fbpx

August 18, 2013

August 18, 2013

The US

Headline: How American Hopes for a Deal in Egypt Were Undercut

To Read: Leslie Gelb argues that the US should back the Egyptian generals-

Let’s get real and tamp down the moral posturing about democracy in Egypt. Freely elected President Morsi and his now-deposed Muslim Brotherhood government weren’t practicing democracy. They were co-opting the laws and slowly destroying all possible opposition. Besides, they were aligning with America’s jihadist enemies in Syria, Gaza, and elsewhere. Egypt’s military leaders, no democratic sweethearts either, are aligned with moderates, need Washington more than the Islamists, and back U.S. interests on the Suez Canal and Israel. Americans rightly can’t stand the military street slaughters. For sure, bloody casualties will mount. But the United States has some modest chance to influence the military in right directions. It has little or no chance of saving Egypt for democracy if the Islamists return to power.  

Quote: “The worker bees [current State Department Employees] are frustrated. Everyone knows it's a coup. They recognize the reasons why we wouldn't call it a coup, but they also see the hypocrisy”, one of several former State officials who are unpleased with the current US policy in Egypt.  

Number: 69, the percentage of Americans who would feel their privacy was threatened if law enforcement began using drones armed with high tech cameras and recording equipment.

 

Israel

Headline: Polio vaccination campaign expands nationwide

To Read: Dore Gold examines the problematic inconsistency and injudiciousness of the EU's recent decisions concerning Israel-

The background to the EU's program with Israel is the need for Europe to improve its global competitiveness and increase jobs and economic growth on the continent after years of sluggish growth. The Horizon 2020 program is not a European handout to Israel, but a joint initiative by which Israel puts up funds by itself and receives 1.6 euros for joint research and development for every euro it puts in.

Because of its scientific prowess, Israel is the only non-European country to have been invited to take part in this program. The Europeans knew what they were doing by inviting Israel, which is no longer viewed as a country known only for its Jaffa oranges, as it was in the 1950s. Clearly, both sides benefit from this cooperation and both have much to lose by its politicization by EU bureaucrats in Brussels.  

Quote: “The air is nice, the weather is good, the view is wonderful. I think this is most of the reason that people come here”, Micha Drori, one of the many non-ideologically motivated West Bank settlers.

Number: 79, the percentage of Israeli Jews who don't believe that peace will come, according to a new poll.

 

The Middle East

Headline: EU to urgently review ties with Egypt

To Read: Shibley Telhami, a Brookings fellow who has been studying Arab public opinion, gives some interesting insights into unclear and complicated role of religion in the rise (and fall?) of Egyptian Islamism

Arabs, like most people, have many contending collective identities, and the weight of each shifts over time; there is rarely a lasting equilibrium. Over the past decade, the rise in people identifying primarily as Muslim was not all or even mostly due to expanding Islamist aspirations. Instead, it resulted mainly from declining identification with the state, thanks to government failings on domestic and foreign policy. Also, the extraordinarily long tenures of individual leaders — Moammar Gaddafi ruled for 42 years and Mubarak for 30 — made it difficult for people to separate state from unpopular ruler. But a vote against something is not the same as a vote in favor of something else.

Quote: “(Nasrallah's) speech takes Lebanon into deeper involvement in the Syrian fire. It's a pity to squander the blood of the Lebanese in such a way”, Lebanon's former PM accusing Hezbollah of dragging Lebanon into the Syrian mire.

Number: 18,000, the number of centrifuges Iran has, according to its outgoing nuclear chief.  

 

The Jewish World

Headline: Anti-Semitism levels in Belgium highest since 2009

To Read: Rabbi David Wolpe writes disapprovingly about a recent crazy viral Bar-Mitzvah video-

Achh. I know I sound like an old curmudgeon. Watching this I thought the adjective ‘godless’ has rarely been more apt. I cannot help recalling the wise words of AJ Heschel — self-respect grows each time we are able to say ‘no’ to ourselves. This video is a “YES” to a child from all the people in his life who should be teaching him “no.” And that kind of education has consequences far beyond Sam Horowitz and his dancing Bar Mitzvah girls.

Quote: “It is obvious that Russia is oppressing the gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender community in a manner similar to the ways in which the Soviet Union once oppressed the Jewish community”, Abraham Foxman standing up for Gay rights in Russia.

Number: 721,711, the updated number of Youtube hits for the Bar Mitzvah video Wolpe writes about.

August 18, 2013 Read More »

Elul Meditation

I am husband and father,

Brother, son, colleague, and friend.

I am a congregational rabbi,

And a Jew in the pews.

I am a cancer survivor,

And support those with cancer,

And heart disease,

And dementia,

And mental illness,

And people in bad marriages,

And with troubled kids,

And unsatisfying jobs,

And too little money,

And frustrated lives.

I am one human being,

And life moves through me,

And through you,

Except when it doesn’t.

Life is wondrous,

Most of the time,

But sometimes it hurts like hell!

There is a second me too,

And a second you –

The always-present Neshamah

That hovers and waits

To become one with Nefesh,

The earthly-animal-life-force

That keeps us alive.

The Neshamah connects us to Divinity,

And infuses us with Essence,

And inspires us

To think and know

That we come closest to God

When we know that we are no-thing

And part of the All.

When we are most receptive to Neshamah

Our lives work.

In Elul each morning I awake wondering –

What is my greatest challenge?

What troubles me about me?

What gives me heartache and grief?

What ruins enslave me?

Am I patient and kind enough,

Generous and respectful enough,

Understanding and wise enough,

Appreciative and grateful enough?

The Yamim Noraim are coming!

There is little time.

Elul Meditation Read More »

3 Short Comments on Egypt, the US, and Israel

1.

The new Egyptian rulers don't really care if the US does or doesn't continue to financially assist the military. Of course, they'd prefer to keep the money, but if they were presented with a choice- receive support and stop killing Muslim Brotherhood protesters, or get no support and continue killing– they would have no doubt: killing it is.

In fact, the Americans have more to lose than the Egyptians if the relations between the two countries further deteriorate: if Washington halts all support for Egypt, Cairo can do two things: It can get funds and support elsewhere (Saudi Arabia, but also Russia), and it can retaliate by suspending the peace accord with Israel – the accord for which it gets the funds. That's a scary scenario that Israel surely wants to avoid. So clearly for Israel it is almost impossible not to be on the side of the new strongman who can A. tame the Islamists, and B. keep the accord intact. Looking at the determination of the military in Cairo, Israel can also hope for a second act in Sinai. If Sisi is ready to take on the radical elements in Sinai with the same cold brutality, he'd have one happy client in Jerusalem.

2.

Here's what an Israeli official told me when I asked him about Sisi and Obama: “The butchery is of course heart breaking, but maybe there's something to admire about a leader who knows what he wants and is willing to put his money – in this case his guns – where his mouth is”. Guess which of the two leaders he was talking about.

3.

The Washington Post reports this morning:

For now, the Obama administration is playing a balancing game, trying to send tactically sharp messages while preserving influence in an increasingly polarized society, protecting other national security interests in the region and positioning the United States for a long-term strategic relationship.

This sounds more like a report by The Onion than a serious news report. Using words like “tactical”, “influence”, “interests”, and “strategic” is supposed to make it resemble a report on American foreign policy – when in fact, there's no policy and nothing much to report. And piling on Obama's confused Egypt policy is not even entertaining anymore.

3 Short Comments on Egypt, the US, and Israel Read More »

An Apology to our MTA Classmates Who Were Victimized

As Elul rushes toward Tishrai, my good friend Joey Lipner and I have penned a letter of apology to our classmates who were compelled to “wrestle” with Rabbi Finkelstein. In it, we apologize for never having said or done anything, even as we were quite aware of the bizarre things that were going on. If you were in MTA in those years, or if you know someone who was, please consider signing the letter and/or passing it along. We hope that it will bring some tikkun to this awful situation. Here's the link:

An Apology to our MTA Classmates Who Were Victimized Read More »