fbpx

November 18, 2026

Setting Our Own Rules

The incoming Speaker of the House of Representatives said last week that “things have to dramatically change over in the Middle East.” 

This statement came one week after the Vice President of the United States asserted that our country must “change our relationship to Israel.”

Within days of each other, two of the three highest ranking officials in our government saw the opportunity to question our country’s relationship with the Jewish state, secure in the knowledge that such an opinion was not just widely accepted but it would help them politically with the most intolerant and extreme members of their respective parties. 

In fact, the United States’ relationship with Israel is already changing. Donald Trump and Benjamin Netanyahu have both said as much: they differ only on the timing of the end of U.S. military aid. The newly-elected Democratic Congress might slightly accelerate that change, but it would be happening regardless of which party holds the majority on Capitol Hill. The next Democratic presidential nominee will have been required to submit to a series of anti-Israel litmus tests, but Vance is only the most visible of a growing number of Republicans looking for opportunities to cultivate anti-Israel supporters in GOP ranks. 

As I suggested here last week, the obvious recourse for Jewish Americans and other supporters of Israel is to step away from both major political parties and become Independent. The hard-core haters who occupy the furthest fringes of the ideological spectrum retain a disproportionate amount of influence within their respective primaries. The answer is not to fight them on their own turf but to establish an alternative political structure that allows us to set our own rules. Candidates may have a difficult time winning their parties’ primaries without support from intolerant extremists. But we can make it impossible for them to win a general election without addressing our concerns and meeting our needs.

As independent voters, we will no longer be forced to pretend that the zealots in our party must be tolerated in the name of “party unity.” In a closely divided country, we can instead affiliate with other internationalists, human rights advocates, free trade supporters and believers in a stable and global community. We can identify allies who see the benefits of these types of multi-national cooperative partnerships that practice tolerance and protect against authoritarian aggression, in the Middle East, on the Pacific Rim, in Latin America, Europe, Africa and throughout the rest of the developing world. These potential allies are just as frustrated as we are. All they require is an organizing entity that can coordinate their efforts to steer our political leaders in a more reasonable and more productive direction.

There will come a time when the United States’ political system features multiple party options rather than the artificial binary choice to which we are now limited. Those of us of a certain age grew up in an era with three television networks, five buttons on the car radio and two political parties. But we now live in a society that provides us with an unlimited number of options for information, entertainment and opinion. We will soon realize that confining ourselves to such a limited number of political options is no longer realistic. Nor is it necessary.

But until that day comes, our community has a choice. Do we continue to struggle as outnumbered pariahs within two increasingly unpopular and archaic political parties? Or do we establish ourselves as the gatekeepers who can hold candidates to a set of higher standards that most Americans agree will better reflect our nation’s heritage, our values, and our interests? 

We know the answer to those rhetorical questions. We just need to be willing to step away from a political tradition that no longer serves us toward a system that isolates the haters and allows the rest of us to move forward toward our shared goals and aspirations.

Is this ambitious? Of course. But throughout our history, our people have accomplished much more sweeping change at much greater cost. We can follow their example and do it again.

Dan Schnur is the U.S. Politics Editor for the Jewish Journal. He teaches courses in politics, communications, and leadership at UC Berkeley, USC and Pepperdine. He hosts the monthly webinar “The Dan Schnur Political Report” for the Los Angeles World Affairs Council & Town Hall. Follow Dan’s work at www.danschnurpolitics.com.

Setting Our Own Rules Read More »

Holocaust Survivor: ‘Life Is Beautiful’

Ella Mandel is 99.

She was 13 when the Germans invaded Poland in September 1939. Ella lived with her parents and two sisters, Zosia and Lola.

The Nazis chased them and other Jews to the cemetery, where they murdered her younger sister Lola. Eventually, after years in the Lodz ghetto and then Auschwitz, the rest of her family perished.

Through many miracles, Ella survived.

So have her memories.

She recounted some of those memories on stage last Sunday at an event hosted by AKLA, a teen fellowship that builds Jewish pride. Much of what Ella spoke about was the suffering of her past, as she repeated “never again” over and over.

But after all those memories of darkness, Ella said three words that stuck with me:

“Life is beautiful.”

Her mood had brightened because she spoke about the joy of meeting her husband, and the happiness she felt today from her children and grandchildren.

She also mentioned gratitude, the theme of our issue this week.

Let’s face it: We’ve had many reasons this year to not be grateful. Antisemitism is at an all-time high, while the U.S.-Israel relationship is at an all-time low. Around the world, people routinely accuse the Jewish state of “genocide,” which has endangered Jewish lives.

Instead of feeling gratitude, we’ve been constantly anxious, or as Rabbi David Wolpe writes, “profoundly uneasy.”

In the face of so much bad news, our collective mindset has been to mobilize and fight.

So why are we taking this detour for gratitude?

It’s not just because it’s Thanksgiving week. It’s also because the more we thought about it, the more we realized there is never a bad time for gratitude.

That realization was brought home this year by Dennis Prager.

As many of you read in his Rosh Hashanah cover story, Dennis had a catastrophic fall two years ago that left him paralyzed from the shoulders down.

He doesn’t deny the disaster but recognizes what he calls the “miracle” that he can still communicate and share his thoughts with the world.

One of his favorite subjects is the virtue of  gratitude, which will be the theme of his address at our “Night of Gratitude” gala.

So, in his honor, we asked several Journal contributors to share essays on gratitude for this special issue. Among the highlights:

Selwyn Gerber reminds us that “Gratitude is not one of the pleasant accessories of a religious life. In Judaism it is the foundation, the first words of the morning, and – as the name of the people itself attests – the thing we are actually called. The Hebrew word for Jews, Yehudim, derives from Yehudah, whose name means ‘I will give thanks.’”

Stand-up comic Mark Schiff connects gratitude to the blessing of sobriety.

Mort Schapiro shares a list of what he’s grateful for, including small kindnesses that make his day, inspiring music, lifelong learning and great writing.

Rabbi Bradley Shavit Artson writes that gratitude “feeds our souls to pause and to thank. Gratitude is the virtue and enables us to harvest life’s bounty and blessings. Acknowledgement brings the consciousness that encourages us to step up to other opportunities and challenges and to know we can see them through.”

There’s plenty more: Eva Robbins shares her spiritual take on “the magic words,” Stuart Halpern on the Jewish connection to the Thanksgiving parade and Yoshi Zweiback on his “lessons in gratitude.”  

To add meaning to your Thanksgiving table, we offer the Jewish Journal Thanksgiving Haggadah that serves as a handy guide to conversation that deepens the spirit of the holiday. 

My own take on gratitude is inspired by my mother. Gratitude fuels her days, as it does mine. I’ve learned that no matter how stressful or anxious life gets, gratitude is the saving grace, the one virtue that can give us the strength to keep going.

It’s the virtue that reminds us that after all the darkness and the uncertainty, life still finds a way to be beautiful. Just ask Ella Mandel.

Happy Thanksgiving.

Holocaust Survivor: ‘Life Is Beautiful’ Read More »