The Young Israel dilemma: Disengagement or confrontation?
Few constitutional concepts are more firmly entrenched in the American consciousness than the separation of church and state. However, this long-standing notion — that law and religion make improper bedfellows — might seem at odds with the recent controversy over allegations that the National Council of Young Israel threatened to seize assets of a branch synagogue for failure to comply with disputed religious doctrine. That the National Council could, under some circumstances, seize such assets is true. But whether the National Council — or any Jewish organization — should use threats of asset seizure to ensure conformity with controversial conceptions of Jewish law is a very different story.