fbpx

July 8, 2015

Through a dog’s ordeal, director focuses on humanity

Filmmaker Boaz Yakin (“Fresh,” “Remember the Titans”) is best known in Jewish circles for controversial, intense works that depict fraught aspects of the tribal experience. 

His 1998 movie, “A Price Above Rubies,” spotlights a sexually frustrated, married Chasidic woman (Renee Zellweger) who chafes against the confines of her rigid community; “Death in Love” (2008) stars Jacqueline Bisset as a Jew who survived the Holocaust by sleeping with a sadistic Nazi doctor and portrays the effect that tortured legacy has on her sons; and Yakin’s graphic novel “Jerusalem: A Family Portrait” — which draws in part on his family’s participation in Israel’s War of Independence — depicts in searing detail the infamous massacre at the Arab village of Deir Yassin in April 1948, among other conflicts.

So some who identify Yakin with these intensely personal projects might find it surprising that his newest endeavor is not an edgy drama at all, but an ultimately uplifting family film, “Max,” released by Warner Bros., which takes place in the patriotic milieu of the American heartland. The movie revolves around a military working dog, a Belgian Malinois named Max, who is severely traumatized after the death of his handler, Kyle, during a battle in Afghanistan. Just as the canine is about to be euthanized, however, he is adopted by Kyle’s family in rural Texas. Over the course of the film, the dog learns to overcome his post-traumatic stress disorder, as he helps Kyle’s parents and troubled teenage brother heal from their respective losses.

On a recent Friday morning, Yakin, 49, was sitting in the backyard of a friend’s house in Los Angeles, surrounded by his pal’s four friendly dogs — one of them a tiny mutt coincidentally also named Max, who jumped up on Yakin’s lap for a pet. 

“The connection that people have with animals is very interesting,” the writer-director said of one reason he wanted to make the movie. “We drop many of our defenses and our self-protections, because we relate to animals in a way that we don’t with other people.

“I love dogs, even though I don’t have one of my own right now, and I felt it had been a long time since we had a hard-hitting dog film that wasn’t so much in a kiddie framework,” Yakin added, as a Shih Tzu approached for some attention, along with an elderly black Labrador.  

And so when Yakin’s longtime friend, Sheldon Lettich, a Vietnam veteran and screenwriter, suggested two years ago that they co-write a film about a military dog, Yakin was immediately in. He explained that, at the time, he had recently overcome a lifetime of deep depression through the implementation of a writing exercise — part meditation, part cognitive realignment — that he had developed and begun to practice daily. 

“The films I was being offered at the time were cynical,” he said. “But I was in a place where I felt like I wanted to do something positive.”

Yakin’s parents grew up in Israel, his father of Syrian and Egyptian roots, his mother descended from Polish Jews, many of whom died in the Holocaust. Even though his parents were secular — they’re mimes who met while studying with Marcel Marceau in Paris — they were also ardent Zionists who sent their son to an Orthodox yeshiva with a strong Zionist focus in New York. 

Yet by the age of 11, Yakin had helped spur a classroom debate about the validity of creationism; he also was deeply affected by what he described as the yeshiva’s “super Holocaust stuffed down your throat 24/7” method of teaching about the Shoah.

“It promoted a sense of victimization and otherness,” he said. “And they also used it as a kind of narcissistic proof that the Jews are so much better than everyone else. I know it sounds cruel to say that about something like the Holocaust, but it’s not the Holocaust I’m talking about. It’s the way people used the Holocaust afterward. So you develop on the one hand this sense of inferiority and anxiety, and on the other hand a sense of narcissistic isolation.”

Yakin channeled some of those feelings into “Death in Love,” which, he said, was also spurred by his own decades of depression. “My entire experience of life had been colored by this intense negativity, and at some level I felt that unless I tackled and explored that, I wouldn’t be able to go on,” he said. “ ‘Death in Love’ is a study of the cyclical quality of depression, and perhaps about being in love with your own negativity. And that certainly raises provocative questions about how much that cycle is a part of our Jewishness today.”

Even though “Max” is a very different kind of film, Yakin said, it, too, asks tough questions — in this case, about the psychological repercussions of war for man and beast. 

“Dogs are being bred and trained and basically thrown into combat, although the dogs didn’t ask for it; it isn’t their fight,” he said. “There’s something challenging and uncomfortable about that. But the truth is, we’re doing the same thing to people.”

Yakin added that the film “becomes a metaphor for sending innocent beings off to battle. It’s tremendously clear that this movie is about a bunch of people who are traumatized by war and unable to be who they should be because of this constant burden. The subtext of the movie — and it’s not that hidden — is the emasculation of the American male in this constant state of war. The character of the father [a Vietnam veteran played by Thomas Haden Church], is literally crippled and unable to be honest; his son, Kyle, is f—–g dead; [Kyle’s friend and fellow Marine] has become cynical and twisted; and [Kyle’s] younger brother has to figure out where he wants to land in the middle of this mess.”

Meanwhile, the character of Max, who in combat was sent ahead of the troops to sniff out bombs, cowers as he relives his wartime ordeal amid fireworks on the Fourth of July, among other symptoms of post-traumatic stress.

“The film acknowledges the power of a family to exist in the midst of tragedy, to be healed and to bond,” Yakin said, “but I hardly think of it as a flag-waving exercise.”

“Max” is now in theaters. 

Through a dog’s ordeal, director focuses on humanity Read More »

Argentine President Kirchner doesn’t understand why her Shylock comment angers Jews

Argentine President Cristina Fernandez de Kirchner is in trouble over her evoking of William Shakespeare’s “Merchant of Venice” Jewish antagonist, Shylock, in an attempt to explain Argentina’s national debt to… schoolchildren.

Argentine Jews, needless to say, were not amused.

Kirchner told the kids that Argentina’s economic trouble could be understood by reading “The Merchant of Venice,” where the heartless Jewish moneylender seeks revenge on his nice, Christian debtors, whose only fault is that they took his money and wouldn’t give it back.

Kirchner tweeted that the idea had come to her after she asked the children what Shakespeare play they were reading and they told her: “Romeo and Juliet.”

And, so, she tweeted, “I said, you have to read the ‘Merchant of Venice’ to understand the vulture funds,” and that, apparently, made everybody laugh. So she tweeted, “No, don’t laugh, Usury and bloodsuckers have been immortalized in the greatest literature for centuries.”

The vulture banker, in case you haven’t been following the Argentine debt crisis over the past decade or more, is Jewish Billionaire Paul Singer, whom Kirchner and her Minister of the Economy Axel Kicillof have actually accused of behaving like a vulture — for insisting Argentina pay him back the $1.5 billion they owe him.

He’s dragged them through US courts, and has been beating them, to the point where the Argentine credit rating has been seriously curtailed. And when they offer him fistfuls of Argentine pesos he insists—Shylock that he is—on green bucks, which clearly spell, “In God we trust,” not in Argentine promissory notes.

This is, then, an ancient rivalry, and the President figured she was using humor to illustrate financial matters for the little ones.

Kirchner would not apologize, and instead tweeted an ad for “The Merchant of Venice” which was performed two years ago in Spain by an Israeli company.

Which means she honestly did not comprehend the difference between watching a WW2 movie and joining the Nazi party.

The last political celebrity to put his foot in his mouth over “The Merchant” was everybody’s favorite VP, Joe Biden. Speaking at a conference celebrating the 40th anniversary of the Legal Services Corporation, Biden shared stories he’d heard from his son (now departed), Beau, about his military experience in Iraq as Major in the Judge Advocate General (JAG) Corps.

“That’s one of the things that he finds was most in need when he was over there in Iraq for a year,” Biden said, “that people would come to him and talk about what was happening to them at home in terms of foreclosures, in terms of bad loans that were being…I mean these Shylocks who took advantage of, um, these women and men while overseas.”

It’s the gift that keeps on giving.

Argentine President Kirchner doesn’t understand why her Shylock comment angers Jews Read More »

Anti-Semitism watchdog: Bucharest mosque could lead to radicalization

A Turkish-funded plan to build a giant mosque in Bucharest could lead to radicalization and incitement to hate, Romania’s main watchdog on anti-Semitism warned.

Maximillian Marco Katz, founding director of MCA Romania-The Center for Monitoring and Combating Anti-Semitism, issued the warning in a statement on Monday about reports in the local media that Romania has agreed to a request made in April by Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan to allow his government to fund the construction in the Romanian capital of a mosque and Islamic university by 2018.

“MCA Romania warns against likely attempts to transform this ambitious project into a center to be used by radical Islamic elements as a regional base for their anti-Semitic, anti-Christian, anti-democracy, pro-terror activities,” the statement read.

It further said that it had been “clearly demonstrated around the world [that] mosques and Islamic universities are often involved in advocating for and supporting terrorism, anti-Semitism and violence against ‘infidels'; Jews and Christians alike.”

The planned complex will accommodate 8,000 worshipers and students. The agreement for its construction includes the construction of a Romanian church in Istanbul.

Former Romanian President Traian Basescu also spoke out in the Romanian media against the plan, saying that “there is no higher risk than bringing Muslim students to Romania.” Basescu called the project “irresponsible.”

MCA said it would welcome any house of worship promoting tolerance. But in the case of the planned mosque, it urged the government “not to proceed without first investigating fully the sources of funding” and parties behind the project, MCA’s statement read.

Anti-Semitism watchdog: Bucharest mosque could lead to radicalization Read More »

Will the special session help people with special needs?

The current California developmental disabilities system, once a model system for the entire nation in providing individualized, community-based care for children and adults with intellectual and developmental disabilities, is starving for funds to keep programs going. Because Gov. Jerry Brown signed next year’s $115.4 billion budget without the needed funding, our last chance for help may be in the upcoming special session of the state Legislature, which will be focused exclusively on health care issues. Without an influx of new funds, many providers will have to shut down their programs and services, and lives will be endangered or even ended prematurely.

Right now, the lines on the charts are all heading in the wrong direction:

• Since mid-2011, 435 residential homes for adults with developmental disabilities have closed, representing a loss of nearly 2,300 beds.

• In the same period, 57 day and work programs closed their doors, affecting 1,200 people.

• And 15 supported employment programs ended, a loss of 176 opportunities to work in community settings.

How did it ever get this bad? In the late 1960s, a group of parents in California who had children with Down syndrome, autism, cerebral palsy and other developmental disabilities (DD) joined together to create an ambitious new alternative to the state hospitals, which at that time were the expected destination for their children. The parents challenged the medical establishment’s status quo, which said their children needed to be “put away” out of sight, and out of their communities of family and friends, for the “good of the rest of the family.” 

Out of frustration with forced institutionalization and given no support to keep their kids with DD at home, these parents became fierce advocates, working with disability rights champion Assemblyman Frank Lanterman from Glendale to sponsor civil-rights types of legislation. They succeeded in getting the California Legislature in 1969 to muster bipartisan support and passed the Lanterman Developmental Disabilities Services Act, or Lanterman Act for short. This landmark legislation declares that persons with developmental disabilities have the same legal rights and responsibilities guaranteed all other persons by federal and state constitutions and laws, and charges the 21 regional centers in California with advocacy for, and protection of, these rights.

So far, so good. But as the years have gone by, the number of eligible children and teens has increased, driven especially by the dramatic spike in autism cases. Meanwhile, California’s reimbursement rates for services have remained essentially flat for two decades, while the costs to provide services have grown.

This funding gap was widened by the Great Recession, when legislators slashed funding for the DD system by more than $1 billion. As a Contra Costa Times newspaper editorial said, “The system that supports roughly 280,000 individuals with developmental disabilities is in a crisis that few outside that community understand.” 

Leading the charge to finally “bend the curve” is an umbrella group of nonprofits and providers that serves the developmentally disabled, called the Lanterman Coalition. The coalition is pushing for a 10 percent one-time across-the-board increase in provider rates, as well as a 5 percent cost of living increase annually until there is a systematic reform of rates and, most important, a complete review and overhaul of those rates. Paying the staff who work directly with adults with developmental disabilities little more than minimum wage makes it very hard for provider agencies to hire qualified staff in the first place, and also leads to high employee turnover, which is very detrimental to those needing care but who often take a very long time to trust someone new. 

For parents or other family members, having to constantly build a new relationship with an assigned service coordinator at the regional centers also is exhausting, frustrating and time-consuming. My family has had four different service coordinators assigned to our son in just the last two years because of these funding cuts. At one point, I had to call a supervisor every day for a week just to get a call back to find out who was our assigned person; our current saving grace is that our son is still in high school and therefore needs fewer services from the regional center system than he will after he completes his education.

As I mentioned above, we have one last chance left to fix this crisis. State Sen. Jim Beall (D-San Jose) has introduced a bill for the upcoming special session to increase rates for regional centers and the purchase of service vendors serving individuals with developmental disabilities. Joined by state Sens. Bill Monning (D-Carmel) and Fran Pavley (D-Calabasas), this bill will also call on the California Department of Developmental Services to create a financial sustainability plan to ensure the community-based developmental services system is working effectively. It’s time for the rest of the Legislature to support this bill and to begin to restore the system for our family and friends with developmental and intellectual disabilities.

Michelle K. Wolf writes a monthly column for the Jewish Journal. Visit her Jews and Special Needs blog at jewishjournal.com/jews_and_special_needs.

Will the special session help people with special needs? Read More »

Shabbat, Brokenness and Light: My Reflections at an Interfaith Event

Over this past 4th of July weekend, I shared some Shabbat reflections at the Walking Meditation on Interdependence, which was held at the beautiful Echo Park Lake in Los Angeles.  The Interfaith Commons of Southern California, an emerging alliance
 of interreligious organizations coming together in common cause, produces this lovely annual gathering.  Bob Williams, the incoming president of the Interreligious Council of SoCal, and a Canon with the Episcopal Diocese of Los Angeles, had organized the event.

As we walked around the lake, there were six stopping points, with each representing a different tradition: Buddhism, Bahaism, Hinduism, Judiasm, Christianity and Islam.  At each stop, one person shared a prayer and reflection.

Station #4: My Shabbat Reflection

    

We read in the Book of Genesis that G‑d created the world in just six days, and then rested on the seventh.  Shabbat is taught to be one of the most essential Jewish practices, and provides a sacred time and space where pausing and resting enables the practice of creation to be sustained week after week, month after month, and year after year.  Shabbat is meant to last 25 hours, and begins at sunset on Friday evening and ends Saturday after nightfall.  It is supposed to end as soon as three stars are visible in the night sky.

This time of reflection and spiritual enrichment commemorates G-ds hand in creating the entire world, and pulling us out of slavery in Egypt.  We are encouraged to remember times in the past when were not free, but are especially encouraged to come into this 25-hour window of the here and now, and be in gratitude for our faith, our lives, our company and our freedom.

Deeping my Connection to Judaism                                 

It has seemed to be during my darkest times, where I have felt the most broken and raw, that I have found myself experiencing a profound connection to Judaism.  I get more deeply rooted in Torah, and incorporate the teachings into my every day life, as a narrative that beautifully helps me to navigate my emotions and perceptions.  

Judaism brought me tremendous peace through learning how every human being, no matter how broken or lost they may feel, is still created in B’tzelem Elohim, “in G-ds image,” and that every person has a unique and holy soul, and infinite and unconditional worth.  At the same time, we also are taught that our souls are made of dust in order to maintain our humility and stay grounded.

Brokeness = Wholeness                                                      

Judaism teaches how something that is broken is of equal value to something that is whole, and that some things actually need to be broken in order to move forward.  Such as when Moses broke the tablets on Sinai, and God said, “congratulations (yashar koah) that you broke them.” 

Like myself, the Jews had been living in the past and stuck in their failures, and Moses needed to break the tablets in order for the Jewish people to move forward and create a new sense of wholeness, and a new nation.

By connecting to Judaism, I was connecting with a religion that spoke such a universal message about being human, and was teaching me to accept my humanness, and to see my brokenness as something holy.  I began to see that those piercing fragments within one self also present a blessing, and a wonderful opportunity to bring those pieces back together and create something new, and reach an even higher level of consciousness.  

Breaking and repairing is one of Judaism’s most holy forces of creation.  The world was born out of brokenness, and light was born out of darkness.  And the word Shalom means so much more then simply peace; it is about feeling complete peace.  It is a feeling of wholeness, well being and harmony.  I now believe that Shalom is also a sense of wholeness that requires a person to own all their parts, which may also include the broken ones, and isn’t any less holy.

The Myth of the Shattering of the Vessels, by Rabbi Isaac Luria of Safed

At the beginning of time, God filled the entire universe.  When G-d wanted to create the world, God contracted its breath to allow the space for creation, and in that space darkness was born.

And then God said, “let there be light,” and light began to fill the darkness, and ten holy vessels came forth, like a fleet of ships, and each filled with immeasurable amounts of beaming light.  But those vessels were too fragile and couldn’t handle such powerful amounts of divine light, and thus broke open and shattered into divine sparks that covered all the land. 

Repairing the World

God created humanity to sift all the holy sparks from the four corners of the earth, and perform tikkun olam, which means to repair the world.  We are taught that this repair is critical for future survival of humankind, and that tikkun olam can only be fulfilled if all of humanity collaborates on this endeavor.

Repairing Ourselves

Nobody goes through this life without experiencing some sort of hardship at some point.  While it is important to repair the world and gather the sparks, at the same time, it is just as important to heal ourselves and recognize and nurture our own spark.  

Shabbat is so much more than a day of rest. It is an opportunity to turn things around and step into our own lives in a more powerful way.  For me, I was trying to rest by stepping into a sacred time and space, where I wasn’t being consumed by the fear-based thoughts, judgments, blame, guilt, or shame, which may have impacted me throughout the week.   I am giving myself the permission to take a Shabbos pause from using uncompassionate self-communication, but also reflect on how I can take more proactive steps towards changing and re-patterning my behaviors, and take better responsibility for my relationships, thoughts, feelings and actions.

Through praying, singing, talking, walking, dreaming, and sleeping, we reinforce the part of ourselves that knows that things can be better, and must be better.  We reflect on how we can live differently in the coming week, and to see each week as an opportunity to create a reality that reflects more of what ought to be.  We are ultimately patching the cracks in the foundation to create something more stable and whole.

Not that I don’t reflect during the entire week, but there is something powerful about reflecting in an allotted time in space where you are intentionally trying to help your mind become a personal sanctuary.  May the sacred shabbos space I create within me continue to spill into the rest of the week, and the rest of the week gently pour back into the shabbos space. I am more free to learn and grow in this infinite exchange.

Walking the Talk

I could not think of a better way to celebrate Shabbat then by walking side by side with people from different (yet also similar) holy paths.  Within this sacred time and space, we are bringing together those divine sparks that had shattered at the time of creation, and we are interdependently creating wholeness and a greater sense of harmony between G-ds creation. 

Today, as we walk together, we are putting one foot in front of the next and doing tikkun olam by repairing the world. We are actively taking part of an actualized dream of a better world. 

– The ending of my shared reflection.

  

After Station #6

The walk concluded at the 6th station representing the Islamic tradition.  Following the words shared by the speaker, we all ate dates to signify the breaking of the Ramadan fast.  I have learned that Ramadan is the ninth month of the Islamic calendar, and is observed by Muslims worldwide as a month of fasting to commemorate the first revelation of the Quran to Muhammad according to Islamic belief.

I also got to witness one of the five daily prayers, which is central to the 5 pillars of Islam.  I am always excited and feel honored to bear witness to someone praying.  It’s a  sacred window into what can be such a vulnerable moment for someone.  The event ended with an Iftar to break the fast.

The entire experience was wonderful, and I look forward to next year.

For more…

To hear an extraordinary sermon on the emotional and spiritual brokenness of the world, please see this video that my dear friend, Esther Kustanowitz, had made for a Shavuot sermon slam.  I used some of her insights in writing my reflection.  https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Tlv8kDaF0gg

Shabbat, Brokenness and Light: My Reflections at an Interfaith Event Read More »

Here’s what United Airlines says happened today with its computers

All United Airlines flights were grounded for almost two hours early Wednesday due to a computer hardware problem, creating travel headaches for tens of thousands of passengers that stretched into the afternoon.

“We are restoring regular flight operations, but some customers may experience residual delays (Wednesday),” United said in an afternoon statement.

The Federal Aviation Administration said all flights operated by United, the fourth largest U.S. passenger carrier, were grounded starting at about 8 a.m. EDT after the airline experienced a systemwide computer problem. Some travelers were forced to look for alternative flights and connections before the order was lifted 9:47 a.m.

United said 800 flights had been delayed, with four flights canceled on its main carrier and 55 on its regional partners.

“An issue with a (computer) router degraded network connectivity for various applications, causing this morning's operational disruption,” United said in a statement. “We fixed the router issue, which is enabling us to restore normal functions.”

United said it would rebook flights for affected passengers without charge.

Diane Menditto, 66, a retired teacher from Hackensack, New Jersey, on the United Airlines check-in line at Newark Liberty International Airport said she and her sister-in-law were worried about making a connecting flight en route to Calgary, Alberta in Canada.

“The only thing I would wonder is, now that we're here and things are running smoothly, if we'll actually get out on time,” Menditto said.

A separate computer outage affected stock market trading Wednesday morning. The NYSE Group, which includes the New York Stock Exchange, suspended trading in all securities due to technical difficulties. Trading resumed shortly after 3 p.m. EDT.

U.S Senator Dianne Feinstein, the top Democrat on the Senate Intelligence Committee, said she had not yet been briefed on the two major outages. She told reporters: “This is not an oddity. This is going to continue to happen and we have to begin to deal with it … and we have to deal with it legislatively.”

Aviation industry consultant Robert Mann said technical disruptions have been on the rise since airlines began automating more of their operations and since they switched from private, proprietary communications for flight operations to Internet-based communication, which is cheaper but exposes the carriers to more risks.

Technical disruptions “are nagging problems, but these are not problems that are going to draw the huge capital investment necessary to (approach) 100 percent reliability,” Mann said. “The revenue loss in these cases is relatively modest.”

United flights were also grounded on June 2 due to “automation issues.”

United Continental Holdings Inc shares fell 3 percent to $52.67.

Here’s what United Airlines says happened today with its computers Read More »

Honoring Max Steinberg

Family, friends and supporters of fallen Israeli soldier and Woodland Hills native Max Steinberg gathered on June 28 at the Luxe Sunset Boulevard Hotel to commemorate a Torah in his honor.

Families of Lone Soldiers (FOLS), an organization committed to supporting the loved ones of people who leave their home countries to fight for the Israeli military, sponsored the event where guests had the opportunity to write a letter in the Torah, which will be sent to Israel and used by soldiers. A campaign on the crowdfunding site Jewcer raised more than $50,000 for the project from more than 250 donors. 

Steinberg served as a sharpshooter in the Golani Brigade’s 13th battalion. His death during Operation Protective Edge last year when his unit was ambushed in Gaza touched lives across the world; 30,000 people attended his funeral. 

The Steinberg family and the Torah, with help from FOLS, were scheduled to travel to Israel to commemorate Max’s yahrzeit on July 9 at Mount Herzl. On July 12, plans call for the Torah to be ceremoniously completed with the help of Israeli President Reuven Rivlin and Golani soldiers alongside whom Max fought. 

FOLS co-founder Larry Platt hosted the recent local event and presented several community leaders who honored Steinberg’s memory and his service. He spoke on the strength of the late soldier’s parents, Stuart and Evie Steinberg.

“Their hearts, their emotions, their trials and tribulations, their dedication to family, their dedication to each other, and their commitment to Israel honors Max,” Platt said. “His life will go on in the memory of what he has done, what we have seen and what his parents have shared with us.”

The Steinbergs also addressed loved ones and supporters, many of whom were lone soldiers, like their son. Both spoke emotionally about the loss of their son and the importance of supporting lone soldiers.

“It is still hard for me to grasp that Max is no longer with us in body,” Evie Steinberg said through tears. “Max was and always will be my hero.”

The Steinberg family showed video from Max’s bar mitzvah ceremony, which took place at the Luxe in 2005 and which he shared with his brother, Jake. The video included footage of Max’s bar mitzvah speech, in which he talked about his Torah portion and the importance of the rite of passage. He also spoke about the legacy of generations and overcoming hardships. 

“When the Israelites left Egypt, every obstacle that they faced was a sign of discouragement,” a teenage Max said. “They could only see the obstacles, not the opportunity to move forward, to live in freedom. Having faith in ourselves and in God is really important, but so is our attitude of how we handle what happens to us in life.”

The idea for a Torah-writing ceremony and dedication in Max’s honor was first proposed by Rabbi Shlomo Bistritzky of Chabad of the Conejo. The Steinberg family approached FOLS to organize the project and the ceremony. Max’s father credited FOLS with showing the compassion and dedication necessary for helping the unique situations of families of lone soldiers.

“Our biggest disappointment was that we were not there to celebrate Max’s accomplishments as he went through training,” Stuart Steinberg said. “When [FOLS co-founders Platt and Eli Fitlovitz] came to our home, we shared that disappointment with them. They told us what FOLS was about, and we knew that FOLS was a cause we wanted to put our arms around.” 

Honoring Max Steinberg Read More »

West ‘unimpressed’ with Iran’s new proposal in nuclear talks

Iran has offered “constructive solutions” to resolve disputes in nuclear talks with six major powers, the Iranian Students News Agency (ISNA) reported on Wednesday, but Western officials suggested they had heard nothing new from Tehran.

Iran and the powers are in the last stretch of talks to reach a final agreement to end a more than 12-year standoff over Iran's nuclear program. The aim is to lift sanctions in exchange for at least a decade of curbs on the program.

“Iran has presented constructive solutions to overcome the remaining differences. We will not show flexibility regarding our red lines,” an Iranian diplomat, who was not identified, told ISNA.

But Western officials indicated they had yet to see substantive new proposals. The biggest sticking points include issues such as a United Nations arms embargo, U.N. missile sanctions, the speed of sanctions relief, and research and development on advanced nuclear centrifuges.

“I haven't seen anything new from Iran,” a Western diplomat close to the talks told Reuters on condition of anonymity. Another Western official echoed the remarks.

U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry and Iranian Foreign Minister Mohammad Javad Zarif have stayed behind in Vienna, along with EU foreign policy chief Federica Mogherini, in an attempt to break the logjam while most of the other foreign ministers returned to their capitals.

Air-conditioning systems in the luxurious Palais Coburg hotel are struggling with outside temperatures approaching 40 Celsius (104 Fahrenheit), and some negotiators have found it hard to keep their cool during the discussions, officials say.

TENSE EXCHANGE

Kerry and Zarif were involved in a tense exchange over U.N. sanctions on Monday night, diplomats said. Tehran says conventional weapons and missiles have nothing to do with the nuclear issue and embargoes should therefore be removed.

“There was no slamming of doors but it was a very heated exchange of views,” one of the senior Western diplomats said.

Iran's official news agency IRNA quoted unnamed residents at the Palais as saying Kerry and Zarif could be heard shouting at each other during a one-on-one meeting on Monday. A Kerry aide had gone in to tell them that they could be heard clearly.

Western countries accuse Iran of seeking the capability to build nuclear weapons, while Tehran says its program is peaceful.

A successful deal could be the biggest milestone in decades towards easing hostility between Iran and the United States, foes since Iranian revolutionaries stormed the U.S. embassy in Tehran in 1979.

It would also be a political success for both U.S. President Barack Obama and Iran's pragmatic President Hassan Rouhani, both of whom face scepticism from powerful hardliners at home.

Iran, the United States, Britain, France, Germany, Russia and China have given themselves at least until Friday, but a source from one of the powers said on Tuesday they had to wrap up in the next 48 hours.

A senior U.S. official told reporters on Tuesday: “I believe we will in the near term either get this deal or find out we can't.”

The disagreements over U.N. Security Council sanctions are among the most difficult.

Russia and China, which have never hidden their dislike of sanctions, had indicated they would support the termination of the United Nations arms embargo and missile sanctions on Iran, both of which date back to 2006.

MIXED MESSAGE

In the end, however, they agreed not to break ranks with the Americans and Europeans, who want to maintain the measures given the instability in the Middle East.

“In the current context, it would be pretty obscene as a political message if we resolve the nuclear issue but then give them money and the capacity to import and export arms,” a senior Western official said.

Russia is especially sensitive about sanctions, Western officials say, due to the fact that it itself is under U.S. and European Union sanctions over allegations that it is supporting pro-Moscow rebels in eastern Ukraine, which it denies.

French Foreign Minister Laurent Fabius and British Foreign Secretary Philip Hammond were expected to return to Vienna on Wednesday evening.

U.S. and European officials have indicated that they are prepared to walk away if there is not a deal soon, while the Iranians have said they are happy to continue negotiating.

Iran's Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, who has the power to block a deal, last month ruled out either a long freeze of sensitive nuclear work or opening military sites to inspectors. Western officials say Khamenei's “red lines” have made things more difficult for the Iranian delegation.

“There is a sort of 'good-cop/bad-cop' between Zarif and the supreme leader,” a Western official said. “Zarif is under a lot of pressure.”

The latest extension of the talks to Friday left open the possibility an agreement would not arrive in time to secure a 30-day review period by the Republican-dominated U.S. Congress.

If a deal is sent to Congress after July 9, the period grows to 60 days, increase the chance that the deal could unravel.

West ‘unimpressed’ with Iran’s new proposal in nuclear talks Read More »

Nicholas Winton and the goodness effect

In our celebrity-obsessed, information-worshiping culture, where TED Talks determine what’s cool, and technology icons are conferred with near-mythological status, it’s good to be reminded of who the real heroes are. 

Last week, we learned of the death of 106-year-old Sir Nicholas Winton, a London stockbroker by trade, who for nearly 50 years said nothing of his role in saving the lives of 669 children from Czechoslovakia, mostly Jewish, on the eve of World War II.

“I wouldn’t exist if it wasn’t for Nicholas Winton,” Kim Masters, editor-at-large for The Hollywood Reporter and host of KCRW’s “The Business,” said during a phone interview last week. “And neither would my siblings, my daughter, my nieces and nephews, my cousins …”

Kim Masters is the daughter of Alice Masters, one of the children Winton saved. Often called “the British Schindler,” Winton was only 29 years old when he skipped a Swiss skiing vacation after a friend asked him to come to Prague to witness an escalating refugee crisis. It was December 1938, and the Nazis had just seized the Sudetenland, the German-speaking western region of Czechoslovakia, displacing thousands of people into refugee camps — in the dead of winter. There, a young Winton saw the brutal living conditions of the refugees, the freezing, frightened children, their parents overwhelmed by despair, and decided to do something very leading man. 

“I work on the motto that if something’s not impossible, there must be a way of doing it,” Winton said on “60 Minutes” last year. There would be no turning the page, no business as usual after Winton bore witness; feeling bad was a luxury this stockbroker couldn’t afford. “All I know was that the people that I met couldn’t get out, and they were looking for ways of at least getting their children out.”

Winton went Bond-like in his rescue efforts, employing a little bit of trickery to get the job done: He forged documents, bribed and blackmailed officials and created a front organization, the Children’s Section of the British Committee for Refugees From Czechoslovakia, in order to execute his plan. Although American President Franklin D. Roosevelt refused to help, the British government agreed to take the children if Winton found host families, which he did, often guaranteeing these “adoptions” with his own money.

Within six months, the first of seven trains organized by Winton and his friends chugged through Nazi Germany and into Holland, where the precious child-cargo was ferried to the English coast and finally put on trains to London. An eighth train carrying 250 lives never left the station.

Alice Masters was 14 when her parents, Sidonia and Salamon, put their three daughters — including Alice’s sisters Josi, then 15, and Elli, 10 — on one of Winton’s trains. At the time, none of them had ever heard of Nicholas Winton, and it would be many decades before they would learn of his role in their fate. That day at the train station, there was only the agony of parents parting with their children — indefinitely. The distress was so visceral, Kim Masters said, the two older sisters begged their parents to “keep” the youngest, and her grandmother removed 10-year-old Elli from the train, embracing her one last time before putting her back on. For a while there were letters, and then, finally, silence.

“That story was never discussed when we were children,” Masters said. “Like many, many children of the Holocaust … a lot of effort was made to blend in and not talk about that. So we just didn’t talk about it. It was not part of our family lore.” 

By age 14, Masters had learned about her mother’s and aunts’ shared past, but it remained taboo at the dinner table. It wasn’t until 1988, when the BBC learned of Winton’s story and invited him to sit in the audience for an episode of “That’s Life!” that there was a silver lining to the tale of Hitler’s slaughter.

Before rolling cameras, Winton was introduced to a woman whom he had saved many years before. She presented him with her forged travel document and kissed him on the cheek. Winton remained seated in the audience, completely unassuming, until, suddenly, the moderator of the show asked whether anyone else had been saved by Nicholas Winton. “If so, could you stand up, please?”

The whole audience stood.

Winton would later say this was “the most emotional moment” of his life. But for Masters and her family, it had a different, stunning effect: “When you don’t have the presence of Nicholas Winton in the story, it’s a pretty awful story,” Masters said. But the addition of Winton’s heroism, his moral courage, ingenuity and human goodness somehow changed the tragic story. “Instead of being a story with just death and destruction, it became the story of a hero.”

In the darkest period of modern history, Winton symbolized “the power of good,” Masters said.

Winton was not always a willing hero; for a long time he was reluctant to speak about the past, and reticent when he did. It took time for him to adjust to the world’s attention and praise. When Masters’ mother invited him for dinner in the 1990s, her seasoned reporter-daughter tried to draw him out.  

“He was absolutely unwilling,” Masters recalled. “He simply would not engage. To him, I think, this was one episode in his life, and it became so defining. He was kind of, a little bit, maybe baffled by the whole thing.” And also, she said, a little bit guilty. There were others who had assisted Winton, but they died unacknowledged. “I think he ultimately decided, ‘This is the role I have been given, and I will accept this role.’ ” 

It is evident during interviews in his later years — including one from 2008 with Masters for National Public Radio — that Winton warmed to the role of “hero,” revealing himself to be an eloquent but laconic man whose lips flowed with wisdom. By the time of his death, he had amassed many prestigious honors: He was knighted by the queen, nominated for the Nobel Prize, made an honorary citizen of Prague and received countless letters of appreciation from presidents and prime ministers the world over. Books were written about him and documentaries made; though none of these accolades compare with the actual impact of what he did:  Many thousands of people are alive today because he had the courage to respond to his conscience. 

As a child, Masters said, “I always used to have this thing in the back of my mind, like, if the s— really hit the fan, which of my Christian friends would hide me? Who was really a righteous person? I always wondered: Would you? Would you? And even, would I? Because the courage it would take to hide people, that is incredible courage. 

“And I wonder if my grandparents knew,” she added wistfully, “as the end was coming near, if they knew they had saved their children?” 

Winton is the hero we know, but he wasn’t the only one.

Nicholas Winton and the goodness effect Read More »

Obama’s eulogy: Stirring words, disturbing theology

Am I the only one who had a problem with the stirring eulogy President Barack Obama delivered recently for the Rev. Clementa C. Pinckney of the Emanuel African Methodist Episcopal Church in Charleston, S.C.? The speech has been hailed as a masterpiece. The New York Times called it “remarkable” and “eloquent.” The Atlantic hailed it as “his most fully successful performance as an orator.” Forbes marveled that “his speech soared rhetorically and emotionally.” 

I read these gushing appraisals and began to question my own sanity. I rewatched and listened and read the transcript of Obama’s eulogy. At the beginning, he had me in the palm of his hand. He morphed before our eyes from President Obama to the Rev. Obama. He became our pastor and we all became his congregation. As a rabbi and speaker myself, I paid close attention to the way the president achieved this shift. He gave us permission to identify with the mourners assembled before him. He allowed us to empathize with the victims of hate and violence. Yes, I thought. We are all one nation and we are all members of “Mother” Emanuel Church. 

But, midway through the sermon, something went awry. Suddenly our Pastor-in-Chief began offering up a theology that I believe isn’t just wrong, but dangerous. He began by describing the hate and racism that led a homicidal young man to gun down nine innocent people in prayer. And then in a crescendo of confidence, Obama went on to speak about God’s intentions: “Oh, but God works in mysterious ways,” Obama said to an applauding audience. “God has different ideas.” Then, speaking of murder suspect Dylann Roof, who confessed to the killings, Obama said, “He didn’t know he was being used by God.”

The congregation applauded wildly — but that’s where our president lost me. If a preacher had uttered those words at the funeral, I could have lived with his or her statement of faith — it’s their church and their faith. But when our president asks me to believe that a suspected killer was “used by God,” then I feel left out of his flock.

Drawing on the lyrics of the hymn “Amazing Grace,” Obama pressed his point. He preached that God used an unspeakable crime to give us eyes to see the truths we’ve been blind to: “As a nation, out of this terrible tragedy, God has visited grace upon us, for he has allowed us to see where we’ve been blind.” Obama went on: “For too long, we were blind to the pain that the Confederate flag stirred in too many of our citizens. … For many, black and white, that flag was a reminder of systemic oppression and racial subjugation. We see that now.” Obama moved on to guns: “For too long, we’ve been blind to the unique mayhem that gun violence inflicts upon this nation. … The vast majority of Americans — the majority of gun owners — want to do something about this. We see that now.” 

Yes, I see why Obama’s theology is tempting. Suddenly the dead weren’t victims of a senseless act of hatred. Their deaths had a higher purpose, divinely ordained. But I cannot give in to that temptation. 

Is it the stiff-necked Jew in me? The skeptic? Or is it the thinking mind of any person of faith who refuses to identify God’s hand with acts of evil? When theology flies in the face of sanity, we must choose sanity. We must reject assertions of faith that attribute horrible acts to God. 

Did God use Adam Lanza to shoot the children at Sandy Hook Elementary School in Newtown, Conn., so that we could learn to love children more? Or so that we could pass more stringent laws banning the sale of semiautomatic weapons?

Did God use James Eagan Holmes to mow down innocent moviegoers so that we could learn some lesson about mental illness?

Did God use the Columbine shootings to teach high school jocks to be more compassionate to the freaks? Or was God trying to teach us to curb the use of violent video games?

Does God use only certain special murderers or is God behind all murders? If so, do murderers belong behind bars or should we forgive them because they were just tools of God and didn’t act of their own volition?

If you extend Obama’s theology to all murders, you’d say his thinking was positively nuts. God doesn’t use shooters to teach us lessons about love or to influence policy change.

God doesn’t use racists; God loses them. 

God lost Dylann Roof when he entered a Bible study group and opened fire.

God didn’t use a suspected killer as a wake-up call to our nation so that we could overcome hatred or gun violence, so that we could pass better gun control laws or so that we could remove the Confederate flag from the South Carolina state house. And God did not work through an assassin so that we could finally learn to love one another. God has nothing to do with heinous slaughter. Why teach people to hate God when we can teach them to love and to emulate God?

Here is what I wish President Obama had said about God at the Rev. Pinckney’s funeral:

“You might have thought that God would extend some extra compassion to the men and women who were studying the Bible and praying in a church. That somehow God would have stopped the shooter, struck him down with a lightning bolt. But God did nothing of the sort. God’s ways are a mystery. Unfortunately, God is not in the evil-prevention business. That is the sacred mission God has placed in our hands. The Rev. Pinckney understood that. He became a state senator because he wasn’t waiting for God to fix our world. He understood that God was waiting for us! His faith moved him to dedicate his life to improving the lives of others. I wish God would save the 21,000 innocent children who die each day of poverty, hunger and easily preventable diseases. I wish God would provide them clean water to drink. I wish God would heal racism and violence. But that’s our job. God has planted amazing grace in our souls. That’s why we are here. It’s our job to care for one another. That’s what God is praying for every day. That we will take care of the sick. That we will put an end to violence and racism and hatred. That we will find solutions to hunger and homelessness. God’s amazing grace is in our hands and we’ve been blind to that fact for long enough. The Rev. Pinckney could see it. He taught his parishioners to see it, and his death was not in vain because his life and the lessons he taught are leading us to see that same truth.”

My faith teaches me that God has given humanity the sacred power to create and to destroy. Free will is our greatest blessing and our greatest curse. God does not intervene in human affairs to perpetrate evil — even with the best of intentions. Yes, I do believe God works through people. We can see God’s hand in acts of compassion and kindness. My faith teaches me that God was indeed inside Mother Emanuel church on the night of the massacre. God was inspiring the Rev. Pinckney as he taught his Bible study class, and God was weeping with the dead and the dying, gathering their innocent souls into a shelter of peace. God was speaking words of comfort in the ears of the survivors and the mourners, just as God is whispering words of comfort to our entire nation: “Do not fear, for I am with you.”


Rabbi Naomi Levy is the founder and spiritual leader of Nashuva and the author of “To Begin Again,” “Talking to God” and “Hope Will Find You.”

Obama’s eulogy: Stirring words, disturbing theology Read More »