Destruction and Regeneration – Thoughts on Parashat Noah 2023 (adapted from previous versions)

Destruction and Regeneration

Thoughts on Parashat Noah 2023 (adapted from previous versions)

I imagine warring bands of murderous maniacs, spreading ruination everywhere they went. Anyone who stood up to them was hacked down. Just about everyone eventually joined the frenzy. Something like the zombie shows, except in this case, the zombies win, and the murderous hordes are not zombies. These are mobs of human beings, but they have gone very, very bad.

We’ve seen awful, horrific evidence of this maniacal evil in the atrocities committed by Hamas on 10/7. The wound is fresh, so horrific, so painful that we might forget that Hamas is yet another in a long line of incarnations of evil.

We’ve seen awful, horrific evidence of this maniacal evil in the atrocities committed by Hamas on 10/7. The wound is fresh, so horrific, so painful that we might forget that Hamas is yet another in a long line of incarnations of evil. We see this humanity-gone-bad in the depredations of Nazism and the bloodlust reigns of Stalin, Mao, Imperial Japan, Pol Pot, the Kims of North Korea, and Saddam Hussein. We see this in the genocides in Rwanda, Myanmar, and the Balkans. We see it in the crazed viciousness of ISIS, Al Qaeda, and the Taliban. Slavery and the destruction of indigenous populations. Every time I dig into world history, I see it. The Armenian genocide. The Mongols. The Russian depredations in Ukraine. The list is long.

Imagine that the background of our Torah portion is that these maniacal tribes are winning their war against humanity and are closing in to murder the final remaining other tribes and everyone in their path. You might write, as the Bible does, that “the world had become corrupt and was filled with violence.” If you believed in a God that acted in history, you might pray that this powerful God would wipe out this heinous humanity and all its cruelty. (If you have trouble imagining this, go watch Darren Aronofsky’s movie “Noah.”)

The Bible, in the Noah story, imagines this depravity and its consequences in its own way. Humanity, the Bible tells us, has been an awful error. The solution will be that human beings, made from earth and water and animated by spirit, would be dissolved back into the earth from which they came, and ultimately into the abyss of water that existed before creation. The spirit, trapped in a form that became monstrous, would be released back to God. The form would crumble. The spirit of God would hover silently again over the face of the waters. Cries of savagery would be stilled.

The bone chilling story of an ancient flood seemed to inhabit the minds of everyone in the ancient world of the Middle East. The “Black Sea Deluge” theory holds that the Mediterranean Sea broke through the Bosporus around 5600 BCE, flooding an ancient littoral civilization within months. Others believe that the Mesopotamian Rivers overflowed and deluged the cradle of civilization for centuries. Plato taught that the ancient island city of Atlantis fell out of favor with the gods and sank into the Atlantic Ocean (of all places). Whatever the source of the ancient Middle Eastern cultural memory of the flooding, The Deluge became part of the collective memory of that part of the world. Everyone knew it happened. Why it happened was the question. Ancient mythological systems came up with a variety of answers; for example, human beings were too noisy and disturbed the dreams of the gods.

The biblical author(s) held that this flood was an act of God to reverse creation. In other words, the Bible rewove an ancient tradition of a flood to support its theory that, referring to the human being, “every form of the thoughts of his heart are all bad, all the time” (Genesis 6:5). It took 10 generations, from Adam to Noah, for such a complete human degeneration that would require creation to be reversed to a watery silence.

As in other flood stories there was a “last good man.” In some flood stories, this person was hidden by a renegade god to survive the flood, much to the displeasure of the other gods who wanted to do away with all of humanity.

In the biblical story, it is the one God who is looking for the righteous person, the one who walks with God, to regenerate humanity out of the havoc and debris. The regeneration of humanity told in our Torah portion is bizarre and seems to forebode something awful. The parsha ends with the tower of Babel story. The Midrash on this tale foreshadows the fascist state.

The God of the Bible has apparently learned a lesson and waits patiently, 10 full generations, for the next chapter of the regeneration of humankind – the election of Abraham and Sarah.

There would be 10 generations from Noah to Abraham. Abraham would “walk before God and be whole.” Abraham would teach his descendants, spiritual and biological, to keep God’s way and the righteous law. The Bible, as literature and philosophic psychology, sees the human being as fallen but also able to stand up again. To achieve moral standing, however, we would need a teaching – a vision and a path so strong and clear that this teaching would guide us in turning back the flood of destructiveness.

People would learn to stand up against hordes that want to destroy humanity. We would also learn to turn back the destructive flood that rises within each of us and among us. It is in our nature to be destructive, but it is also within our nature to transcend our nature. Chaos, too, can be reversed. Entropy is not the ultimate law of the universe.

People would learn to stand up against hordes that want to destroy humanity. We would also learn to turn back the destructive flood that rises within each of us and among us. It is in our nature to be destructive, but it is also within our nature to transcend our nature. Chaos, too, can be reversed. Entropy is not the ultimate law of the universe.

New tribes would come into being, holding the line against evil, fighting evil regimes, making room for teaching the vision and the way.