May 23, 2019

Can Judaism and Liberalism Coexist?

“The theme of a recent Yeshiva University Beit Midrash Shabbaton was “Can Orthodoxy and Liberalism Coexist?” I believe the question was wrong, if it refers to classical liberalism and the philosophical foundation upon which our Canadian democracy stands. We should not ask “Can Orthodoxy and Liberalism Coexist?” – We must ask, “Can Orthodoxy and Judaism exist today WITHOUT Liberalism?” I refer to liberalism not in the sense of the Liberal party or the welfare state. I refer to the idea, codified in Canada’s Charter of Rights and Freedoms that everyone has fundamental freedoms (life, liberty and property). Governments exist to serve the needs of their people, and to protect these basic rights; not visa versa.

Today, these concepts are under attack. Some argue that the nation-state must protect only some of its citizens, based upon their ethnicity. Some argue that the nation-state must look upon its citizens through the prism of their identification with historically marginalized groups and intervene to rebalance past wrongs. These are serious claims – but they are dangerous. They are dangerous to us as Jews and as human beings. To see a person based upon their ethnicity is not to see them as a person. It behoves us to advocate with whatever political power we have on behalf of the life and liberty of every person, irrespective of their ethnicity.

With this said, I imagine that there is another definition of liberalism that lies at the root of the question, “Can Liberalism and Orthodoxy Coexist?” Liberalism privileges the individual to the exclusion of the community and, to some degree, of God. It is this call to freedom that says my truth need not accord with anyone else’s. My rights entitle me to live for myself, without interference from anyone. This individualism interferes with any ability to judge the individual – be it by God or by man.”

Read more

JJ Editor's Daily Picks

"With many other countries already studying the Asian playbook, the United States and Europe could benefit from doing the same."

"Trump's cursing is one of the most straightforward parts of his appeal... Trump is not the only politician whose profanity has stood him in good stead."

"‘If we get all of this because Netanyahu wants to make Trump happy, that’s fine with us,’ says local council rep in Golan Heights as plans ramp up for ‘new’ neighborhood honoring U.S. president..."

"...there is something worth paying attention to in this latest petition from fans keen to have a creative work made the way that they want it. The comments on the petition are instructive."

"The sunny job numbers and steady growth hide the fact that most people think the economy works only for people in power."

"Like many other Americans, I now wear AirPods all day at my desk to combat the awful tyranny of the open office. Since they don’t cancel noise, they provide me with writing music..."

"The logic of attributing mental states to nonhuman animals is complicated. We cannot use deductive inference, because there are no general rules..."

"As the canon of English literature slowly, gradually opens itself up to books by women and authors of color, Modern Library and Penguin Classics have just launched two new series..."

"Egalitarian couples assume their progressive ideology will carry the day. Sociologists know that it doesn’t.... sharing child care is associated with valuing gender equality..."

"Business Booms for Sephardic Food: Women are leading the way as small businesses bring traditional recipes to the commercial marketplace..."

"With most animal populations, the niches that encase the populations are of constant size. Animal societies growing in a given niche have dynamics neatly fitted by equations with a constant limit or ceiling."

"Now some 200,000 Jews live in Germany, a nation of 82 million people, and many are increasingly fearful.... 85 percent of respondents in Germany characterized anti-Semitism as a “very big” or “fairly big” problem..."