fbpx

Louisa May Alcott Doesn’t Need to Be Trans To Be a Trans Icon

If Louisa May Alcott, author of “Little Women,” were alive today, would she identify as a trans man?
[additional-authors]
January 6, 2023
Louisa May Alcott – Scanned 1891 Engraving (Getty Images)

If Louisa May Alcott, author of “Little Women,” were alive today, would she identify as a trans man? The answer is unknown and unknowable, but this hasn’t stopped author Peyton Thomas from issuing a verdict in a recent piece for the New York Times, in which Alcott, dubbed “Lou,” is referred to with male pronouns.

Thomas is not the first to make this claim—only the most recent and perhaps the most prominent. This isn’t without reason. Louisa May Alcott was famously masculine, once referring to herself as “a man of all work” and “a gentleman at large.” Notably, she once told an interviewer that she possessed “a man’s soul, put by some freak of nature into a woman’s body.”

Is this not a profession of trans identification? And, if so, shouldn’t we, as Thomas suggests, “take Lou at his word?”

Sure, except that we don’t really know what Lou’s word meant. Perhaps she was, as Thomas seems to think, being completely literal and telling her interviewer that she was actually a man, and not a woman. Perhaps, however, she meant something else—more akin to what we mean when we call a young person an “old soul.”

It’s not uncommon for people to speak this way. I have met non-Jews who say they have a Jewish soul. I have met Americans who say that they are Europeans at heart. I have heard straight women say that they are gay men in women’s bodies.

Such statements are an expression of something that is actually a quite common part of the human experience—which is that we don’t always feel a total alignment between who we are and who the world expects us to be.

With this in mind, are we certain that we can know the precise meaning of Alcott’s statement? Certain enough to “assign” her a new gender? For that matter, even if one was convinced that Alcott was trans, why a trans man? Why not nonbinary? Or genderqueer? Why “he/his/him” and not “they/their/theirs”?

Of course, amidst all these unanswerable questions, one might ask why I insist on continuing to refer to Alcott as a woman and using female pronouns when referring to her. Is this not an equally uninformed guess? The answer to this is that we have no good reason not to—and the burden of proof remains with those who want to claim that one of history’s most beloved female writers was actually a man.

The truth is that we don’t, and can’t, know how Alcott, if she lived today, would have understood herself. For that matter, we don’t know how we would have understood ourselves if we had been born in the 19th century, or the 18th, or the 31st. And we have no grounds to say which time period’s array of cultural constructs and paradigms should be taken as authoritative.

The truth is that we don’t, and can’t, know how Alcott, if she lived today, would have understood herself.

The urge to exhume and relabel the dead is a common one. A ghoulish example is the Mormon Church’s practice of posthumously baptizing dead Jews into their faith. In the world of progressive Jewish academia which I inhabit, this takes the form of op-eds, academic papers, and viral tweets claiming that Jesus was a communist or a Palestinian freedom fighter; or that King David was a gay man; or that Ruth was a lesbian; or that Abraham was a Zionist.

In many instances, there is a good reason for the inquiry, but the case is almost always overstated. This is because such inquiries are rarely about the pursuit of truth. As Thomas admits, what’s really at stake is “who gets to claim a hero.”

Fortunately for all of us, we don’t need someone to have batted for our team in order to claim them as a hero. What matters is that they evoke something deep in us that speaks to our own experience of the world. This is in no way diminished by the fact that the feeling might not be mutual.

We can therefore acknowledge that Jesus’ message of egalitarianism and non-materialism might have profound significance to modern-day Marxists, without saying that Jesus was a communist. Because, of course, he wasn’t.

We can look to the story of King David and Jonathan as a poignant portrayal of love between two men that will speak to gay male couples. We need not assert any unverifiable truth claims about King David’s sexuality for this to be the case.

We can see how Abraham’s sojourns in the holy land become a midrashic thread in the Zionist tapestry despite the fact that the biblical patriarch was, obviously, not an adherent of a 19th-century secular national movement.

And we can appreciate how many in the trans community look to Louisa May Alcott’s relationship to her sex and find a deep resonance with their own experience.

After all, we are free to claim anyone we want as an icon for ourselves and our communities. We are free also to ask and re-ask the question about whether or not our icons would claim us back if they had the chance. What we are not free to do, however, is to baptize the dead—changing their pronouns and their names when they can neither protest nor consent.


Matthew Schultz is the author of the essay collection “What Came Before” (2020). He is a rabbinical student at Hebrew College in Newton, Massachusetts.

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

A Night of Gratitude Honoring Dennis Prager

Latest Articles

Print Issue: What Happened? | November 13, 2026

A story of bipartisan support that gradually became a story of one-party support, until it flips entirely and becomes once again a story of consensus – this time, of bipartisan opposition.

Why Are We Even Here?

When we’re tempted to ask, Lamah zeh anochi? — Why am I here? What’s the point? — we can remind ourselves of the extraordinary goodness that exists in the world. And, even more importantly, we can become part of it.

Leo David Honored as FIDF Gala Raises

Throughout the years, David has donated millions of dollars to numerous causes, but FIDF has always held a particularly special place in his heart.

What If Jewish Americans Just Showed Up?

We mourn on Oct. 7, but Nov. 8 gave us something to celebrate: a community that showed up, on its feet, public and proud. Now we need to make that response a habit.

Genocide and International Relations

The book casts its net far and wide, from debates within the field of research itself to the analysis of genocidal events across the past century.

A Concrete Case for Hope

Over the last few weeks, Americans and Israelis voted in elections that are consequential to the characters of both countries. For many, these elections represent inflection points, where the outcome signals the directions their respective societies will take moving forward.

AIPAC Isn’t the Problem. It’s Part of the Solution.

The future of the U.S.-Israel relationship will not be secured by winning one more primary. It will depend on whether Americans understand why Israel matters, why Jewish self-determination is legitimate, and why the alliance benefits both nations.

The Last Signer

Carroll, having helped swing Maryland toward independence, was elected to Congress on July 4, and signed the Declaration in August, the only Catholic among the signers and the only one to add his estate to his name.

Torah Portion: Toldot

The parsha begins with a direct statement: “This is the story of Isaac, son of Abraham.”  

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.