fbpx

Should ‘Irvine 11’ be prosecuted for disrupting Israel ambassador?

[additional-authors]
March 16, 2011

” title=”protested their prosecution” target=”_blank”>protested their prosecution and attorneys for the Muslim students ” title=”disrupting a speech at UCI by Israel’s ambassador” target=”_blank”>disrupting a speech at UCI by Israel’s ambassador to the United States, Michael Oren. UCI is ” title=”ugliest anti-Israel rhetoric” target=”_blank”>ugliest anti-Israel rhetoric on American college campuses, and the Irvine 11’s behavior at Oren’s speech ” title=”suspending the Muslim Student Union” target=”_blank”>suspending the Muslim Student Union after the Oren outburst. As ” title=”reports” target=”_blank”>reports:

The students “are passionate; they are caring and deeply believe in social justice,” said Arif Shaikh, who moderated a Saturday night panel at the Islamic Institute of Orange County, where religious leaders and political activists called on Dist. Atty. Tony Rackauckas to drop the charges.

(skip)

“Protests like this happen all around the country,” said Reem Salahi, a Pasadena lawyer representing the 11 men who at the time ranged in age from 19 to 23. “The O.C. district attorney has engaged in a witch hunt … with its highly selective and unwarranted criminal charges.”

The students have won support from UCI faculty, free-speech advocates, Muslim leaders and a liberal Jewish group. But other Jewish organizations, including the prominent Simon Wiesenthal Center in Los Angeles, have denounced the students’ actions, saying they infringed on the rights of those who came to hear Oren speak.

The LAT doesn’t address it, but the statement from Shaikh presumes that there was something righteous about what these students were protesting, which in turn presumes things about the state of Israel. There are arguments both ways, of course, but for some reason the reporter felt it appropriate to just take as gospel the Israel-is-bad perspective.

As for the charges, like I said, I’m on the fence. Anyone compelled to nudge me?

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Editor's Picks

A Night of Gratitude Honoring Dennis Prager

Latest Articles

The View from Israel

Three years after Oct. 7, Israel is still waiting for a full accounting of what went wrong.

Remember and Be Grateful

Memory is the mother of gratitude. If we do not remember our past, it is difficult to improve our present or build a better future.

From Atop the Pulpit

New opportunities and challenges have always come and gone. But pulpit clergy with their years of training, education and perspective on life, generated from atop the pulpit, are especially well suited for whatever lies ahead.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.