fbpx

July 3, 2013

Morsi reportedly ousted by Army

This story originally appeared on themedialine.org.

Egyptian state media reported Wednesday night that the army has deposed President Mohamed Morsi. Earlier, a meeting presided over by the Egyptian military that included representatives from political, religious and national groups was held on Wednesday evening. State media, citing anonymous sources, reported that the army deadline demanding President Morsi’s compliance with opposition demands had been extended in order to reach a peaceful conclusion among the diverse interests. By late evening, tanks were deployed in Cairo and elsewhere in an attempt to prevent chaos.

Rumors from inside Egypt’s military echelon speak of the creation of a ruling council that would include representatives of all relevant sectors – military, political, religious – and allow Morsi to remain in power with the promise of “early presidential elections once the constitution is re-written.”

The Egyptian military took control of state television on Wednesday as the army’s ultimatum to President Mohamed Morsi to reach an agreement with his opponents approached. Morsi issued a plea for calm in remarks aired on Egyptian TV Tuesday night, but his rejection of the army's 48-hour threat to intercede appears only to have heightened tensions in the street with the president offering his people an olive branch that few were prepared to accept.

The situation remained fluid Wednesday morning as the Egyptian people were watching and contemplating the possibility of civil war.

After his speech, clashes erupted between pro- and anti-Morsi demonstrators resulting in the deaths of at least sixteen of his supporters who were camped out in front of Cairo University. “Heavy clashes are taking place and cars are on fire,” journalist Baher Ghorab told The Media Line.

[Related: Egypt army commander suspends constitution, appoints interim head of state]

Through Tuesday night, the army sought to maintain neutrality between the government and opposition, with no signs of intervention apparent.

“Morsi defied the army's 48-hour ultimatum given to all political factions in Egypt to find a resolution that benefits Egypt,” Egyptian Army Capt. Amr Tolba told the Media Line.

In his speech, the president was adamant in rejecting the ultimatum and asserted that he would remain in office.
Morsi also assured Egyptians that, “Egypt will sustain its production of food, its own defense, and maintain its natural resources.”

On the streets, however, it appeared to observers that the Egyptian people were uninterested in paying heed.  Huge crowds estimated as high as 25 million protesters poured out across the nation in what was the largest mass protest seen since the first day of the revolution that brought down Hosni Mubarak in January 2011.

Sky News Arabia reported that anti-Morsi protesters in Alexandria had started blocking the railroad to Cairo, as the army’s deadline loomed.

Several  Morsi supporters interviewed by The Media Line said they are willing to pay with their lives to protect the legitimacy of Egypt's democracy and constitution.

“We will protect the president and those behind him, and if required we will seek martyrdom to protect the Islamic Project,” [referring to a plan calling for Islamic party rule throughout the region]. “We will not allow the immoral opposition to take this dream of a better life away from us,” demonstrator Hamdy Sayed told The Media Line.

On the other hand, liberals who oppose the Muslim Brotherhood's rule, are equally adamant.

“Morsi escaped from prison with the help of foreign militias. Egypt and Egyptians don't support terrorism or terrorists,” anti-Morsi demonstrator Yasmine Khatab told The Media Line from Tahrir Square.

Khatab was referring to the years Morsi spent in prison following allegations that he spied for a foreign country during the rule of Hosni Mubarak when the Moslem Brotherhood was outlawed. Morsi escaped at the beginning of the revolution that overthrew Mubarak in 2011, and in turn, accused the ousted president of corruption and of stifling democracy.

“Some people don't want democracy to succeed because it will not allow them to steal your money,” Morsi said in his rambling late-night speech on Tuesday.

The embattled president added that Egypt is an independent state with challenges that will take time to overcome, claiming that thirty-two families control most of Egypt's wealth. Morsi lamented that supporters of the old regime don't like the democratic experiment going on in the country now.

Morsi’s supporters argue that he was elected through a democratic process and should therefore remain in power.

“The opposition [at the time] shoved an election process in our face — 25 million Egyptians participated in the elections, and Morsi won. Now they are like kids who want to spoil a game because it doesn't go their way,” Mohammed Zahran, a Muslim Brotherhood supporter, told The Media Line.

In an effort to defuse the on-going tension in his remarks, Morsi spoke of an initiative for reforms that would include reviewing the articles of the constitution many Egyptians oppose and of bringing a better government to serve their needs. He stressed that he will protect the constitution and will lead an open dialogue with opposition groups for the benefit of all Egyptians.

Morsi also urged Egyptians not to clash with anyone from the army. “The army is the backbone of Egypt and all Egyptians need to respect it and let it protect Egypt from foreign enemies. Don't confront the army and don't use violence against it,” the president admonished his constituents.

Egypt's key geopolitical position as the largest Arab country underscores its importance to the international community. It is the second-largest recipient of American foreign aid, just behind Israel with $3 billion annually. Some in Egypt fear that aid could be jeopardized if Egypt pursues an anti-democratic course.

Egyptians also stress their nation’s importance by referring to the Suez Canal, the vital waterway for global shipping; its strategic position bordering the Gaza Strip; and the importance the world community places in Egypt maintaining the Camp David peace treaty, in force since 1979.

There is concern that unless the Egyptian army remains vigilant and prevents chaos during the current crisis, the United States could reduce or retract its military support and find another player to help protect its interests in the region.

“The country is already divided between different religious and political factions; all they need are guns like in Libya,” Ahmed Seddik, a tour guide who voted for Morsi told The Media Line. He said that, “Egypt is lucky that Egyptians aren't that violent compared to places where similar revolutions took place.”

Morsi reportedly ousted by Army Read More »

Obama urges Egyptian military to quickly return to democratic government

President Barack Obama expressed deep concern about Egyptian removal of President Mohamed Morsi on Wednesday and called for a swift return to a democratically elected civilian government.

In a written statement commenting on dramatic events unfolding in Cairo, Obama said he had directed relevant U.S. agencies to review the implications of the military intervention to determine whether it would have any impact on U.S. aid.

He urged the Egyptian military to avoid any arbitrary arrests of Mursi and his supporters.

“During this uncertain period, we expect the military to ensure that the rights of all Egyptian men and women are protected, including the right to peaceful assembly, due process, and free and fair trials in civilian courts,” he said.

Reporting By Steve Holland and Roberta Rampton; Editing by Philip Barbara

Obama urges Egyptian military to quickly return to democratic government Read More »

In Egypt, Pita over Allah

It’s tempting to see the chaos in Egypt, with President Mohamed Morsi ousted and his Muslim Brotherhood party discredited, as just another failure of government. But there’s another aspect to this failure — and that is religion.

It’s conceivable that if human beings didn’t have to eat, the holy clerics who have been running Egypt into the ground over the past year would still be in power. But if they want to ever regain their credibility with the people who soured on them, they will have to learn a lesson that every religion needs to learn: God is not great at finding jobs and building economies.

The Muslim Brotherhood was founded more than 80 years ago on a philosophy that “Islam is the solution.” Well, it’s not. Islam, like any religion, can nourish your soul, increase your self-esteem, give you an identity and comfort you in times of grief. But it can’t run a government effectively, especially not a democratic government that is accountable to all the people.

The Brotherhood is accountable first and foremost to Allah, their all-powerful God who determines their every act and belief.

A newly translated book on Islam, “The Laws of Da’wa,” published in 1995 by an official Brotherhood leader and reported in the Jerusalem Post, explains the movement’s ideology: “The Brotherhood’s objectives [are] of advancing the global conquest of Islam and reestablishing the Islamic Caliphate, the public and private duties of jihad and the struggle Muslims must wage against Israel.”

Not exactly the kind of ideology geared toward more mundane stuff like creating jobs, attracting more tourism, liberating women, improving education or energizing a country’s economy.

Those millions of people who demonstrated throughout Egypt weren’t just screaming for their rights and their freedoms. They were screaming because so many of them are jobless and hungry.

Morsi and his Islamic fundamentalists took a suffering nation desperate for life’s essentials and managed to make things even worse. “Inflation, unemployment, government debt and poverty have all swollen markedly during Mr. Morsi’s short tenure,” the Economist reported. “Shortages of fuel and power are now chronic.”

In the end, hard reality — things like, “What will our children eat tonight?” or “We don’t have enough gas to go to the hospital” — always trumps religion.

Religion, when followed zealously, imbues zealots with the arrogance that comes from “owning” the divine truth. When you’re so intoxicated with this truth, when you believe with absolute certitude that everyone else must have this truth, it is impossible to allow other truths and realities to penetrate your consciousness — which is precisely what a democratically elected leader is obligated to do. As Daniel Brumberg wrote on CNN’s Web site, “Despite [Morsi’s] inauguration day promise to represent ‘all Egyptians,’ in the year that followed, Brotherhood leaders communicated intolerance and arrogance to both their secular rivals and their Salafi competitors.”

Drunk on their truth, devoid of good ideas and suddenly in a position of power, the Islamists couldn’t help themselves: They simply made a grab for more power.

It’s not a coincidence that the Brotherhood was more respected and valued in Egypt when it was not in power — when it was focused on being a religion, and not on coercing a country.

Blinded by their arrogance, Morsi and the Brotherhood forgot the one crucial ingredient that comes with gaining democratic power: accountability.

Whoever runs Egypt in the future is now on notice: Don’t ever forget that above and beyond everything else, above religion and above fancy statements of freedom and constitutions and human rights, the most fundamental human right is the right to work and feed your family.

In Egypt, Pita over Allah Read More »

Washington Notes: The Egyptian c-word dilemma

It is a full-fledged coup, says the Morsi camp. It is the unlawful removal of a democratically elected President from power.

“Don’t call it a coup”, cry the supporters of the military, the opponents of the Muslim Brotherhood who are taking over Egypt. They know that labeling it a “coup” makes it mandatory for other nations to call for Morsi’s reinstatement.

So, is it a coup? The response of the American administration is cautious, as one would expect it to be at a moment like this. Its dilemma is not difficult to understand:

On the one hand, intellectual honesty makes it almost impossible not to call the recent events a coup. President Morsi was elected by a majority that was never in dispute; he intimidated the opposition, but didn’t get to a point of eliminating democracy; he was removed by the military – an institution that isn’t elected by the people; he was removed without much justification – there were demonstrations against him, and the opportunity was ceased by Morsi’s opponents.

In other words: when something looks like a coup and sounds like a coup – it’s a coup.

On the other hand, intellectual honesty isn’t always the best guide to international policy. What if a coup removes from power a problematic leader? What if a coup promises to strengthen a weak administration and make a country on the verge of chaos more governable? What if sticking to democracy leaves one with a result that is easy to defend but makes but harder to live with?

The new Egyptian dilemma is fascinating, but hardly a new one: think about the US having to learn to live with the 2006 emergence of Hamas as the leading political power in the Palestinian territories. On the one hand, the elections were supported by the US (amid objections raised by Israeli Prime Minister Ariel Sharon). On the other hand, the result was troubling. The Bush administration had a plan that “sought to undo the results of elections in the West Bank and Gaza in January 2006 which, to the chagrin of White House and State Department officials, saw Hamas win a majority of seats in the Palestinian legislature”. So, in Hamas’ case the US was supporting a planned coup (that never materialized), while deciding not to stick with a straightforward, and possibly too simplistic, definition of “democracy”.

One gets the impression that the Obama administration is preparing itself to travel the same route. It will choose acrobatic verbosity over intellectual honesty. Obama is quite good at this: he can make the case, he can be gymnastically elastic with his definitions of “democracy”, “election”, “coup”, “the will of the people”, and all other related key words. And he will do it for good reasons:

1.    Because he can’t reinstate Morsi, even if he wants to.

2.    Because new elections might provide Egypt with a better leader.

3.    Because Morsi – even though he didn’t cause a lot of trouble for the US – wasn’t an effective leader for Egypt.

4.    Most of all: because he has to stick with the victorious party, and right now the military is winning.

Think about the ousting of Mubarak – the ousting that Obama decided to back due to a lack of a better option. Think about the long period of hesitation and deliberation before the decision was made to let the Egyptians have their own way. The Obama administration was heavily criticized for the supposed “abandonment” of Mubarak, but it had few other options.  Maybe it could have attempted to personally save him from the humiliation of arrest and trial. Possibly, it could have worked better with the military back then, to preserve a regime that is Mubarak-like or could have helped arrange for a better transition. It will not have a second chance at working with the military. Thus, if a similar process of a slow and deliberative abandonment of Morsi takes place in the coming weeks this should not come as great surprise.

The bottom line, crudely stated, is this: the Egyptian coup is not a “coup” because calling it a “coup” will only complicate something that is already complicated enough.

Washington Notes: The Egyptian c-word dilemma Read More »

Falling tree at Calif. summer camp kills counselor

A tree fell through a dining hall at a Jewish summer camp in Northern California, killing one and requiring four others to be airlifted to a nearby hospital.

NBC News reported that a counselor, Annais Rittenberg, was killed.

A Cal Fire spokesman, Daniel Berlant, posted on Twitter that emergency crews were responding to a “mass casualty” event on Wednesday at Camp Tawonga, with 20 reported injuries, the Los Angeles Times reported.

There were conflicting reports as to whether any children were injured in the incident. Gregg Rubenstein, director of finance for the camp, told The Associated Press that the staff was still assessing the situation but no campers were among the injured.

A spokesman for the Tuolumne County Sheriff’s Office, Sgt. Jim Oliver, told myMotherLode.com that children had been trapped under the tree but were not necessarily injured.

Founded in 1925, Camp Tawonga is located near Yosemite National Park and headquartered in San Francisco.

Falling tree at Calif. summer camp kills counselor Read More »

Morsi opponents, loyalists clash in Egypt’s Alexandria

Opponents and supporters of Egypt's deposed president, Mohamed Morsi, clashed in the Mediterranean city of Alexandria on Wednesday after the army announced his removal from office.

Gunfire was heard as rocks and bricks flew, said witnesses.

“We are dealing with the situation … We have called for security reinforcements in the area,” said senior police officer Sherif Abdelhamid.

Reporting by Abdel Rahman Youssef; Writing by Tom Perry/Asma Alsharif; Editing by Andrew Heavens

Morsi opponents, loyalists clash in Egypt’s Alexandria Read More »

The Procrastination Blog

By Matt Shapiro

Yesterday, I had to write a tremendously difficult email to Josh, editor of this blog, and tell him I made a mistake. Not just any mistake, mind you, but a mistake born out of procrastination, a long-standing foe of mine. You see, my blog posts are supposed to go up on Mondays. The problem with that is Mondays are directly preceded by the weekend. Sarah and I both work full time, so those are the two days in the week when we spend time together as a family with our son. We keep Shabbat, so no blog writing happens between sundown Friday and sundown Saturday. Sunday's out because we're running errands or doing family activities together. Saturday night isn't an option because, honestly, who would work on a Saturday night? Sunday night is a no go, because that's when I'm getting ready for the week; I could write while my son Jonah is napping on Sunday, but if I do that, when's my Sunday nap going to happen?

This past Wednesday night, Dr. Garrett O'Conner gave a lecture about procrastination at Beit T'Shuvah. Even though I already considered myself to be an expert on the topic, he shared a number of insights that stuck with me. He emphasized how procrastinating is a destructive pattern of behavior that's very difficult to break out of, even comparable to an addiction. Like any pattern, it takes concerted effort over time and direct attention in order to be decreased or eliminated; it's not just something that you “stop.” The biggest take-away for me was how Dr. O'Conner painted it as a conflict between impulse and responsibility. For example, I know I have to put together a blog entry every week, but actually setting aside the time to put it together takes foresight and discipline, when any number of impulses will arise between that plan and the action. It seems much easier, at least in the short term, to enjoy my weekend and pray I can find a few spare moments on Monday (or even Tuesday) to pull it together. I'm sure it's also no accident that this procrastination was particularly egregious after last week, when I wrote a post I felt particularly good about. If it's true, as Dr. O'Conner posits, that procrastination is born out of fear of negative judgment of my competence, the gremlins telling me my post won't be as good as last week's would be particularly loud, most conveniently silenced by watching another episode of Arrested Development after Shabbat is over.

And so, per doctor's orders, I will not succumb to malignant shame, the experience of shame growing when I hide and feel badly about something I feel I've done wrong, but instead share my motivational shame, seeing what doesn't feel good and using it as a launching pad. I recognize the negative way I feel when I procrastinate, and see that it impacts others, that it's not just about me (sorry, Josh!). I also recognize the real challenges prohodiating (being in favor of today, per DOC, the opposite of procrastination) presents. While writing this blog, I've continued to procrastinate: responding to other emails, reading up on the coming fantasy football season, and even washing dishes. Recognizing the procrastination in and of itself doesn't solve the problem, especially since I know how easily I can come up with “good reasons” (see: first paragraph) to do so. So, here I am, an out of the closet procrastinator. The plan for next week is to set aside at least half an hour Saturday night and Sunday night to avoid scrambling so much on Monday, saving both me and Josh some serious angst on Monday. It might not sound like much, but it's a concrete plan and it's a commitment, and that's a start. As long as nothing else comes up.

The Procrastination Blog Read More »

U.S. declines to criticize Egypt’s military as it ousts Morsi

The United States declined on Wednesday to criticize Egypt's military, even as it was ousting Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi from power.

Minutes before Egypt's army commander announced that Morsi, the country's first democratically elected president, had been deposed and the constitution suspended, the U.S. State Department criticized Morsi, but gave no public signal it was opposed to the army's action.

Asked whether the Egyptian army had the legitimacy to remove Morsi from power, State Department spokeswoman Jen Psaki said, “We're not taking sides in this.”

The muted U.S. response – at least thus far – to the dramatic events in Cairo suggested that Washington may be willing to accept the military's move as a way of ending a political crisis that has paralyzed Egypt, a long-time U.S. ally.

Still, the distant attitude toward Morsi, who has come under U.S. criticism in recent days, could open up President Barack Obama to complaints he has not supported democracy in the Arab world.

There was no immediate reaction from the White House or the State Department to the military's announcement that it was installing a technocratic government to eventually be followed by new elections.

But the fact that the Egyptian military announced plans for elections and a constitutional review, and that those plans were immediately backed by the country's leading Muslim and Christian clerics, could help the transition roadmap earn Washington's backing.

Earlier, Psaki had made clear that U.S. officials were disappointed in Morsi's speech on Tuesday night. In that speech Morsi said he would defend the legitimacy of his elected office with his life.

Morsi must “do more to be truly responsive” to concerns of Egyptian people” after huge rallies over the weekend, she said. “We are calling on him to take more steps.”

Specifically, Psaki said Morsi should call for an end to violence, including violence against women. He should also take steps to engage with the opposition and the military and work through the crisis in a political fashion, she added.

The military move also presents Obama with a dilemma over continuing U.S. aid to Egypt. Underlying the importance for Washington of keeping ties to Egypt's military, Secretary of State John Kerry in May quietly approved $1.3 billion in military assistance, even though the country did not meet democracy standards set by the U.S. Congress for it to receive the aid.

U.S. law requires most American aid to be cut off “to the government of any country whose duly elected head of government is deposed by military coup d'etat or decree.”

But the law gives the State Department discretion to decide whether a coup has taken place, according to Republican and Democratic congressional aides.

Additional reporting by Laura MacInnis; Writing by Warren Strobel; Editing by Alistair Bell and Vicki Allen

U.S. declines to criticize Egypt’s military as it ousts Morsi Read More »

Egypt’s Morsi quoted as calling army action a military coup

The Facebook page of Egyptian President Mohamed Morsi quoted him on Wednesday as saying he rejected measures announced by the army as a “military coup.”

The army, in a statement aired live on television, appointed a new, interim administration to replace Morsi as president, suspended the constitution and called for an early presidential election.

It was unclear whether Morsi has access to his own Facebook page or if the statement was posted by an aide.

Reporting by Asma Alsharif; Writing by Patrick Werr; Editing by Yasmine Saleh

Egypt’s Morsi quoted as calling army action a military coup Read More »