fbpx

October 8, 2014

Take Back Our Rights!

The First Amendment to the Constitution of the United States says: “Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, or prohibiting the free exercise thereof.” Most States (and Commonwealths) have similar, even identical, provisions in their constitutions.

Yet, in a great number of the fifty States, statutes and regulations have been enacted and enforced that serve to limit the ability of the Chevrah Kadisha to provide the services that have long been a part of traditional Jewish practice. These State laws and regulations create a monopolistic control of Funerals through limitations on who may collect, transport, store, prepare, and bury bodies. The justifications stated cite considerations of health and public safety, but there is neither any basis nor any justification for these assertions, and licensure requirements do not actually address these issues.

Thus, the States take the right to follow traditional Jewish practices, and instead of the community, place other non-governmental organizations, such as an Association of Funeral Directors in that State, in the position to regulate and invoke enforcement of these matters. Such an association is comprised of members – those licensed to operate a business of Funeral Direction (sometimes called mortician or undertaker). This means that those who are in a position to gain by enforcing the regulations are empowered to do so, and the full weight of the power of the State backs them.

These associations in several states have and continue to seek to prevent Jewish communities and Congregations from following traditional practices, claiming that they are violating the State regulations concerning unauthorized practice of Funeral Direction, and pose a threat to public health. In some instances, the effort to prevent the Jewish community from following traditional practices has risen to the level of harassment.

A recent federal court case in Pennsylvania was settled. As a result, Chevrot Kadisha there can now conduct full Jewish funerals on a non profit basis.

It is time for this same battle to be joined in each State, and for the Jewish community to reclaim the right to offer members of the community this important mitzvah. I urge that federal court litigation be brought in each State. Attorney’s fees will be awarded to your lawyer, if you are successful.   So, law firms will be willing to undertake these cases and look to the Court for their attorney’s fees.  We can, and should reclaim our rights under the Constitution, and re-establish the role of the Chevrah Kadisha and the mitzvah of Taharah.


Rabbi Arthur Grae is a retired New York attorney who specialized in federal constitutional litigation. He now serves as the spiritual leader of a community in Florida. He is also a student of the  Rabbi & Mrs. Arthur Grae To find a list of of other blogs we think you may find to be of  interest, click on “About” to the right.


GAMLIEL INSTITUTE COURSE: Chevrah Kadisha – Origins & Evolution

We want to acquaint you with the work of the The “>Kavod v’Nichum (“Honor and Comfort”), the educational resource for Chevrah Kadisha groups throughout North America. Kavod v’Nichum provides a comprehensive website (The Gamliel Institute offers a program of online, interactive classes at an advanced level. 

The Gamliel Institute will be offering Course 1: Chevrah Kadisha – Origins and Evolution – to begin October 14, 2014. Course sessions will be on Tuesday evenings. This course is an in-depth study of the origins and history of the Chevrah Kadisha, the Holy Society that deals with the sacred tasks surrounding practical and ritual preparations of the deceased person for a Jewish funeral. The course further examines how the institution and role of the Chevrah Kadisha has evolved over the centuries and in different localities into the modern day.

Are you interested in taking this course? IT IS NOT TOO LATE!  If so, please be in touch with us with questions, or sign up for the course at We are looking for motivated students who want to engage in study of this subject matter and use it to make a difference in their communities.

We also want to enlist your help in finding others who would benefit from this course. Please pass this information along to anyone you think might be interested. Thank you! 

 


 

Kavod v'Nichum Conference!

Join us for an unforgettable time in beautiful Austin, Texas, Feb 22-24, 2015 for the 13th N. American Chevra Kadisha and Jewish Cemetery Conference. Regiser now! Visit the web page to register, reserve a hotel room, and to make your plans!

 

 


Take Back Our Rights! Read More »

Spaghetti Squash Primavera

What makes this particular spaghetti squash so unique is that the base is vegetarian, vegan, Paleo, gluten free, and all that other health nut stuff….. but the topping is 100% sensual, succulent Italian.

Ingredients:

for 2-4 people

  • one large spaghetti squash

  • 1 recipe of Simple Basic Tomato and Basil Sauce

  • Roasted Broccoli (see recipe)

  • Spring Peas and Onions (see recipe)

  • Olive oil

  • Pine Nuts

  • Freshly Grated Parmigiano Reggiano

 

Directions:

  1. Preheat oven to 375°F.

  2. Prick spaghetti squash with a knife.

  3. Place in oven for an hour or until soft-ish.

  4. In the meantime prepare other ingredients.

  5. Toast the pine nuts by placing them on a hot pan over medium heat. (Heat pan first for a few minutes) BE VERY CAREFUL: I tend to burn them regularly because I lose focus. Shake the pan every so often so they don’t burn and can toast on both sides. They will take about 5 minutes to become golden brown.

  6. Once squash is done, cut it in half.

  7. Remove the seeds with a spoon.

  8. Using a fork, scrape out squash insides so it forms “spaghetti” on a serving platter or individual plates.

  9. Drizzle with a little olive oil.

  10. Top with Tomato Sauce.

  11. Place a few spoonfuls of peas and onions.

  12. Place a few handfuls of roasted broccoli.

  13. Sprinkle a handful of toasted pine nuts.

  14. Top with freshly grated Parmigiano Reggiano.

 

If you want to learn more about cooking clean, delicious, and practical recipes I recommend signing up for my Mid-Holiday Detox Class.  “>MealandaSpiel.com for more great recipes and classes.

Spaghetti Squash Primavera Read More »

Building for a better future – check out the new student village in Sderot

Sukkot is all about houses, and having a sense of place, even when you’re far away from home. On this Sukkot, I am proud to tell you a story I recently heard, of a new form of housing that is currently forming in the Israeli city of Sderot:


After over a decade of living under constant rocket attacks from Gaza, the Israeli city of Sderot has become a place most people prefer supporting from afar. With many young people leaving and economy weakening, it became clear that something needs to be done in order to bring a drift of fresh air into the city. That’s when the *Ayalim foundation stepped in, with their most ambitious project so far – a student village at the heart of Sderot.

 

On August 10, during operation Protective Edge, the Prime Minister’s Office announced the establishment of Sderot’s new student village, at the cost 50 million shekels. The village will consist of 150 apartments built out of abandoned buildings and shipping containers for 300 students attending Sapir College there. In return for housing, the students will have to give 10 weekly hours of their time to volunteer in the local community. 

 

The project, a joint initiative of the Israeli government and Ayalim foundation, is aimed to strengthen the local economy, boost social welfare, and bring back young people to balance Sderot’s disproportionately elderly population following the many years of rockets raining down on the city. Later this month, the students will move to their new Sderot residence and give new hope to the beaten city, boosting it with youthful energy, while sending a strong message to those who seek to destroy our country: We will not break – we will build!

(A demonstration of the finished project. Courtesy of Ayalim)

 

In the past three months, 1,000 volunteers, including some of the students who are about to live there, “Shin Shin” (Shnat Sherut – National Service) teens and a group of Reform Rabbis from the U.S., participated in building the village. Standing strong in front of Hamas, they continued to build even as thousands of rockets were launched at the city.

 

One of the volunteers, 18 year old Livnat, told Israelife: “During the war, there was a feeling of pride, mostly. We worked under fire, literally, and even though Hamas tried to weaken us – the opposite happened. I was, and still am, proud to be here and build, sending a message that now terror organization can bring us down or tell us this country is not ours.”  Ido, another volunteer, told me he was a bit scared to be there during the war, but the feeling of satisfaction overcame the fear: “When the rocket-alert siren was heard, we ran to the shelters and it was a bit scary for all of us, but the goal was more important than anything else. We knew this village must be built, and we are still working hard in order to have it done by the end of the month.”

 

Effy Rubin, the Head of Partnership Development at Ayalim: “Even during the war, we stayed in Sderot and continued building. We are racing against time in order to open the village for students at the beginning of their school year, so we couldn’t allow ourselves putting down our tools. In less than four months we built an entire village, which is quite amazing. What made it happen was our volunteers’ work ethics and us seeing our goal in front of our eyes – bringing young, educated Israelis in our country’s less desired areas, helping them connect to the land and have a sense of place. We want to give those areas an energy boost from young people who would move there. We also believe that by taking part in building their place of residence and taking an active part in rebuilding the city and helping the community, they would want to continue living there, even after their school years are over.”

 

In the past 13 years, the people of Sderot spent their days and nights running for shelter, with only 15 seconds to run for shelter during the tseva adom “code red” rocket alert. Always restless, always alert. With the hopes that this time around the cease-fire agreement would last and with a positive view towards the future, Sderot Mayor Alon Davidi, said: “Founding a student village in Sderot is great news for the city. It is the first forward-looking step in our strategic plan to transform Sderot into a student city in addition to providing affordable housing for our young people, and of course to hundreds of students who study at Sapir College.”

 

“>here.

Building for a better future – check out the new student village in Sderot Read More »

Rosner’s Torah-Talk: Sukkot with Rabbi David Segal

Our guest this week is Rabbi David Segal, spiritual leader of the Aspen Jewish Congregation in Colorado. Rabbi Segal graduated from Princeton University with a BA in Classics and Jewish Studies. After graduation, he worked at the Religious Action Center of Reform Judaism in Washington, DC for two years. He was ordained in May 2010 by the Hebrew Union College-Jewish Institute of Religion in New York City. Rabbi Segal, an alumnus of the Wexner Fellowship program, serves on the board of the Aspen Homeless Shelter and the United Jewish Appeal-Aspen Valley. He also writes a monthly column for the Aspen Times and ocassionally blogs.

Our discussion focuses on the idea of Sukkot as the perfect epilogue to Yom Kippur and on the curious relation between the etrog and the story of the Garden of Eden.

 

 

Rosner’s Torah-Talk: Sukkot with Rabbi David Segal Read More »

Date Night with God: A Time of Joy.

“Why can’t you come to my basketball games?” My daughter’s tears were convincing, and more so at nine years of age.

As a physician, I am painfully aware of my limited time with my children.  I run the math. Ariel will be a preteen for twelve years.  Subtract the first couple of nonspeaking years, extract sleep time, remove school time, take away times that either one of us is “too busy” for the other- best case scenario, I will have a few months with her before she is abducted by aliens.

It’s not just me.  I hear it from all walks of life, those damning words “I just don’t have time for…”

Most couples, a few years into marriage, and after children, realize that they need “date nights” to refresh, reconnect, recharge, lest they drift apart. 

We need to create pockets of time, into which we step, out of the world, off the self-imposed treadmills.  To be sure, these are holy spaces we create, to receive love, to share love, to allow God to walk between our souls.

Shabbat is a pocket of time when we step out of the temporary and experience a taste of eternity.

Sukkot is a pocket of time and space where we build permanence out of the ephemeral.  As in the story of Noah, coming out of a sea of communal sins and having been pardoned by The Master of The Universe, we build a temporary arch, and decorate its pierced top with a rainbow made of fruits.  The promise remains the same:  Miracles are with us every day, if we make the time to sense them.

With our children, with our loved ones, even with strangers invited into the tent in the tradition of Abraham, we step into the tabernacles to share the joy of life.  In that pocket of time and space, under the stars, we experience “date night” with God.

The most elaborate castle is built on sand and will be washed away with waves; everything is temporary- except for our connections with one another and with God.

Though our flesh and blood is born with an expiration date, true love has no shelf life.  Permanence is built out of the ephemeral.

Wishing you a time of joy.

Date Night with God: A Time of Joy. Read More »

Excerpt from: “The Luminous Heart of Jonah S.”

That word, aabehroo, is one of those for which no equivalent exists in the English language. It alludes to the impression that others hold of an individual’s virtue and respectability. To have aabehroo means that the world regards a person in high esteem. To lose it — or, more literally, to have it leave the person — means he will live in shame unless he somehow manages to get his aabehroo back. You may be born with aabehroo because of your family history, but holding on to it requires a great deal of restraint and self-sacrifice. It means making sure you do everything in compliance with society’s idea of what is right, that you live honorably and protect the sanctity of your family’s name and reputation. It means being capable of feeling deep, personal shame before an exacting, infinitely multitudinous jury.

You have to have lived in a place like Iran, Leon thought, grown up with a strong sense of propriety and shame, and feared the judgment of others, in order to understand such a word. You certainly can’t imagine what it means, really, if you’ve lived most of your life in America. In this land of perpetual hope and endless good fortune, this country built on the promise of “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness”— where else in the world is happiness a right? — where even the dead look good and healthy, dressed up and painted and coiffed in the coffin as if on their wedding day, there’s no awareness, perhaps no need, nor would there be any tolerance, of that kind of sacrifice.

Leon could see how Kayla, born and raised in Los Angeles, might throw the word around so carelessly or deride her parents for being concerned with the judgment of others. If not for his own Iranian past, he might share Kayla’s scorn.

As it was, however, he had nothing but appreciation for this and other aspects of a culture that valued grace, harmony, and spiritual growth above all. Even this emphasis on aabehroo, while stifling if carried to an extreme, signaled the importance of individual righteousness to a society’s well-being. Raphael’s Son and his ilk were not representative of the Iranians Leon knew; they were unfortunate aberrations and as such, alas, stood out from the crowd. 

Copyright 2014 by Giina Nahai, reprinted by permission of Akashic Books.

Excerpt from: “The Luminous Heart of Jonah S.” Read More »

Home is where ‘The Luminous Heart of Jonah S.’ is

Gina B. Nahai’s new novel, “The Luminous Heart of Jonah S.” (Akashic Books) is a wildly inventive story of the Soleyman family that travels back and forth in time between 1950s Tehran and present-day Los Angeles. This Iranian Jewish clan was thriving in Iran before Ayatollah Khomeini decimated their world. Los Angeles has offered some of them safe haven, but it is still not home, and Nahai shows us their struggle with a continued disorientation. Her story focuses on a man she calls “Raphael’s Son,” who believes himself to be the rightful heir to the Soleyman name and fortune; although the family have all negated his claim. We learn of his mysterious and brutal murder in the opening pages of the book. Raphael’s Son had been living in Los Angeles for many years by now, partaking in one criminal exploit after another, and was generally feared and hated. When the police begin to investigate his murder, all kinds of secret alliances and past transgressions among the entire Soleyman family are revealed. Nahai shows us how often what we believe to be true isn’t.  

Her novel has an intoxicating and driving rhythm that pulls you right in, but sometimes her third-person narrative voice can seem distant. One senses she is holding back from revealing darker truths about some of her characters’ lives, almost as if she fears shaming them. The Soleyman family seems a sad lot, yet they are bound together by their desire to uphold their family name and reputation. They bear their grief and guilt stoically and privately, calling upon only their inner resilience for comfort.  

Nahai, 54, a Jewish Journal columnist, author, professor and mother of three, left Iran at 13 for boarding school and never returned. Her father’s foresight prompted the family to move to California several years before the Iranian revolution. She has written of her family as an outspoken bunch who often felt uncomfortable among their fellow Jews in Iran. Yet, Nahai seems to feel her abrupt departure from Iran traumatized her in ways she still hasn’t fully sorted out. Los Angeles has been a good home for her and her family, but it doesn’t offer her something she needs that she seems to believe she left back there. And home, even with its cruel misogyny and violence and palpable anti-Semitism, still seems, at least in part in her mind, to be Iran.  Some of her most moving descriptions in this novel show us characters who are still plagued by an intense sense of having been dislodged prematurely. They walk the broad and sunny streets of Los Angeles like ghosts — unseen by others, but, more scarily, also invisible to themselves.  

[Read an excerpt from 'The Luminous Heart of Jonah S.']

For example, the Iranian cop, Leon, who has been assigned to investigate Raphael’s Son’s murder, came to this country as a 14-year-old with the help of the Hebrew Immigrant Aid Society, which was trying to save him from being used as a minesweeper on the battlefront with Iraq. He was placed with a host family of Ashkenazi Jews who attempted to help him assimilate. They were surprised when he chose a career in law enforcement — unusual for an Iranian Jew. The pressures on Leon already were mounting. He needed to help his sister and mother and father, who had followed him to America in 1997, 13 years after Leon left Iran. Leon had once briefly harbored secret fantasies of becoming a crime writer, but the reality of his life had become engulfed by the pressure to take care of his family, who were completely dependent upon him.

Nahai describes for us in memorable prose the feelings of uselessness that are destroying Leon’s father, and in effect destroying Leon, too, as he was forced to be a daily witness to it. She writes, wistfully, “His father was one of the many thousands of Iranian men who had to choose between living in fear at home or running to safe obsolescence, between being alone in Iran because all their family had moved away, or moving to America to be with his son and, without a job, having to depend on him entirely. He woke up every day and dressed in a suit and tie even though he had nowhere to go. In the afternoon, he took the bus to the Orthodox Iranian shul that was held in a room on the second floor of a strip mall. Then he strolled down to the Persian grocery store on the ground level and spent half an hour selecting the slimmest, crispiest Persian cucumbers. … On his way home, Leon’s father sat in the rear of the bus and cried quietly for his wasted life and ravaged pride.”

We can feel this sense of psychological disintegration and muted yearnings in much of Nahai’s prose. The author herself has confessed in this newspaper that she, too, feels she “lost the country of [my] birth, the places of my childhood, the handprints of my ancestors on the landscape. … I lost the beauty of the land where history began, the glow of a sunlight that was older, more seasoned, more forgiving than what I’ve seen anywhere else. … I lost the colors of the costumes little girls wore to perform the ethnic dances, the faces of young boys who sat on rotting rowboats along the Caspian shore, the sound of the water crashing against smooth black rocks in the Karaj River, the rosewater scent of the first harvest of apples. I lost the ability to go back and see with my own eyes what I can only now revisit in memory.”

But Nahai does go back in her imagination and sometimes reaches transcendent heights, particularly in some of the passages that describe Jewish life in Tehran in the 1950s, when doors had just swung open that had been shut tight for centuries. We hear her restrained elegance and sorrow in her exquisite rendering of Aaron Soleyman, who has just been summoned back to Iran from studying abroad to take over the family business after his father’s sudden death: 

“The truth about Aaron Soleyman is that he was at once blessed and cursed by a birthright he would never be able to escape. You could see it in his eyes — this awareness of the heft of the responsibility he had to bear. He was the offspring of a wealthy Jew who had, thanks to the kindness of the shah and his own outsize abilities, risen overnight from the hardships and deprivations of the ghetto into a world of privilege and excess, who remembered the past too well and was determined never to go back, or even to pause long enough to catch a glimpse of where they came from and how far he had traveled. His father had given Aaron every financial advantage a young person could reasonably aspire to, but he had also charged him with the backbreaking task of fulfilling, in his own life, every lofty ideal and impossible expectation, every foolhardy dream and failed ambition of all the generations of Jews who had lived and died in all the ghettos and back alleys over three thousand years of history in Iran.”

Like her character Aaron Soleyman, Nahai feels this burden, too, and tries to explain to us what it really feels like to be forced to leave the land in which you were raised and then go and try to create something magical somewhere else. Yet she has done so by producing this beautiful book. 

Home is where ‘The Luminous Heart of Jonah S.’ is Read More »

Building a stable sukkah, building a stable L.A.

Many years ago, my wife and I lived in a ground-floor apartment in the Ocean Park section of Santa Monica, on a hill with a view of the bay.

When Sukkot came around, my wife naturally expected me to build the hut — the sukkah — in which Jews are commanded to eat, and even sleep, during the holiday. No problem, I thought — I’d watched every episode of “Gilligan’s Island,” and I even owned a hammer.

But I didn’t own a level. So, on the first night of Sukkot, we invited a group of friends into my homemade booth, a travesty of 2-by-4s, cinder blocks and PVC piping topped with bamboo and banana leaves. I made dinner — green corn tamales with black beans and crema — we all sat down to eat, and the sukkah collapsed.

Not completely, but it swayed so far left our view became a perfect trapezoid of horizon, and my friend Jim Morton suggested we grab the tamales and get the hell out. Jim is an architect.

Many rabbis will tell you the theme of Sukkot is the fragile, transitory nature of life and our ultimate dependence on something Greater Than Ourselves. All true.

But that evening I realized there is something else Sukkot is trying to teach us: how to build.

Maybe this lesson was self-evident to our desert-wandering ancestors, who could turn goats into goat-skin tents. But from the time we Jews decamped to the cities of Babylonia, Europe, Arabia and, eventually, America, it is something we’ve needed to remember. We are not here just to inhabit, but to construct, refurbish, improve. We are wanderers, yes, but wherever we arrive, we must also become builders.

This is especially true in Los Angeles, and it is especially incumbent upon us now.

I don’t know about you, but I look around the city and see the greatest momentum for progress I’ve seen in my lifetime.     

The major public-transportation initiative begun by former L.A. Mayor Antonio Villaraigosa is accelerating under Mayor Eric Garcetti. As much as its construction snarls traffic in the short term, I’m happy to finally see light-rail lines rising on the Westside, and plans for more rapid-bus lanes in the works.

Downtown is looking different, too. South Broadway has been redesigned to become more pedestrian-friendly, the first example in Garcetti’s “Great Streets” program. The late Ira Yellin’s vision for Grand Central Market as a hub of great food and urban life is coming to fruition under his widow Adele’s leadership.  

More importantly, Garcetti has spearheaded an ambitious multidepartmental, intergovernment project to reduce homelessness, beginning with L.A. County’s 6,400 homeless veterans. And I couldn’t have been prouder as an Angeleno than when the mayor committed Los Angeles to welcoming and housing the immigrant children detained after crossing the border from Mexico.

Meanwhile, the federal government just approved $1 billion for Los Angeles River restoration. As someone who has rafted a mile-long stretch of the river, I can tell you the waterway’s rebirth will bring business and recreational opportunity to the city in ways beyond our imagining.

There are bigger plans in the works, too, like the push to end L.A.’s dependence on imported water. Garcetti wants to cut our water imports in half by 2025, and as TreePeople’s Andy Lipkis and others have shown, it’s no pipe dream. There’s even a plan being developed at UCLA to make part of Westwood a showcase for driverless cars.

All these City Hall initiatives from above are being met by a new sense of urban activism from below. CicLAvia, which turns the streets of L.A. into bike- and pedestrian-friendly pathways several times a year, just wrapped up a hugely successful outing this past weekend. Neighbors in Santa Monica and Venice are on track to stop jets from flying in and out of Santa Monica Airport, residents near downtown have grand plans for a “freeway cap” that would create an urban park above the 101 freeway (and Grand Park in the city’s Civic Center itself is a new gift that the city is just beginning to enjoy). On Fairfax Avenue, young black entrepreneurs are revitalizing your bubbe’s storefronts as a center of urban design.  

Speaking at The Atlantic magazine’s CityLab 2014, which brought together more than 300 mayors from around the world to downtown last week, senior editor Richard Florida summed it up: “There’s something happening here. You can feel it.”

Not only can you feel it, you can take part in it. Beyond seeing these endeavors through, there are still huge challenges: fixing our education system, raising the minimum wage in a way that reduces inequality and protects entrepreneurship, bringing more local food to urban neighborhoods, addressing areas of hard-core unemployment and gang violence. At CityLab, developer Rick Caruso raised a pie-in-the-sky idea worth considering: What if business, philanthropy and government teamed up and focused all their efforts at once on a single neighborhood most in need?   

What if ? If there was ever a fruitful time to get involved in some way to help improve our city, now is it. Not all our labors will succeed, but as my first sukkah taught me, even when they don’t, you can still get a glimpse of the horizon.


Rob Eshman is publisher and editor-in-chief of TRIBE Media Corp./Jewish Journal. E-mail him at robe@jewishjournal.com. You can
follow him on Twitter @foodaism

Building a stable sukkah, building a stable L.A. Read More »

Hezbollah says border attack was message to Israel

An attack by Hezbollah on Lebanon's border with Israel which wounded two Israeli soldiers was a message that the group remained ready to confront its old foe despite its engagement in Syria's civil war, the group's deputy leader said.

The soldiers were wounded by a bomb planted by Lebanese Hezbollah fighters in the Shebaa hills, drawing Israeli artillery fire in response. It was the first time Hezbollah has claimed responsibility for an attack against the Israeli army since 2006, when the two sides fought a 33-day war.

“This is a message.. Even though we are busy in Syria and on the eastern front in Lebanon our eyes remain open and our resistance is ready to confront the Israeli enemy,” Sheikh Naim Qassem told Lebanese OTV television late on Tuesday.

Israel and Lebanon are technically at war but their 50-mile border has been largely quiet since the 2006 conflict.

Hezbollah members have been fighting alongside forces loyal to President Bashar al-Assad in Syria's civil war. The move by Hezbollah, which is backed by Shi'ite Iran, has helped turn the tide of the war in Syria against insurgents seeking to oust Assad.

The group said it took the decision to fight in Syria to prevent jihadi fighters, like those from Nusra Front and Islamic State which seized parts of Syria and Iraq, from advancing into Lebanon.

On Sunday, 10 of the group's fighters were killed during a battle with hundreds of Nusra Front militants on the border in eastern Lebanon.

Reporting by Laila Bassam; Editing by Mariam Karouny and Janet Lawrence

Hezbollah says border attack was message to Israel Read More »

A 100-year cease-fire

The Arab-Israeli conflict seems to be without end. All the “big powers” have tried to resolve it without much success and no party is willing to change its mind. The majority of Arabs would like Israel to cease to exist, and most Jews, whether they live in Israel or not, see Israel’s existence as existential. What can be done?

Inventing the future has been part of what I have been doing for the past 40 years, since I was a student of architecture. I call it “pragmatic idealism.” I shoot for the feasible best and work its development with a pencil in one hand and an eraser in the other. My approach to a solution for the Arab-Israeli conflict follows the same principle. The discovery unfolds. While navigating toward an objective, ideas arise that would not have developed without movement toward the goal. To do that, one needs time. In this case, given the present level of distrust, mutual grievances and hatred between the parties, it will take at least three generations.

The Agreement

Consider a 100-year ceasefire as a framework. It is critical to establish a number of goals to be worked out within it based on performance. Without that, effective negotiations are impossible. The agreement would be based on a reward-punishment method to be monitored and policed by a neutral third party, possibly composed of Supreme Court judges. For every year of effective ceasefire, the total of 100 years would be reduced by one year. For any year of ceasefire violation, the contract would be extended by one year. In other words, the agreement would be as short as 50 years and as long as 200 years, based on performance.

The territorial resolution would be regional and based on the concept of a condominium: a unit of common interest—water, security, and access—and individual sovereignties. The boundaries of such a condominium (perhaps called “Eastern Mediterranean Union”) would include present-day Israel, the West Bank, Jordan, Gaza, the Sinai Peninsula, and Lebanon. 

For the condominium model to succeed, it must be based on an agreed-upon “Education Charter” and a “Master Plan of Construction and Economic Development” to be adjusted periodically, taking into consideration changes in science and technology.

Education

The Education Charter would be mandatory for all members, separated from political, ideological and religious dogma, and geared toward scientific, technological, and artistic development. Distinctive cultural education, Arab and Jewish, would be inclusive of mutual knowledge and based on respect and tolerance of differences. 

Construction

Construction can be divided into three categories: 1. Interdependent, which shall include the use and development of water, energy, mobility, and industrial production, 2. Joint work on common-goal projects, and 3. International redevelopment, which may include a bullet train around the Mediterranean Sea, freeways linking Africa, the Persian Gulf, and Eastern Europe through the region, and the development of artificial islands accommodating millions of residents and inclusive of deep-water ports and international airports.

Two Precedents

One-hundred-year agreements are not common, but two precedents have been successful: the Panama Canal and Hong Kong. In 1904 the United States took over the canal project from France and it officially opened in 1914. The U.S. continued to control the Panama Canal Zone until 1977. After a period of joint American–Panamanian control, the canal was taken over by the Panamanian government in 1999.         

The transfer of sovereignty over Hong Kong from the United Kingdom to China took place in July 1997. It marked the expiration of British rule in Hong Kong at the termination of a 99-year lease agreed upon in 1898. The negotiation was long and complicated, but the agreement was executed.

Summary

Any solution to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict needs to address cultural, territorial, and economic differences. The road to real peace can go through a 100-year ceasefire marked by benchmarks of achievements that are rewarded or by violations that are punished. Ultimately, human interaction between former enemies can become the real glue of social, cultural, and economic development.         

Rick Meghiddo is a realtor on the Westside. He practiced architecture and urban design for four decades and produced over 30 architecture documentaries. In 1998 he headed the Technion’s delegation to the first (and only) urban design workshop for Israeli, Palestinian, and Italian architects in Palermo, Sicily. Born in Argentina, he lived in Rome for seven years and has divided most of his life between Los Angeles and Tel Aviv. 

A 100-year cease-fire Read More »