fbpx

November 1, 2010

California: Caught in the weeds?

This is the fourth piece of a weekly series in which the Progressive Jewish Alliance looks at the propositions on this year’s California ballot in light of the weekly Torah portion.

After stone-throwing media ads from Jerry Brown and Meg Whitman this election season, you would think the two California gubernatorial candidates were constitutionally incapable of agreeing on a single issue.  Not so!  As part of a larger “tough on crime” stance, Whitman has proclaimed she’s “firmly against Proposition 19.”  More colorfully, Brown has declared, “We got to compete with China.  If everybody’s stoned, how the hell are we going to make it?” 

Meg and Jerry may agree on this one, but Proposition 19 has been an intense source of debate among progressives and policy wonks alike.

Fortunately for us, grappling with complexity and nuance are hallmarks of Jewish religious text and tradition.  Evidence of Judaism’s love of debate can be found in any page of Talmud, replete with rabbinical volleys across the generations, or in this week’s Torah portion (parshah), which celebrates the delightfully imperfect Abraham and Sarah. 

Proposition 19 proponents claim the initiative will, “Put police priorities where they belong,” and, “Generate billions of dollars in [state tax] revenues.”  They argue legalization will save $1 billion annually from reduced arrest, prosecution and incarceration of drug users and will reduce cross-border narcotics trafficking controlled by Mexican cartels.  Proposition 19 continues prohibition of and penalties for driving under the influence.  Proposition 19 also preserves criminal justice system referrals to drug treatment programs for certain individuals.

Perhaps the most powerful arguments in favor of Proposition 19 are made by those studying the disparate impact that criminalization has historically had on communities of color.  The Drug Policy Alliance reports: “In Los Angeles County, with nearly ten million residents and over a quarter of California’s population, the marijuana possession arrest rate for blacks is 332% higher than the arrest rate for whites. Blacks make up less than 10% of L.A. County’s population, but they constitute 30% of the marijuana possession arrests.”  This pattern is repeated across California:

Congresswoman Sheila Jackson Lee has used the term “scarlet letter” to describe the stigmatizing effects of a drug possession record.  Even if you can pay the $450 plus in fines and court costs for a possession charge, the recorded misdemeanor “drug crime” follows you like a plague, inhibiting your ability to rent an apartment, enter college, get a student loan or find a job.  Governor Schwarznegger recently signed sentencing reforms into law, but it is too soon to tell what impact they will have.

Judaism abhors the idea that a person could be stigmatized for life.  Rather, great value is assigned to the practice of repentance or tshuvah, translated literally as, “Returning from evil” (Mishneh Torah, Laws of Repentance, 2:2-5).  Jewish law also suggests that public policy reflect the Biblical notion that neither the community nor any individual should cause another to sin.  This concept is based on Leviticus 19:14 (‘and you shall not place a stumbling block before the blind’), understood by the Rabbis and codified by Maimonides as the principle of not making one’s fellow a criminal (Mishneh Torah, Laws of Murder and the Preservation of Life, 13:14).

The opponents of Proposition 19 make their own set of powerful arguments.  For starters, they claim Attorney General Eric Holder’s commitment to enforce the Controlled Substances Act even if Proposition 19 passes means that California could become embroiled in costly legal battles and lose billions of dollars designated for states that follow federal “drug free” requirements.  And, the Rand Corporation has issued a set of studies that question whether legalization would have any meaningful impact on Mexican drug cartels and whether legalization actually provides budget relief, given the unforeseen public health impacts that could result from increased usage.

The San Diego Union-Tribune pointed out that Proposition 19’s imprecise drafting could create an unmanageable patchwork of local regulations and taxes:

“[Proposition 19] would allow every one of California’s nearly 480 cities and each of its 58 counties to develop their own regulation and tax schemes for the cultivation, processing, distribution, transportation and sale of marijuana. In San Diego County alone, that could mean 19 separate sets of regulations and taxes[]. That provision alone is an invitation to law enforcement chaos.”

In the end, Proposition 19’s imperfections are endemic of the ballot initiative process itself, which is ripe for critique and even an overhaul.  Perhaps that is why pairing a proposition with each week’s Torah portion has felt so apt to us.  In politics and religion, our best and highest calling may be to engage in the spirit of intellectual debate – to test, question, study, argue and sometimes resolve the complexities of our time. 

The Progressive Jewish Alliance has wrestled with the issues and we’ve taken strong positions. We’ve examined and discussed and decided: 

• Yes on Proposition 19

• No on Proposition 23

• Yes on Proposition 24

• Yes on Proposition 25/No on Proposition 26

We hope our arguments have been compelling.  But when you enter that voting booth next Tuesday, it will be up to you.  Until then, California, get inspired, get informed, and get to the polls. 

Happy voting!

 

California: Caught in the weeds? Read More »

Israeli movie takes top prize in Tokyo

An Israeli movie took the grand prize at the Tokyo International Film Festival.

“Intimate Grammar,” based on the Israeli novel “Book of Intimate Grammar” by David Grossman, was awarded the $50,000 Sakura Grand Prize Film Award on Sunday.

The film, directed by Nir Bergman, is about the son of Holocaust survivors growing up in Israel in the early 1960s.

“Intimate Grammar” also won the prize for best film at this year’s Jerusalem Film Festival. It received 12 nominations for the Ophir Awards—Israel’s equivalent of the Academy Awards—but received none.

Bergman is the first director to win the Sakura Prize twice. He also won in 2002 for his first feature film, “Broken Wings.”

The Best Director prize was awarded to Gilles Paquet-Brenner for “Sarah’s Key,” a French movie about the fate of a Jewish family during World War II. The movie also won the Audience Award.

Israeli movie takes top prize in Tokyo Read More »

Jewish cemetery in France vandalized

Graves were desecrated in a small Jewish cemetery in northeastern France.

Some 49 large, limestone tombstones were found knocked over and broken last Saturday in a cemetery not far from the German border. No written messages were found at the scene. The 19th century cemetery in the town of Bar-le-Duc, in the Lorraine region, contains 126 graves.

Several Jewish and Muslim cemeteries have been desecrated in the past year around the northeastern French region.

Police believe the large stones could not have been moved by a single individual. The local state prosecutor opened an investigation, the AFP news service reported.

The French National Bureau of Vigilance Against Anti-Semitism condemned the crime.

Jewish cemetery in France vandalized Read More »

In the war on breast cancer, Israel leads

Irit Paneth, in and out of remission from breast cancer for more than a decade, was among the thousands who wound their way like a giant pink-and-white ribbon through Jerusalem’s streets in the first Susan G. Komen Foundation’s Race for the Cure held in Israel.

“What’s important here is to raise awareness,” Paneth said during the Oct. 28 march, wearing the pink T-shirt reserved for breast cancer survivors.

The shirts are a signature of the Komen foundation, which has become the global leader in the war against breast cancer and co-sponsored last week’s event with Hadassah, the Women’s Zionist Organization of America, and the city of Jerusalem.

The route of the 5-kilometer race that ended in the valley of Ben Hinom, in the shadow of Jerusalem’s Old City walls, tread on especially fertile ground: Israel has one of the highest breast cancer rates in the world. It’s the most prevalent disease among Israeli women, with about 4,000 diagnosed every year.

Genetics are partially to blame. Ashkenazi Jews are 10 times more likely than the general population to carry the BRCA genes, mutations that often lead to breast or cervical cancer. Iraqi Jews also carry the genes in higher numbers.

Meanwhile, the number of cases has risen among Arab Israeli women, for whom the disease once was rarely found.

New studies show that Israeli women have nearly a one in seven chance of developing breast cancer; in the United States it’s closer to one in eight.

Beyond the bleak numbers, there is some positive news out of Israel concerning breast cancer: The country is a world leader in survival rates and cutting-edge research. One of the two BRCA gene mutations was discovered as part of a collaboration that included Tamar Peretz, the director of Hadassah Medical Center’s oncology department.

Israel has become a model for other countries. Hospitals offer targeted therapies for specific types of tumors based on in-house and international research as well as holistic treatments—including psychologists trained to counsel cancer patients and their families. The national health system provides free mammogram screening for those over 50 or considered a high risk for the cancer. Some women from around the world come to Israel for treatment.

With about 70 percent of Israeli women diagnosed at an early stage, survival rates are over 90 percent, according to Miri Ziv, director of the Israel Cancer Association. This year, she said, new breast cancer cases were reported to be on the decline.

Outreach to communities that in the past may have missed out on detection has been improved with the help of the Israel Cancer Association’s mobile mammogram clinic, which travels throughout the country.

Other organizations reach out to haredi Orthodox, Arab and Russian immigrant communities to help ensure they get screenings. Among the haredi and Arab populations the problem is especially acute because of cultural taboos that make discussion of the disease, let alone treatment, difficult.

Israelis and Palestinians are cooperating in the breast cancer battle.

The American Jewish Joint Distribution Committee’s Israel office has worked with a Palestinian nonprofit organization to create support groups for women diagnosed in Gaza and the West Bank. Israeli oncologists from Hadassah and their Palestinian counterparts at Augusta Victoria in eastern Jerusalem consult with one another and visit each other’s patients.

During last week’s Komen race, secular and religious Jewish women could be seen walking alongside Druze and Arab women.

Nancy Brinker, who founded the Komen Foundation in 1982 after her sister’s death from breast cancer, told JTA that she was excited about bringing the race to Israel.

“I’m Jewish and I have the BRCA gene, and my sister probably did as well,” she said.

Brinker’s recently published memoir, “Promise Me: How a Sister’s Love Launched the Global Movement to End Breast Cancer,” tells the story of the promise she made in 1980 to her older sister, Susan G. Komen, then 36 and dying of cancer, to do all she could to eradicate breast cancer. Since its founding, the organization has raised $1.5 billion for research, treatment and awareness.

“We look at regions very carefully and decide where we can help people make giant steps forward in any points of our mission,” Brinker said. “We’ve put almost $40 million into 50 different countries, and Israel is an important part of our global community.”

Over the years, the Komen Foundation has given more than $2 million in research grants to Israeli scientists. Research the organization helped fund at the Weizmann Institute contributed to the development of Herceptin, one of the first breast cancer drugs on the market.

Given the Jewish genetic dimension to the disease, Israel also is playing a leading role in genetic research.

Ephrat Levy-Lahad, who heads the Jerusalem Shaare Zedek Medical Center’s department of medical genetics—as well as the Israel Cancer Association-funded Genetics Consortium Project—is working to evaluate the risk level that carriers of BRCA1 and BRCA2 have of developing breast and ovarian cancer. Levy-Lahad found, for example, that a specific minor genetic change in another gene greatly increases the risk of those with BRCA2 developing the disease.

Israel’s health funds provide free testing for the BRCA gene among those with a family history of breast cancer.

For Jennifer Griffin, 40, a Fox News correspondent who spent seven years based in Jerusalem, the research in Israel is personal. Diagnosed a year ago with triple negative breast cancer, a particularly aggressive strain of the disease that tends to attack younger women, she returned to Jerusalem last week as an ambassador for the Komen Foundation.

“The answer to it probably lies somewhere here because there is such a strong community affected here and more scientists are working on it,” Griffin said of triple negative breast cancer, which though rare is more common among Ashkenazim who have the BRCA1 gene.

“The more funds Komen can funnel here,” she said, “the more progress can also be made worldwide.”

In the war on breast cancer, Israel leads Read More »

Jerusalem church fire being probed

A Christian Zionist group warned against blaming Jewish settlers for a possible arson attack against a church in downtown Jerusalem.

On Sunday, the International Christian Embassy in Jerusalem condemned the attack early last Friday on the Jerusalem Alliance Church, part of the Christian Alliance headquarters near the haredi Orthodox neighborhood of Mea Shearim.

An accidental cause has not been ruled out by firefighters, The Jerusalem Post reported. Church neighbors said there were often lit candles in the building.

Church and Palestinian leaders have blamed the attack on extremist Jewish settlers, though there is no solid evidence to back their assertion.

The International Christian Embassy warned against pinning the blame on settlers, who have been accused of perpetrating recent arson attacks on two mosques in the West Bank.

“We urge Israeli authorities to investigate this matter thoroughly and prosecute those found responsible,” the embassy said. “We note that this process has already begun and while no conclusions can be drawn yet, it appears this was not a ‘price tag’ attack by extremist Jewish settlers, as some media are already claiming.”

The church was built in 1914 and is used by several congregations, including an Arab congregation and Messianic Jewish congregations.

Several staff members live in the building. Three were taken to the hospital suffering from smoke inhalation, according to reports.

Jerusalem church fire being probed Read More »

Civility statement on political discourse to be unveiled

A Statement on Civility in national political discourse is set to be unveiled by the Jewish Council for Public Affairs.

The statement, the first step of a multi-part campaign led by the JCPA to inspire more civility in national political discourse in the United States, will be presented Monday.

More than 100 prominent Jewish leaders from Jewish community and pro-Israel groups, former Washington government officials, educators, rabbis and activists have signed on to the statement. Signers include Republicans and Democrats.

The statement can be signed online, where a list of signatories can be viewed .

It reads, in part: “(T)oday, the expression and exchange of views is often an uncivil, highly unpleasant experience. Community events and public discussions are often interrupted by raised voices, personal insults, and outrageous charges. Such incivility serves no purpose but to cheapen our democracy. When differences spiral down into uncivil acrimony, the dignity of individuals and community is diminished, and our precious democracy is weakened. People holding diverse views cease to listen to each other. Lack of civility makes it more difficult, if not impossible, to open minds, much less find common ground.”

“Therefore we as a community and as individuals, must pledge to uphold the basic norms of civil discussion and debate at our public events. We do this not to stifle free expression of views, but rather to protect it.”

Also Monday, former Bush administration official Noam Neusner will lead a panel discussion on civility titled “Toward Civility: A Community Conversation” at 2 p.m. at the UJA-Federation of New York building, 130 E. 59th St.

Civility statement on political discourse to be unveiled Read More »

Dutch author Harry Mulisch dies at 83

The influential Dutch Jewish author Harry Mulisch has died in Amsterdam.

Mulisch, who died Saturday Oct. 30 from cancer, wrote powerfully about World War II, often focusing on moral and philosophical themes. He was 83.

His most famous book internationally was “The Assault,” which centered on life and death in German-occupied Holland. Translated into more than 30 languages, it was turned into a movie that won the Academy Award for best foreign film in 1986.

Mulisch was the son of a German-Jewish mother and an Austrian father who was jailed after the war as a Nazi collaborator.

Mulisch’s father used his connections with the Nazis to save his wife and son, but his wife’s parents were deported and killed in Nazi death camps.

“I didn’t so much experience the Second World War,” Mulisch once said. “I am the Second World War.”

Mulisch won numerous Dutch awards and, in 2007, newspaper readers voted his 1992 novel “The Discovery of Heaven” as “the best Dutch book ever.”
Dutch Prime Minister Mark Rutte called Mulisch’s death “a loss for Dutch literature and the Netherlands.”

Dutch author Harry Mulisch dies at 83 Read More »

Federation’s GA offering big name but reaching out to young

The Jewish federation system is set to kick off its annual General Assembly in New Orleans with an eye toward figuring out how to reach those not typically associated with Jewish federations.

As always, the annual gathering for the network of 157 Jewish federations and 400 affiliated fund-raising outposts, which raises about $3 billion per year, will feature dozens of sessions dedicated to helping federations better tell their stories and raise money. This year’s lineup includes a heavy dose of workshops focused on dealing with the recession, balancing domestic and international needs, and new modalities of partnerships and fund-raising vehicles.

The conference also will feature such headline-grabbing speakers as Vice President Joe Biden, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, Israeli Defense Minister Ehud Barak and Tzipi Livni, the leader of Israel’s largest opposition party, Kadima.

But the Jewish Federations of North America, which organizes the GA, also is pitching this year’s conference as one dedicated to outreach to younger generations.

Approximately 600 college students affiliated with Hillel from 96 campuses have received subsidies to attend the conference, and much of GA programming is designed to resonate with the younger attendees, including sessions on social media and volunteerism, a Jewish Federations spokesman said.

The organizations also worked with the Jewish blog Jewlicious.com to invite a number of bloggers to cover the GA in a project it is calling Bloggers Alley.

“The outreach to younger people is part of a broader look to the future and where do we go from here,” Jewish Federations spokesman Joe Berkofsky said.

The federation network raises just under $1 billion per year for global and domestic Jewish needs through its annual campaign and another $2 billion for endowments and special campaigns.

More than 3,000 federation officials and volunteers are expected in New Orleans for the Nov. 7-9 meeting, which kicks off Friday with a charity golf tournament. Netanyahu’s speech is expected to be among the GA highlights.

“The entire Jewish Federation movement is thrilled to have Prime Minister Netanyahu joining us,” said Jerry Silverman, the president and CEO of the Jewish Federations of North America. “The prime minister will be joining an array of inspiring world leaders who will help make this a powerful and memorable GA.”

The GA was scheduled to be held in Orlando, Fla., but Jewish Federations officials abruptly switched to New Orleans earlier this year after realizing, they said, that Orlando did not have sufficient space for the gathering.

One major benefit of the change in venue is that it will allow federations to showcase the work of their network with the $28 million it raised for New Orleans following Hurricane Katrina in 2005. In addition, organizers have structured the conference around a day of community service in New Orleans, marking the first time a GA has included a mass volunteer project.

The project represents something of uncharted territory for the federations in that they are working with several non-federation organizations, including Repair the World, Avodah: The Jewish Service Corps, American Jewish World Service and Jewish Funds for Justice, to provide service opportunities for up to 1,500 GA attendees.

“It is part of a broader initiative to focus on Jewish service and to engage younger Jews and more people in ‘tikkun olam’ [repair of the world] and Jewish philanthropy,” Berkofsky told JTA. “It lets them get involved in a form of Jewish philanthropy, a pathway and experience into Jewish life. For some people, Jewish service is their means of Jewish expression.”

Lion of Judah, the division of the federation system dedicated to encouraging women to make gifts of $5,000 or more in their own names, will hold its conference Nov. 8-10 in conjunction with the GA. Some 1,100 women are expected. That conference also will feature a community-service project, as organizers raised $20,000 before the conference to buy 5,000 books that they will distribute to 1,000 poor children in New Orleans.

Unlike the GA, the biennial Lion of Judah conference is a fund-raising event. When the International Lion of Judah Conference took place in Jerusalem in 2008, the recession was just starting and the women raised $18 million. This year they hope to beat that number, Jewish Federations officials said.

Federation’s GA offering big name but reaching out to young Read More »

Homeland Security in Chicago to beef up Jewish security

Agents from the U.S. Department of Homeland Security are in Chicago to beef up security at Jewish institutions.

They arrived Sunday and are working through the Chicago Jewish federation, according to Paul Goldenberg, national director of the Secure Community Network (SCN), a security agency that is the product of the Jewish Federations of North America and the Conference of Presidents of Major American Jewish Organizations.

On Wednesday, senior Homeland Security leadership will begin a series of conference calls with senior Jewish leaders across the country focusing on increased security concerns in the wake of last Friday’s bomb threat in which two packages of explosives mailed from Yemen and allegedly targeting Jewish institutions in Chicago were intercepted. One was intercepted at a FedEx way station in the United Arab Emirates, and one in London.

Hidden inside printer cartridges, the explosives were powerful enough to bring down a plane. Officials are still trying to determine the intended targets—the planes carrying the bombs or the institutions to which they were mailed.

SCN is “closely monitoring the situation,” said Goldenberg, who is in Chicago working with Homeland Security.

Homeland Security in Chicago to beef up Jewish security Read More »

Northwestern University Jewish center vandalized

A Chabad House serving Northwestern University in suburban Chicago was vandalized.

Saturday’s attack came a day after President Obama revealed in a televised news conference that two packages containing remote-controlled bombs addressed to Jewish organizations in the Chicago area were intercepted on the way to the United States.

The large menorah in front of the Tannenbaum Chabad House, located a block from the university’s Evanston campus, was vandalized for just the second time since the Jewish center opened more than 20 years ago, the Daily Northwestern reported.

“I’ve been in this community for so long, and we’ve never had vandalism of this nature,” Chabad director Rabbi Dov Hillel Klein told the student newspaper. “I was pretty saddened by it. I felt somewhat violated.”

Evanston police have classified the incident as a hate crime, Klein told the newspaper.

Northwestern University Jewish center vandalized Read More »