fbpx

September 1, 2015

For Hasidic Jew who consults for Google, no college degree required

When Issamar Ginzberg enters his Jerusalem office on a sweltering summer day, he’s wearing a long black coat tied at the waist and a black hat. His long, scraggly beard and sidecurls, or payos, offer no relief from the heat.

The office — thank God — is air conditioned, and Ginzberg offers kosher candy from a bowl on his desk. Nearby sit his laptop and LG phone, complete with a “kosher” filter that restricts it from many websites. While some haredi Orthodox men do without any smartphone, Ginzberg has two. He also keeps a Blackberry handy for U.S. business trips.

On a nearby shelf sits a series of Yiddish audio CDs on how to succeed in business that Ginzberg produces and sells. The room, which has an interior that wouldn’t look out of place in a Tel Aviv office building, is on the parking level of his apartment building in a haredi neighborhood about where the building superintendent might sit.

A scion of a Hasidic rabbinic dynasty, Ginzberg lives in Jerusalem’s haredi world, attending synagogue daily and spending hours every morning learning Torah. But by afternoon, evening and night, he is a marketing consultant to more than 100 clients, among them Google and Oracle.

“My key clientele is the corporate world and entrepreneurs in the non-Jewish, non-Orthodox world,” said Ginzberg, 35, a father of four. “One of the reasons I’m trusted so much by the Orthodox community is because they know I’m legit, because I actually work in the real world.”

The Brooklyn native moved to Jerusalem five years ago, just as the movement in Israel to integrate haredim into the army and labor force was gaining attention. Labor force participation rates for haredi men have risen in recent years and now stand at 45 percent; many haredi men still opt to study Torah full time rather than work.

Many haredim see a contradiction between secular workplace culture and their own, but Ginzberg says his black hat and beard are a feature, not a bug. He emphasizes his religious background on his promotional materials, calling himself “Rabbi Issamar” and “a character who just stepped out of ‘Fiddler on the Roof.”’

“It’s harder to be taken seriously, but the novelty that you look different gives you 10 seconds of, ‘Let me see what this guy has to offer,’” he said. “If you meet 20 WASPs and one guy who looks like me, which one will you remember six months later?”

Ginzberg grew up speaking Yiddish and English in an Orthodox neighborhood of New York, and had an early appetite for business. As a teenager, he used classified ads and the early Internet to buy 386-model computers in bulk and resell them for profit. He became a mortgage broker 15 years ago and parlayed that into a consulting business. He now has 120 regular clients that pay $3,000 for 10-hour packages.

To accommodate his haredi lifestyle, Ginzberg begins his days at 7 a.m., responding to late emails from U.S. clients before attending morning prayers at 8 or 9 a.m. He then studies Torah with a partner until 1 p.m., when he moves back to consulting, generally switching between clients in one-hour shifts. Aside from spending two-and-a-half hours with his family in the evening, Ginzberg works well past midnight with West Coast businesses, getting five hours of sleep at most.

“He and I as well think it’s better to learn [Torah], but you can’t learn all day because there’s no salary,” said Moti Feldstein, director of Kemach, an organization that has helped 7,400 haredi men find work. “You have kids. You need to make a living. He says, ‘Look at me: I go around with my suit, with my hat, I learn Torah and I work.”

Clients say what makes Ginzberg valuable is his ability to quickly understand a diverse set of topics despite having no professional training in them. Ginzberg says that comes from being an autodidact with a work ethic formed by learning at yeshiva. He doesn’t have a college degree, but has taught himself, he says, by voraciously reading books and papers on business and psychology.

“I like that he can get to the point,” said Yael Sela-Shapiro, a Hebrew-English translator who consulted with Ginzberg and helped set up a seminar he gave to Google’s Israel office in 2013. “He talks for a few minutes and manages to pinpoint the exact question that can get the information he needs to give you the best advice.”

Since moving to Israel, Ginzberg has become involved in increasing the employment rates of haredi men. He interfaces between Kemach and potential employers like Google and Intel, helping bridge cultural gaps between the high-tech and haredi worlds. And he lectures at yeshivas in Israel and America, introducing students to the fundamentals of business.

“He explains what it is to work, professionalism,” Feldstein said. “You work with a staff, you have a manager, you have to come on time, how to work when there’s someone different next to you.”

Judging from Ginzberg’s Facebook page, he doesn’t just use the Internet to make a living — he also enjoys it. In addition to business advice, he posts links to articles on the Middle East, Shabbat and, in one case, being mistaken for an Amish man. Ginzberg maintains it’s all part of the effort to promote his work.

“You can’t run away from social media,” he said. “Business is three-dimensional. People are three-dimensional. When I say have a good Shabbos, I’m basically proud of the fact I’m a religious Jew. I’m reminding people, whether they’re religious or not, Shabbos is coming. I’m showing everyone that I’m lucky to be who I am and do what I do.”

For Hasidic Jew who consults for Google, no college degree required Read More »

Hundreds of Palestinians riot following Israeli raid in West Bank

An Israeli soldier was wounded, possibly by friendly fire, during clashes between Israeli soldiers and Palestinians following an Israeli raid in the West Bank city of Jenin.

Israeli soldiers, as well as officers from the Shin Bet security service officers and Israel Police, came to Jenin early Tuesday morning to arrest a senior Hamas operative, the Israel Defense Forces said in a statement. Security forces surrounded the home where the alleged operative was hiding, ultimately demolishing it when the wanted man refused to come out.

Following the arrest, hundreds of Palestinians rioted in the area, throwing rocks and firebombs, according to the IDF, leading to the injury of the soldier as well as at least five Palestinians.

The IDF is investigating the circumstances surrounding the shooting of the soldier.

Hours after the arrest, rockets were fired from the Gaza Strip toward Israel, triggering the Code Red warning in towns on the ssouthern border. The rockets landed in Gaza territory, however.

A group affiliated with the Islamic State claimed responsibility for firing two rockets at Israel, saying it was in retaliation for the Jenin raid, Ynet reported.

Hundreds of Palestinians riot following Israeli raid in West Bank Read More »

#myLAcommute I enjoy the food in L.A., but French food is better

PIERRE DESCAMPS

I’m from a small town near Marseille, France. I’m studying English at a school for international students. I’ve been in L.A. for one week and I will be here for two more weeks. I really like Hollywood because I love cinema. My favorite films are by David Lynch. Donnie Darko is also one of my favorites.

I can go anywhere on the bus or train. Tomorrow I’m going to Santa Monica—I love the beach. I like Los Angeles but I already miss France, especially the food. I’ve enjoyed the Chinese food, Mexican food, and Korean food, but I think French food is better. I think we have the best cuisine.

Eagle Rock Boulevard to Fair Oaks Avenue

#myLAcommute is a project of Zócalo Public Square.

#myLAcommute I enjoy the food in L.A., but French food is better Read More »

Debate rages over filmed confrontation between Palestinian activists and Israeli soldier

This article first appeared on The Media Line.

Images of an Israeli soldier grabbing a Palestinian child around the neck and pinning him to the ground, during an arrest in the West Bank have gone viral on the Internet. One version of the video, on the Tamimi Press Facebook page, was viewed over 3.5 million times. The result is a wave of arguments from across the Israeli-Palestinian political divide trying to frame the photographs and videos of the incident in terms which reinforce their own narratives.

To parts of the pro-Israel world, the soldier, who was arresting a stone-throwing Palestinian, is being attacked by a well-known group of violent and media-savvy Palestinian activists. They say the soldier shows remarkable restraint throughout the incident and is clearly under distress.

To the Palestinians, the video shows a masked and armed soldier attempting to interrupt the peaceful demonstration of a young boy, whose arm is in a cast, by physically detaining him. The angry reaction of the child’s female relatives, they say, including biting the soldier, are the natural response of anyone seeing their family attacked.

The incident took place during clashes outside the Palestinian village of Nabi Saleh, northwest of Ramallah, in the West Bank. Residents have staged a weekly demonstration since 2009 relating to a number of disputes with a neighboring Jewish community, Halamish over land and access to water. The protests, held every Friday, frequently turn into confrontations with the Israeli army with international and local media in attendance.

One particular point of the video which caught commentators’ attention was a young girl, the boy’s sister, who bit the soldier during the confrontation. Ahed Tamimi, 14, is a familiar face in a number of videos from 2012 showing the teenager confronting Israeli soldiers.

Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdoğan personally presented Tamimi with an award for bravery. To right-wing Israeli commentators, Tamimi is the poster girl for what they describe as “Pallywood” – confrontations with security forces that are deliberately provoked and then recorded by Palestinian activists.

“The role of the town (Nabi Saleh) has been a lesson in how you can fool some of the people all of the time – in particular reporters,” Arnold Roth, an Israeli blogger who has followed activities in the village for a number of years, told The Media Line. Following the killing of their daughter in a terror attack in Jerusalem in 2001, Roth and his wife Frimet established the blog This Ongoing War, which posted a number of articles detailing what they believe is the “staged provocation” of the Tamimi family.

Roth argued that professional journalists should know that these confrontations are staged.

“There is clear open passion for Jewish blood and the peaceful demonstrations (are in fact) provocative acts designed to cause confrontation,” Roth said. “I don’t believe that reporters are (that) gullible.”

Palestinian photographer Mohanad Darabee, who was present during the episode, rejects claims that anything was staged.

 “I used a GoPro (video camera) – (it shows) the whole incident unedited and showing everything,” Darabee told The Media Line. He said the angry reaction from the family was natural and to be expected from a mother witnessing her child being attacked by an armed soldier.

Generally, the weekly demonstrations by residents from Nabi Saleh are peaceful, Darabee said, explaining that although Palestinian youth do throw stones at security forces this only occurs after the soldiers have fired tear gas at protesters. Evidence of the women’s peaceful intent could be seen in that no serious effort was made to hurt the soldier, Darabee argued. He was isolated, outnumbered and not wearing a helmet.

The Israeli army refused to comment on suggestions of “staged media-focused events” by Palestinian protesters or on any issues regarding the use of such events to push political narratives. “We’re about safety and security rather than media sensitivity,” the spokesperson told The Media Line.

The army did release a press statement which said: “IDF forces attempted to detain an individual who had been identified as throwing rocks. A group of rioters, including women and children, attacked the soldier in an attempt to prevent the arrest. The commander on site stopped the arrest in order to prevent an escalation of violence.”

For her part, Ahed Tamimi, the fourteen-year-old at the center of the controversy argued that it was as a result of Israeli military actions that she had become a part of the equation. “Daily… I see my father being humiliated by an Israeli soldier who is not even twenty-years-old. This obliges us to insist that all of the family should participate in demonstrations until they leave and we become free,” Tamimi told The Media Line.

Much of the Israeli media pushed a narrative, favored by the army and the government, that the incident took place in the context of a legitimate arrest and that the soldier was the victim and not the aggressor, according to Yoram Meital, the head of the Herzog Center for Middle East Studies and Diplomacy at Ben Gurion University. “It’s highly important from the perspective of the IDF (the Israeli army) to show these women actually disturbing the work of the soldier,” Meital told The Media Line.

At the same time Palestinian media has attempted to show the event as an “example of the… evil, negative and brutal (nature of) the occupation,” the professor said. 

Debate rages over filmed confrontation between Palestinian activists and Israeli soldier Read More »

Letter to the editor: Dueling lawsuits

Dear Rob,

I have just sent the following email to your reporter, and am now sending it to you.

Regarding your story, “Will dueling op-eds turn into dueling lawsuits?” I find it highly objectionable that you used quotes made by me in confidential emails with the parties.  

Let me say for the record that this is unprofessional and unethical.

I do not think Mr. Ron Torossian is “nuts” and we never said we wouldn’t run another op-ed by him.

On the contrary, The Jerusalem Post is open to hearing both sides of the story, just as I’m sure you are.

Regards,

Steve Linde

The Editors Respond:

We stand by Debra Nussbaum Cohen’s reporting. Using emails to report stories in the public interest is established journalistic practice supported by case law and engaged in by all responsible media, including the Jerusalem Post.

That said, in an email dated August 20, 2015, Mr. Linde wrote to Naomi Paiss of the New Israel Fund, regarding Mr. Torossian, “Will you help me when they sue us? (Which you know they’re going to do, because they’re nuts).” 

In an email dated April 21, 2015 to Naomi Paiss and cc’d to a Jerusalem Post editor, Mr. Linde wrote, “We have already taken a decision never to run a Ronn Torossian op-ed in the paper again. My apologies.”

Letter to the editor: Dueling lawsuits Read More »

Campaign to push Islamic State from Anbar Province in Iraq intensifies

This article originally appeared on The Media Line.

One month after the Iraqi government announced a new initiative to take back Anbar province in western Iraq, analysts and diplomats say the campaign is beginning to take root and Iraqi troops have regained control of some important areas.

“There is a shift in momentum towards unifying Iraqis and trying to win back the trust of the Sunni fighters in Anbar province who are on the front lines,” Renad Mansour, an expert on Iraq at the Carnegie Middle East Center told The Media Line. “Ramadi hasn’t been won back yet, but some territory has been going back and forth.”

The Iraqi army said it had 10,000 troops ready to participate in the fight, along with members of the Popular Forces, a predominately Shi’ite militia, who has successfully battled Islamic State, which practices an extreme form of Sunni Islam. Currently, Islamic State still controls large parts of Anbar province, the largest in Iraq, and hundreds of thousands have been displaced by the fighting.

Iraqi analysts say that the popular tide has turned against Islamic State, after brutal killings, arrests and torture of thousands in Ramadi.

“All of the citizens of Iraq, even the Sunnis, are waiting for the end of the nightmare of Daesh,” Methaq al-Fayydh, an Iraqi journalist told The Media Line, using the Arabic name of Islamic State. “What happened in Mosul (the first city taken over by Islamic State) – the killings and displacement of Christians and Muslims (Shi’ites and Sunnis) and Yazidis alike, make people want to get rid of Daesh.”

The Iraqi government has been trying to rebuild its army which was decimated when Islamic State swept through Iraq and neighboring Syria. Tens of thousands of soldiers fled, and a small number even joined Islamic State.

Along with the military efforts, President Heidar Abadi is working to streamline government and cut back on corruption, to help in the fight against Islamic State.

“Both sides are connected,” Mansour said. “People need to see the government fighting corruption and that will strengthen it as well.”

There have been some successes already. Military officials said that the army has recaptured the desert area west of Samarra and is preparing to move down into Anbar province. At the same time, suicide bombers recently killed two Iraqi generals last month as they led forces against Islamic State.

The media arm of Islamic State also released a video showing four Shi’ite fighters, suspended by their hands and feet, being burned alive. “Now retribution has come, for today, we will attack them as they attacked us and punish them as they punished us,” a masked Islamic State member said in the video.

The international community has been hesitant to get too involved in the fighting in Iraq, after the US withdrew from Iraq in 2011, eight years after tens of thousands of US troops entered the country to overthrow long-time Iraqi dictator Saddam Hussein. Almost 4500 US soldiers were killed during that time in Iraq, along with at least 150,000 Iraqis.

But many in Iraq called for more US involvement.

“The US must provide Iraqi forces with modern weapons,” al-Fayyadh said. “We also want them to increase air strikes targeting Islamic State.”

Campaign to push Islamic State from Anbar Province in Iraq intensifies Read More »

Can an Israeli teacher protest the IDF?

Let’s suppose that the school your child attends gets a new principal. And let’s  suppose — you’ll soon see why — that this new principal just signed a petition that calls on citizens to cheat on their tax forms because he believes taxes are immoral or he is not satisfied with the way the government spends its tax money. Or let’s say the school doesn’t have a new principal, but your daughter gets a new teacher. He is a great math teacher, but, when not working, he spends his time pouring sugar into the gas tanks of police cars — because he wants the police to get out of his neighborhood, or because he thinks police officers are racist.

What will be your position toward these educators?

A. It is a free country — and the principal/teacher can do whatever he/she wants in his/her free time.

B. If he\she is charged by the legal system, he/she should not be allowed to teach. As long as the legal system isn’t involved, the education system should tolerate him/her.

C. A principal/teacher is a role model, and we have the right to demand that a principal/teacher will be a member of our society who respects the law — so I want him/her fired.

D. Signing a petition is one thing, disrupting the police is another matter — so I’d keep the first and fire the second (or vice versa — although it’s harder to see how we would get to that conclusion).

Israeli children are going back to school this week, and at two schools they — or, to be more exact, their parents — will have to grapple with dilemmas somewhat similar to the ones presented above. In one school, in the city of Ashkelon, the parents threatened to keep their kids out of school because of the appointment of a new principal. The principal’s sin: In 2002, she signed a petition calling on Israeli soldiers to refuse to serve in the occupied territories. Namely, not to obey orders. The mayor supports the parents, and the public seems to support the parents, but the Education Ministry decided to let the principal get her appointment.

Earlier this week, the principal, after a few days of silence, sent a letter to the parents. In the letter, she says that she “never encouraged soldiers and officers not to serve, or not to serve in the territories.” I’m not certain this is an accurate description of her past deeds. The petition that she signed said that the signatories “support the fight of the officers and soldiers that refuse to serve in the territories.” She also said that she did nothing unlawful by signing the petition. Whether that’s true or not, Israel’s legal system does not bother with people signing such petitions. Still, the mayor doesn’t understand the rationale: As a principal of a school, this woman is supposed to be supportive of an educational agenda that encourages teens to serve in the military. Can she do that job when her students know what she really thinks?

The second case, involving a teacher, involves controversial behavior that is more recent. One could argue that the principal should not have to pay today for something she signed more than a decade ago — but this teacher was caught on camera just last week taking part in an incident in which an Israel Defense Forces (IDF) soldier was beaten up by Palestinians. The teacher, who works at a school in Ramat Gan, did not physically harass the soldier, but he didn’t try to assist him or prevent his peers from harassing him. So the parents want him gone, and the mayor of Ramat Gan wants him gone. He cannot be a role model for children, they say. He might be able to be a teacher in the narrow sense, but if our teachers are also educators — and that is what most teachers would like to believe — he should be fired.

The responses to such incidents tend to be predictable. There is the “right” response and the “left” response. The “not in our backyard” response versus the “this is a witch hunt” response. The minister of education said on Sept. 1 that the ministry is looking into the matter carefully. That is a good thing. The minister refrained from being a populist on such a delicate matter. In fact, he reminded his audience that the educational system does not belong to a specific political camp. It has to make room for everyone and has to make sure it does not punish teachers for their personal views.

And, of course, the personal views of the teachers should not be of any concern to the system. Or should they? Before you make your final judgment, imagine other possible scenarios. What if a principal were to sign a petition calling on soldiers not to obey orders concerning the evacuation of settlers in the West Bank? Or a petition supportive of the position that soldiers in the IDF should obey the orders of rabbis rather than those of military commanders? Would you still want that principal to be the one in charge of your children’s school? Or imagine the teacher joining a violent protest of right-wing radicals that harass Palestinian farmers, or marching in a provocative rally in an Arab village. Would that change your outlook on this matter?

If teachers were in charge only of teaching — if all they were asked to do is educate our children in math and science, Hebrew and history — it would be easier to say that their views are irrelevant, or much less relevant, to the way they do their job. But in Israel — and I’m far from certain that this is the right policy — we are constantly taught that schools are not just for teaching, that schools are for educating. We expect the schools to make our children better citizens, to make them more tolerant, to make them more patriotic, to make them more aware of human rights. All these are things that are not “technical” — they are ideological.

Hence, the demand for a certain consistency makes sense. A principal that teaches the students that they need to be polite is expected to be polite in his “private life.” He cannot say that in his “private life” it is his right to be aggressive and impolite. Because when it comes to education and to being a role model, there is no such thing as a “private life.” A teacher in a religious school cannot dress in a way that religious families deem immodest in his “private life” for the same reason: The students are watching. A teacher also cannot tell the students that serving their country is their sacred duty, but then dodge the draft and evade military service. If he does that, the students will call his bluff.

So here is the challenge: Assuming that Israel wants the principals and the teachers to educate and not just teach — and it seems to want that — how should it balance the need to have them as role models without Israel becoming a place that enforces uniformity? That is not an easy challenge, as parents and teachers in Ashkelon and Ramat Gan have just learned.

Can an Israeli teacher protest the IDF? Read More »