President Biden spoke to Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu yesterday, ending the first manufactured crisis in U.S.-Israel relations, as the Israeli and Jewish press were abuzz with the question “why hasn’t Biden called?” I have no idea why President Biden waited to call Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu until the 28th day of his administration. But I can think of nine good reasons why he may have taken his time. Readers of this piece are likely to think of a few more.
The prime minister is in the middle of an election campaign. Anything that is said by Biden will be used by the prime minister to advance his own campaign and not necessarily to advance the interests of Israel. In previous campaigns, for example, Bibi has used his relationship with then President Trump to advance the notion that he was indispensable to the U.S.-Israel relationship.
The prime minister has hired a Steve Bannon protégé, Aaron Klein of Breitbart News, to run his campaign. Anything said by President Biden on that call may be spun to undercut the president.
Netanyahu is on trial for corruption. The call could be interpreted as the president’s personal support for Netanyahu and not only as a call between a U.S. president and Israeli prime minister.
Prime Minister Netanyahu took his time in calling President-elect Biden to congratulate him on his victory at a November 17 news conference. That is to say, for two weeks after the election, Bibi deliberately avoided calling Biden as president-elect.
The prime minister supported President Trump for reelection, openly and directly, unequivocally. Netanyahu also allied himself with a Republican Congress to undermine then President Barack Obama, addressing a Joint Session of Congress attacking the Iran deal and agreeing to come to the United States at the initiative of the Republican speaker of the House and his own ambassador, a former Republican operative, without first informing the president. These actions alienated Democrats in Congress, the president and then Vice President Biden, making support for Israel a partisan issue.
The first time Biden visited Jerusalem as vice president in 2010, he had a long and friendly dinner with “his old friend” Netanyahu, only to find out when he got back to his hotel that Israel’s Interior Minister had announced a new building program in East Jerusalem, a deliberate and politically embarrassing culmination to a long and leisurely dinner.
Nothing is wrong with the U.S.-Israel relationship now. There are no crises and no difficulties. Foreign aid is going forward, military and intelligence cooperation is ongoing, the embassy will not leave Jerusalem and the Abraham Accords are going forward — albeit with less support for quid pro quos. Biden well knows of Netanyahu’s reservations about the Iran deal, and he factored that into his support for reentering the agreement.
The President’s domestic agenda is full — COVID-19 Relief, vaccine distribution, economic recovery, social justice, climate change, immigration, infrastructure initiatives. Foreign policy is not his primary or even secondary concern at this point in time.
Despite the prime minister’s support for President Trump’s reelection, between 70 and 75% of American Jews voted for Biden. That percentage may have increased if the election was held after the January 6 storming of the Capitol, Trump’s support for Marjorie Taylor Green and the Republicans’ refusal to ban her from serving on committees. Since Biden is naturally pro-Israel in orientation, he is unlikely to lose Jewish support at home if he takes his time in calling the prime minister.
It is remarkable to see how insecure our Israeli brethren are that the delay of a call has become an issue at home. One wonders if it makes them feel abandoned, neglected, unappreciated. We all can recall the fuss that was made when President Obama visited Egypt but not Israel on his first trip to the Middle East. According to Obama’s memoir, he did so at the request of the Israeli government, who then interpreted it as a snub. After all, Biden only called China last week. The U.S.-Israel relationship is on solid ground. I sleep far less comfortably worrying about the domestic issues dividing Israelis from another — four elections in two years is not reassuring — and the polarization of the American populace.
Michael Berenbaum is director of the Sigi Ziering Institute and a professor of Jewish Studies at American Jewish University.
Editor’s note: Shortly after this piece was published, Biden called Bibi. The piece has been changed to reflect that event.
The collective assault against Israel has gone so broad and deep this past year it’s been hard finding anyone in the mainstream press who will dare criticize the Hamas murderers who massacred 1,200 innocent souls on Oct. 7, 2023.
Clinical trial statistics tell us where investigational drugs are tested. They do not tell us who owns the assets, who uses the evidence to obtain regulatory approvals or who captures the economic value when those drugs succeed.
While it’s normal to bemoan the hate that comes our way, let’s be grateful that we’re not the ones doing the hating; that we’re not allowing hate to corrode our souls; that we still have the power and the wisdom to be happy.
In standing up to Macklemore and declaring, “I was born a Jew,” Pink did something painfully rare in today’s entertainment world: she refused to abandon her people when supporting Jews became unfashionable.
The 9/11 families who asked him to stay away were not judging his beliefs about G-d. They were responding to what he has said, whom he has hired and endorsed and whom he chooses to associate with.
Opportunities include internships in biomedical research, engineering and 3D printing, high-tech, investment banking, communications, government and nonprofits, and marine life and zoology.
The United States once attached “Never Forget” as a catchphrase of post-9/11 memory. Its people, however, are now fast forgetting, flirting instead with the descendants and sympathizers of those who flew those planes.
This is a season when we think about obligations and about what we owe one another. Here is a communal obligation, arvut hadadit, that we can actually meet.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.
Nine Reasons Why Biden May Not Have Called Bibi Until Now
Michael Berenbaum
President Biden spoke to Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu yesterday, ending the first manufactured crisis in U.S.-Israel relations, as the Israeli and Jewish press were abuzz with the question “why hasn’t Biden called?” I have no idea why President Biden waited to call Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu until the 28th day of his administration. But I can think of nine good reasons why he may have taken his time. Readers of this piece are likely to think of a few more.
It is remarkable to see how insecure our Israeli brethren are that the delay of a call has become an issue at home. One wonders if it makes them feel abandoned, neglected, unappreciated. We all can recall the fuss that was made when President Obama visited Egypt but not Israel on his first trip to the Middle East. According to Obama’s memoir, he did so at the request of the Israeli government, who then interpreted it as a snub. After all, Biden only called China last week. The U.S.-Israel relationship is on solid ground. I sleep far less comfortably worrying about the domestic issues dividing Israelis from another — four elections in two years is not reassuring — and the polarization of the American populace.
Michael Berenbaum is director of the Sigi Ziering Institute and a professor of Jewish Studies at American Jewish University.
Editor’s note: Shortly after this piece was published, Biden called Bibi. The piece has been changed to reflect that event.
Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.
Editor's Picks
Israel and the Internet Wars – A Professional Social Media Review
The Invisible Student: A Tale of Homelessness at UCLA and USC
What Ever Happened to the LA Times?
Who Are the Jews On Joe Biden’s Cabinet?
You’re Not a Bad Jewish Mom If Your Kid Wants Santa Claus to Come to Your House
No Labels: The Group Fighting for the Political Center
Latest Articles
Jason Arday, Donald Trump, and the Post-Truth World
How Yom Kippur’s Afternoon Prophet Inspires America
Knowing Our History
Macklemore Dropped from Ed Sheeran Tour After ‘Free Palestine’ Remarks at MetLife Stadium
Noah Wyle, Rob Reiner, and the Jewish Winners at the 78th Emmys
Rosner’s Domain | Choosing the Next Government
The Essay of the Year
The collective assault against Israel has gone so broad and deep this past year it’s been hard finding anyone in the mainstream press who will dare criticize the Hamas murderers who massacred 1,200 innocent souls on Oct. 7, 2023.
More Time to Dream
Israel’s Clinical Trial Illusion: Testing Drugs Is Not the Same as Capturing Economic Value
Clinical trial statistics tell us where investigational drugs are tested. They do not tell us who owns the assets, who uses the evidence to obtain regulatory approvals or who captures the economic value when those drugs succeed.
Iran’s Mandatory Hijab Is its Achilles’ Heel
A government can force a woman to cover her hair. It cannot force loyalty.
Yom Kippuring
We are all trying, in our own imperfect ways, to find an entrance into a better self.
Embracing Paradox
Grappling with the seemingly inexplicable is something to keep in mind as we resolve to improve ourselves in the days ahead.
When Eleven Jurors Agree — and One Does Not
The law demanded unanimity. An ancient Jewish court might have taught us to be suspicious of it.
Why Do I Write?
Yizkor This Year for Me Is Like Never Before
This year on Yom Kippur, I will stand for Yizkor, and I will say my mother’s name, for the first time.
A New Way to Look at Hate
While it’s normal to bemoan the hate that comes our way, let’s be grateful that we’re not the ones doing the hating; that we’re not allowing hate to corrode our souls; that we still have the power and the wisdom to be happy.
The New Dividing Lines in Israeli Politics
Bibi-ism has been the nation’s dominant philosophy for a generation. That may be about to change.
VBS Community Rallies After Fatal Crash During High Holiday Services
The two-vehicle collision occurred Saturday morning at the intersection of Ventura Boulevard and Densmore Avenue, where VBS is located.
Pink Found Her Courage When the Music Industry Lost Its Spine
In standing up to Macklemore and declaring, “I was born a Jew,” Pink did something painfully rare in today’s entertainment world: she refused to abandon her people when supporting Jews became unfashionable.
The 9/11 Families’ Case Against Mamdani Never Needed His Faith
The 9/11 families who asked him to stay away were not judging his beliefs about G-d. They were responding to what he has said, whom he has hired and endorsed and whom he chooses to associate with.
Tennis, Neilah at 3 a.m.
Neilah means “closing.” It’s the fifth and final prayer of Yom Kippur, the one no other day of the year has.
High Schoolers Spend Summer in Israel with NCSY/JSU’s Next Step Internships
Opportunities include internships in biomedical research, engineering and 3D printing, high-tech, investment banking, communications, government and nonprofits, and marine life and zoology.
Requiem for 9/11
The United States once attached “Never Forget” as a catchphrase of post-9/11 memory. Its people, however, are now fast forgetting, flirting instead with the descendants and sympathizers of those who flew those planes.
On the First Night of Rosh Hashanah, We Remember Shabbat
Have you noticed that we’re hearing “Shana Tova” a lot more than “Shabbat Shalom”?
Chosen Links by Boaz – Ep 19 | 9/11: Remembrance and Resilience, 25 Years Later (Part Two)
If episode one was the brain of this two-part 9/11 series, episode two is the heart.
Let’s Create Real Support for Our Nation’s Jewish College Students
This is a season when we think about obligations and about what we owe one another. Here is a communal obligation, arvut hadadit, that we can actually meet.
More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.