Israel’s leaders in Jerusalem are “not rushing toward an Obama-like public spat with the Biden administration over Iran policy,” writes Brig. Gen. Michael Herzog of the Washington Institute. Jerusalem “is preparing for dialogue.”
“Wars begin when aggressive powers believe that their targets are weaker, or give the false impression that they are weaker, or at least stay inert in the face of provocation,” warns Victor Davis Hanson of the Center for American Greatness and Stanford University’s Hoover Institution.
The Iran issue is back on the table. The Biden administration is looking for a way to return to the nuclear agreement. Iran is looking for a way to return to it on its own terms and with no additional conditions attached. Israel is seeking to either disrupt the return to the old deal or verify that a new deal, much stricter, is implemented. Saudi Arabia is looking for a way to work alongside Israel without being dragged into a public spat with someone else.
The implied conclusion of what we know is this: Not all parties will get what they want. To make it even more complicated, some players are seeking a compromise solution on a topic that, for some players, there can be no compromise.
America is stepping into this field with an inherent deficiency: In tough negotiations, the party with higher stakes has a natural advantage. Nuclear Iran is much more important for Iran, Israel and Saudi Arabia than it is for Biden and his team.
This prioritization makes the Americans more likely to accept compromise and makes Iran and Israel less likely to do so. Is dialogue itself a show of weakness? No, not always. But in this case, all parties can easily identify an American weakness. The United States cares about Iran — but not as much as Iran or Israel do.
The United States cares about Iran — but not as much AS Iran or Israel do.
Under such circumstances, America must compensate, in some fashion, for its weakness. Of course, it has the means to do such a thing because it is a superpower, unlike Iran and Israel. If countries in the Middle East suspected that the United States is fully invested in getting a workable agreement, they’d have no other choice but to pay close attention to its priorities. Almost two decades ago, Libya’s leader Muammar Gaddafi agreed to eliminate his country’s weapons of mass destruction. He agreed because, at the time, America seemed fully committed to the elimination of such means in the region.
Today, we do not yet see a similar commitment. Not even close. For obvious reasons (many of which are easy to sympathize with), America seems more committed to restoring the agreement than to achieving the ultimate goal of making sure that Iran does not become a nuclear weaponized aggressive regime. This makes Iran more emboldened and makes Israel more nervous. Herzog writes, “the option of taking military action against Iran’s nuclear program… is not mere posturing.” So Jerusalem is preparing for a quiet dialogue, alongside preparations for other things.
Iran Negotiations: America’s Inherent Disadvantage
Shmuel Rosner
Israel’s leaders in Jerusalem are “not rushing toward an Obama-like public spat with the Biden administration over Iran policy,” writes Brig. Gen. Michael Herzog of the Washington Institute. Jerusalem “is preparing for dialogue.”
“Wars begin when aggressive powers believe that their targets are weaker, or give the false impression that they are weaker, or at least stay inert in the face of provocation,” warns Victor Davis Hanson of the Center for American Greatness and Stanford University’s Hoover Institution.
The Iran issue is back on the table. The Biden administration is looking for a way to return to the nuclear agreement. Iran is looking for a way to return to it on its own terms and with no additional conditions attached. Israel is seeking to either disrupt the return to the old deal or verify that a new deal, much stricter, is implemented. Saudi Arabia is looking for a way to work alongside Israel without being dragged into a public spat with someone else.
The implied conclusion of what we know is this: Not all parties will get what they want. To make it even more complicated, some players are seeking a compromise solution on a topic that, for some players, there can be no compromise.
America is stepping into this field with an inherent deficiency: In tough negotiations, the party with higher stakes has a natural advantage. Nuclear Iran is much more important for Iran, Israel and Saudi Arabia than it is for Biden and his team.
This prioritization makes the Americans more likely to accept compromise and makes Iran and Israel less likely to do so. Is dialogue itself a show of weakness? No, not always. But in this case, all parties can easily identify an American weakness. The United States cares about Iran — but not as much as Iran or Israel do.
Under such circumstances, America must compensate, in some fashion, for its weakness. Of course, it has the means to do such a thing because it is a superpower, unlike Iran and Israel. If countries in the Middle East suspected that the United States is fully invested in getting a workable agreement, they’d have no other choice but to pay close attention to its priorities. Almost two decades ago, Libya’s leader Muammar Gaddafi agreed to eliminate his country’s weapons of mass destruction. He agreed because, at the time, America seemed fully committed to the elimination of such means in the region.
Today, we do not yet see a similar commitment. Not even close. For obvious reasons (many of which are easy to sympathize with), America seems more committed to restoring the agreement than to achieving the ultimate goal of making sure that Iran does not become a nuclear weaponized aggressive regime. This makes Iran more emboldened and makes Israel more nervous. Herzog writes, “the option of taking military action against Iran’s nuclear program… is not mere posturing.” So Jerusalem is preparing for a quiet dialogue, alongside preparations for other things.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
Why Are Presidential Statements About Jews So Weak?
UCLA Hillel on Pro-Palestinian Encampment: Jewish Students “Feeling the Intensity of the Situation”
USC Cancels Main Commencement Ceremony
Chosen Links – Colleges and Passover Edition – April 25, 2024
Nova Festival Exhibit in Manhattan Harrowing and Inspiring
Steve Garvey Holds Press Conference Calling for Action Against Pro-Palestinian Campus Protests
Culture
Beth Lee: OMG Yummy, Exciting Flavors and Preserved Lemons
Passover Breakfast
Dr. Nicole Saphier on Motherhood and Jewish Advocacy
Friendship Warms the Heart of ‘The Bespoke Overcoat’
West Hollywood’s MASH Gallery Exhibition to Feature Female Jewish Art
West Hollywood gallery hosts a charity art exhibition of female Jewish artists, “Women of Valor: In The Land of Milk and Honey.” Proceeds from the event will benefit women victims of trauma and sexual violence in Israel.
Echad Mi Yodea? Who Knows One?
The numbers never change.
The First Alphabet and the Third Plague
A Bisl Torah – The Fifth Child
Perhaps, since October 7th, a fifth generation has surfaced. Young Jews determining how (not if) Jewish tradition and beliefs will play a role in their own identity and the future identities of their children.
A Moment in Time: “A Week without Bread: Do we Really Kneed It?”
Hollywood
Spielberg Says Antisemitism Is “No Longer Lurking, But Standing Proud” Like 1930s Germany
Young Actress Juju Brener on Her “Hocus Pocus 2” Role
Behind the Scenes of “Jeopardy!” with Mayim Bialik
Podcasts
Beth Lee: OMG Yummy, Exciting Flavors and Preserved Lemons
Shani Seidman: Manischewitz, Passover Memories and Matzo Brei
More news and opinions than at a
Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.