fbpx
Sunday, March 7, 2021

The Conspiracy Theories Around HIAS, Debunked

We spoke with HIAS CEO Mark Hetfield and ZOA president Morton Klein to debunk some of the accusations against HIAS.

Print This Article

Ariel Sobel is a TED talker, writer and Bluecat Screenplay Competition Winner.

https://jewishjournal.com/wp-content/uploads/2020/04/jj_avatar.jpg
Ariel Sobelhttps://www.arielsobel.com/
Ariel Sobel is a TED talker, writer and Bluecat Screenplay Competition Winner.

Jewish-run nonprofit HIAS, which resettles refugees, has come under fire from Jewish groups, especially the Zionist Organization of America (ZOA), which alleges HIAS is in bed with figures and organizations associated with anti-Semitism and anti-Zionism.

The Jewish Journal spoke with HIAS CEO Mark Hetfield and ZOA president Morton Klein about some of the accusations against HIAS.

HIAS was founded in 1881 when the acronym stood for “Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society.” Its original mission was to help destitute Jewish refugees pay for legal aid and travel to the United States and other sanctuary nations.

In recent years, as the number of indigent Jewish refugees decline, HIAS has expanded its mission to aid refugees regardless of their religious or ethnic background. For that reason, and its leadership’s belief that the term “Hebrew” was “exclusionary and outdated, much as the word ‘’colored’’ is to refer to African Americans,” HIAS abandoned its original name for its initials. 

GOZ AMIR, CHAD – APRIL 20: (ISRAEL OUT) A Sudanese refugee child holds up a drawing as part of a project by HIAS (Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society) in Goz Amir Refugee Camp on April,20, 2007 near the border with Sudan in Chad. HIAS conducts psychlogical projects for refugees including painting classes where the refugees convey their experiences in drawings. (Photo by Uriel Sinai/Getty Images)

“At HIAS, we used to help refugees because they were Jewish; today, we help refugees because we are Jewish,” HIAS CEO Mark Hetfield told The Journal. However, in recent weeks, the name change has drawn judgment, with critics claiming that it is symbolic of HIAS disowning its Jewishness and stance against anti-Semitism. 

The idea of HIAS becoming a “generic” refugee-assistance group has upset some who valued the organization for its specific aid to Jewish families and individuals.

The idea of HIAS becoming a “generic” refugee-assistance group has upset some who valued the organization for its specific aid to Jewish families and individuals.

HIAS’ 2018 annual report does report assisting Jewish refugees; however, the majority of it talks about HIAS’ general assistance efforts around the world to those of all faiths.

According to ZOA, “In 2016, a total of 239 Jewish refugees entered the United States, and HIAS resettled 169 Jewish refugees (70.7% of the total). In 2019, only 38 Jewish refugees entered the United States. If HIAS resettled the same percentage (70.7%) as in 2016, then it would have resettled only 27 Jewish refugees last year.

WASHINGTON, DC – SEPTEMBER 14: Activists hold a banner during a demonstration organized by HIAS, founded as the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society, outside the U.S. Capitol September 14, 2017 in Washington, DC.  (Photo by Aaron P. Bernstein/Getty Images)

Is HIAS anti-Israel?

“HIAS is steadfastly pro-Israel, as we recognize that a strong Israel fulfills HIAS’ founding mission — to ensure that Jewish refugees finally have a homeland to go to,” Hetfield said on behalf of the organization. “HIAS has stood with the Conference [of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations] in its public positions against BDS and against U.N. bias against Israel.” According to him, HIAS does not affiliate with organizations that support the boycott, divestment and sanctions movement (BDS).

“HIAS is steadfastly pro-Israel, as we recognize that a strong Israel fulfills HIAS’ founding mission — to ensure that Jewish refugees finally have a homeland to go to,” Hetfield said on behalf of the organization.

HIAS supports Israel’s immigration policy of aliyah, runs scholarship programs for olim, Jews who invoke their right to return. For the past three decades, HIAS has given higher-education scholarships to olim. HIAS, however, has challenged Israeli policies, including penning a joint letter with the Anti-Defamation League in 2018 to Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, urging him not to deport African asylum seekers.

Does HIAS partner with anti-Israel or anti-Jewish organizations?

The major complaint from detractors is that HIAS affiliates with anti-Zionist groups, which undermines the nonprofit’s pro-Israel stance. A recent column in the Jewish publication Israel Hayom alleged that “HIAS collaborates with Islamic groups that allegedly have links to Hamas and terrorist activities. It also works with other post-Jewish, pro-BDS groups like IfNotNow and Jewish Voice for Peace.” While HIAS has signed petitions that these groups have also have signed, the groups have never partnered for a program.

“Allegations that HIAS ‘partners’ with organizations like IfNotNow, MPAC and CAIR are not true,” Hetfield said. He also noted that HIAS partners with AIPAC. 

“Allegations that HIAS ‘partners’ with organizations like IfNotNow, MPAC and CAIR are not true,” Hetfield said. He also noted that HIAS partners with AIPAC. 

WASHINGTON, DC – MARCH 06: Ibrahim Hooper (R), Corey Saylor (C), and Gadeir Abbas (L), of the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR), speak to the media about the executive order U.S. President Donald Trump signed today about middle east travel, on March 6, 2017 in Washington, DC. (Photo by Mark Wilson/Getty Images)

However, ZOA has pointed out that on the HIAS website, it states, “HIAS is partnering with the Gulf Coast Jewish Family and Children’s Services in another pilot program to support successful Syrian refugee resettlement through a range of activities including resource development, bridging cultural differences, and educating the community about their potential contributions to the community. The program also works closely with the Council on [American-] Islamic Relations [CAIR] and other faith-based organizations.”

CAIR, the leading American Muslim civil rights organization, has connections to the terrorist group Hamas. It does not formally endorse the BDS movement, but several CAIR leaders have publicly supported it.

Hetfield maintains HIAS does not affiliate with CAIR. “All ZOA points to is a single episode of cooperation by one of our local refugee resettlement partners in Florida, an agency which is completely legally independent of HIAS,” the CEO said. 

Hetfield maintains HIAS does not affiliate with CAIR. “All ZOA points to is a single episode of cooperation by one of our local refugee resettlement partners in Florida, an agency which is completely legally independent of HIAS,” the CEO said. 

HIAS does not dispute ZOA’s claim that it works with Islamic Relief USA (IRUSA), which Hetfield frames as “a completely apolitical humanitarian organization with no position on BDS.”

WASHINGTON, DC – SEPTEMBER 14: Signs are seen during a demonstration organized by HIAS, founded as the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society, outside the U.S. Capitol September 14, 2017 in Washington, DC.  (Photo by Aaron P. Bernstein/Getty Images)

ZOA asserts that IRUSA is a terrorist-affiliated organization, citing how its parent company, Islamic Relief Worldwide (IRW), was banned in 2014 from operating in Israel for allegedly funding Hamas. IRW denied connections to the group, reporting that an audit by an unnamed “leading global audit firm” cleared its name and challenged the decision in Israeli courts. Additionally, the United Arab Emirates and Germany have ruled that IRW was linked to the Muslim Brotherhood. Bangladesh banned the organization from working on behalf of the Rohingya people, alleging that it funds militants.

Islamic Relief denies all these terrorist affiliations, as does HIAS.

“Allegations against Islamic Relief Worldwide, also an apolitical humanitarian organization, remain unsubstantiated,” Hetfield said.

Another charge from ZOA is that “HIAS collaborates with anti-Semitic U.N. agencies,” in which it names U.N. High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) and UNICEF as anti-Semitic. HIAS does not dispute that it works with these and other U.N. agencies. “These vital partnerships have never prevented HIAS from standing up against U.N. bias against Israel in the General Assembly, the Human Rights Council, or anywhere else,” Hetfield said.

GOZ AMIR, CHAD – APRIL 20: (ISRAEL OUT) Sudanese refugees paint as part of a project by HIAS (Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society), HIAS conducts psychological projects for refugees including painting classes were the refugees draw their experiences in the Goz Amir Refugee Camp April 20, 2007 in Goz Amir, Chad. (Photo by Uriel Sinai/Getty Images)

The American Jewish Joint Distribution Committee, Alpha Epsilon Pi, Hillel, JCC, UJA Federation have partnered with at least one of U.N. agencies, as has the ADL, which publicly declared that UNICEF was not anti-Israel in 2008.

When asked if other Jewish organizations should be chastised for working with these U.N. agencies, Klein told the Journal: “I would have to see what they are trying to do with them.” He said that HIAS’ collaboration with these councils is more concerning “because they’ve done such work with such inappropriate groups that are so hostile to the Jewish people.”

Does HIAS partner with BDS activist Linda Sarsour?

Many in the Jewish world see anti-Zionist American activist Linda Sarsour as radioactive. The former Women’s March leader repeatedly has been condemned by left-wing, right-wing and big tent Jewish groups for her connections to the Nation of Islam group and rhetoric about Jews and Israel. 

ZOA said that Sarsour fundraises on behalf of HIAS, and they have a partnership. Hetfield denies the nonprofit affiliates itself with her. 

LAS VEGAS, NV – JANUARY 21: Women’s March Co-Chairwoman Linda Sarsour stands onstge during the Women’s March “Power to the Polls” voter registration tour launch at Sam Boyd Stadium on January 21, 2018 in Las Vegas, Nevada. (Photo by Ethan Miller/Getty Images)

On the day of the Tree of Life shooting in 2018, in which the assailant explicitly invoked the Pittsburgh synagogue’s work with HIAS as motivation for his violence, Sarsour started a fundraiser on her personal Facebook page for the organization. 

“This act was neither solicited or coordinated in any way,” Hetfield said.

In a letter to the Conference of Presidents, ZOA writer Klein alleged HIAS signed a letter embracing Sarsour and that “they will work alongside” her.

The letter he is referring to is from 2017, titled “Jewish Leaders Statement Against Attacks on Linda Sarsour.” It condemned often threatening harassment of the activist, explicitly stating that “We will not stand by as Sarsour is falsely maligned, harassed and smeared, as she, her organization, and her family suffer vicious public threats and intimidation.” However, Hetfield claimed HIAS did not sign the letter as an organization.

“In my personal capacity, I was among over 170 Jewish leaders who signed a statement which explicitly did not endorse her views, but was simply a call for civility urging an end to personal attacks and threats against Sarsour and her family,” Hetfield said. “I do not regret signing the letter at all.”

“In my personal capacity, I was among over 170 Jewish leaders who signed a statement which explicitly did not endorse her views, but was simply a call for civility urging an end to personal attacks and threats against Sarsour and her family,” Hetfield said. “I do not regret signing the letter at all.”

Linda Sarsour speaking onstage during the Women’s March on Washington in Washington, D.C, Jan. 21, 2017. Photo by Theo Wargo/Getty Images

The letter explicitly states the leaders don’t offer a stamp of approval to all of Sarsour’s messages, but “with Sarsour and others, we work as allies on issues of shared concern and respectfully disagree when our views diverge.”

ZOA counters that by stating an individual cannot sign under the name of his or her organization without invoking the organization’s clout. “HIAS President Hetfield and HIAS Vice President [Jennnie] Rosenn cannot now claim that they signed in their individual capacities, when they listed HIAS together with their names.”

ZOA added, “Further, for top leaders of an organization, there really is no such thing as signing such a letter in one’s personal capacity. When a president and vice president of an organization signs such a letter, it is widely viewed as a statement of the organization. Mark Hetfield and Linda Rosenn are HIAS. Most organizations do not let its leaders sign such letters, and certainly do not allow them to sign together with the organization’s name, unless the organization has approved of their action.”

Although Klein says he personally condemns violence against Sarsour, he feels the letter went beyond that.

WASHINGTON, DC – NOVEMBER 08: Morton Klein of Zionist Organization of America attends a hearing at the National Oversight and Government Reform Committee on moving the U.S. Embassy in Israel to Jerusalem on Capitol Hill on November 8, 2017 in Washington, DC. (Photo by Tasos Katopodis/Getty Images)

“I want to make clear if that letter defending Linda Sarsour simply said ‘there have been physical threats against her and her family, and no matter what we think of her or her views or how hostile threats against her are unacceptable, we deplore them, I would not have said one word,” Klein responded. “But the letter said we condemn people who malign and smear her — meaning criticize her — and look forward to working alongside her.”

Klein also added that by signing with prominent-BDS supporters and even vocal anti-Zionists, Hetfield lent them credibility.

Has HIAS disowned its Jewishness? 

The overarching thesis of all these allegations against HIAS is that it no longer qualifies as a Jewish institution, whether that be from its expansion in mission or policy takes. “HIAS is, by its own definition, not a Jewish organization,” Klein wrote.

HIAS’ board is 100% Jewish.

“HIAS’ board is 100% Jewish, HIAS’ main partners are Jewish congregations and Jewish family service agencies, we are completely branded as a Jewish agency, we invest over $1 million per year just on engaging Jews and Jewish institutions in our work,” Hetfield said. “Helping those few Jewish refugees who need our assistance are a top priority.”

PHILADELPHIA, PA – NOVEMBER 22: Atmosphere at the HIAS #RefugeesWelcome Thanksgiving at the Old Pine Community Center November 22, 2015 in Philadelphia, Pennsylvania. (Photo by Bill McCay/Getty Images for MoveOn.org)

ZOA asserts that HIAS is not “Jewish enough” to be a member of the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations (COP), a nonprofit coalition of 51 national Jewish organizations that bills itself as the voice of organized American Jewry. HIAS is a member of COP.

“Under the COP’s rules, the faith of the members of HIAS’ board is irrelevant. If General Electric had an all-Jewish board, it would not qualify for COP membership,” ZOA countered. “The organization thus must serve the American Jewish community. Thus clientele — the people who HIAS resettles — is what counts here.”

“We welcome the stranger and protect refugees, as the Torah commands us to do 36 times. No act is more Jewish than that.” — Mark Hetfield

As to Hetfield’s mention of the financial assistance HIAS provides, ZOA said, “$1 million per year is a drop in the bucket compared to HIAS’ $50.9 million annual budget.”

“We welcome the stranger and protect refugees, as the Torah commands us to do 36 times,” Hetfield said. “No act is more Jewish than that.”

Ariel Sobel is the Journal’s social media editor.

Correction: A previous version of this article incorrectly stated that Alpha Epsilon Pi partnered with all the U.N. agencies mentioned. It also incorrectly stated that B’nai B’rith International had partnered with the U.N. agencies.

Did you enjoy this article?

You'll love our roundtable.

Enjoyed this article?

You'll love our roundtable.

Select list(s) to subscribe to


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Jewish Journal, 3250 Wilshire Boulevard, Los Angeles, CA, 90010, http://www.jewishjournal.com. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact

Editor's Picks

Latest Articles

Culture

Latest Articles
Latest

The Raging of Cancel Culture is a Threat to Us All

Our nation is terminally divided, and unlike the Civil War, this time it is not but one single issue that separate us.

What Can Israel Do for America?

“I am concerned about the threat of assimilation by American Jews and about the high cost of a Jewish education in this country."

Will We Miss Anything After We Leave Our Pandemic Cocoons?

With vaccinations spreading rapidly like millions of bees pollinating prairies, our country is finally starting to come out of its hibernation.

A Letter to the IQC and the State Board of Education about Ethnic Studies

I strongly oppose the 2021 California Ethnic Studies Model Curriculum.

Film Review: Intermarriage, Iranian Jewish Style

“Over My Dead Body” chronicles the response of an Iranian Jewish family in Beverly Hills to the news that their daughter has decided to marry a Muslim Iranian.

Hollywood

Podcasts

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.

x