted, she would make the effort to participate in and advance the work of Jewish women.
As we sit shivah this week for Ruth Bader Ginsburg, we should reflect upon her experiences as a Jew, a law student, a law professor, advocate of gender equality, and federal judge and see how we, in her stead, can adopt her genuine insight.
Ginsburg’s genuine insights
For all of Ginsburg’s successes, she did lose one battle. She hoped to outlast the presidency of Donald Trump and to be replaced by a justice who would advance the cause of social justice. Some of her work is at risk of being reversed.
But Justice Ruth Bader Ginsburg was focused on the future — and so should we. Just consider the final words from 2004 speech at the Capitol:
I was fortunate to be a child, a Jewish child, safely in America during the Holocaust …. In the aftermath of World War II, in the civil rights movement of the 1950s and 1960s, in the burgeoning women’s rights movement of the 1970s, “We the People” expanded to include all of humankind, to embrace all the people of this great nation. Our motto, E Pluribus Unum, of many one, signals our appreciation that we are the richer for the religious, ethnic, and racial diversity of our citizens.
Despite the considerable progress, a daunting distance remains to be traveled …
While mindful of current realities, the opening of doors long closed makes me optimistic about a future in which daughters and sons alike will be free from artificial barriers, free to aspire and achieve in full accord with their God-given talents, and their willingness to do the hard work needed to make their dreams come true.
As we sit shivah this week for Ruth Bader Ginsburg, we should reflect upon her experiences as a Jew, a law student, a law professor, advocate of gender equality, and federal judge and see how we, in her stead, can adopt her genuine insight.
According to the eminent Canadian philosopher Bernard Lonergan, genuine insight requires attentiveness, intelligence, reasonableness and responsibility. Ruth Bader Ginsburg had all of these qualities — and more.
At a seminar on gender discrimination led by Justice Ginsburg and her husband, both exemplified the duty of attentiveness. They began each day’s discussion with a focus on actual experiences of the people they represented in these cases. They knew all of their clients by name and how their lives had been affected by irrational legislation. Justice Ginsburg began the seminar by stating, “The first thing Marty and I did was to get to know the client. It is always important to find out what’s happening in the client’s life …. Our primary role as lawyers is to help this person, not to promote a cause.”
Second, Ginsburg was intelligent. The facts she learned from her clients always generated a serious question about a woman’s place in a man’s world. Ginsburg persistently applied the two fundamental norms of American constitutionalism — due process of law and equal protection of the laws — to the rules that confined the freedom and dignity of women and men. She focused sharply on the gendered roles that laws embedded in virtually all aspects of life.
Third, Ginsburg was reasonable in her advocacy of change. She was no dilettante, ready to compromise on any major principle. Her goal was to fundamentally challenge the systematic denial of equality in American law. She stated that clearly in her confirmation hearings, and the senators appreciated her candor, confirming her appointment by a vote of 97-3. Ginsburg was, at heart, an egalitarian feminist. She argued that changing outdated laws would be better for women and men. Her keen and personal awareness of discrimination against women enabled her to identify the prior decisions that needed reconsideration or overturning. And she understood the mentality of many male judges, who were all too comfortable with the idea that legislatures could make laws that appeared to protect women. But she spoke the truth: putting women on pedestals actually put them in cages.
Fourth, Ginsburg was responsible. She listened carefully and imbibed the facts from her clients’ experiences of inequality. She shared with other feminists an understanding of these experiences as a denial of human dignity and personhood. In brief after brief, Ginsburg offered carefully tailored reasons for invalidating a law for its procedural fairness. If government wanted to stop her by throwing a long list of laws at her, she would address each one, one at a time. But Ginsburg also recognized that there was a way to achieve gender equality without litigating law by law. She advocated strongly and persistently for the ratification of the Equal Rights Amendment because she saw it as a move “toward a legal system in which each person will be judged on individual merit and not on the basis of an unalterable trait of birth.”
In short, Ruth Bader Ginsburg was insightful in the most expansive and rigorous meaning of what human understanding entails: being attentive, intelligent, reasonable and responsible. The best way we can honor her legacy is to emulate those character traits.
May her memory be a blessing on us all.
Michael Berenbaum is director of the Sigi Ziering Institute and a professor of Jewish Studies at American Jewish University. Edward Gaffney Jr. is a senior scholar at Valparaiso University.
The Jewess and the Jurist Read More »






