fbpx

May 25, 2017

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FOURTH CIRCUIT affirms the preliminary injunction blocking President Trump’s Muslim Ban

I am one of many Amici Supporting Appellees who signed onto the 4th Circuit Court of Appeals case against President Trump’s ban against immigrants from the six Muslim countries, and I’m delighted by Judge Thacker’s concurring opinion that Trump’s and the government’s reasoning to apply a ban on Muslims coming from the six banned countries “has not met the criteria it claims it used, and the reason seems obvious — and inappropriate.”

The relevant passage from Judge Thacker’s opinion appears on p. 137-138 of his argument, as follows:

The Government’s untenable position is made even worse by the fact that the Government’s purported justification for EO-2 does not logically support the ban it created. EO-2 reasoned that people coming from the six banned countries posed an increased risk of committing terrorist acts because, according to the Department of State’s Country Reports on Terrorism 2015 (the “Country Reports”), “each of these countries is a state sponsor of terrorism, has been significantly compromised by terrorist organizations, or contains active conflict zones,” and were unwilling or unable “to share or validate important information about individuals seeking to travel to the United States.” EO-2, § 1(d); see § 1(e) (citing Country Reports). However, given these conditions as the reason for the ban, and based on the Country Reports, two other majority Christian countries — Venezuela and the Philippines — should have logically been included. See U.S. Dep’t of State, Bureau of Counterterrorism and Countering Violent Extremism, Country Reports on Terrorism 2015 78–85, 297–98, 308–09, 314–15, 352, 380 (June 2016), https://www.state.gov/documents/organization/258249.pdf (excerpts saved as ECF opinion attachment). Neither country is willing and able to help the Government verify information about people attempting to travel to the United States, and both countries have terrorist organizations operating within their boundaries.  Therefore, applying the Government’s logic, the potential of a terrorist act from a national of Venezuela or the Philippines would also justify a blanket ban on all nationals from these countries. Interestingly, however, the CIA World Factbook reports that Venezuelan population is, at most, 2% Muslim, and the Philippine population is 5% Muslim. See Cent. Intelligence Agency, Field Listings: Religions, World Factbook, https://www.cia.gov/library/publications/the-world-factbook/fields/2122.html (last visited May 23, 2017) (saved as ECF opinion attachment). Thus, the Government has not consistently applied the criteria it claims it used, and the reason seems obvious — and inappropriate.

A victory for justice and the first amendment!

 

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS FOR THE FOURTH CIRCUIT affirms the preliminary injunction blocking President Trump’s Muslim Ban Read More »

Lieberman said Israel tweaked intel-sharing after Trump revelations to Russians

Israel’s defense minister said Israel had made changes to how it shares intelligence with the United States in the wake of President Donald Trump’s revelation of highly classified information to Russian officials.

Avigdor Lieberman told Army Radio on Wednesday that the change would not affect the close U.S,.-Israel intelligence sharing relationship.

“I can confirm that we did a spot repair and that there’s unprecedented intelligence cooperation with the United States,” Lieberman said, according to a Voice of America report.

“What we had to clarify with our friends in the United States, we did,” said Lieberman, who would not elaborate. “We did our checks.”

Trump in a meeting with the Russian foreign minister and ambassador to the United States earlier this month described in detail information that led the United States to conclude that the Islamic State terrorist group was planning to attack an aircraft with a laptop bomb.

He did not describe sources, but the detail could lead the Russians to learn who had provided then information and could identify the spy who infiltrated the group, according to reports.

Some reports said Israel had shared the information with Trump.

Britain also reassessed its intelligence sharing after U.S. media published details about this week’s deadly bomb attack on a pop concert in Manchester. Trump ordered an investigation into those leaks.

Lieberman said Israel tweaked intel-sharing after Trump revelations to Russians Read More »

Fran Drescher

Fran Drescher: Flushing’s funny lady finds her voice

Just about every word and sound that’s dropped out of Fran Drescher’s mouth over the last quarter century has made me laugh, but nothing could compare to her description of the “Flamingo Beach Club”, located in Queens, NY.  “There were no flamingos”, she once said, “and no beach.  It was a pool in a concrete slab in the middle of Flushing”.

Like Drescher, I’m a Flushing native, and a fellow alumnus of both the Flamingo Beach Club and Queens College of the City University of New York.  Our paths never crossed, however, until earlier this month, when she received a Lifetime Achievement Award at the Queens College annual fundraising dinner.  Although best-known for her 1990s hit TV sitcom The Nanny, which she created, starred in, and executive produced, Drescher has since gained a reputation as a tireless crusader for cancer awareness, LGBT rights, arts and education funding, and the environment.

Drescher made her big screen debut in a scene with John Travolta in 1977’s Saturday Night Fever, but it was her small screen role as the Jewish nanny Fran Fine from Flushing that made many Americans sit up and take notice. Others, presumably, just covered their ears. Drescher’s nasal, Noo Yawk-accented foghorn of a voice, along with a laugh that sounds like a machine gun snorting, must have come as a shock to viewers in, say, Fargo, North Dakota.

“But I figured out how to monetize this voice”, Drescher noted proudly in a conversation before the fundraising dinner.  “And I kinda put Flushing on the map with The Nanny.  Before that, people were a little embarrassed to admit it. Then they started coming up to me on the street, saying, ‘I’m from Flushing’, and we’d high five each other!”

Drescher also was the first Jewish woman to play an outwardly Jewish character on television in decades, for which she was honored at Israel’s Knesset by Prime Minister Netanyahu.  One episode of The Nanny even featured Miss Fine taking the family she worked for to the kibbutz where she’d volunteered as a teenager.  Another storyline showed Fine falling for a Professor Goldberg.  And, incredibly, Ray Charles once appeared on the sitcom and sang “My Yiddishe Mama” to Fran’s grandmother Yetta.

Drescher’s college tenure was short but enjoyable.  “I loved learning.  I loved history”, she recalled, “and I loved the view of Manhattan, because I already had dreams of going there as an aspiring actress”.   Given that she left the university after a year, I had to ask which had a greater impact on her life:  going to college, or to the Flamingo Beach Club?

Drescher exploded in that unmistakable laugh.  “Let’s see.  At the age I went to Flamingo, I was just starting to have an interest in boys, turning from a child into a young lady.  So it was a very significant time, I would have to say a more transitional stage in my life”.

The now-59-year-old actress married her high school sweetheart Peter Marc Jacobson in 1978; he co-created, wrote and produced The Nanny with her.  They divorced in 1999, after which he revealed he was gay.  “I was always a gay icon to my Nanny fans”, Drescher told the dinner crowd, “but Peter’s coming out moved me up to Judy Garland status!”   The two remain good friends, and Drescher has been honored with several awards for her LGBT-related advocacy.

In 2000, Drescher was told she had uterine cancer, following two years of misdiagnoses.  Surgery saved her life, and after writing a book about the experience called Cancer Schmancer, she formed a non-profit organization with that name.  Washingtonian magazine listed her among the country’s top five celebrity lobbyists, writing “She’s been a prime mover behind passage of cancer-awareness legislation”.

It’s obvious that Drescher is passionate about early screenings and patients’ rights.  “We’re a very uplifting, motivating, educating, fun organization.  We empower people.  We transform patients into medical consumers”.

Drescher continues to “work in show business to stay current”, so she can get attention for the causes in which she believes.  She advises young people to “Figure out what makes your heart sing, and then figure out how to make a living at it”.

What’s next for a still-youthful woman who’s achieved virtually every goal she’s set for herself?  Fran Drescher, who once gazed at Manhattan and dreamed of the future from her college window, says she continues to learn.  “I’m on a journey of self-refinement, and becoming connected to my soul, as much as possible.  I walk through life like I’m in the biggest classroom ever.”


For more information on Cancer Schmancer and upcoming events, go to www.cancerschmancer.org

Fran Drescher: Flushing’s funny lady finds her voice Read More »

Hecklers shout ‘Heil Hitler!’ during Jewish school’s Holocaust play

Teenage hecklers interrupted a South African Jewish school’s performance of a play about the Holocaust with chants of “Heil Hitler!” and other anti-Semitic taunts.

Middle-school children from the King David Victory Park School were performing “The Boy in the Striped Pajamas” on May 18 as part of a one-act play festival at Waterstone College, a private K-12 school in Johannesburg. While they were performing the story of a Jewish boy who perished in a concentration camp, teenagers in the audience from another high school began to taunt them.

“They were chanting ‘Heil Hitler, Heil Hitler.’ I was shocked and disgusted. I couldn’t believe what I was hearing, “Alic Gluch, a 14-year-old King David student, told theSouth African Jewish Report.

The teenagers continued to taunt the Jewish students, their teachers and parents as they retreated to the dressing rooms and packed up early to leave.

Witnesses said the ringleaders were students from Edenvale High School, which was also participating in the festival.

Renos Spanoudes, who heads the drama department and arts and culture at King David, said in a WhatsApp message that an Edenvale High teacher downplayed the seriousness of the incident, while some of the Edenvale students said they were ” very, very sorry.”

Wendy Kahn, national director of the South African Jewish Board of Deputies, said her group was seeking a meeting with the the principal of Edenvale High “to address this issue and determine a constructive way forward.”

“From time to time anti-Semitic incidents of this nature occur during interschool events, both in the cultural and sporting arenas,” she told the Jewish Report. “We have in the past been involved in addressing these incidents. We do not believe that this is an indication of an upsurge in anti-Semitism. ”

The headmaster of Edenvale High did not respond to the Jewish Report’s requests for comment.

Hecklers shout ‘Heil Hitler!’ during Jewish school’s Holocaust play Read More »

Senate panel passes new sanctions on Iran’s missiles

A key Senate committee approved new sanctions on Iran’s ballistic missiles program after amending clauses that critics said could scuttle the Iran nuclear deal.

On Wednesday, the Senate Foreign Relations Committee approved the bill 18-3. It was backed by the committee’s two leaders, Sen. Bob Corker, R-Tenn., the chairman, and Sen. Ben Cardin, D-Md., its top Democrat. Another sponsor was Sen. Robert Menendez, D-N.J., a leader in efforts to sanction Iran.

Backers insisted that the bill would not affect the 2015 deal struck by the Obama administration trading sanctions relief for rollbacks in Iran’s nuclear program. That deal did not include missile sanctions.

However, parts of the text were amended after Adam Szubin, the top Obama administration official handling sanctions, warned that they could be interpreted as violating the deal.

Szubin in a May 12 letter first obtained by the Huffington Post warned the committee that the legislation as then written would “provoke a terrible reaction in Iran and with our allies, as it would be seen as contrary to at least the spirit of the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action,” the formal name for the deal.

The United States forged the deal by exerting pressure on Iran through a sanctions regime built in collaboration with allies and major powers.

Szubin, who is respected by both parties, maintained tough non-nuclear sanctions on Iran after the deal was in place.

Subsequently, language was removed that would have sanctioned individuals and entities who “pose a risk” of materially contributing to the missile program, an ambit that critics said was too broad. The language now sanctions those who have already “materially contributed” to the program.

The American Israel Public Affairs Committee praised the bill’s advancement.

“This bill is directed only at actions outside the nuclear sphere — in no way does it violate the letter or spirit of the 2015 nuclear deal,” the prominent Israel lobby said in a statement. “AIPAC urges the full Senate to adopt this critical, bipartisan legislation.”

The bill’s consideration comes as Iran reportedly has built a third underground factory to manufacture ballistic missiles.

J Street in a statement praised the committee for amending the language but said the bill could still do more harm than good, noting the victory in Iranian elections this weekend of the relatively moderate incumbent president, Hassan Rouhani.

“While the elections were highly constrained, their outcome was significant,” the liberal pro-Israel group said. “They provided a new mandate of support for the president who secured the JCPOA, has criticized anti-American rhetoric and has expressed openness to further diplomatic engagement. In this context, Senators should weigh the merits of passing largely symbolic legislation to achieve objectives that might be better met through future negotiations.”

The Trump administration has ratcheted up rhetoric against the Iranian regime and said it is reviewing the terms of the nuclear deal. President Donald Trump while campaigning sharply criticized the deal, but unlike other Republican candidates stopped short of saying he would scuttle it.

Steven Mnuchin, the Treasury secretary, told Congress this week that he was reviewing contracts arising out of the deal that allowed U.S. aircraft manufacturers to sell their products to Iran.

“We will use everything within our power to put additional sanctions on Iran, Syria and North Korea to protect American lives,” Mnuchin said Wednesday in testimony to the House Ways and Means Committee, Reuters reported. “I can assure you that’s a big focus of mine and I discuss it with the president.”

Senate panel passes new sanctions on Iran’s missiles Read More »

Survivor Tomas Kovar: Hiding in Slovakia, awaiting liberation

The Germans were coming.

Nine-year-old Tomas Kohn, then living as Tomas Blaho, knew the drill. He headed to the front door of the cottage in Ponicka Huta, a village in the Low Tatras mountains in central Slovakia, where he and his parents were living as the supposed cousins of the home’s owners, Alexander and Maria Kur.

As Tomas’ mother grabbed a jacket for her son — it was March 1945 and chilly — Tomas pushed open the door, only to discover three German soldiers already climbing the steep alley leading to their cottage. He couldn’t wait for his mother without arousing suspicion — even with false papers, the Jews in Ponicka Huta didn’t feel safe — and instead walked directly across the alley, disappearing into the forest.

“They didn’t say anything or follow me,” Tomas recalled.

As he walked deeper into the forest, Tomas frequently looked behind him hoping to see his mother. Several hours later, he was lost, certain the Germans had captured her and were lying in wait for him.

Eventually, Tomas came across a woodcutter, who led him back. As Tomas exited the forest, he dashed into the cottage. He didn’t see his mother anywhere.

During the war, Tomas didn’t realize the extent of the dangers he and his parents faced. “They didn’t talk about it. Not during the war and not after the war, either,” he said. Instead, his parents changed the family name to Kovar, a non-Jewish surname, and the family kept a low religious profile.

As he grew up, Tomas didn’t want to hear about the Holocaust, in which many of his aunts, uncles and cousins had perished, and spoke only rarely about his experiences until five years ago, when he attended a talk by another Slovakian survivor at the Los Angeles Museum of the Holocaust. Since then, he has told his story at the museum twice a month. “There are fewer and fewer survivors,” he said. “I want the people to know what happened.”

The only child of Ernest and Klara Kohn, Tomas was born on Feb. 18, 1936, in Nitra, Slovakia, the closest town with a hospital to the western Slovakian village of Zabokreky nad Nitrou, where his parents and 55 other Jewish families lived.

Ernest managed a large farm, which was owned by a Jewish man named Ernest Gruen. The family lived in Gruen’s unoccupied farmhouse.

Sometime in 1941 or so — about two years after Slovakia had declared its independence and allied itself with Nazi Germany — the farm was confiscated and given to a Mr. Kasicky (Tomas does not remember his first name), a private secretary of Jozef Tiso, a Catholic priest who had become Slovakia’s president. Kasicky retained Tomas’ father as the farm’s manager.

By spring 1942, as the Slovak government began deporting its Jewish population, only the Kohns and two other families of men whom Ernest needed on the farm remained in Zabokreky.

After the Slovak National Uprising broke out on Aug. 29, 1944, and German troops began occupying the country, Kasicky could no longer protect the three families. They immediately loaded up a large wagon with some food and household goods and followed the partisans, who were headed toward the mountains.

After reaching Banska Bystrica, a city in central Slovakia, they proceeded uphill to a flat mountaintop area. The partisans departed, and the families settled into separate huts used to store hay. Other Jews hid, scattered across the mountains.

About a week later, townsmen from Ponicka Huta appeared, looking for items the partisans had abandoned. Ernest asked one of the men, Alexander Kur, if he could pay him to hide the three families. Kur, whose cottage was small, left to consult with his brothers-in-law and returned before nightfall, leading the families to the village, already occupied by the Germans.

The Kurs gave their small bedroom to Tomas and his parents, sleeping in the large living room with their three children. The other families each bunked with a brother-in-law.

During this time, according to Tomas, the Germans conducted roundups two or three times a week. Only occasionally did the Jews, who were being harbored in almost all of the village’s approximately 25 houses, have advance warning.

At a moment’s notice, Tomas and his parents could move the living room carpet, where a trap door and a few steps led to a small, dank cellar, a tight fit for three people. With more time, they climbed into an armoire, escaping out a hole in the back into a storage room. But the safest shelter was the forest, directly across the alley. “The Germans shied away from it,” Tomas said.

At some point, possibly in early 1945, the Germans began rounding up the men of Ponicka Huta to dig trenches. The men, Jews and non-Jews, began spending their days in a bunker they had constructed in the forest, essentially a large dirt hole covered with boards.

By February, the roundups had increased, and the men began living full time in the forest bunker. Everyone was waiting for the Russians, “like for the Messiah,” Tomas said.

Ernest was in the bunker on the day Tomas escaped into the forest without his mother. And Klara, Tomas discovered, had been hiding in the cellar. She emerged, grateful that the Germans had not captured her son.

A few nights later, at midnight, Russian soldiers knocked on the Kurs’ door. “We don’t want to destroy this town,” a Hungarian-speaking soldier told Klara, who spoke the language, explaining that they needed to find the German trenches. Klara took the soldiers to the bunker, and Ernest led them to the trenches.

The following day, sometime in mid- to late March 1945, Ponicka Huta was liberated.

Soon after, the Kohns returned to Zabokreky, where Ernest again managed the farm for Ernest Gruen. Tomas enrolled in public school.

On Sept. 24, 1945, a pogrom broke out in Topolcany, about 60 miles southeast of Zabokreky, spreading across the country. “Wherever they could find Jews, they were beating them up,” Tomas said. He and his parents quickly left, returning later that day and deciding they needed to leave Slovakia.

Finally, in January 1947, they boarded a ship in France, headed for Chile, where they had relatives.

Ernest rented a farm in La Florida, an area southeast of Santiago. Tomas attended Jewish school, Instituto de Hebreo. A year later, he transferred to Escuela Nacional de Artes Graficas, a boarding school in Santiago, graduating in 1956. He began working in the meat market his father then owned in Santiago.

In summer 1960, Tomas met Rita Bromet, who had moved to Santiago after the May 22 earthquake in Valdivia. They married on Jan. 27, 1963. By then, Tomas managed his own meat market.

Their daughter Jacqueline was born in November 1963 and son Bernardo in April 1965. Eleven months later, the family immigrated to Los Angeles, and their son Desidario was born in April 1968. They now have six grandchildren.

In Los Angeles, Tomas first worked as a meat cutter for Gelson’s Markets. Then, after a series of jobs, he and Rita owned Hallmark stores from 1978 to 2000, when Tomas began working as a Spanish-English interpreter assisting workers’ compensation patients. He retired in 2015.

Tomas, now 81, is trying to donate a piece of his history, a Torah that belonged to the Zabokreky Jewish community and that was safeguarded by the town’s Catholic priest during the war, to the Los Angeles Museum of the Holocaust. Tomas’ family carried the Torah to Santiago, where it now resides in their former synagogue, La Sociedad Cultural Israelita B’nei Israel.

“It’s very old and will disintegrate,” Tomas said. “It should be in a museum where it could be more appreciated.”

Survivor Tomas Kovar: Hiding in Slovakia, awaiting liberation Read More »

Tillerson embraces Middle East linkage theory

Aboard Air Force One on Wednesday, Secretary of State Rex Tillerson appeared to embrace the linkage theory of Middle East peace, as he explained President Trump’s investment in relaunching direct talks between Israel and the Palestinians. “He was putting a lot of pressure on them that it was time to get to the table,” Tillerson told reporters referencing the meetings the President had with both Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas. “We solve the Israeli-Palestinian peace dilemma, we start solving a lot of the peace throughout the Middle East region,” he explained.

[This story originally appeared on jewishinsider.com]

While Tillerson did not fully explain his comments, the mere suggestion that solving the Israeli-Palestinian is key to solving the broader problems of the Middle East in challenging violent extremism is “nonsensical,” said Tamara Cofman Wittes, a Senior Fellow in the Center for Middle East policy at Brookings Institute. “I don’t see how resolving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict helps unwind the Syrian or Libyan civil wars, helps the Gulf states and Iran step back from a war in Yemen that is savaging the civilian population there, or helps defeat ISIS in Iraq or Syria or replace its rule with inclusive governance that will shut out extremists.”

Grant Rumley, an expert on Palestinian politics at the Foundation for Defense of Democracies (FDD), told Jewish Insider, “This type of language harkens back to the Bush administration era concept of ‘linkage,’ whereby solving the Israeli-Palestinian conflict would somehow unlock regional peace. I think time, and the Arab Spring, has largely debunked the idea that the Israeli-Palestinian conflict is somehow central to regional stability.”

At the same time, Rumley emphasized that there were some kernels of truth in Tillerson’s comments. “Certainly, one of the reasons the concept of an ‘outside-in’ approach has fallen out of favor with this White House is that Arab leaders have communicated their reticence to bring their covert relationships with Israel to light without advancement on the Palestinian front. So I do think there is a layer of truth here in that solving the ‘peace dilemma’ may give regional actors the ability to advance their relationships with Israel.”

Tillerson embraces Middle East linkage theory Read More »

Doctor Dermer makes his Jewish mom proud

In front of thousands of graduates, their family members and friends, gathered in the Madison Square Garden Theater on Thursday, Israel’s Ambassador to the U.S. Ron Dermer delivered the keynote address – his first commencement since his own graduation – at Yeshiva University’s 86th Commencement.

[This story originally appeared on jewishinsider.com]

“Doctor Dermer, Doctor Dermer. Finally, after all these years, my Jewish mother can be proud,” the American-born Israeli Ambassador said with a touch of pride in his voice after receiving YU’s honorary doctorate.

The Donald Trump connection: “When I was 15, I read a best-selling book by a very successful entrepreneur who had gone to the Wharton School of Business. I wanted to be an entrepreneur too so I decided to study there. But my life ended up taking a very different course. From an interest in business and finance, I became interested in public policy and politics, and later decided to move to Israel determined to serve my new country. The funny thing is, I just saw the author of that best-selling book in Israel and he lives not far from me in Washington. His book is called the ‘Art of the Deal’ and people call him President Donald Trump. I guess reading that book proved to be very useful after all.”

The Hillary Clinton connection: ‘While this degree from YU is not a first, this commencement speech is. Last time I attended a commencement was my own graduation from the University of Pennsylvania in 1993. The speaker that day was the new First Lady, Hillary Rodham Clinton. I don’t remember what she said, but I do remember how I felt.  I had no idea what I’d be doing the next year, let alone for the rest of my life.”

Doctor Dermer makes his Jewish mom proud Read More »

New Jewish group vows fight to uphold democratic principles

new group called Jews United for Democracy and Justice (JUDJ) held its first meeting on May 21, as nearly 500 people, most of them Jewish, filled the pews of Leo Baeck Temple’s sanctuary for a day of activism, with a focus on opposing the Trump administration’s proposed immigration restrictions.

The event, called “Building Bridges–Building Movements: A Los Angeles Activist Summit” drew a broad coalition of participants committed to upholding the principles of democracy, justice and equality.

“Jews know what it’s like to be strangers in a strange land,” Leo Baeck Rabbi Ken Chasen said in his opening remarks. “Such is mentioned in the Torah 36 times.” He reminded the group that Jews have been at the forefront of social justice and civil rights issues in the United States for decades.

Chasen then recounted the genesis of the organization: At a Super Bowl party in early February at the Beverlywood home of UCLA Jewish History professor David Myers, more attention was paid to politics than the big game.

President Donald Trump’s two-week-old travel ban proposal and the ensuing chaos at airports was still in the day’s headlines. Chasen said everyone at the party viewed the executive action as an affront to “our American values and our Jewish traditions,” and they agreed they needed to respond in a way that went beyond an airing of grievances.

“We lamented the lack of a convening presence for Los Angeles’ Jews to act collectively under fundamental values,” Chasen said. “We felt the urgency to create that presence.”

Less than a month later, guests from Myers’ party, including Chasen, wrote a founding statement and put it online. The statement quickly drew more than 2,300 signatories and JUDJ was born. (The full text can be found on JUDJ’s website at judjla.org/action.)

At the May 21 summit, featured speaker Rep. Karen Bass (D-Los Angeles) praised organizations like JUDJ for their support of local governments’ efforts to resist cooperation with the Trump administration’s new immigration and deportation policies.

“I’m hopeful that Jews United for Democracy and Justice will be at the forefront of the wave that changes the power provision and bends the arc back toward justice and freedom for all,” Bass said.

Following her address, California State Sen. Ben Allen (D-Santa Monica), who represents much of the Westside and the South Bay, moderated a lively panel discussion with Los Angeles City Attorney Mike Feuer, City Councilmember Marqueece Harris-Dawson, L.A. County Supervisors Sheila Kuehl and Hilda Solis, and L.A. Board of Police Commissioners Vice President Steve Soboroff. The conversation focused mainly on local police involvement with Trump’s deportation policies and the human narratives concerning deportation within the city’s Latino community.

Solis, who served as the nation’s first Latino Secretary of Labor under President Barack Obama, told the crowd that in parts of East Los Angeles, the San Gabriel Valley and other areas with large Latino populations, parents routinely avoid grocery shopping during the daytime, fearing deportation forces. She said parents in these communities are taking precautions, such as leaving emergency contact information on the refrigerator in case their children return from school to an empty house.

“These are real people,” Solis said. “All I’m telling you is this is what I see and what I hear every day. I hope that all of you would understand that we’re here to find a solution. It doesn’t matter how we get it. Every little bit can help. That’s all I’m asking you to do, to listen to those voices you might not hear today, but they’re out there.”

Following the speeches, attendees were invited to participate in small groups focused on such activities as community organizing and a Jewish response to the Syrian refugee crisis. Rabbis met in a session called “Justice Beyond the Bima” and lawyer Randy Schoenberg led a lawyers-only strategizing and training session.

Danielle Berrin, a Jewish Journal columnist and senior writer, led a session called “The Fourth Column: How a Free Press Changes Everything.”

Participating organizations included Bend the Arc, the Anti-Defamation League, Bet Tzedek, Jewish World Watch, the National Council of Jewish Women, the Interfaith Refugee Project and NewGround: A Muslim-Jewish Partnership for Change.

Allison Lee — who was at Myers’ Super Bowl party with her husband, Chasen, and who co-chaired the event and serves on JUDJ’s coalition committee — said she was impressed by the summit participants’ enthusiasm.

“To see so many Angelenos do a deeper dive, to understand how they can inform their own activism, to commit and recommit to the work is really rewarding and shows the tremendous need out there,” Lee said.

Hal Reichwald, 80, of Brentwood and a University Synagogue member, who participated in a session on a Jewish response to refugees, said he came to the event partly to stop throw-ing his shoe at the television.

“I think it’s a very good step to energize a group of people who perhaps have been on the sidelines a bit in the last eight years,” Reichwald said. “They see the need, they feel the need, and now they want to take the next steps to do something. I think this gives them a focus.”

New Jewish group vows fight to uphold democratic principles Read More »

BDS debate at UCLA breaks no new ground

campus debate on the Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions (BDS) movement on May 22 at UCLA offered little in the way of new ideas or understanding, as representatives on each side held to their well-established positions.

An audience of about 100 students and adults listened and made clear their sentiments — with cheers and boos — as professors Judea Pearl and Saree Makdisi were the featured speakers for their respective sides.

Both stated personal connections to their positions at the two-hour event, organized and moderated by the UCLA Debate Union.

Although the debate was devoid of references to President Donald Trump’s trip to Israel and lacked formal consequences for the BDS campaign at UCLA, it did provide a view into how American universities have become both training ground and battleground for advocacy on Middle East issues.

While Makdisi, who is of Palestinian descent, took most of the speaking time for the pro-BDS side, Pearl shared his time with Philippe Assouline, a doctoral student who teaches an Israeli history course at the university.

“Jewish students are being forced to choose between pride in their people — due pride — and acceptance on campus,” Assouline said in the anti-BDS side’s opening remarks.

Pearl, a computer-science professor and father of slain Wall Street Journal reporter Daniel Pearl called the BDS movement a “slander machine” with “small character,” and argued that its unwillingness to compromise impeded the peace process.

“Rejectionism is the main obstacle to the two-state solution,” Pearl said. “No country can come to life that seeks the elimination of its neighbors.”

The BDS movement originated in 2005 as a broad international boycott on Israeli products and has gained the most traction on American college campuses, particularly on University of California (UC) campuses. It has been a defining political issue at UCLA in recent years as student government elections have become a proxy war for supporters of Israel and Palestine beyond the school.

The movement aims to force Israel to accede to various demands for Palestinian human rights, including Israel’s withdrawal from West Bank settlements and the dismantling of the security barrier at the Green Line.

In November 2014, UCLA’s undergraduate student government became the fifth UC campus to pass a resolution in favor of BDS. The motion called for the school to divest any endowment funds from companies that do business with the Israeli government or military.

“BDS is moral because it’s a time-honored, effective and nonviolent method for people of goodwill to contest the injustice of states that have proven themselves unresponsive to other modes of persuasion,” said Makdisi, who teaches English literature. He presented a history of Palestinians’ expulsion from their homes in 1948 and asserted that Israeli leaders, anticipating the forthcoming refugee crisis, uprooted them anyway.

He also suggested that there is no such thing as an Israeli nationality, countering Pearl’s argument that Israelis and Palestinians are “equally indigenous” and therefore equally deserve statehood.

The debate provided an opportunity for new voices to join the fray. A pair of students on each side served as the undercards, displaying a range of experience and methodology as they laid the groundwork for the professors, who were given nine minutes each to the students’ seven.

There was plenty for the engaged but divided crowd to cheer and scoff at. The loudest reaction of the night was a chorus of long groans and derisive laughter as Makdisi asked in his closing argument, “You hear the language of, ‘Oh, my God, the Arabs will outnumber us,’ and ‘Oh, my God, the Jews will become a minority.’ What’s so bad about being a minority?”

The Debate Union’s faculty adviser, who was moderating the debate, asked for order to allow Makdisi to continue. 

BDS debate at UCLA breaks no new ground Read More »