Best Of The Web
“It’s increasingly clear that Roe v. Wade, the U.S. Supreme Court decision protecting a woman’s right to choose abortion, is in jeopardy. But what is Roe all about? Privacy? Liberty? Women’s equality?
Its survival may depend partly on the answer, so let’s go back to first principles.
The Roe opinion, written by Justice Harry Blackmun in 1973, was entirely about privacy. As Blackmun put it, the right of privacy “is broad enough to encompass a woman’s decision whether or not to terminate her pregnancy.”
For two reasons, that’s awkward. First, the U.S. Constitution does not protect a general right of privacy at all. Second, any right of privacy, if it does exist, would not seem to encompass the right to choose abortion. Privacy usually refers to the right to control access to personal information. 1 What does abortion have to do with that?
In 1992, the court switched gears. In an opinion jointly written by Justices Sandra Day O’Connor, Anthony Kennedy and David Souter, the authors spoke not of privacy but of liberty. They said that “there is a realm of personal liberty which the government may not enter.”
They added that a “mother who carries a child to full term is subject to anxieties, to physical constraints, to pain that only she can bear” — suffering that “is too intimate and personal” for government to override.
The word “liberty” is in the Constitution, so it’s an improvement on “privacy.” In ordinary language, liberty does include the right to make intimate and personal decisions.
Still, the Constitution does not protect all such decisions. You can’t marry your mother, or more than one person. There is no constitutional right to smoke cigarettes. Liberty can be curtailed when the interests or rights of others are at stake. What about the fetus?
In a short, cautious essay published in 1985, eight years before she joined the Supreme Court, Ruth Bader Ginsburg struggled with these issues. She made two points. First, she argued that Roe badly overreached. In her words, “the court ventured too far in the change it ordered.””
JJ Editor's Picks
"When Mark Twain observed that rumors of his death had been “greatly exaggerated,” he left out the fact that those words would become true eventually, as they did in 1910 when the great American author died. Similarly, given the huge resources..."
"No one is going to confuse President Trump’s remarks Tuesday at the Economic Club of New York with anything approaching eloquence. He is at his worst when he stiffly reads the teleprompter or flies widely off script with gratuitous remarks about..."
"Everything we think we know about the shape of the universe could be wrong. Instead of being flat like a bedsheet, our universe may be curved, like a massive, inflated balloon, according to a new study. That’s the upshot of a new paper published..."
"Being lonely hurts — it can even negatively impact your health. But the mere act of being alone with oneself doesn’t have to be bad, and experts say it can even benefit your social relationships, improve your creativity and confidence, and help..."
"Sen. Elizabeth Warren is campaigning for a 2% surtax on anyone’s net worth over $50 million and 6% on more than $1 billion. Most discussion of the wealth tax has focused on whether it could generate sufficient revenue to fund Ms. Warren’s..."
"TV depression looks fabulous. I’d love to have that kind of depression. And it’s not just TV depression; any mental illness on-screen looks rather thrilling. Either it’s dark and dramatic — unlike day-to-day depression, which is at best super..."
"Hebrew remained, to Oz, Zionism’s greatest achievement. Certainly, it was the one he was least ambivalent about. “I have said many times that I’m a chauvinist only in respect of the language,” he told the Paris Review. “I feel for the language..."
"Talk about missed connections. Earlier this week, hundreds of people received seemingly random text messages, out of context and out of the blue, addressed from friends, family, and loved ones. The first part of the mystery was solved pretty..."