Advertisement
Advertisements
April 3, 2008 | 2:12 pm
Accurate news coverage of the incident involving popular Iranian Muslim singer Dariush Eghbali in Las Vegas last December has been no easy task for me during the past three months. My article this week in the L.A. Jewish Journal concerning the incident can be found here.
Tensions had been and still are running high in Southern California’s Iranian Jewish community concerning the concert on Dec. 23rd when some local Iranian Jewish fans were shocked after Eghbali made what some considered to be an anti-Semitic remark between songs. In a video clip from the Las Vegas concert posted to Eghbali’s Web site, dariush2000.com, the singer speaks in Persian, quoting an alleged passage from a book he attributed to Lebanese American poet Khalil Gibran. He said, “Different people have different talents.” He elaborates, saying that Iranians notice one bad tree in a beautiful park; Germans are power-seekers; Italians are fashion-oriented; and Jews are “mochareb,” which is the Persian word for “saboteurs.”
The video of that concert can be found here:
After this Eghbali incident I was literally bombarded with e-mails from readers of this blog and some Iranian Jewish community members demanding that I denounce the singer for his words. My response was a simple NO. As an unbias journalist, my duties are not to pass immediate judgment on any person or activity, but merely uncover and report the real facts of each story. Now at this juncture, I am not defending nor am I denouncing Eghbali for his comments, my position is just as a neutral observer. Trying to get to the facts of this story without the drama and emotion involved, was not an easy task and a few local Iranian Jewish community leaders (which shall go unnamed) were not helpful to me in my quest to find real answers to this problem. Interestingly, Eghbali never returned my calls for comments and it’s sad because he could have used the opportunity to set the record straight and put the issue to rest for good.
In my opinion, Iranian Jewish community leaders need to learn how to respond to the news media more respectfully and accurately, instead of hurling threats and shouting-- yes I did encounter some of both when asking certain leaders for their comments. Local Iranian Jewish community leaders need to wake up to the reality that we no longer live in a bubble, as was the case in Iran, and they are accountable to the community for their actions or inactions. I am not out to cast a negative light on anyone, but as a journalist who is trying to sharing this community’s stories accurately it is disappointing to see some involved with stonewalling.
Posted by Karmel Melamed in 3 Comments — Leave your comment
Share this post:
del.icio.us
Digg
Facebook
Google Bookmarks
Reddit
StumbleUpon
Technorati
YahooMyWeb
We welcome your feedback.
Your information will not be shared or sold without your consent. Get all the details.
2008 elections amnon netzer anti-semitism by muslims bahais chadorchi domestic violence taboo gaza gina nahai great neck new york hezbollah homeless iran iran divestment bill iran expert iranian anti-semitism iranian government propoganda iranian jewish podcast iranian jews iranian jews podcast iranian mullahs iranian muslims iranian revolution iranian studies israel israel independence day jewish conspiracy joel anderson john mccain karmel melamed nateq-nouri nessah synagogue nouriel cohan obama persian jews purim super tuesday thirty years after violence yom ha'atzmaut zoroastrians
Advertisement
July 2008
June 2008
May 2008
April 2008
March 2008
February 2008
January 2008
December 2007
November 2007
October 2007
September 2007
August 2007
July 2007
June 2007
May 2007
April 2007
March 2007
February 2007
Advertisements
JDub was never supposed to be just a record label, and as JDub records celebrates its fifth anniversary with a free concert on July 27 downtown at California Plaza, it is more clear than ever that the organization's founders have greater ambitions than merely putting out good
Diet books don't often include approbations from rabbis, but they're appropriate for "The Life-Transforming Diet," a structured eating plan based on the writings of physician and Torah scholar Maimonides.
Barack Obama arrived in Israel and stressed the historic ties between the United States and the Jewish state. The presumptive Democratic presidential nominee is on a Middle East and European tour aimed at shoring up his foreign policy credentials.
But the surveys had bad news for Obama: If the U.S. presidential election were held today, American Jews would support the Illinois senator at a significantly lower level than they did his most recent Democratic predecessors.
The new Contemporary Jewish Museum in San Francisco is a hip amalgam of modern art. Daniel Liebeskind's peculiar architectural dazzle looks like a giant Rubik's Cube in metallic steel, standing on its tip beneath the city's downtown skyscrapers. Beside it is the Jessie Street
Jewish groups have taken lead roles in drawing attention to China's policies and specifically sought to spotlight the country's record in advance of this summer's Olympic Games in Beijing. Yet it appears as if China will suffer no significant international sanction when the
"I wish I had 10 percent of the success with the Israeli government as I have with private donors," sighed Moshe Kaveh, the president of Bar-Ilan University.
Jewish groups have taken lead roles in drawing attention to China's policies and specifically sought to spotlight the country's record in advance of this summer's Olympic Games in Beijing. Yet it appears as if China will suffer no significant international sanction when the
Parshat Pinchas (Numbers 25:10-30:1) "God spoke to Moses, saying: 'Pinchas, son of Eleazar, son of Aaron the Kohen, turned back My wrath from the children of Israel with his zealotry for My sake ... Therefore ... I grant him My covenant of peace....'"
Natan Sharansky's previous book, "The Case for Democracy," changed the world. It inspired a generation of U.S. policymakers and influenced President George
W. Bush in his decision to go to war against Saddam Hussein. So when Sharansky's second book, "Defending Identity," came
Serving a community of 600,000, The Jewish Journal of Greater Los Angles is the largest Jewish weekly outside New York City. Our award-winning paper reaches over 150,000 educated, involved and affluent readers each week. Subscribe here.
© Copyright 2008 The Jewish Journal and JewishJournal.com
All rights reserved. JewishJournal.com is hosted by Nexcess.net
“Trying to get to the facts of this story without the drama and emotion involved, was not an easy task and a few local Iranian Jewish community leaders (which shall go unnamed) were not helpful to me in my quest to find real answers to this problem.”
It is frustrating when a writer is unable to find information about a story or is treated improperly by possible sources.
For the purpose of my curiousity, please elaborate on how you think the Persian leaders could have helped you in writing the news story.
Persian leaders, religious ones especially, are not interested in listening to fruitless conversations regarding a recent incident.They are probably one of the last people to go to to get “the facts of this story” or “the real answers to this problem”. You could ask them for their opinion of the incident, and how Iranian Jews should face it. Rabbi David Shofet’s quote in my opinion is sufficient to demonstrate your point. He is a prominent Persian rabbi in the community known for his trusted name (his father was also a spiritual leader in Iran)and moderate views on religion (Religious, but not too extreme for his congregants at Nessah Synogogue). Other rabbis would have helped further solidify your point.
The wide range of opinions on this topic is represented in your article, an.
“Trying to get to the facts of this story without the drama and emotion involved, was not an easy task and a few local Iranian Jewish community leaders (which shall go unnamed) were not helpful to me in my quest to find real answers to this problem.”
It is frustrating when a writer is unable to find information about a story or is treated improperly by possible sources.
For the purpose of my curiousity, please elaborate on how you think the Persian leaders could have helped you in writing the news story.
Persian leaders, religious ones especially, are not interested in listening to fruitless conversations regarding a recent incident.They are probably one of the last people to go to to get “the facts of this story” or “the real answers to this problem”. You could ask them for their opinion of the incident, and how Iranian Jews should face it. Rabbi David Shofet’s quote in my opinion is sufficient to demonstrate your point. He is a prominent Persian rabbi in the community known for his trusted name (his father was also a spiritual leader in Iran)and moderate views on religion (Religious, but not too extreme for his congregants at Nessah Synogogue). Other rabbis would have helped further solidify your point.
The wide range of opinions on this topic is represented in your article.
I think your blog is wonderful and every Iranian-Jew must have it bookmarked.
The story of Dariush is one thing but I feel it is crucial that we hear the true story about the Iranian community’s beloved singer Moein. I personally continue to hear anti-semitic stories regarding Moein yet he is the singer of choice at many Iranian-Jewish wedding.
You are in the best position to raise awareness about Moein and whether or not his support is deserved.