A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to an Antisemitic Spin Class
A funny thing happened on the way to a pedal-power pogrom in Philadelphia last week. A biker gang (okay, the kind that spins), calling themselves Philly Bike on Your Left, numbering a mere 200 (with an additional 100 standing on two feet), had intended to harass and intimidate Jewish businesses on Rittenhouse Square, leaving them with the distinctively familiar message received by Jews for millennia: “Get Out!”
But this time, the unwelcome party for the world’s longest suffering outcasts was greeted by hundreds of Jews and Zionists with a message of their own: “This is our city. We are law-abiding American citizens. The Jewish state is a model to be replicated, not revoked. And Israel’s brief history has taught Jews living in the diaspora to not be afraid and to fight back.”
The unwelcome party for the world’s longest suffering outcasts was greeted by hundreds of Jews and Zionists with a message of their own: “This is our city. We are law-abiding American citizens. The Jewish state is a model to be replicated, not revoked. And Israel’s brief history has taught Jews living in the diaspora to not be afraid and to fight back.”
Jews not residing in Israel are always the minority wherever they happen to be—being only .02% percent of the world population. This time, however, as counter-protesting Philadelphians, Jews outnumbered the cyclists. The protesters never got near the Jewish storefronts. There was scuffling, slogan-shouting (“Genocide!” and “Show Your Faces!”) and name-calling. The police reported only three arrests. The brainless bikers accused Jews of throwing tacks onto the streets, taking some of the air out of their animus. (An unconfirmed accusation, but I hope it was true.)
Proud Zionists from the City of Brotherly Love sang songs and formed a human barricade, protecting business establishments that may or may have not been owned by Zionists. It made no difference to pathological Jew-haters. For them, Israel’s justified war in Gaza is treated as a blank check to threaten and harm Jews living anywhere—all under the pretense of Palestinian rights.
Don’t ask me to explain that illogic. We know that China has for many years persecuted its Uyghur population with ethnic cleansing, forced sterilization and abortion, and concentration camps. Uyghurs happen to be ethnic Muslims. They should be seen as no more or less valuable under the eyes of Allah than Palestinians.
Actually, given that Uyghurs don’t engage in acts of terrorism while Palestinians luxuriate in such murderous hobbies, Allah might be disappointed in them, but in the eyes of the West, the Uyghurs should be regarded as a most favored, sympathetic minority.
Yet, no one seems to care at all about the fate of China’s Uyghur population. Most people have never heard their name or known of their existence. And get this: There are 1 million Uyghurs in China! How does that compare with the allegedly 70,000 Palestinians killed in Gaza—more than half terrorists, the rest casualties of war?
If a pro-Uyghur movement magically materialized in America, would they be permitted to ransack Chinese restaurants shouting, “Shame!” and “Genocide!”, or breaking glass storefronts, or smearing Chinese people with fake blood? Would it even make sense for them to do so?
Having met and been bested by the opposition last week, the organizers of Philly Bike on Your Left canceled its second ride, a “ride of return,” which had been planned for this past Sunday. Meanwhile, another group of cyclists—this one completely circumcised—calling themselves Philly Israel Alliance, organized their own pro-Israel ride on Sunday, which started at the Philadelphia Museum of Art.
Of the literally thousands of public assemblies against the Jewish state since the Gaza war began—rupturing university campuses, synagogues, and public streets—few generated any simultaneous critical mass of counter-protest from local Jews and their Zionist allies.
In the capital cities of Europe—London, Paris, Madrid, Brussels, Stockholm, Berlin, Amsterdam—where Muslim populations are sizable, prone to extreme acts of violence and largely insulated from punishment because local officials are too afraid to interrupt a pogrom in progress—it makes sense that Jews would not voluntarily wade into a riot of rabid antisemites.
But what if Jewish communities throughout the West prepared themselves to engage in self-help, fearlessly fighting back, even in the face of numerical disadvantages? Taking justice into one’s hands is always morally appropriate whenever legal systems refuse to apply the rule of law in their defense. Nowadays, antisemites seem to be operating with relative impunity, and, at times, with the apparent well-wishes of local officials.
What would Jewish self-defense look like? What would it take?
It’s easy to forget that long before Jews excelled at Nobel Prizes in the hard sciences, were enriched from high finance, and innovated high-tech marvels, they never shied away from mortal combat. Before the life of the mind became their primary milieu, Jews from the Middle East cultivated more brutish instincts for survival.
Being perpetually outnumbered never altered their military calculations. Remember the story of Hanukkah? Jews spend the eight days recalling the heroics of Judas Maccabeus and his intrepid guerrilla warriors, the Maccabees. They achieved numerous military victories against the much larger Seleucid Greek-Syrian Empire. When the sand settled, in 164 BCE they preserved the Jerusalem Temple and the reclaiming of the Kingdom of Judea.
The Romans invaded the Holy Land and found themselves confronted by pesky Jewish freedom fighters known as Zealots in what became known as the First Jewish-Roman War (66-73 CE). The Zealots triumphed with some surprising early victories, defeating an entire Roman legion led by Cestius Gallus.
Jerusalem ultimately fell to the Romans in 70 CE when the Second Temple was destroyed. Today many remember the legendary story of the Zealots committing mass suicide on top of Masada in 73 CE, rather than surrender to Roman rule.
By 132 CE, Jewish avengers were at it again with the Bar Kokhba revolt, the final Jewish uprising against Rome. That war ended in 135 CE, when the last Jewish stronghold in the region, Betar, was overtaken, and the leader of the uprising, Bar Kokhba, was killed.
Jews were then barred from Jerusalem. Judea was renamed Syria Palaestina. And the Jewish diaspora began its 2,000-year exile to such far-flung places as Iraq, Rome and then north to Europe and Russia.
A small band of militant Jewish renegades was founded in New York City in 1968—popularly known as the Jewish Defense League, led by Rabbi Meir Kahane. Kahane was avowedly more versed in violence than in rabbinic studies.
For decades, the group engaged in bombings, arson and other violent acts on behalf of beleaguered Jews from Brooklyn and captive Jews in the Soviet Union. Several of its leaders were arrested. The FBI designated the JDL a terrorist group. Kahane himself was assassinated in New York.
Perhaps the JDL should never be emulated. But some modern form of Jewish self-defense may have to emerge—someway, somehow. The key takeaway from the Holocaust—a lesson that most American Jews have forgotten or apparently never learned—is that rescuers are sparse and largely nonexistent. There are just so many John Fettermans, Marco Rubios, Bill Mahers and a handful of others. No one else is coming.
The key takeaway from the Holocaust—a lesson that most American Jews have forgotten or apparently never learned—is that rescuers are sparse and largely nonexistent. There are just so many John Fettermans, Marco Rubios, Bill Mahers and a handful of others. No one else is coming.
Israel’s first days of statehood, in 1948, when Israel declared its independence, began with a war initiated by five invading Arab armies. Their objective was to rid the region, entirely, of Jews. Israelis know that letting their guard down, even for an instant, can have grave consequences. The massacre on October 7, 2023 is one of several examples of lessons forgotten.
These past several years have given global Jewry much to ponder. Should there be another mass Exodus to Israel—this time not from Egypt, but from Europe, Canada and the United States? What are the risks of remaining in place?
The diaspora may one day be called upon to do its own fighting.
Thane Rosenbaum is a novelist, essayist, law professor and Distinguished University Professor at Touro University, where he directs the Forum on Life, Culture & Society. He is a contributing writer for White Rose magazine. His most recent book is titled, “Beyond Proportionality: Israel’s Just War in Gaza.”
A Funny Thing Happened on the Way to an Antisemitic Spin Class Read More »

