fbpx

Israel’s “Sand Storm” eliminated in Oscar race

[additional-authors]
December 16, 2016

 Israel’s hopes for an Oscar as best foreign-language film were dashed Thursday evening (12/15) when “Sand Storm” failed to make the cut as competing entries from 85 countries were narrowed to nine semi-finalists.
Noticeably, however, three of the nine movies on the shortlist deal with the Nazi era, indicating once again the hold that World War II and Holocaust themes have on the imagination of filmmakers.
The elimination of “Sand Storm” spelled the end, for now, of a Cinderella story, in which Elite Zexer, in her first feature film, dominated the Israeli equivalent of the Academy Awards, winning six “Ophirs,” including best picture and best director.
Centered on a clash between tradition and modernity in a Bedouin village, the film, set in the Negev and entirely in Arabic, has won top prizes at international film festivals in Taiwan, South Korea, Seattle and Jerusalem and the World Cinema Grand Jury Prize at Sundance.
Among the nine surviving entries are Russia’s “Paradise,” Norway’s “The King’s Choice,” and Denmark’s “Land of Mine.”
The Danish entry represents perhaps the most unlikely twist in a movie about the World War II era. During their occupation of Denmark the Germans, guessing mistakenly that the Allies would invade Europe by landing on the Danish west coast, had seeded the beaches with land mines.
At war’s end, the Danish army rounded up a group of young German soldiers, still in their teens, and had them walk across the beaches to dig out and defuse the mines.
Day after day, more and more of the Germans, driven by a sadistic Danish sergeant, were blown up, so that even the most anti-German viewer can’t help but sympathize with the youngsters and detest their overseer.
Norway presents a more traditional view of resistance to Nazi occupation in “The King’s Choice.” In April 1940, Nazi forces invaded Norway by sea and demanded that King Haakon capitulate. The monarch refused and, in exile, orchestrated his countrymen’s resistance to the German occupation.
At the center of Russia’s entry, “Paradise,” is a Russian noblewoman, working as a fashion editor in Paris, who is thrown into a concentration camp during the Nazi occupation for sheltering two Jewish children.
Other movies making the shortlist are Australia’s “Tanna,” Canada’s “It’s Only the End of the World,” Germany’s “Toni Erdmann,” Iran’s “The Salesman,” Sweden’s “A Man Called Ove” and Switzerland’s “My Life as a Zucchini.”
Given the complicated voting system for selecting the best international picture, some early favorites, such as France’s “Elle” and Chile’s “Neruda” were also eliminated.
The list of nine movies will be narrowed to five on Jan. 24, when the nominees in all categories will be announced. The ultimate winners will be crowned on Feb. 26 at the Dolby Theatre in Hollywood.
The gala evening will be televised to 225 countries and territories worldwide.
   

Did you enjoy this article?
You'll love our roundtable.

Print Issue: The Year Everything Changed | March 13, 2026

Crazy as it might sound, it all started with the Dodgers, and how they won back-to- back World Series in 2024 and 2025. That year, with those two championships on either end, is the exact same year l became a practicing Jew. And I don’t think that’s a coincidence.

Rabbi Jerry Cutler, 91

In 1973, he founded Synagogue for the Performing Arts, drawing the likes of Walter Matthau, Ed Asner and Joan Rivers.

Pies for Pi Day

March 14, or 3/14 is Pi Day in celebration of the mathematical constant, 3.14159 etc. Any excuse to enjoy a classic or creative pie.

It Didn’t Start with Auschwitz

Jews today do have a voice. For the moment. But we have not used it where it counts – in the mainstream media, the halls of power, on campuses, on school boards, in the public square.

Regime Humiliation: No, You Won’t Destroy Israel

After years of terrorizing Israelis with existential threats, the Islamic regime is now worried about its own existence. In a region where the projection of power is everything, that is humiliation.

The War in Iran and the Long-Term Relationship with America

There is a golden opportunity to expose the intellectual bankruptcy of antisemitism based on current identity politics discourse, and to credibly argue that the current struggle is a global confrontation between the forces of terror and oppression and the Free World.

Ladino Shabbat at Sinai

On a recent Shabbat, Sinai celebrated the Ladino tradition and invited me to tell my story.

More news and opinions than at a Shabbat dinner, right in your inbox.