fbpx

September 15, 2014

Philly kosher butcher shop vandalized with swastikas

A kosher butcher shop in Philadelphia was defaced with anti-Semitic graffiti.

Crude swastikas were painted on the butcher shop, Simon’s Glatt Kosher meats, between the evening of Sept. 10 and the next morning, the Jewish Exponent reported. The butcher store has been at its location for 20 years.

A nearby synagogue was similarly vandalized in June.

There are no witnesses and no suspects in either case.

“The defacement of public property in Philadelphia with swastikas represents an attack on the entire community,” Anti-Defamation League associate regional director Joshua Cohen told the Jewish Exponent. “The swastika is a universal symbol of hate meant to instill fear and intimidation. It’s clear that the perpetrator intended to not only damage property but also to send a message of hate to the entire community.”

Philly kosher butcher shop vandalized with swastikas Read More »

I Want Your Sex: Haftarat Nitzavim, Isaiah 61:10-63:9

What does it mean to make love with God? Perhaps a strange question, but one that is demanded by this week’s Haftarah:

I greatly rejoice in the Lord,
My whole being exults in my God,
For He has clothed me with garments of triumph,
Wrapped me in a robe of victor,
Like a bridegroom adorned with a turban,
Like a bride bedecked with her finery.
For as the earth brings forth her growth
And a garden makes the seed shoot up,
So the Lord God will make
Victory and renown shoot up
In the presence of all the nations.

In case you didn’t get all the stuff about seed shooting into a garden, a few verses later, we read

[Y]ou shall be called, ‘I delight in her.’
And your land ‘Espoused.’
For the Lord takes delight in you,
And you land is espoused.
As a youth espouses a maiden,
Your sons shall espouse you;
And as a bridegroom rejoices over his bride,
So will your God rejoice over you.

Why do betrothal and sexuality serve as potent images of the relationship of humanity and God? It isn’t just here, of course: Rabbi Akiva famously argued that the very erotic Song of Songs comprises a metaphor of the love between God and Israel, and a large portion of the Zohar takes him up on it, extending and deepening the metaphor into something not exactly metaphorical.

But why? Even if we accept that God and Israel love each other, it’s not obvious that erotic love forms the best metaphor. Eros is a Greek word, but Christians use the Greek word agape to describe the love of God for humanity, and agape implies a sort of selfless, completely giving love, far from eros. Alternatively, one could use the notion of brotherly love, or philia, as the metaphor. God-as-brother or sister seems more plausible than God-as-bride or bridegroom. If anything does not seem to be sexual, it is the love between God and Israel.

One could just say that the Haftarah’s erotic symbolism simply reflects the prophet sublimating his own sexual desires. But that hardly serves as a good reference for the prophet or his prophecy.

Instead, recall the subjective experience of a bride or bridegroom. It is not simply love: it is being in love.  It is a heightened state; one’s “whole being exults.” Being in love most closely resembles not the mature love of long-time partners, but rather infatuation. As Thomas J. Tyrrell, the author of “>The Lonely Man of Faith, recognized the problem:

Companionship and friendship do not alleviate the passional experience of loneliness which trails me constantly. I am lonely because at times I feel rejected and thrust away by everybody, not excluding my most intimate friends, and the words of the Psalmist, ‘My father and my mother have forsaken me,’ ring quite often in my ears like the plaintive cooing of the turtledove. It is a strange, alas, absurd experience engendering sharp, enervating pain as well as a stimulating cathartic feeling.

Most fundamentally, eros subsumes sex because eros includes a feeling of ontological connection, a sense that here is some entity that truly understands me and I truly understand him or her. Our consciousnesses as well as our bodies mix: we can touch and communicate with each other in some sort of basic, unspoken inarticulate way that cannot be shared with anyone else.  When someone is in love with a requited lover, she is not thrust away.

Being in love carries with it something that “loving” someone does not, and also goes to mitigate ontological loneliness: a sense of possibility and a vision of a wondrous future.  Someone in love “exults” as he or she dreams of an extraordinary future existence, inchoate and ambiguous to be sure, but within the realm of possibility. Is it sexual? Of course. But it is more than that. Being in love means in being in hope.

Hope undermines loneliness because it holds the promise of participating in something bigger than ourselves. Participation with others in such a project means, in Soloveitchik’s words, finding “one’s place and role within the scheme of events and things willed and approved by God, when He ordered finitude to emerge out of infinity and the Universe, including man, to unfold itself.”

If that sounds vague and unclear, it should. What precisely happens there, what makes it a delight, what even is the feeling or consciousness of delight, what is the substantive content of this joy, remains Godot. That is what so much of falling in love is: a waiting and anticipation and joy feeling and envisioning a boundless future but not knowing precisely what it is.

The problem is that the human experience of falling in love and being in love cannot last. It fades, even if – especially if – the lover is united with his beloved. Erich Fromm, a well-known critic of eroticism, argues in “>Zen Mind, Beginner’s Mind: Informal Talks on Zen Meditation and Practice, by Shunryu Suzuki, who brought Zen practice to the United States.  What did he mean by beginner’s mind? Zen practice, Suzuki explained,

is to have a simple, pure mind, open to possibilities. Our normal mind congratulates itself for achieving certain things, but such self-centered thoughts prevent us from really learning and seeing. The beginner's mind goes beyond 'me' to the realization that it is just an expression of the larger universal Mind, and this naturally produces compassion.

The appearance of a new lover gives us a sort of Beginner’s Mind, open to the possibilities of, well, anything. With a new lover, we can explore the universal Mind, with another with Whom we can be infinitely, intimately close. Can we do this with a longtime lover? Of course. But wouldn’t it be extraordinary if we could have a Lover who is always there, who knows us so intimately, and yet is always new, for Whom we are always a beginner?

In sum, then, Haftarat Nitzavim and other Jewish sources eroticizing the Divine are not sublimating sexual desire; rather, they express erotic love’s most fundamental goal: an intimate connection with the Universal, a conviction that our lives have meaning, and that no matter where we find ourselves, we are never alone.

I Want Your Sex: Haftarat Nitzavim, Isaiah 61:10-63:9 Read More »

Marvelous Malaysia: Housesitting in Langkawi

While sitting in our guesthouse in Fortuna, Costa Rica last Fall, I was imagining our upcoming trip to Volcan Arenal when I found a housesitting assignment in Langkawi, Malaysia in the Caretakers Gazette. After nearly a year and a half on the road, staying in one place for three weeks sounded like heaven.  I wrote to Valerie and Donal, the homeowners, indicating my interest and all about past travels to Asia including a brief visit five years ago to Langkawi.

We recommend waiting for one or two posted jobs that pop out at you. Once you know you are interested in a particular assignment, use a standard prewritten letter listing your qualifications. When corresponding with homeowners, be sure to be professional, prompt and sincere. Be careful about what you place in your emails and your online profile; a recent book release entitled, “What Happens in Vegas, Stays Online!” is a reminder that digital memory is permanent. What would our first housesitting assignment be like? We received a photo of the owners but knew very little about the house and cats.

I was confident that it would all work out but looking back I realize that tips from two leading housesitting books would have helped clarify our job. Both books recommend attaining photos or a Skype tour of the property. The books also suggested ironing out all details in advance as part of an agreement letter or contract. Fortunately, Valerie and Donal were wonderful and treated us like special guests, even picking us up at the ferry and feeding us dinner before they departed. When their car broke down on our tour of the area, we were all concerned. Together we problem solved and organized a taxi and a tow truck. Valerie left us money for the car repairs and the phone number of her favorite taxi driver.

For the first ten days, we sat in the large garden and worked on our website, ” target=”_hplink”>YouTube channel. The cats were fairly independent but watering the sizeable garden was more work than we had originally imagined. We also raked the property, moving wheelbarrows full of leaves to the nearby dumpsite. We were surprised on December 31 when our idyllic retreat turned into a construction zone.

The glass patio table was covered in dust. The air was full of diesel fumes and the noise of chirping birds in the quiet village was replaced with roaring lorries and trackers. Since we took the assignment as a respite from constant travel and as a way to focus on reaching our website related goals, this was a calamity. It became difficult to enjoy the property and complete our work objectives.

After two days we figured out how to manage the situation but it was still not ideal. Remember that while traveling you must be flexible. We agree with the authors of the book, ” target=”_blank”>How to Become a House Sitter” is beautifully laid out; I enjoyed the landscape format and the design almost as much as the content. Traveling since 2009, they share how to make life on the road work out with housesitting as a main component. Their book is “an introduction to the wonderful world of house-sitting – for the aspiring house-sitter.” The chapter on things to consider will help you clarify all pertinent information prior to taking your next assignment. They share about profiles, interviews, contracts, communication and their personal experience. I plan to use their three-page checklist for any future housesitting assignments.

While in Langkawi, we enjoyed the beaches all around the island since the homeowners lent us their car. We also shared a New Year's Eve picnic with friends of the homeowners and made significant progress toward attaining our personal and professional goals while we relaxed in the three-bedroom garden home.

Marvelous Malaysia: Housesitting in Langkawi Read More »

Brussels Jewish Museum opens its doors four months after shooting

Four months after a shooting that killed four people, the Brussels Jewish Museum opened its doors to the public again on Sunday in a solemn ceremony attended by Belgian Prime Minister Elio Di Rupo.

The museum in central Brussels had been closed since the May 24 attack by a gunman who opened fire in the museum with a Kalashnikov rifle, killing an Israeli couple, a French woman and a Belgian man.

French national Mehdi Nemmouche is suspected of having carried out the attack after spending most of 2013 fighting inSyria with Islamist rebels, French prosecutors have said.

“We are fighting and will continue in our fight against terrorism,” Di Rupo said at the opening ceremony marked by tight security.

“Belgium has strengthened and will intensify further its European and international cooperation to combat more effectively the networks and individuals that threaten our democracies.”

Sunday's opening coincided with the European Day of Jewish Culture, and a new bronze plaque with the names of the four victims has been put up by the entrance hall.

The ceremony comes at a time when Western governments are increasingly worried about the flow of European citizens to Syria and Iraq to fight alongside Islamist militants, returning home radicalized.

Di Rupo reaffirmed his willingness to join the coalition of countries fighting Islamic State militants.

“The international situation is very worrying. If a request is made of us, I am supportive in this respect of our country taking part in the coalition of countries fighting Islamic State,” he said.

The United States has been seeking to galvanize Western and Middle Eastern governments to join it in fighting the extremist group in Iraq and Syria, which has shocked observers with its rapid advances and brutal methods.

Nemmouche is in custody in Belgium having been extradited from France in July.

A French journalist who was held hostage for months in Syria has said that Nemmouche was one of his captors.

Brussels Jewish Museum opens its doors four months after shooting Read More »

Israel falls to Argentina in relocated Davis Cup match

Israel lost in the Davis Cup to Argentina in a match that was moved from Tel Aviv to Florida due to the conflict with Hamas in Gaza.

Israel lost 3-2 after dropping the two singles’ matches on Sunday in Sunrise, Fla. Argentina, which was favored, will go on to vie for the 2015 Davis Cup. Israel will compete next year in the Davis Cup World Group II.

A day earlier, Israel had taken a 2-1 lead with a five-set victory by its doubles team, Andy Ram and Jonathan Erlich. Ram, a Uruguay native, was playing in his last professional match after announcing his retirement recently.

“The most successful double partners in the history of Israeli tennis made aliyah with their families and speak fluently in Spanish,” Erlich, who was born in Argentina, joked with a journalist from his native country, adding that he wasn’t sure which team his parents were backing.

Argentina’s Davis Cup team has two Jewish players who are active in the Jewish community: Martin Jaite, the team’s captain, and Diego Shvartzman, the youngest player on the team.

Jaite also had announced that he would retire from the team after the Israel match.

 

Israel falls to Argentina in relocated Davis Cup match Read More »

Belarus museum opens exhibit about Ariel Sharon

The National History Museum of Belarus inaugurated an exhibition about Ariel Sharon.

Titled “Profile of a Leader,” the exhibition on the late Israeli prime minister was launched Monday on the entrance floor of the state museum. The ceremony was attended by diplomats, Jewish community leaders and Israeli guests connected to Sharon’s life, including his youngest son, Gilad, and Israel Maimon, who served Sharon’s Cabinet secretary.

“Ariel Sharon brought pride to Israel, but also to Belarus, where his roots lay,” said Yuri Ambrazevitch, a senior official of the Belarusian Foreign Ministry.

Sharon was born in prestate Israel in 1928; his parents had immigrated there from what is now Belarus.

The exhibition — featuring of dozens of photos of Sharon as well as quotes from his speeches and letters — was compiled by the Limmud FSU educational nonprofit.

“Russian-speaking Jews responded to Sharon’s warmth, they adored him,” said Limmud FSU founder Chaim Chesler, who knew Sharon. “He spoke Russian and would correct you if you made a mistake in Russian.”

Chesler added that “celebrating his life is celebrating world Jewry’s deep, deep roots in Belarus.”

The exhibition on Sharon, a former general and defense minister who died in January after eight years in a coma following a stroke, opened with a quote from his 2005 address before the United Nations General Assembly, months after Israel pulled out of Gaza.

“If the circumstances had not demanded it, I wouldn’t have become a soldier but rather a farmer,” he said. “My first love was and remains farming, sowing and harvesting, the pastures, the flocks and the cattle.”

Belarus museum opens exhibit about Ariel Sharon Read More »

U.S. sees Middle East help fighting ISIS, Britain cautious after beheading

Washington said countries in the Middle East had offered to join air strikes against Islamic State militants and Australia said it would send troops, but Britain held back even after the group beheaded a British hostage and threatened to kill another.

U.S. Secretary of State John Kerry has been touring the Middle East to try to secure backing for U.S. efforts to build a coalition to fight the Islamic State militants who have grabbed territory in Syria and Iraq.

The United States resumed air strikes in Iraq in August for the first time since the 2011 withdrawal of the last U.S. troops, fearful the militants would break the country up and use it as a base for attacks on the West.

The addition of Arab fighter jets would greatly strengthen the credibility of what is a risky and complicated campaign.

“We have countries in this region, countries outside of this region, in addition to the United States, all of whom are prepared to engage in military assistance, in actual strikes if that is what it requires,” Kerry said.

“And we also have a growing number of people who are prepared to do all the other things,” he said in remarks broadcast on Sunday on the CBS program “Face the Nation.”

Offers of Arab air participation have been made both to U.S. Central Command overseeing the American air campaign and to the Iraqi government, a senior State Department official said.

The official said the offers were not limited to air strikes on Iraq. “Some have indicated for quite a while a willingness to do them elsewhere,” the official said. “We have to sort through all of that because you can’t just go and bomb something.”

As of Saturday, U.S. fighter jets had conducted 160 air strikes on Islamic State positions in Iraq. The United States will present a legal case before expanding them into Syria, U.S. officials said, justifying them largely on the basis of defending Iraq from militants who have taken shelter in neighboring Syria during its three-year civil war.

Australia became the first country to detail troop numbers and aircraft to fight the militants in Iraq. It said it would send a 600-strong force and eight fighter jets to the region but did not intend to operate in Syria.

Russia, at odds with the West over Ukraine, has said any air strikes in Syria would be an act of aggression without the consent of President Bashar al-Assad or an international mandate.

Britain has often been the first country to join U.S. military action overseas and is under pressure to get much tougher with IS after video footage of the killing of Briton David Haines by the militants was released on Saturday.

In footage consistent with the filmed executions of two American journalists, James Foley and Steven Sotloff, in the past month, they also threatened to kill another British hostage.

Speaking after chairing a meeting of the government's emergency response committee in London, Prime Minister David Cameron called the killing of Haines, a 44 year-old Scottish aid worker, callous and brutal and hailed him as a “British hero.”

“We will hunt down those responsible and bring them to justice no matter how long it takes,” he said, calling IS “the embodiment of evil” and saying his government was prepared “to take whatever steps are necessary” against the militants.

SUNNI 'ANVIL'

But he did not announce any air strikes, mindful of war-weary public opinion, parliament's rejection last year of air strikes on Syria, and sensitivities surrounding Scotland's independence referendum on Thursday.

U.S. allies are skeptical of how far Washington will commit to a conflict in which nearly every country in the region has a stake, set against the backdrop of Islam's 1,300-year-old rift between Sunnis and Shi'ites. Many fear there is not enough emphasis on ensuring the Iraqi government is strong and united enough to overcome sectarian divisions and run the country effectively after any intervention.

Britain and the United States have ruled out sending ground troops back into Iraq and Kerry did not say which countries had offered.

“We're not looking to put troops on the ground,” he said. “There are some who have offered to do so, but we are not looking for that at this moment anyway.”

On the CNN program “State of the Union,” White House Chief of Staff Denis McDonough was asked if the coalition would need ground troops beyond opposition forces in Syria and Kurdish and government forces in Iraq.

“Ultimately to destroy ISIL we do need to have a force, an anvil against which they will be pushed – ideally Sunni forces,” he said, using an acronym for Islamic State.

'EXTREMELY ENCOURAGED'

On Thursday, Kerry won the backing for a “coordinated military campaign” from 10 Arab countries – Egypt, Iraq, Jordan, Lebanon and six Gulf states including rich rivals Saudi Arabia and Qatar.

“This is a strategy coming together as the coalition comes together and the countries declare what they are prepared to do,” Kerry said in the interview, taped on Saturday in Egypt.

“I've been extremely encouraged to hear from all of the people that I've been meeting with about their readiness and willingness to participate,” Kerry added.

France has offered to take part in air strikes in Iraq and is expected to give more details this week on what it is willing to do, although its financial resources and forces are already stretched with more than 5,000 soldiers in West Africa.

Michael McCaul, a Republican who chairs the House of Representatives Committee on Homeland Security, told the same CBS program that Prince Faisal bin Al Hussein of Jordan told him “he is ready to put his troops into Syria to fight ISIS”.

Washington could also try to persuade Egypt to put troops in Syria, McCaul said.

John Kerry will meet British Foreign Secretary Philip Hammond during a conference on Iraq in Paris on Monday. The conference brings Iraqi authorities together with about 30 countries and organizations to coordinate their response to Islamic State.

“It will also be the first time to really gauge what Russia thinks and is ready to do,” a French diplomat said.

The diplomat said Syria was a different case.

“The situation is not the same either legally or militarily. We do not want to strengthen Assad, so we have to be sure that strikes there don’t do that,” the diplomat said. “We are ready to help Iraq’s government, which has asked for our help, but not Assad’s dictatorship.”

Additional reporting by Jason Szep and John Irish in Paris, Timothy Gardner in Washington, Morag MacKinnon in Perth, Australia and William Maclean in Dubai; Writing by Philippa Fletcher; Editing by Anna Willard, Peter Cooney and Mohammad Zargham

U.S. sees Middle East help fighting ISIS, Britain cautious after beheading Read More »

North Korea sentences U.S. citizen Matthew Miller to six years hard labor

North Korea sentenced U.S. citizen Matthew Todd Miller to six years hard labor for committing “hostile acts” as a tourist to the country, a statement carried by state media said on Sunday, as the United States requested his immediate pardon and release.

Miller joins Kenneth Bae to become the second American currently serving a hard labor sentence in North Korea. A third, Jeffrey Fowle, is awaiting trial.

“He committed acts hostile to the DPRK while entering the territory of the DPRK under the guise of a tourist last April,” the short statement said. The Korean version of the statement described Miller's punishment as a “labor re-education” sentence.

Miller, from Bakersfield, California and in his mid-20s, entered North Korea in April this year whereupon he tore up his tourist visa and demanded Pyongyang grant him asylum, according to a release from state media at the time. He was traveling without foreign guides, according to Uri Tours, the company that organized the trip.

North Korea has not publicly elaborated on Miller's charges, but the Associated Press, which was able to attend the trial, said Miller was tried under Article 64 of the North Korean criminal code which refers to espionage.

Photos of the trial released by state media showed some of Miller's personal possessions, including his passport, iPhone, iPad, notebook and North Korean visa – which appeared to be ripped. Miller was shown sitting in a witness box, flanked by North Korean soldiers.

The prosecution argued Miller's reported claims for asylum had been a “ruse”, and that he had falsely claimed to have secret information on his iPad and iPhone about the U.S. military stationed in South Korea, the Associated Press said.

The court said Miller had torn up his visa in order to investigate the North Korean human rights situation from within a North Korean prison, according to the Associated Press.

In Washington, State Department spokesman Darby Holladay said the United States requests that North Korea pardon both Miller and Bae “and grant them amnesty and immediate release so they may reunite with their families.”

In a statement, Holladay said the State Department “strongly recommends against all travel by U.S. citizens to North Korea.”

North Korea has yet to announce a trial date for the third U.S. citizen, Jeffrey Fowle, 56, from Miamisburg, Ohio, who was arrested in May for leaving a Bible under a bin in the toilet of a sailor's club in the eastern port city of Chongjin.

Holladay added that “out of humanitarian concern for Jeffrey Fowle and his family” the United States also asks that North Korea grant him amnesty and immediate release.

The U.S. missionary Bae has been held since December 2012 and is serving a sentence of 15 years hard labor for crimes North Korea said amounted to a plot to overthrow the state.

Earlier this month, international media were granted rare access to the three detained Americans, who in separate interviews all called on the United States to secure their release.

'CITIZENS AS PAWNS'

North Korea, which is under heavy United Nations sanctions related to its nuclear and missile programs, is believed to be using the detained U.S. citizens to extract a high-profile visit from Washington, with whom it has no formal diplomatic ties.

Assistant Secretary of State Daniel Russel, the senior U.S. diplomat for East Asia, said on Friday that the three Americans were being used as “pawns” and their detention was “objectionable”.

Pyongyang has in the past released detained U.S. citizens to delegations led by former U.S. Presidents Bill Clinton and Jimmy Carter, but North Korea has twice canceled visits by Robert King, the U.S. special envoy for North Korean human rights issues, to discuss Kenneth Bae's case.

Tourism to North Korea has increased markedly in the past few years, despite the recent string of arrests, with some operators estimating a tenfold increase in Western visitors over the last ten years.

“Although we ask a series of tailored questions on our application form … it's not always possible for us to foresee how a tourist may behave during a DPRK tour,” said Andrea Lee, CEO of Uri Tours, the U.S.-based company that organized Miller's tour to the country, also known by its official 'DPRK' acronym.

“Unfortunately, there was nothing specific in Mr. Miller's tour application that would have helped us anticipate this unfortunate outcome,” Lee said in an emailed statement.

North Korea on Saturday released a 50,000-word report on its human rights record in rebuttal to a United Nations report earlier this year that said the country's leadership should be tried for ordering the systematic torture, starvation and killing of its people.

Additional reporting by Will Dunham in Washington; Editing by Kim Coghill and Rosalind Russell

North Korea sentences U.S. citizen Matthew Miller to six years hard labor Read More »

Auschwitz guard, now 93, charged with 300,000 counts of accessory to murder

German prosecutors have charged a 93-year-old man with 300,000 counts of accessory to murder for his service as a Nazi SS guard at Auschwitz.

Oskar Groening of Hannover, Germany, has acknowledged that he was a guard at Auschwitz but said he did not personally commit any of the atrocities, The Associated Press reported Monday.

He was a guard at the concentration camp in May-June 1944. Some 425,000 Hungarian Jews came to Auschwitz during that time; about 300,000 died in its gas chambers.

Groening, who reportedly is in good health, is one of about 30 former Auschwitz guards who German federal investigators recommended to state prosecutors to file charges against following the conviction of John Demjanjuk, who died while his case was under appeal.

Some 20 Auschwitz victims and their families are co-plaintiffs in the case against Groening, according to AP.

 

Auschwitz guard, now 93, charged with 300,000 counts of accessory to murder Read More »

Where Do We Learn Right from Wrong?

How does one learn right from wrong? The answer for Jews seems easy: the Torah, our Tree of Life. In actuality, it’s not so easy. The Ramban taught:

It is impossible to mention in the Torah every detail of a person’s conduct with his neighbors and friends, all of his business dealings and the policies of towns and countries, but after it (the Torah) mentioned many (individual laws)…it went back to state generally that we should do the right and the good in everything (Ramban commentary, Devarim 6:18).

Inevitably, society evolves, and every rule from a past era and context should not, and cannot, be slapped upon a new scenario. And, of course, religious law is not the answer to every complex moral dilemma. We often must weigh a considerable number of competing values to determine the appropriate response in a given situation. The Chazon Ish (Rabbi Abraham Yeshaya Karelitz) taught that there is an important distinction between ratzon haTorah (the Torah’s will) and ratzon Hashem (G-d’s will). There are clear ethical mandates (ratzon Hashem) that cannot be found in Biblical verses. Nevertheless, one needs tools to discern moral truths.

Rav Kook taught that we must be engaged in contemplative life, where we tap into the conscience of our souls:

Morality, in its natural state, with all its profound splendor and might, must be fixed in the soul, so that it may serve as a substratum for the great effects emanating from the strength of Torah… Every element of Torah must be preceded by derekh eretz (natural ethical behavior) (Orot HaTorah 12:2-3).

In addition to all the answers not lying within the Torah, they also do not all sit exclusively with the Jewish people. The rabbis are clear that there is wisdom to learn from gentiles (Kiddushin 31a, Zevachim 19a). We must look out to all people of wisdom, to nature, even to animals:

Rabbi Yochanan said: If the Torah had not been given, we could have learned about modesty from the cat, honest labor from the ant, marital fidelity from the dove, and good manners from the rooster—who first coaxes his hen and then copulates with her (Eruvin 100b).

One must take an analytic and open approach to every possible idea of truth. Consider Rav Kook’s value for an open intellectual life:

One must carefully distinguish between a holistic perspective, which succeeds in penetrating the roots of every opinion, enabling it to appreciate every opinion for its intrinsic worth, and the cold tolerance resulting from the difficulty of integrating the spiritual world into life. The later must retreat in its confrontation with the light and energy of life.” (Letters of Rav Kook, Jerusalem, 5745, 79).

Rav Kook teaches further that we do not live in a deterministic, cyclical, declining, or static world. Rather, since the Exodus, we are a part of continuous progress toward ultimate liberation and redemption (Olat Reiyah II, p. 268, cited in footnote).

So if we are to grow morally from the wisdom of the Torah, conscience, gentile wisdom, nature, animals, and all ideas that move the human condition toward progress, how are we to decide what to harvest amidst all of this complexity?

We must hold ourselves accountable to not merely follow authorities but to make hard moral decisions on our own after consulting other forms of wisdom. Gandhi once said that the only tyrant that he ever listened to was his inner voice. May we all take in so much wisdom from the Torah, from our souls, from others, and from the world to the point that we are overflowing, and then may we have the courage to do the hardest job of all: tap into our deepest intellectual and spiritual faculties and make difficult, moral choices.

 

Rabbi Dr. Shmuly Yanklowitz is the Executive Director of the Valley Beit Midrash, the Founder & President of Uri L’Tzedek, the Founder and CEO of The Shamayim V’Aretz Institute and the author of six books on Jewish ethics.  Newsweek named Rav Shmuly one of the top 50 rabbis in America.”

Where Do We Learn Right from Wrong? Read More »