fbpx

November 10, 2013

November 10, 2013

The US

Headline: US has ‘folded’ on Iran, Israeli political sources charge

To Read: According to Leon Wieseltier, there is an unacceptable gap between Obama's words on foreign affairs and his actions-

By doing nothing in Syria, Obama ensured that there is nothing we can do. It worked! When Assad falls, as assuredly he will fall, he will be replaced by an extremist Sunni government, because no significant help came for the rebels who represented an alternative. American action may have mixed results, but the absence of American action will have unmixed results. Meanwhile a headline 
in The New York Times the other day declared that “chemical arms inspectors say Syria has destroyed all declared sites.” Whoop-dee-do. Assad still controls many metric tons of toxic agents, and there is the indelicate matter of Assad’s undeclared sites. At the United Nations, Obama adduced the “searing memories . . . [of] Jews slaughtered in gas chambers” in support of his gun-controller’s—I mean arms-controller’s—approach to mass slaughter. Never mind that in the war against Hitler we did not limit our aims to the confiscation of Zyklon B.

Quote: “The Obama administration has two missions. One is the humanitarian impulse to save the lives of innocent civilians. The other is to provide aid to the opposition to show it has the roots of governance in these ungoverned spaces. It’s got a very different purpose, and different partners are carrying it out. We’re working with humanitarian groups that do not want to choose sides in a battle and do not want to be mistaken for having chosen sides”, US Assistant Secretary of State for Population, Refugees and Migration Ann Richard talking to Barbara Slavin about the Syria crisis.

Number: 22%, the US used to provide 22% of the UNESCO budget before withdrawing its financial support to the organization as a response to a vote which gave Palestinians full membership.

 

Israel

Headline: Netanyahu: I asked world leaders to wait with Iran deal

To Read: Former Shin Bet chief Amy Ayalon and high-tech entrepreneur Oren Petruschka suggest lowering the bar in the Israel-Palestine negotiations-

But decades of failures must mean something. And what that should teach us is not to abandon the goal, but to find a better path.

In addition, we have failed because we set the bar too high.

We have set it at a full-fledged, permanent solution. But that requires courageous and honest negotiations, and leaders, which evidently is not possible in today’s domestic and regional political environment. Negotiations between parties suspicious as to the other’s intentions and hamstrung by domestic constraints cannot yield an agreement.

Quote: “We have no such thing. If you mean what I think you mean – then no. Thank God, this city is holy and pure”, the new Mayor of Beit Shemesh denying the existence of homosexuals in his city.

Number: 12,500, Israel has one public company for every 12,500 citizens (the US has one for every 47,000)

 

The Middle East

Headline: Talks With Iran Fail to Produce a Nuclear Agreement

To Read: The Washington Institute's Simon Henderson takes a look at the Saudis' nuclear ambitions-

But all the frank talk in the world may not convince Riyadh to back down if it believes Iran is on the path toward a nuclear weapon. The best the Obama administration can probably hope for at the Geneva talks is to convince Iran to place restrictions on its nuclear program — actually stopping it seems increasingly unlikely without the use of military force. In these circumstances, the Saudis may well judge that the years of preparation they have devoted to going nuclear were well spent.

Quote:  “We have said to the negotiating sides that we will not answer to any threat, sanction, humiliation or discrimination. The Islamic Republic has not and will not bow its head to threats from any authority. For us there are red lines that cannot be crossed. National interests are our red lines that include our rights under the framework of international regulations and (uranium) enrichment in Iran” Iranian President Rouhani making a 'red line' statement.

Number: 52, the number of journalists who have been killed in Syria since 2011.

 

The Jewish World

Headline: On Kristallnacht anniversary, Obama calls for speaking out against intolerance

To Read: A new survey of Europe's Jewish population features some disturbing statistics-

Two-thirds of respondents (66%) said that anti-Semitism is a problem in Europe, and over three-quarters (76%) noted that there had been an increase in anti-Semitic hostility in their home countries over the last five years.

 Close to half of respondents (46%) are afraid of being verbally attacked or harassed in a public place because they are Jewish, while a third (33%) worry that such attacks could turn physical.

Quote: “Leaders of the United Nations…in reviewing the past year emphasized the fact that one half of [the four million] civilians killed were 2 million Jews. The number of persons massacred by the Nazis in occupied countries is larger than the number of men killed on the battlefields”, an excerpt from a 1943 document from the Council of Jewish Federations' General Assembly which took place soon after news of the extermination of Jews became public.   

Number: 88, Michael Stein, one of the founders of the Washington Institute, passed away last week, one day before he turned 88.

November 10, 2013 Read More »

High Holiday Sermons – 2013/5774 – Ayeka? Where are You?

This past High Holiday season (2013-5774) I asked myself and my congregation one central question in three different ways: Ayeka? (Lit. – “Where are you?”).

The question, of course, is not about one’s location. Rather, it asks about our identity, how we think and what believe, who we are and what values are central in our lives.

Ayeka is the first question to appear in the Hebrew Bible (Genesis 3:9). It was asked by God of the first humans in the Garden of Eden immediately after they ate from the forbidden tree.

Ayeka – Where are You?  Part I – American Jews

Ayeka – Where are You?  Part II – The Jewish People and State of Israel

Ayeka – Where are You?  Part III – God

I include here as well my Yizkor sermon “A Midrash on the Death of Moses” based on a compilation of midrashim (rabbinic legends and commentaries).

In the context of my synagogue mission’s to Israel and the West Bank in October (2013) about which I am still writing in a series of Reports from Israel, the second sermon, in particular, informs my thinking.  All three sermons, however, ought to be considered together.

The sermons are posted on the Temple Israel of Hollywood (Los Angeles) web-site at http://www.tioh.org/worship/clergy/clergystudy

High Holiday Sermons – 2013/5774 – Ayeka? Where are You? Read More »

Sunday Notes: Israelis Disagree with US Policy, Let America Spy

1.

Last week I wrote about the complicated nature of the question of US aid to Egypt – another question on which Israel and the US seem to be divided (in addition to Iran and the Israeli-Palestinian peace talks). While the US seems determined to punish Egypt for its lack of democracy, the Israeli government prefers to see aid to Egypt flow uninterrupted, fearing the negative consequences that might occur if the Egyptian government were pushed to demonstrate its ability to retaliate against the US' punitive measures.

Interestingly, on all three fronts of disagreement, the debate isn't between a US administration and an Israeli government of a certain political bend. Public opinion polls show that on Iran, Palestine and Egypt, Israelis overwhelmingly agree with the Netanyahu government position. The latest example is from last week's Panels Politics poll that pollster Menachem Lazar was kind enough to send me.

“Should the US keep aiding Egypt by strengthening the current regime”, Israelis were asked. 52% of them said yes, 20% said no (28% said they don't know). On Iran, the numbers are even more striking: 85% of Israelis believe that the Iranians are leading the western world by the nose, while only 2% of Israelis believe that Iran really intends to change its policy (13% don't know). On Palestine and the peace talks, skepticism rules, no matter what Secretary Kerry says: 6% of Israelis believe that there's a chance for an agreement, while 86% do not believe such an outcome is probable (8% don't know). 71% of Israelis believe that the Palestinian complaints regarding the new building constructions in the West Bank are merely an excuse for the Palestinians to avoid a resolution to the conflict. Less than a quarter of Israelis – 24% – believe that the settlement building plan that was announced two weeks ago can be considered as “material damage” to the peace process.

 

2.

My INYT (International New York Times) column from last week was about the US spying on allies.

A majority of Americans – 56% – say that it is “unacceptable for the US to monitor the phones of allied leaders”. According to the Pew research center, Republicans and Democrats share this view. According to a survey by The Guttman Center Israelis are split on the question “what is more important” for the US – “obtaining intelligence data from friendly countries or maintaining their trust toward the United States?” – with a majority of people believing that “maintaining friendly countries’ trust in the United States” is the better option (49% to 41%).  

Yet when it comes to Israel the picture changes dramatically: a large majority of Israelis say that they would favor listening to leaders and citizens of friendly countries (if Israel indeed practices such eavesdropping).

You want to know why? Take a look:

The difference between outraged Americans and impassive Israelis is striking, and illuminating. It is the difference between a public for whom security is largely a theoretical issue, and a public for whom defending the homeland is a perpetual concern. It is the difference between a society that is concerned for its privacy no less than its security, and a society that won’t hesitate to trade some privacy for more security.

The explanation is basic. According to a Pew Research Center survey from 2011, “just one-half of one percent of American adults” served in active duty at any given time over the previous decade, even though it was a period of sustained war for the United States. By contrast, a vast majority of Israelis serve in the military at some point. As many as one in five have personally witnessed a terrorist attack. And according to the Israel Defense Forces, in 2012 more than one million Israelis were living under the threat of rocket attacks from Gaza.

In other words, Israelis are both more concerned about the possible consequences of neglecting intelligence, and are more aware of the measures necessary for the useful gathering of intelligence.

Sunday Notes: Israelis Disagree with US Policy, Let America Spy Read More »

Talmud in Action: Virtual House of Study to Span the Globe

A global conference of Jewish learning, including music and art performances, will take place online over a 24-hour period on November 17, 2013. “>24×24” – 24 classes from 24 speakers around the globe – free of charge and live using Google Hangouts On Air and YouTube. World-renowned scholar Rabbi Adin Even-Israel Steinsaltz will speak at 10am PST.  

This is a great opportunity to learn alongside our brothers and sisters from around the world, working with inspiring, dynamic teachers in a cutting edge format. What could be better?

The Global Day will unite 400 communities in 40 countries through the study of Jewish texts. Sponsored by the “>www.theglobalday.com on November 17th.  Viewers around the world will be able to sit in on classes broadcast from in-person community events worldwide. Virtual communities and individuals at home will be able to ask questions live on Twitter, Facebook and Google+. These videos will also be available on YouTube.

Karen Sponder, Project Director, explained that, “our use of Google Hangouts On Air marks the first time this platform will be used for Jewish learning on a global scale.  We hope that 24×24 will inspire others to use the Internet to unite the worldwide Jewish community, and make it easier to access Jewish learning.”  

With God's help, I will be participating from Gettysburg, PA, where I will be attending the festivities connected to the 150th Anniversary of Abraham Lincoln's Gettysburg Address.

____________________________________________

Sal shares a bit of Jewish wisdom at “>accidentaltalmudist.org.

Talmud in Action: Virtual House of Study to Span the Globe Read More »